d1ngal1ngAustralia•

This is just a bit weird, imo. I wonder how the medical professionals responsible for having to carry this out would feel about ending the lives of healthy people.

73
totallyterror•

I wouldn't call somebody who doesn't want to live anymore "healthy" just because their bodies can keep on running but their minds can't.

27
Estoesloquequiero•

Sure, but somebody who is young, depressed and suicidal isn't healthy either because depression is an illness.

5
AceOfReQuiem•

Very on point.

1
uppitywormThe Netherlands•

The law hasn't been drafted yet. Perhaps the method of suicide will not involve the need for a medical professional. Something like the helium exit bag sounds relatively easy to set up for the layman.

15
d1ngal1ngAustralia•

That's not very assisted though. Someone can do that now without changing any laws in basically any country.

7
uppitywormThe Netherlands•

It's not legal to sell a functional suicide kit because assisting with suicide is a crime in most jurisdictions. Also large helium producers have taken moves to make it harder to use their helium, don't remember how exactly.

12
Gawd1•

a functional suicide kit

You mean, like a handgun?

8
ZiggyPoxMango•

helium exit bag

Well, that looks... easy.

1
uppitywormThe Netherlands•

I don't follow fill a plastic bag with helium, then put it over you're head and breath in and out until you're dead. Getting the helium is the most complicated part. A convenient bag might take some searching too, you want to be able to tighten it around the neck I believe, to minimize the loss of helium. But you could probably figure something out for that if you wanted to.

1
ZiggyPoxMango•

Well, I'm a handyman, I like to make stuff and, well... most of the stuff that I would need is back at my home: bags, fasteners, bunch of one-way aquarium valves with tubings. I could make really handy suicide bag and that's the really disturbing part.

I also know where to get over 95% pure helium canisters, the 80% kinds will only give you brain damage.

Fuck it, I would rather hug the concrete.

3
sultry_somnambulistGermany•

Medical professionals have huge issues with assisted suicide even in the cases of terminally ill patients, which oddly enough is very rarely discussed.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16676767

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION: The physician is centrally involved in PAS and euthanasia, and the emotional and psychological effects on the participating physician can be substantial. The shift away from the fundamental values of medicine to heal and promote human wholeness can have significant effects on many participating physicians. Doctors describe being profoundly adversely affected, being shocked by the suddenness of the death, being caught up in the patient's drive for assisted suicide, having a sense of powerlessness, and feeling isolated. There is evidence of pressure on and intimidation of doctors by some patients to assist in suicide. The effect of countertransference in the doctor-patient relationship may influence physician involvement in PAS and euthanasia. CONCLUSION: Many doctors who have participated in euthanasia and/or PAS are adversely affected emotionally and psychologically by their experiences.

13
anarquistosLithuania•

I wonder if there would be room for specialists of assisted suicide. Like doctors whose only job is helping people end their lives peacefully. Would specialized psychological training help overcome the negative consequences?

10
als01Moldova•

Some people will feel just fine doing this job. Suum cuique.

3
philip1201The Netherlands•

It seems like a natural expansion for the job description of undertakers. The medical training required to kill someone can't be that great, and they need to be there anyway to dispose of the corpse properly. Maybe a doctor should still be on hand to save the moribund if they change their mind, but that falls within the old job description.

3
BobzerIreland•

We need some futurama-esque suicide booths.

1
SystemicPluralEngland•

We need to automate it. Maybe in a small cinema showing beautiful scenes and relaxing music.

1
sultry_somnambulistGermany•

I don't think so at all. I don't think we should support suicide in healthy individuals. As a society we have no obligation to do this, I think we ought to try to prevent it if anything.

3
BurningFox•

I think it was sarcasm.

1
SystemicPluralEngland•

Have you never seen Soylent Green?

Damn shame. Should be required viewing.

1
LynxingParty•

Depends on the medical professional. This culture exists much less in the Netherlands, as you can infer from this proposal being on the table in the first place.

I know some doctors, and some of them have done things that would be considered murder abroad, but are accepted as part of the profession, here. Take something like the Terry Schiavo case. That wouldn't happen here.

In Belgium there have already been cases of euthanasia that would fall under this proposal. That is, of medically healthy people who made a case that their life was suffering. And I believe in France there was a case of a woman who developed a tumor in her face, and requested assisted suicide. She was denied. Spoiler alert: She was still found dead a few months later.

In fact, an idea for this has been on the table as long as I can remember. It's called "Drion's Pill", which would basically be a suicide pill.

1
sultry_somnambulistGermany•

I don't really see why society is obligated to help otherwise healthy people to commit suicide. This seems wrong to me. The medical profession exists to uphold life and preserve it, as do society's obligations towards any individual. We should not normalise assisted suicide, and I don't see assisted suicide in an otherwise healthy individual as rational. What we instead should do is provide support to someone who has suicidal thoughts and try to prevent it.

1
SchurkjeBoefjeThe Netherlands•

What we instead should do is provide support to someone who has suicidal thoughts and try to prevent it.

Surely you understand that there's a long, long process trying to exhaust all other options that takes place before such an assisted suicide request is granted.

It's not like you can just walk in and get it done. It's very specifically aimed at the, if I may call it this, 'lost causes' that stand a very high chance of taking their own life regardless, even after years and years of therapy.

2
SvartvannNorway•

Im a F*** idiot.

1
LynxingParty•

Well, I see you've already had a big discussion about this, which I've not read at this time. So I'll keep it short.

I think the crux here is your perception. In our culture, these questions are much easier to answer. And who is to say what constitutes a "healthy individual"? The people presiding over the case of Terry Schiavo considered her a "healthy individual" despite her being objectively braindead. I would call that a travesty of justice, but they clearly would not.

In the end, this is a self-deterministic view of things. It's your life, and your right to end it as you see fit. If you are ill, and your viewpoint is not grounded in reality, that calls for treatment. But if you are sound of mind, and it is your well-reasoned opinion that you're done, it's your life. And your death.

1
Rekkt_Gaming•

I know I wouldn't mind. If the law is passing they have strict policys and ways to make sure it is what they really want and not something they just rushed into. Also I think it is a good thing to have it in an controlled enviroment as here in the Netherlands still quite some suicides happen in ways they harm other people just as much, think about jumping in front of a train and a team people have to gather and clean up whats left over.

8
VeeronIceland•

It's more than a bit weird. The reasoning behind legalizing euthanasia is that the person can't actually do it themselves. Assisted suicide is a moral gray area under the best of conditions and should never be considered anything better than a necessary evil. If the person is fully capable and not even ill, then there's nothing "necessary" about that evil.

6
Rekkt_Gaming•

In my honest opinion, everyone has the choice to live or not. And I think it is better to do it in an controlled enviroment rather than having strangers pick up body parts from the railroads for example.

If someone is done with his or her life they often end it anyway.

6
772751•

It's very possible to be in terrible health without being terminally ill

3†
VeeronIceland•

Sorry, I don't find that relevant. If you're able to commit suicide without assistance, then I don't see why there should be a legal avenue for pushing the actual killing onto someone else. That strikes me as morbid in the extreme.

3†
Jstuyfzand•

If I was 95 and my life sucked, lonely, all friends are dead, unable to do activities, I'd want to die

7
Milites01•

The problem is that atempting suicide is hella risky. It is very hard to get concrete information on suicide methods (on reddit for example subreddits get banned if they allow the discussion of concrete methods). And even the best methods do not have a 100% success rate and can leave you completely fucked when they fail. So yeah assisted suicide would be a gift for a lot of people and choosing to end your life should be a human right. But we all know that our society is far far away from that. How fucked up is it that I get locked away (against my will) for wanting something completely legal. Today you can't even tell anyone that you want to die because of that. But hopefully soon there will be a safe, assisted method to end our misery if we want so.

4
narwi•

The reason is that it is very hard to do it efficiently and without harming other people in the process or accidentally ending up crippled from it.

1
narwi•

What is your argument for not allowing people to end their life whenever they want ? Is it really better if they continue to jump in front of trains, trying to (often unsuccessfully) hang themselves, taking prescription drugs (which also is often unsuccessful and results in damage) and so on?

0
VeeronIceland•

That's not my argument. Forcing or coercing doctors or anyone to kill people through the law is not palatable. Suicide should be the responsibility of the individual (giving information about suicide methods or even providing the means does NOT breach this principle), but I can stomach an exception given in euthanasia cases where the person is physically or mentally incapacitated.

4
JCutterTeam Chaos & Anarchy•

You realize there are people who would actually sign up for the job of assisting in suicide, right?

2
narwi•

Assisted suicide is not just "doctor delivering the dose", it is equally somebody giving you the dose in a syringe (or probably two) and explaining how it should be administered (but not doing it) or really just selling you a kit. Some kind of tracking would be needed of such so that it does not become a trivial to acquire murder weapon.

In UK, people have been prosecuted for merely accompanying people who could not get on plane due to their incapacity to Switzerland. That too is assistance in assisted suicide and ought to be legalized.

0
eastmaven•

I think it's possible to just take a set of pills. A medical professional might give you the pills but you physically take'em and swallow 'em.

2
TintenlampeEuropean Union•

Pills are shit for suicide. They have delayed onset and other issues. From a medical / pharmaceutical perspective you would want to use IV or inhalation.

1
eastmaven•

Well thanks! I'll keep that in mind should I want to go that route!

1
TintenlampeEuropean Union•

Please don't go that route. If you seriously consider suicide you should seek help and not listen to the advice of a random internet dude like me.

3
newusernameredditFederation•

But they have completed all achievements in life.

1
als01Moldova•

Very good. This shows respect to personal freedom and choice. Also, I'm inclined to think that should such a law be adopted, then there would be less people faking suicide just to bring attention (and killing themselves nevertheless).

This law would mean one more aspect of human life is taken real care of.

13
DraconianWolfUnited States of America•

This is a discomforting thought. People may always change their minds about their lives in different circumstances. They won't get this chance if they're dead.

10
LogicChick•

I thought so too but after thinking more I see this as imposing your ideas onto someone else. Fact is, they WON'T change their mind if they are dead and they MAY NOT change their mind if you force them to live. In the end I have to give the choice to the individual, not others who know nothing about them.

I don't know if this will increase or decrease the number of people who end up dead though. People already end their own lives and lot's of people have an idea in the back of their head how they would do it if things got really rotten.

26
Rekkt_Gaming•

Also when you are dead you won't change your mind.

17
Paddo_In_WonderlandThe Netherlands•

This is kind of ironic coming from someone who lives in a nation where the death penalty is still a common practice. Not saying you are pro-death penalty or anything, but it at least skews the opinion about it.

8
millzPoland C•

It is not ironic, because capital punishment is a way to protect the society from criminals. No connection to euthanasia whatsoever, unless you (eugenically) think people with illness are a threat to the society.

-4
Paddo_In_WonderlandThe Netherlands•

Capital punishment gives no more protection from criminals than a life-long sentence in prison.

The ironic part is that it's okay to decide whether someone else may or may not life, but it's not up to an individual to decide whether they may or not life.

Neither this is about euthanasia, but about assisted suicide. Euthanasia only relates to assisted suicide in case of physical pain and suffering.

10
dukenPLCAN'T STUMP THE TRUMP•

I support both the death penalty and decriminalizing suicide (is that how I should call it?)

0
millzPoland C•

Capital punishment gives no more protection from criminals than a life-long sentence in prison.

Ever heard of prison breaks? Or intra-prison murders? Yeah, a guy sentenced to life-long prison has a carte blanche for his activities within, it's not like they are going to sentence him to another life. But I guess life of an 'innocent' petty criminal is less worthy than a life of a convicted murderer for you?

The ironic part is that it's okay to decide whether someone else may or may not life, but it's not up to an individual to decide whether they may or not life.

Of course they can, it's called suicide. What is wrong here is involving the state, and especially doctors, who are taught to help and never harm, and it fucks up their morality and ethics.

-7
Mortlach78•

I believe the law would apply to (very) senior citizens, like 80 year olds and up. A physically healthy 20 year old would probably not be considered and would be offered a psychological evaluation.

2
grim_asdfSlovenia•

Hopefully everyone would be offered psych evaluation first, before making such a decision. Not just young people. But ultimately everyone should get the choice.

5
bigbramelThe Netherlands•

From what I understand, they will use the same procedures as for the very ill persons. That means that a psych evaluation is surely included.

5
[deleted]•

They won't get this chance if they're dead.

They wouldn't be able to regret it anyway.

2
nybblethAmsterdam•

I agree with you in principle, but keep in mind the rules would make it so that a mental health professional would be involved and would have to be completely certain that the individual's making a well-thought decision; and isn't just doing it on a whim.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
narwi•

SO you want people to have to resort to jumping in front of trains?

1
JCutterTeam Chaos & Anarchy•

Nor would they care anymore either. My comment might seem callous but I think people tend to look at suicide as a bystander or someone who loses that person which in my opinion is a bit selfish (not saying that's bad either, its absolutely understandable and normal).

1
plutei•

Here is the story of two Australian scientists who took their own lives in their old age. It offers an interesting perspective. http://www.theage.com.au/interactive/2016/the-big-sleep/

10
LakedaimonioisThe Netherlands•

To me it simply comes down to this:

Who is ultimately in charge of my life?

Is it the government that tells me I have to live or die or is that decision ultimately up to me? To me, if you're a liberal, this is something you should be in favor of simply because nobody else should be allowed to stop you from doing what you want with your own body/life, so long as it does not harm others.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
nidrachAustria•

This is about assisted suicide though. If you are healthy just hang yourself. No help needed.

-3†
TYMRHI•

Because people don't deserve to die with dignity and human company?

4
nidrachAustria•

Why does that matter? It's suicide, don't romanticise it ffs. You can't kill yourself and hold your head up high. And I say that as someone with a history of severe depression. If you are nihilistic enough to say that you are through with life why would you care about stupid stuff like dignity? Suicide should always be perceived as something negative other than. In cases that are absolutely hopeless from a medical standpoint.

0†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
LakedaimonioisThe Netherlands•

And then who gets to find you? Who gets to be shocked by finding out what you did and gets to deal with the fall out? Police gets to waste resources on it because they have to come and rule it a suicide. I clearly stated "so long as it does not harm others" in my comment. What you suggest does not qualify as that, assisted suicide does.

2
terraorbem•

Skip credits. Straight back to menu.

7
DavidJARomania•

This movie is shit. I'm turning it off.

3
ImJustPassinBy•

New game+?

2
DrZiggyBowie•

New galaxy discovered

2
deadmeat33•

Futurama already predicted it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EbmQxZkSswI

6
23PowerZEuropean Union•

That's a reference to Soylent Green (1973).

E: Which is ultimately also a reference to the Sorrows of Young Werther (1774).

1
P4p3Rc1iPFriesland•

The largest opponents of this law's biggest argument against it is that extra money should be spent towards the well being of depressed elders, instead of having them kill themselves and saving some money.

6
teh_fizz•

While this is a good sentiment, sometimes we don't want to be treated because we don't believe we will get better. This is a scary but comforting idea for me. I don't see myself enjoying life like I used to in my mid-20's, and it's making my life less worth living. While there are a lot of experiences I would love to go through, I feel I lived a very fulfilling life. To me this law would be very useful.

6
terraorbem•

My great-aunt requested euthanasia last week. She was 91 and while not suffering from a directly debilitating disease, old age had ravaged her body to the point she could no longer take care of herself.

She was 100% mentally sound and had a lot of children and grandchildren perfectly willing to take care of her. She lost her husband almost two decades ago and just felt that it was time, that her role on this Earth was up.

I can't help but respect that. At the end of a long (even fulfulling) day, when one is dead tired, sleep is the sweetest of releases. I can only imagine this is similar but of course many magnitudes larger in scope.

7
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Low_discrepancyPosh Crimea•

I don't see myself enjoying life like I used to in my mid-20's, and it's making my life less worth living

So you're 80+ smth and you're planning on assisted suicide?

2
teh_fizz•

My age doesn't matter at this point. 35 or 90, if I don't think my life is enjoyable, that's on me. My decision.

1
Low_discrepancyPosh Crimea•

Then buy a gun. I fail to understand why we should legalise this aspect of life.

-2†
[deleted]•

should be spent towards the well being of depressed elders

Oh the elders again. Sometimes you wonder wether there are still other people in the country as well besides elders.

3
nixielover•

been in elderly care lately? my granny was forced into on of those homes by 3 of her 4 children; 2 hours waiting time to go to the bathroom is standard. And I'm not even going to continue on this because I don't want to ruin my day again

2
[deleted]•

I have, service was fine. Maybe look for a better one and leave a review or complaint somewhere about the current one.

4
nixielover•

well as I said, 3/4 of her children forced her into one so we can't, they managed to get POA etc so we can't do shit. they barely ever visit her and just say that it's perfect there.

in reality the nurses are quitting because they can't bear it anymore over there, it's that bad. last month 3 nurses who all worked there for more than 10 years quit because they couldn't take it anymore and almost two dozen volunteers quit because of the new management.

1
Nemeblubb•

I would like to subscribe to your newsletter, please.

2
hamptyhams•

So it turns out the slippery slope is real.

5†
philip1201The Netherlands•

Is it slippery, though? If this is a bridge too far, people can still protest and lawmakers can still vote no and voters can still punish or reward lawmakers who voted a certain way.

And if we do overshoot the mark, are the consequences that terrible compared to the decades we've undershot the mark by fearing slipperiness? A couple dozen people more whose last few seconds are "wait, I've changed my mind, I don't want to die yet. Oh no, I can't find the button". Or tens of thousands of old people, and their families, forced to watch as their minds and bodies failed them over the course of years or even decades, wishing that someone would just end it.

That isn't to say the former image isn't horrific. The decay of people is a horrible thing no matter how you slice it. But both undershooting and overshooting the mark are similarly bad, so it's more important that we quickly zero in on the best option, than if we don't overshoot it.

10
damage3245United Kingdom•

That doesn't mean the slippery slope is bad though.

0
AceOfReQuiem•

Such addition to the discussion, much wow

-3†
HaveJoystick•

Just set up suicide booths and be done with it.

3
faerakhasaSpain•

Frankly, I don't understand this. The assisted suicide started for the benefit of people who wanted to die, but could not kill themselves due to their disabilities.

To put it bluntly, why do we have to force doctors to kill people that are perfectly able to kill themselves if they want to?

2
bigbramelThe Netherlands•

Nobody is forcing doctors. Anyone can refuse to be part of this.

And this system doesn't abandon anyone that thinks about suicide, like the current system does.

1
SchurkjeBoefjeThe Netherlands•

why do we have to force doctors to kill people that are perfectly able to kill themselves if they want to?

The doctor is more of a control factor. To assist someone in stepping out of life without a literal mess of blood and corpse and people finding the body, or the person inadvertently doing something wrong and dying painfully.

1
LandGullNorway•

As a handicapped person I hate this. The line for what is acceptable is moving. And I fear that eventually people with handicaps or poor health will feel obligated to kill themselves as not to be a burden upon their families and society in general.

I belive if this is allowed they cross this last line.

2
optionplusRomania•

What do they to put them to sleep ? At least they should be able to donate vital organs.

1
pulicafranaruRomania•

What do they to put them to sleep ?

Drugs, obviously. I think they generally give them an overdose of Pentobarbital.

1
LeeuwVanWesTransvaalBelgiumZA•

Reading the headline and then OP username, lol

1
Dricatica•

That's just suicide, plain and simple. Ifs it's not ok for some why is it ok for others?

1
tryin2immigrateIndia•

Like 30 year old virgins?

1
archaios12•

I have completed life, this is my high score, I just want to logout.

1
jm7xPortugal•

In the near future, states may enforce assisted suicide for people deemed to have 'completed life' but are not terminally ill...

Wait a minute...

1
dukenPLCAN'T STUMP THE TRUMP•

I do not understand how this can be forbidden currently

1
Gin_Alley_LegendSweden•

Any healthcare professional be that a physician, nurse, pharmacist, whatever, that would aid in the suicide of a physically healthy person is a disgrace to their field and to humanity in general. Assisted suicide should be about allowing people to escape a situation that does not allow for basic human dignity and from which there is no recovering, not about projecting this stupid romantisation of suicide on the healthcare sector.

1