Is Garden of Terror irredeemable?

Blizzard Response

I think that the majority consensus is that Garden of Terror is the worst map in the game. The pros don't play on it (HGC) and after some tweaks here and there its popularity still remains in the gutter.

I've been thinking about ways that it can be improved and here are some of my thoughts:

Limit sprint to one or two castings per Terror invocation

One of the things that I often read is that it's a chore to chase the Terror around the map trying to kill it. Currently the Terror can use Sprint every 14 seconds until it is destroyed.

What if it was limited to a couple of times? I think it would make it more strategic about when to use it. Do I use it to get to them faster or do I save it for retreating?

Remove Queen's Curse

Why does it even do this? Replace this in favor of the slam with stun that the Kingscrest Horror Boss (http://heroesofthestorm.gamepedia.com/File:Andrew-kinabrew-akinabrew-siege-kingscresthorrorboss.jpg) uses. Or maybe it throws down a seed that creates a poison gas that damages enemy heroes in an area of effect.

Overgrowth

Limiting Sprint's casting to once or twice per incarnation means that the annoying drop an overgrowth so that your team can mop up while I go and do more damage to buildings would be limited. However what if it didn't disable structures instead just making them vulnerable to the Garden Terror for the duration?

Night time

A lot of people have complained that when the map transitions into night mode that it makes it really hard to see and makes ambushing a little too easy. What if there were intermittent bursts of moonlight that lit up random areas around where the Shamblers were at?

Replace mid Siege Giants camp with Sappers

Just a thought, might speed things up

What if there was no Garden Terror at all?

This would be a major reworking but what if there was no Garden Terror at all? What if there was an objective that spawned during day time where you collected seeds by channeling (aka water the ground) these seeds would then be used to summon Shamblers during night time.

There could be a few types of Shamblers, some that charge heroes, grab onto them and slow them (think like the little Murlocs that Murky summons with his Heroic) and some that attack heroes and structures alike (ala the Zerg wave in Braxis holdout).

Those are some of my thoughts on the map but I'd love to hear everyone else's.

If you could rework this map, what would you do?

Posted Feb 13, 2017, 12:56 AM UTC

012
Throw_a_tass•

The pros don't play on it (HGC)

I think HGC uses a rotating map pool (summoning u/eSportsMatt). Garden of Terror, Blackheart's Bay and Haunted Mines are currently out, but that can change.

7
n8mare27•

AFAIK, pros just had kind of a gentleman's agreement, to which blizzard agreed too, on perma-banning these maps, because they are all considered imbalanced at top/pro level and too snowbally for competitive matches. Imo the aren't planned to come back for HGC 2017 unless they're getting a drastic rework.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
eSportsMattBlizzard•

Confirming u/Throw_a_tass comment, those three maps are not currently in play for HGC. The next map change will be after the Mid-Season Brawl.

7
AnologHotsMaster Kerrigan•

I think some of the issues at the root of this idea are self critiquing. For example: -Anticipate the garden terror better and you won't get poly'd, it shows up on the minimap -Communicate and have good map awareness and you'll minimize getting caught out at night I like your suggestions, and think they could make a cool new map. Nerfing things just because they are hard isn't a good way to cultivate a fun and competitive game.
Just my two cents.

3
JudoTrip•

Very little reason for the terror to have sprint.

2
5kad000sh•

actually there is real valid ones ;

late game walking from core to core litterally takes 35-40 sec.

with sprint you limit it to 25-30 sec.

The thing is unlike the dragon knight who spawns in the middle of the map ; garden terrors spawns in the friendly nexus.

On top of that the terror is made as a teamfight tool. She is by far the strongest "hero" in the game in terms of damage/utility and CC. Sprint allows her to have chase and escape potential.

I agree that the terror is freaking strong. But that's the point of the map : having the ability to change a hero that is the least useful in fights ('wether because he used his ult already or because he's meant as a utility tool) into a teamfight/push monster.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Shadow3ragonMaster Alarak•

Garden is fine... worst map is blackhearts bay no question..

That's the map that pros never ever touch.

1
o8livion||<[]>||•

Even when I was new I hated blackheart's bay.

1
Koshzor•

Hunted mines still worse

1
CamRothMaster Medivh•

I really have no problem with this map.

1
theKalash6.5 / 10•

The map is fine. I like especially because games are longer. Not all maps need to encourage hardcore snowballing.

1
TVAntigone•

Overall cool ideas - even if i don´t agree with all of them. At least someone is talking about my least-favorite map. What annoys me the most, is that a terror, even at 5-8 minutes, will kill your keep if it´s only defended by one hero. Sure, the enemy team didn´t react, but does that mean that the keep should go down? No other objective in any map does that.

1
YoreWelcomeMaster Nova•

I kind of like the idea of leaving things as they are, but then the seeds collected send zerg, I mean shambler waves at the enemy, alternating lanes like Braxis. I like that a lot actually. The garden terror as hero vehicle is somewhat frustrating and doesn't feel as fun as the dragon knight.

EDIT: Actually, what if you send shambler waves... but the catch is that you always spawn a garden terror each night/day cycle, but your earned shamblers are more powerful if your GT is with them, and vice versa, instead of by itself?

1