How does everyone feel about Centralization?

I've seen statements from YesCascadia about how their goal is decentralized communities helping each other while at the same time seeing comments like this getting tons of upvote seeming praising centralization as a form of protection.

Just wondering your thoughts.

Posted Nov 24, 2016, 5:59 AM UTC

66
a-brown-bear•

I prefer decentralization. There is state and private centralization.

that comment brings up "reclusive cowboys" and Trump. To me such a situation is more centralization, and not decentralization. Its private centralization.

Between the two I guess I would prefer collective centralization over private. At the end of the day I am more social and communal.

4
filmnutsWashington•

This sub, and Cascadians in general, are pro-decentralization. However, in the case of public lands, the federal government is better equipped to protect them from exploitation than state or local governments. And technically, the since the lands are publicly owned, everyone owns them and the federal government is just stewarding them for us, so in that sense, it's about as decentralized as you can get.

3
1rational_guy•

Dentralization gives power to locals. I support decentralization.

2
rpnon1•

Certain things should be centralized due to the need for consistency (e.g., the justice system, voting) or the need for / benefit of scale (e.g., military, large infrastructure).

In addition, having common standards can be valuable and powerful. These standards, being common, become "centralized". The most obvious is in defining criminal law / what's a crime and what isn't. That should be centralized, as a representation of common values.

But, execution is often best designed and conducted in a decentralized way, allowing for local groups and regions to determine what is best for them given their specific wishes and needs.

So, it's not so much "decentralize" vs. "centralize" but what should be decentralized and what should be centralized.

1
samdo123Washington•

As I Marxist, I obviously support centralization with power being given to the Cascadian governments, along with collectivization of resources within Cascadia. Although as of right now I am supporting the mainstream that Cascadia seems to go with, and believe that once an independent state is achieved that advocating for different systems can follow.

1
rea1l1•

I'm generally against centralization, because throughout history powerful positions have always been sought for the potential profits of those motivated by greed. The more powerful the position, the more likely to be corrupted. I can't reasonably trust anyone trying to get into these positions today.

For the first time in history thanks to technological advancements, we have the ability to not need to depend upon providing trust to stranger celebrities under privately-owned spotlights. We can actually demand government transparency; those who bare power ought voluntarily bare their lives to the world, constantly and wholly, and juries ought be well paid to oversee major government functions. Reports ought be made daily about EVERYTHING, constantly.

We, having and regularly making use of the world's largest military, have the greatest responsibility to reign in the government. Of course, good luck getting them to pass those laws.

1