Bait and Switch?

DB Help

So, I'm going to grant you all at the outset that I am new here, and no, my relationship is not in a good place, but stick with me. If you are curious or interested as to the details of the relationship itself, ask, or PM.

I've realized that in addition to the fade that sometimes comes with challenge (and/or children and/or challenging children) in a relationship, the "rules" of our sex life have changed. More specifically, in addition to almost being in a DB, when it does happen, many of the acts of intimacy that used to occur on a regular basis (I'll call them "the things I like") no longer happen, even when requested.

I talked to my wife about this recently (and did it outside the bedroom and as non-confrontationally as I could manage) and she basically said "I never really liked that stuff anyway but did it because you did."

I feel like we either had a major communication gap early in our relationship or that she is withholding doing the things I like because she's stressed, not happy, etc.

But this is untenable for me - even my love language says I'd rather show my appreciation in physical ways - hugs, kisses, I'm pretty handsy with someone I care about, and you should see what giving and getting massages does to my libido, but...

But the idea that she once did all of these things and now chooses not to do any of these things is bothersome. And I don't really buy "I did it for you" over the course of years. If it was something she truly didn't enjoy, she would have said so long before now in a decade-long relationship.

I've done a good bit of reading, and many of you seem to have great heads on your shoulders, so I throw myself at your mercy.

[ETA: one young school-age child, lots of prior counseling, she has a history of depression.]

Posted Sep 21, 2016, 5:09 PM UTC · edited

1832
Cockring_Buddha♂ 49 ⚭ tarnished halo, shiny cockring•

A lot can change when kids enter the picture. Many women suddenly struggle with the reinvention of who they are. "Mommy Mode" kicks in, and some sexual acts suddenly become unacceptable to them. This is perfectly natural, but not always so fun for the guy. You just have to be patient. Sometimes years later, when the Mommy Mode settles down, those previous acts suddenly start to look good again to her. But it can take years.

There is no bait and switch in our sex lives. People evolve over time. We all change. We're supposed to do that. What I want from sex now is completely different from what I wanted 20 years ago. Now I wear cock rings and play with my ass. I enjoy BDSM and exhibitionism. None of that was on my radar back when I got married!!! I changed. Fortunately, my wife understands this and does her best to accommodate my needs, within what she's willing to do. Our sex life is all about communication, and continually reevaluating what is on and off the table, for the both of us. She never used to play with toys. Now she takes great pleasure in playing with vibes and dildos, during solo and couple play. We both changed, and somehow found a way for it to be fun for the both of us. It's not easy. Tons of honesty is required, and even more patience. Sometimes you just don't get everything you want, and you have to be happy with what they're currently willing to give; "currently" being the operative word here. Life is all about change and how we deal with those changes.

17
threeinthebedOP♂ 42•

I applaud your menu of fun stuff to do! But honestly, when it feels like forced "I don't want to make you happy", I can't really see it as natural evolution. I would love to add a whole bunch of things to our repertoire!

2
Cockring_Buddha♂ 49 ⚭ tarnished halo, shiny cockring•

That natural evolution doesn't always add things. Sometimes it takes them away. That's just how it is. You have to settle on the things that you both like today, if you both want to enjoy them, and this may change tomorrow.

Don't lose heart. "Mommy mode" sucks for you, but deep down inside, it's no fun for her either. But she sincerely needs to feel this way right now. Let her be okay with it for now. When she's ready, she'll open up again. You just need to give her the space and the positive encouragement to change when she's ready.

6
loquacious_deviant♀ 35 ⚭ •

Lots of truth here. Sometimes patience is key. My husband could have given up on me after our first child. He is reaping the rewards now. Sex is super important.... but it isn't all there is to a relationship. Sometimes you have to see the other side and bide your time. YMMV

1
Prisoner-of-Paradise♀48 PM me your beard!•

I guess for me the next question would have been, "Well, if you once did those things for me, why do you not want to do them for me now?"

6
threeinthebedOP♂ 42•

I was told by a therapist that "why" questions in sensitive situations can be perceived as threatening. Maybe I just had a crappy therapist, because here we are.

2
Prisoner-of-Paradise♀48 PM me your beard!•

I... don't even know what to say to that. I mean clearly you want to be non-confrontational, but seriously, how are you supposed to know why, without asking why?

7
Beautiful_Disasster♀ 40s nerdy kinky cougar•

Could you ask, "What has happened that makes doing those things less rewarding for you?"

6
sexover30ingeorgia♂ 39•

My ex wife did this too. In some ways worse. Some of it was my fault as there were red flags early on. I shouldn't have settled for a relationship so flawed at the beginning. In some cases we never did certain things I wanted to. In some cases she promised me she would someday "when we get married". Yeah that should have been obvious looking back. But she also did the same for non sexual things. Quit working, quit trying to maintain a healthy weight, quit trying to help around the house. I didn't suffer quietly and would complain and fight about stuff. She would promise to do something about it. Never happened.

I don't have much advice. See if she is depressed, does she want help? Are you doing all you can?

4
myexsparamour♀51 likes playing with fire•

It doesn't sound exactly like a bait and switch to me. More like she's made a mental shift to no longer wanting to please you or get pleasure from your pleasure. She enjoyed doing The Things You Liked because you liked them, but now that's not so rewarding for her.

It's very common in long term relationships. At first you love doing things for the other person. You love seeing their face light up when you bring a little gift or do them a favor. You give long, sensual massages just for the reward of seeing them dreamy and satisfied.

But over time, it's really common to stop doing that. Part of it is just familiarity and the loss of that infatuation or NRE, and part of can be resentment, feeling unappreciated, taking on a tit-for-tat, score-keeping mentality where you don't want to give more than you're getting back.

Do you still do all the Things She Liked as much as you did while you were dating? Not just sexual things, but whatever you used to do just to give her happiness? Not that if you start doing those things again it will change how she is in bed necessarily, but it's worth thinking about whether no longer getting pleasure from the other's pleasure goes both ways in your relationship.

3
idigthedank♂ 40+ English dirty minded old man•

We all make mental shifts in all areas of our lives and if we notice one in our relationship with a person we love, we need to accept the changes and grow with them. Our desires may not be fulfilled but the trust of not having demands, they may feel uncomfortable with, placed on them can only be good for the relationship.

1
myexsparamour♀51 likes playing with fire•

I'm not sure what you're getting at here. Are you saying that when your partner stops getting pleasure from your pleasure that's just a normal shift in the relationship and you need to accept it?

1
idigthedank♂ 40+ English dirty minded old man•

I'm saying, none of us are the same person we were last year. Let alone twenty years ago when our relationship started. For anyone to like, love, do, want, the same things as twenty years ago, it would have to be expected for those things to be done exactly the same each and every time. But we grow old and our knees hurt so we have to do it this way. Or she really likes watching porn where they do that thing and there's no way I'm trying that. I think that i am agreeing with what you said.

1
myexsparamour♀51 likes playing with fire•

I totally agree about preferences changing over time, physical limitations due to aging and injuries, and all that.

But I also believe there is a fundamental trait of a relationship partner. Does that person want to please you? Does he or she derive joy from making you happy?

If the answer is 'yes', then all the other stuff is just logistical problems to be worked out. That partner will find a way to satisfy your needs.

If the answer is 'no', then you're fucked. That partner is only going to satisfy his or her own selfish desires, and your needs be damned.

It goes the other way as well. If you don't get joy from making your partner happy, then sex (and everything else) is just going to be about taking what you can while giving as little as possible. And if both partners have lost their desire to please, the relationship is in a bad, bad place.

1
MaxFury8036 ♂ •

Yep.....she could give a shit about your needs here. I don't know how old your kids are but do understand that when they are little and don't sleep through the night there can be challenges.

I would have a very serious talk about her attitude and your DB issue and if she still pops off with not caring then time to go to marriage counseling. Communication is very important and stone walling is not communication and her saying that she won't do anything that you like says a bunch about her attitude.

2
Rob_Dead•

If you where suddenly out of the picture and she was netting a new guy she'd do all those things again to draw him in then, maybe, stop. Ask yourself if this is a bait and switch.

I'm not a father but I have seen this happen to friends before. If the husband left the girl went back to being a freak after the first half bottle of wine.

Do yourself a favor and get in shape (if you're not already). It might help, and if it doesn't at least you'll be fit and will make some good friends at the gym, also if this ends up a deal-breaker you will be in a better place to move on without her.

2
threeinthebedOP♂ 42•

Wow, I appreciate the large number of responses, but in order to get it tapped out, I'll summarize what I've heard from people (both in comments and PMs) and respond.

First, there's a contingent of people who advocate for the red pill process. When you take all of the peacock strutting and dick waving out of the red pill process, it boils down to "be the most confident version of yourself and do whatever it takes to get there."

I feel like many people in here are very sex-positive, and one of the things that does is to encourage confidence in whatever you decide to do. That's awesome. People have a point that it's very easy to let go of oneself (weight, health, friends, hobbies, etc.) in a not-so-exciting relationships scenario, and I am certainly guilty of that on some level. I know I need to work on myself, and be truer to the person that I was in my 20s before all this began, but I have to believe that I've learned a thing or two in that time, and following red pill to the letter is absolutely unnecessary, and I can be (and am, to most people) a confident, desirable, interesting man without being a prick about it - and that's true already.

Second, there's a group that suggests that this is a relationship problem and not a sex problem, and on a base level, you're right. The relationship may not die because of the lack of sex, but it may die because of the issues that lead to the lack of sex. And I have to thank one person in particular (who shall remain nameless) for reminding me that for people who feel it, kink is not particularly optional if you plan to be happy.

So here's what I'm going to do: I am going to spend much more time thinking about what I can do to make things better, and much less time thinking about what she can do to make things better. Obviously, I will be supportive and encouraging if she chooses to make any changes. If, by the time I am fully happy that I have done and continue to do everything possible to get what I want and do what I can to contribute to what she says she wants out of the relationship, I am still not happy with the relationship and she has still not addressed her contribution to the problem, then it will end.

If it ends, it will end with the knowledge that I did my part. That's really all I can ask of myself, and as u/925Copper pointed out, there comes a point in time where there's nothing else that I can do, no matter what it is that I actually want to happen.

The diversity of opinion here is fabulous, and though we have just met, I am pleased to meet all of you. You ladies and gentlemen are amazing.

2
urchigold♂ 36 ⚭ •

Just to give a short success story - I had an issue somewhat like this (I detailed my issues here in a few threads called "Trying")

I delved deeper and my wife basically said it was a turn-off that I kept requesting or talking about the things I like.

So finally I agreed 100% not to bring the stuff up. And then a few weeks later, she did it for me. Then weeks after that, really got into it during my birthday weekend.

This may seem overly simplistic though "duh just stop asking." But there was dialogue that led to me realizing I just had to do that.

1
Cockring_Buddha♂ 49 ⚭ tarnished halo, shiny cockring•

That's good advice. Sometimes you have to give the other person that availability to give you a treat; a surprise gift that they know you love, without it being requested. It's like thinking up an awesome Christmas present for someone you love, which gives you tremendous pleasure to give, just because you were the one to think of it, not them.

2
threeinthebedOP♂ 42•

Thing is, the overall event happens so rarely that I'm not actually asking that often.

1
very_hard_spanker♂ 38•

"I never really liked that stuff anyway but did it because you did."

That's my ex-wife in a nutshell, although she stopped doing all the non-"normal" stuff before we got married and I was too dumb to see what was happening.

1
ImplausiblyObvious♂ 50 Finally enjoying my sex life•

Ok, I feel for you. I agree with u/myexesparamour that it sounds more like a change than a bait and switch. Still, I've been in your shoes (feel free to look at my profile posts for the whole story) and the basis of why doesn't matter. It just sucks when you're there.

If you've tried therapy and it hasn't worked, there are some hard questions you need to ask of both her and yourself. I had that same conversation with my ex. She told me she never liked any of that stuff, that she though it sounded sexy, and now that we were married with a couple of kids this was how it was and I needed to simply get used to it.

She was very wrong.

I'm a huge advocate for open communication here. Talk openly with her. Let her know how important all this is to you and why. She needs to know how both not having good and having those things makes you feel. She also needs to hear clearly what you're thinking if she decides that she's just not interested. Listen openly to what she has to say and be open to alternatives.

Like the recent mod post said, we talk feelings and sex here, bc they're largely inseparable in a long term relationship. Put it all out there...

1
selfishlicker♂40+defender of monogamy and religion... and drug use•

Depression is a bitch on the libido. I just went through a round of it with my wife where sex fell off quite a bit. What helped us immensely was for us to connect on an emotional level and for me to focus more on supporting her and less on being upset by the lack of intimacy. While this didn't fix the depression, nor did it bring about more sex during the depression, it brought us closer together in a big way, and I felt more emotional intimacy from her. It turns out, that was what I craved more than sex. Recently, her depression has gone away for now. With the lifting of depression combined with our renewed emotional connection, her libido has skyrocketed like never before.

Now here's hr thing. None of this would have worked if we hadn't been communicating about how we were feeling and what we were going through. In he past, I've tried to take the pressure of sex off in more of a silent protest. That just ended in me being frustrated, and her not wanting sec any more than before. Then my frustration would cause tension... you see the pattern. For us communication, honesty, and support were key.

1
sfriedrich♂ 60 ⚭•

What others have said about "mommy mode" is completely true. However, as with everything else in life deliberateness and willingness can overcome a lot.

She has two kinds of challenges: physical and psychological.

First for the physical... get yourselves to a good doctor that understands sexuality and the human body and life changes. My wife and I go to the best one in the world (annually. and BTW, we're 60-me and 54-her), Dr. Irwin Goldstein (http://www.sandiegosexualmedicine.com). After children the chances are pretty good that your wife could be needing testosterone supplementation among other things (It's not uncommon even in the 30's - 40's). There's also the possible complication of HSDD for her. The best docs are hip for all of this and can offer you a variety of solutions.

Psychologically, get thee to an MFT - sex therapist. Drag her if necessary. Commit yourself and do the work.

Finally, get yourself a copy of "Intimacy and Desire" by Dr. David Schnarch (my sex therapist pointed me in this direction). The first three chapters seem like it's all about sex but, then chapters 4 - 7 bring you around to see that it's all about intimacy and that the irresistible driving force in that can be unilateral and that it's YOU. Change yourself and you can drive change in the relationship far beyond your wildest dreams (it worked for me/us). The book can teach you how to have a "second growing up", becoming more and more differentiated so that you can also effect growth in your relationship.

EDIT: Corrected spelling to Schnarch

1
925Copper♀43 Submissive Hotwife/Cuck Kink/Mod•

The only problem I have with this advice is that sometimes you can work your ass off for years but you can't change the other person's half. I agree that any person in a DB relationship needs to look at themselves first. But after enough talks over many years it's not only proven to be not my fault anymore, it's also been proven that the other person doesn't care enough to fix it.

I can only fix my half. If you give lip service to fixing your half, if you can't hear my message and all the clear signs that I'm eventually slipping away emotionally, then there will come a point where I don't even know why we're doing this anymore.

While I applaud the idea of looking at one's self first I think we should acknowledge that sometimes a person has done all they can, and they have a breaking point.

Most people on this sub get that it's not about the sex. It's about the emotional intimacy, bonding, and connection that sex provides in a relationship.

While we should encourage everyone to look within themselves first, we should also acknowledge that at a certain point it's not on them anymore.

2
sfriedrich♂ 60 ⚭•

I completely agree that sometimes nothing gets better no matter what you do. But, the only thing that you have any power to change is yourself... and even that with real effort and persistence.

Sometimes, it does entice the other partner to change (and then AMAZING things happen) and sometimes they just try to bait you back to their level and sometimes they turn away to work/affairs/other-distractions.

2
threeinthebedOP♂ 42•

Regarding the book, so that others who see this have some idea...

This is a damn good book, and worth the read, and it goes fairly quickly. I'm only about a quarter of the way through it, so there's much more to go, but you were so right that many parts of it described my relationship to perfection, and the concept of emotional gridlock has been where we've been for quite some time. I look forward to finishing it off over the next couple of weeks as time permits.

[NB for those searching: The author's last name is actually Schnarch. And he loves to pop little jokes and put-you-in-your-place moments to his clients who get a little too over-the-top in their protestations, which keeps the reading lighter.]

My wife is skeptical, but as I said, I am working primarily on myself right now while encouraging her to do what she feels she should do.

2
Barf_Dexter•

Sounds to me like a relationship issue and not a bedroom issue. Fix the relationship and the other stuff will follow naturally.

1