thatnerdguy1•

Holy shit—he got early acess to BFR plans and pics and stuff? That is so awesome. So many people, especially here, would love to have that, plus personal interviews! Great article, too.

21
robertmassaioli•

With respect to "do you send people or the fuel first?" this blog post by Tim clarifies that in Blue Bullet Point #8:

Elon says that this is the plan if the refuelling process is quick, like a couple weeks or less. If it takes a lot longer, then the spacecraft will be launched first without people, and then whenever it’s all refuelled and ready to go, a spacecraft carrying just people will be launched and it will deliver the crew to the spacecraft for an Earth orbit rendezvous.

So, in short, it is not set in stone.

They will send humans or people up first depending on what makes the most sense after it becomes clearer how long everything takes to get into orbit (or what other factors dictate about the launch).

10
flattop100•

In that case, wouldn't it make sense to send a tanker up first, then a MCT loaded with people?

3
kwisatzhadnuff•

It requires multiple tankers to refuel the ship, so just like Elon said, that only makes sense if the refueling process is quick enough.

1
Minthos•

I don't understand. Can't they fly a tanker up there, then fill up that tanker with a second tanker doing multiple trips? A full tanker in orbit should be able to refill an empty ship and still have enough to land if it needs to.

3
Vulch59•

The tanks with refuelling propellants will be probably be designed for that purpose and have something along the lines of a diaphragm in them to make it possible to pump. That's the way virtually every in orbit propellant transfer to date has been done. Trying to pump out of the main tank will be problematic to say the least.

2
CtG526•

Was this one removed? I don't see it in the new posts for the sub. I thought it had nice bits of Elon's own insight that he didn't specifically mention at the IAC.

3
AmbiwlansMOD•

It was removed in a bit of miscommunication. This sort of post generally is supposed to go to the media thread for the event, but given the quality, it was given an exception.

Sorry for the inconvenience.

7
AppableOP•

Yes, it should have gone into the media thread, my fault and I should have asked the mods first. Feel free to contribute to the subthread on the media thread though.

3
flattop100•

I disagree - there is new info that hasn't been discussed ANYWHERE:

Upcoming Mars Oppositions – and what SpaceX is planning for each

July, 2018: Send a Dragon spacecraft (the Falcon 9’s SUV-size spacecraft) to Mars with cargo

October, 2020: Send multiple Dragons with more cargo

December, 2022: Maiden BFS voyage to Mars. Carrying only cargo. This is the spaceship Elon wants to call Heart of Gold.

January, 2025: First people-carrying BFS voyage to Mars.

Let’s all go back and read that last line again.

January, 2025: First people-carrying BFS voyage to Mars.

12
GeniDoi•

Seriously, mods?

4
zlsaMODArtist•

This post has been reapproved now.

6
3_711•

I'm still hoping they send two red dragons in 2018. Like Elons plan before starting SpaceX, a double mission increases the chance one will succeed and they don't have the time to let Mars oppositions go to waste.

4
requestingflyby•

I agree. If it is possible to stagger the red dragons by a couple of days or weeks within the same launch window, they would have time to learn from the telemetry data (assuming the first one failed) and adjust the second red dragon's software to give it a better chance of landing successfully. Otherwise, they can't try again until the next window.

5
zlsaArtist•

This info has been public knowledge for a while.

1
flattop100•

I'm hadn't heard it before, and I'm a little surprised he left it out of the presentation. A few news outlets pointed to the absence as a hole in his/their plans.

3
gromthebomb•

What do you guys think will happen to NASA after all of this? Since this will blow the SLS out of the water with sheer capabilities, does NASA just cancel and see what happens?

3
Iamsodarncool•

I expect NASA will be heavily involved in the development of the technology that will be used in the mars colony (habitats, mining equipment ect) since SpaceX will be taking a back seat on that stuff.

11
gromthebomb•

I didn't even think of that! Thanks for the info!

3
Iamsodarncool•

Welcome :) yeah, SpaceX's focus is on creating a reliable and cheap transportation system to and from mars. They have a cargo compartment and a crane to lower the cargo to Mars's surface, and they expect governments/universities/private companies to pay to get their cargo on it.

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
air_and_space92•

Not at all. It's taken a lot of time and political effort to get the whole Mars thing going this long after Apollo and NASA's not going to sit back and see what happens. What if the carbon fiber structure just doesn't work out, or more unlikely, SpaceX folds after not being able to sort the He issue? NASA will continue as scheduled with full stage SLS core testing in fall 2017 and first flight in 2018. EUS is still being developed and moving to PDR soon. Best not to change course until the alternative is more than paper.

5
MarcysVonEylau•

Hey! Thanks for using my video :D

3
_rocketboy•

Your video? Which one?

1
MarcysVonEylau•

ORBCOMM-2 Recap

1
p4di•

I hoped there we would be a more critical analysis of the plan.

3
StupidPencil•

Interesting bit

I asked Elon why there were 42 smaller-sized engines instead of a smaller number of huge ones, and he said that they had imagined larger engines at one point but that “optimization seems to call for more small engines, not fewer big engines.” I can’t explain more than that because I don’t get it.

Anyone cares to explain? I don't really get it either.

2
AppableOP•

My guess, based on Elon Musk's AMA comment, is that they were optimizing for TWR and a larger engine was inconsistent with that. I don't know (i.e. complete stab in the dark) but maybe the ludicrously high chamber pressure also required a smaller engine size?

3
Captain_Hadock•

Optimization of manufacturing (same size as the current merlin, ie. they can keep their existing process in Hawthorne, same economies of scale could be expected, same increase in reliability due to making hundreds of engines a year)
Optimization of combustion. Big engines (F-1 size) tend to suffer more from combustion instability that require complex R&D processes.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
DecronymAcronyms Explained•

### ###### ####

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

Fewer LettersMore Letters
BFRBig Fu- Falcon Rocket
BFSBig Fu- Falcon Spaceship (see MCT)
EUSExploration Upper Stage
IACInternational Astronautical Congress, annual meeting of IAF members
MCTMars Colonial Transporter (see ITS)
SLSSpace Launch System heavy-lift
TWRThrust-to-Weight Ratio

^(Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented )^by ^request
^(I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 30th Sep 2016, 06:09 UTC.)
^[Acronym ^lists] ^[Contact ^creator] ^[PHP ^source ^code]

1
graaahh•

In this instance, I believe "Big Fucking Rocket" and "Big Fucking Spaceship" would actually be more appropriate.

2