Mill Reporters Revisited

Discussion

Hi all! I just want to say that even though my initial try at a Mill Rogue was kind of a failure, my new iteration is a lot of fun, especially with all of the Reno decks hanging around.

I cut a lot of extraneous minions from the list above, but I kept the Daring Reporters and the Arcane Giants. They actually help shut down more aggro type decks, as long as they can't close you out by turn 5 or so. If they get perfect draw, you're screwed. But I have cut down the minion count to: 2x Mistress of Mixtures, 1x Brann, 2x Coldlights, 2x Daring Reporters, 1x Emperor, 1x Reno, 2x Arcane Giants.

Everything else is a spell, and ideally one that gives some card draw (FoK, Shiv). I don't play a minion without a specific reason to, basically, although sometimes I'll go ahead and play a Coldlight or Brann just to Shadowstep them, in order to set up a later turn.

I can't say that the deck is perfect by any means, but I feel like it still eats Reno/Control decks for lunch, and has the minions to handle Jade/Midrange, and at least stands a chance against aggro. When I'm off my Chromebook I'll post my actual deck.

EDIT: Link formatting

EDIT 2: Current decklist.

Posted Jan 7, 2017, 11:42 AM UTC · edited

1122
Nishla•

It seems like refreshment vendor would be infinitely better than daring reporter in this deck.

Unless there's a circumstance where you can out race an aggro deck with daring reporter (you have no other tools to do this with so I find that unlikely) I can't see any way it performs better in the aggro match up than vendor.

Against control you don't have many threats so they will likely have the answer to a daring reporter, enabling full value of a card that they would otherwise have to throw away for less value against a regular mill deck or it would clog their hand.

I can maybe see their value maybe against jade decks, but druid is an auto loss anyway if they have some board presence early, and jade rogue is rare.

Cool concept though, I would love to see a mill deck that can perform in the current climate, especially one that includes the never used minions that require filling the opponent's hand

EDIT: do you run conceal? You could get some big damage turns in with daring reporter if you use conceal which could make a difference vs control. Might be worth considering van cleef too which might actually enable you to race aggro if you run preps.

5
ProzacElfOP•

Yeah, ultimately this version is still not that great against aggro, but I'm not certain how much the Refreshment Vendors would help either. As it stands I already need a near perfect draw to deal with aggro (basically get all of my Backstab/Eviscerate/Shiv/Fan of Knives early enough to deal, and hopefully my Mistresses early enough to recover some health). And that gets complicated by the fact that in any matchup that I even think might not be aggro I want to hard mulligan for Gang Up and Coldlight.

I've gone back and forth between Conceal and Cold Blood. Conceal is great specifically for the Reporters and/or to help Brann stick an extra turn, but Cold Blood is also nice to just stick on any of the minions to push that extra bit of damage. I'd like to run both, but I haven't decided what to cut yet.

Anyway, I don't actually have Refreshment Vendor or EVC or Prep, which sort of complicates matters. I do plan to get Van Cleef and the Preps eventually (only got about 200 dust right now since I just crafted Kazakus), but I keep hoping I'll unpack at least one of the three before I worry about having to craft the others.

1
deadrat-•

I love playing mill rogue, but always had to switch decks around rank 18. Let me know if you have more success!

2
ProzacElfOP•

That's about where I ran out of steam with it last season, but I've refined it a bit more and the meta seems to have solidified into a bit more of a Reno-heavy one, so I'm hoping I can push it a bit farther. The question is if I can figure out how to reliably deal with aggro.

1
A2i9•

How about a defender of Argus? Getting it on even 1 reporter/giant would save you quite a lot, won't it?

1
ProzacElfOP•

Probably wouldn't hurt.

2
troublinyo•

I unpacked Nat the darkfisher and never dusted it in hope that mill might be viable sometime. Is your reason for not including it just that you don't have it? Seems fairly handy against aggro too.

1
Stickyw1cket•

I highly doubt darkfisher is good against aggro, the last thing you want to do is give them more resources. The two ways to beat aggro are to race them, or to hold them off until you can stabilise and they've run out of resources.

3
ProzacElfOP•

Darkfisher was the first non-C'thun legendary I got from WotOG. =) I've gone back and forth on including him here, but he very rarely actually mills a card, and he isn't as helpful against aggro as you might like. About the best use I've found for him is if you can get him to stick on the board early and you happen to have both of your Cold Bloods; then you can get an early 12-14 damage before he gets removed.

Generally speaking though most people are smart enough to realize that if you're throwing out a card as bad as Darkfisher that they'd better neutralize it before you can pull off whatever zany plan you have for it. I call it "Angry Chicken Syndrome," where if somebody deliberately put an Angry Chicken in their deck and played it, you'd better get rid of it before they buff the ever-living shit out of it and murder you.

3
Spanospy•

Hmmmmm, I should make an angry chicken deck...

1
mattortz•

I'm wondering why you don't have The Curator instead of Sprint/Gadget. I think Gadget and Sprint will make you cycle too fast. I often find myself with trying to balance my hand with a Coldlight in it. Sprint would just be a placeholder, same with Gadget.

1
ProzacElfOP•

I actually don't run Sprint or Auctioneer in the deck anymore. I've generally found Shiv, FoK, and Coldlight/Shadowstep to be enough to get me by. Curator might not be a bad idea though. I'm sure I could cut a Giant or a Reporter for it.

1
mattortz•

Yup! Two FoK is probably better for the meta currently. May I see your decklist?

While mill Rogue is not my main, it's my favorite.

1
ProzacElfOP•

I'm not currently at a place where I can access it but when I get back to my desktop I'll post it.

1
mattortz•

I might try to fit an Arcane Giant in my mill rogue. Thanks for the idea!

1
ProzacElfOP•

Hey everyone, just letting you know I added my most recent decklist to the OP.

1
ProzacElfOP•

This deck is shit, and I can only recommend it if you like to concede a lot and then maybe win if you get a decent draw against a reno deck.

I've never played a "standard" mill rogue, but I'm convinced that I have managed to do it worse.

EDIT: I'm a little cranky because I've managed to lose 10 straight games, but I think it either means my deck is terrible or I'm totally incompetent. Probably both.

1
ProzacElfOP•

OK, so that was a little overboard there. But I don't think a mill deck can consistently win in this meta. Just too many hyper aggro decks that you're only helping by giving them cards. Maybe I'll try to take it for a spin in Wild later.

1