The End of the YouTube Annotations Editor - May 2nd
youtube-creators.googleblog.com/2017/03/keep-...Posted Mar 16, 2017, 5:36 PM UTC
Posted Mar 16, 2017, 5:36 PM UTC
So, I'm just wondering what people should use to actually, you know, annotate the videos.
Should people use subtitles for that now? Seems like that is not intended, but if that's what's supposed to happen, then that's fine
If they want to subtitle the videos then they should use subtitles, yes.
Most of the other "legit" creators that used annotations used them mostly for creating their own end cards / end screens. Cards replace most of anything else not covered by end screens.
Subtitles aren't a suitable tool to replace annotations. I understand why Youtube wants to do this. Having 5 annotations covering more than 50% of the screen for the duration of the video is annoying and unneeded, but I watch several creators who teach boardgames and if they make rule mistakes, they annotate that after the fact. It's a critical tool to being able to continue to make videos for these folks.
Maybe limit the annotations in some way, but don't take them away.
Could they not just edit in, in-video text overlays using their editing program to do that? That shouldn't require annotations, just a bit of extra care before publishing the video. (Given that annotations never worked on any device but Desktop / PCs anyway meaning 60% of viewers of those videos would not have seen the corrections if they were annotations.)
The problem is these "goofs" are found by viewers days, weeks, even months after posting the video... so the annotations are added as they're discovered, with explanations of what the error was. I suspect most of the viewers of these videos are watching on computers and not mobile.
I could just see youtube saying that subtitles should be used for things actually said in the audio, not for any supplementary data. But if that's the not case, then that's probably what I'll recommend as a replacement when people start asking
I watch some guy that uses annotations for Let's Plays. Well, this is a sad sight.
This is like that time when video responses were removed as well.
You did that joke on purpose didn't you.
I think Annotations have definitely been misused in the past, mostly with people just cluttering the entire screen with them for the entire video. But I do feel like they still have some current value. Making corrections to content without having to reupload the whole video, directing people to other videos and such, all things that aren't really that outdated or harmful to the content itself. I don't really see the point of forcefully removing them. I get they don't work on mobile, which sucks, but I still feel they have some value on the site. If they're outdated let them fade into irrelevance, but doing it forcefully seems excessive.
Corrections for me is a big point. I think just the power of being able to communicate directly to the audience in your video after it is set in stone is a big feature we're losing.
You are posting those corrections in the assumption they'll reach your audience. They do not. 60% of watch time is happening on mobile (70+% of users using mobile), and another chunk can be attributed to tablets, game consoles, SmartTVs and desktop users who have annotations turned off by default. Realistically, you're reaching a quarter of your viewers with those corrections.
That said, a feature to allow corrections (perhaps in the design of the "this video contains product placement" notification) that works everywhere would be great.
I checked out cards, and it looks like they're limited to promoting other content, merchandising, that sort of thing. How am I supposed to do things like link to research sources or make corrections? Is dumping them into the description the only option now?
Exactly! Cards/end screen doesn't replace the functionality of annotations
Annotations were never a good way of doing this either as they only ever showed on Desktop, meaning approx. 60% of viewers would not see these sources / corrections anyway.
I'd recommend linking sources in the description instead.
60% is the average. I'm sure it's lower for channels with videos that wouldn't work well on a small screen in the first place, like mine.
You can link to your website which then contains the source, like here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OQxEGLOFyto
I am a content creator who will be very negatively affected by this decision. I make hundreds of free, educational videos used by thousands of university students around the world.
Annotations are essential for organization and discovery within my channel. I use them to indicate next and previous videos, updates to videos, typo and verbal error correction, guiding users into playlists, as well as linking to other courses chapters, or associated videos.
6% of my direct traffic (and much more indirectly) comes from annotations, and my click-through ratio is 3500% higher than the values the blog post cites. 80% of my traffic is desktop, and that hasn't changed for years, as it's difficult to study from a phone screen.
Cards and end screens do not achieve any of these tasks in a timely, efficient, or non-intrusive manner.
We all hate users who use annotations as click traps for useless bullshit. But when used effectively in the appropriate context, annotations provide a vital functionality which no other feature on the site comes close to replicating.
YouTube decision makers seriously need to reconsider this choice, as it costs virtually nothing to maintain this simple, existing feature, and not doing so adversely affects far more creators than me, as the comments on the original post clearly indicate.
This is absolutely horrible. Annotations should only be removed once end cards are a good replacement. My outro lasts 50 seconds during which I pitch my Patreon, social media, past videos / playlists etc. The 20 second limit alone is bad, let alone the bulkiness of these cards and lack of customization.
Longer than 20 seconds would be bad because people would place them randomly over content in the video.
You should focus on lowering your end-caard time instead. Any gains you make on directing people to playlists etc. will be wiped out by YouTube recommending your videos less because your watch % is low when the majority of people don't watch the last minute of any video.
I'd also recommend not directing people to social media from your end cards (only put them on your channel or deep in your descriptions for those who go looking for your social media), the reason for this is that YouTube penalises your video's recommendations ranking when you cause a viewer to end their viewing session by navigating off of YouTube to another website.
people would place them randomly over content in the video
It's almost like they need a feature to annotate the videos ¯\(ツ)/¯
As someone who only uses annotations to link to the next video in a series, this is very bad. Not even to mention those that use them to correct incorrect information in their video. They fill a function that nothing else fill. Please, reconsider this YouTube.
Agreed 1000 times. That and a dozen other functions. Once you have more than a few videos in a series it's impossible to organize for easy discover and a pleasant user experience without annotations.
Can you not organise them by putting them into a playlist? If you do this and mark this playlist as a 'series' playlist, then YouTube will always recommend the next video in the series playlist in the "Watch Next" / autoplay list for viewers.
I make extensive use of playlists, as well as series playlists where the ability exists. The primary limitations are that you can only place a video into one series playlist, and "up next" links to not keep / bring users into the playlist environment.
Often there are multiple logical levels of organization desired (sort by course, sort by chapter, sort by topic), and only one level can be chosen as a series. Additionally when users are in the playlist they can use the right-side window for scroll searching the entire list without clicking to the playlist page.
Additionally there are "review" videos which briefly cover the contents of a chapter or course with links in each screen section to the appropriate video or chapter of that content. Cards are limited to a max of 5, cannot be placed into the proper screen location, and don't remain visible for the desired amount of time.
These videos keep a static notes slide image available to the user for the duration of the video without obstruction. Cards are intrusive for that purpose compared to static corner annotations which may be clicked at any time and link into the playlist.
My descriptions have many other links which users often want to be aware of, including course and chapter introduction, playlist, and review videos, as well as other courses. Though these are always in the description they have much higher engagement through my end slate annotations, which the end screen feature cannot reproduce (4 links max if you're lucky).
If I make a typo or verbal error, I can correct it easily with a brief on-screen annotation, and cards provide no replacement for this. Placing corrections in the description still results in comments asking about the error, and aren't sufficient.
If I upload a new version of the video, it takes months before the new one rises to a similar height within search, even when replacing the thumbnail and title with "(old version)". Even with a description link to the new video, users frequently end up watching the old one. A single on-screen annotation link to the new video kills traffic to the old video and redirects discovery to the new video 10 times more effectively, because it kills the watch time for the old one, making YouTube's algorithm prioritize the new.
There are dozens of cases where properly used annotations provide high-engagement value with no current functional replacement. I understand that cards and end screens are probably better for the average creator, but their are many niches where annotations are still heavily used and needed.
As someone who only uses annotations to link to the next video in a series, this is very bad
This is exactly what end-cards are meant to be used for though and the benefit being that end cards show up on all devices whereas annotations only ever displayed to viewers using the Desktop site / youtube.com
I use annotations at both the start and end of the video. Also I prefer the look of annotations.
Not sure how I feel about this. Annotations get a much better CTR than cards for me.
FUCK YOU, YOUTUBE.
Annotations are so much more flexible. I use them for specific video types. And here they are just saying fuck you to everyone who does.
I use annotations to jump between the sections of my review videos. Its an amazingly useful navigation tool. Fuck off. I use the endcards, too... Because they're better for certain situations. Don't just go and rip away options when the new system is super inflexible.
Fuck off youtube. Just let us use the old system as we please. You don't need to support it or update it to work with new stuff like mobile. Just let us keep using it.
Also see the YouTube Help Centre Article: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/7342737
I think this is great news, annotations just annoy me... the new end cards are so much better - so no more screens cluttered with them, at least on new videos after May 2nd.
I set up a poll to try and get idea of what kind of impact this change might have.
I agree that annotations needed an overhaul and that they can be abused and annoying, but I don't think Cards replace all of the functionality of Annotations yet.
It's a good change really - a lot of creators don't know that 40-90% of their viewers wont see the annotations, and most use of them was spammy.
That's more of a flaw with YouTube's implementation of mobile into its platform than an issue with annotations.
You cannot put annotations on mobile because annotations are mobile unfriendly by design:
You can cover the entire screen in invisible, clickable annotations. If you want to pause the video, on desktop, you can just hover above the video and click the pause button, if you want to leave, you can close the tab. On mobile, it's impossible to do anything without clicking an annotation.
Text annotations face another issue: Phones are smaller than desktops, ^[citation ^needed] so scaling down the annotations to keep the relative size to the video may result in the text being unreadable. Not scaling down the annotation may result in different annotations overlapping, or annotations bleeding over into vital parts of the content.
[deleted]
This is fantastic. I practically applauded when my YouTube rep let me know it was happening the other day.
Your shoe shiner didn't tell you first?
Not about this, but he told me about the thing tomorrow.
Applaud the removal of flexible video interaction? Sigh
What do you feel they do that isn't a novelty and is actually effective? We saw some good results for them for a period, but that has waned over the past 18 months. The cleaner options of cards and end screens are driving much more effective engagement for us.
And as a viewer I have always loathed annotations. 99% they were baloney and not any kind of interaction tool for me.
That's just stupid. Annotations are flexible and capable of being used in a lot of ways. They serve a million and a half purposes that end screens and cards don't come close to. For example, I do reviews where you can jump between sections by using annotation buttons. I've seen LPs that use it like a table of content for longer videos with navigation buttons. Others here talk about how they use it to build a designed discovery system that the new stuff can't even come to replicating. There are so many ways they've been used, and Youtube has done jack shit in actually replacing that flexibility.
Whether it works on mobile or not, this is just a big 'fuck you' to everyone who wants to be the least bit creative with their episode/video structures. Applauding the removal just makes you seem like a dick that is more concerned with your own little world that the actual impact. All this does is remove options, and that's stupid.
That it's possible to use them in a bunch of different ways doesn't mean that they are utilized in such a fashion by a high percentage of channels. While I don't particularly put all of my trust in YouTube, I'm pretty sure they looked at the numbers and decided it was a feature not worth the overhead of maintaining at this point for a more standardized experience. I'm okay with that as a producer and as a viewer.
If you want to talk about edge cases, my company was one of the few that actually used the old bumper feature quite heavily and we were gutted when it was taken away, so I can sympathize. We still adapted.
As someone who also worked in the music industry for a long time, yeah, using annotations to program a whole album within a single video was a thing for a while, but increasingly music on YouTube is consumed through mobile and via the music service through art tracks. There's not much of a reason to keep the feature for that use, either, in that light.
The statistic about annotation usage drops is manufactured and misleading, since entering into the end card program removed the annotations section from the video manager.
I actually think annotations would help for my videos. The way my videos are set up there are 4 different parts, and having an annotations to skip to the next one using a timestamp would've definitely helped me..
personally I prefer the end cards better. The ones at the end of the video where you can promote your stuff and channel, it's perfect.
Now, I use only end sceen, I like it
I'm certainly giving up on engaging with someone who can't bring and actual argument to the table and just wants to get angry at folks with different opinions. Please, have the last word!
Great change, now I won't have to keep turning them off because channels decide to make annotations covering 20% of the video for the whole duration..
Now all we need is a tutorial popup / modal for first-time users of the end cards to tell them how to use them properly rather than placing them over the end of the actual content of the video. (Some end-card graphices / templates to choose from could be a nice idea to include too, for creators with less experience in editing / photoshop)
I hate those videos, specially the ones with multiple huge annotations that cover the whole screen so when you try to pause the video by clicking on the screen, you accidentally click one of those annotations that will direct you somewhere else.
I remember when annotations were first released, there was an option for allowing other users to add annotations to the video with a secret link. I remember a couple videos where the uploaders made their secret link public in the video description... you'd get hundreds of funny annotations from random people, ascii art, and swastikas made out of annotation boxes covering the screen. That function didn't last very long...