How has Linux improved since 2008-2013?

Discussion

I've attempted to use Linux off and on around 2008-2013. Stuff like Ubuntu, Linux Mint, Debian and Slax. I haven't stuck with it for a few reasons:

1 - Things break too easily.

(Basically the tl;dr of this entire post - things break too easily for power users, or even basic users, and require needless, annoying troubleshooting.)

I constantly had problems when installing and running a Linux distro. Hardware doesn't get detected. Problems sometimes require manual fixes to config files. You're probably going to need to ask for help on a Q&A site when things don't work. Once you're up an running, glitches can occur, X11 can freeze and crash. You might have access to an F1-F12 terminal but you have no clue what to do, and you simply reboot. Hardware problems can persist even after installation, maybe Wi-Fi or Ethernet doesn't work, etc. USB devices may not work.

2 - Most software is distributed in source code, and is not guaranteed to work.

Unless the software you want to use is very common and in most package repositories, you're probably limited to source-code only. I've had an extremely high failure rate when attempting to build/run these programs. 99% of the time, it won't compile. Or you don't have the specific version of a dependency. Even a .deb binary file can tell you to fuck off with dependency errors. There are tons of obscure Linux software on Sourceforge/GitHub, that may be old, abandoned, etc, and aren't in package repo's. It's near to impossible to get them to run.

3 - User-interface inconsistencies

Sometimes when you open a program that has a GUI or 'window', it can glitch the fuck out. It won't close, or it won't show up in the taskbar, or the titlebar disappears, and you can't move the window. You might expect Drag/drop, box-selection or clipboard to work but it doesn't. I also remember being unable to revert changes I did, trying to customize GNOME2.


I like to think I know how to operate a PC, I am a decent coder (non-professional), I like to automate shit with scripts, make apps, but in my experience, desktop Linux is not that user-friendly. In Windows, I can do relatively complicated things and not have to worry about bricking or needing to reinstall my system.

I don't always want to troubleshoot, hit up Q&A, find guides, just to get an OS working and running, and getting software on it. Linux is supposed to be super 'stable', but I feel like it's only stable if you either know exactly what's going on, or if you don't touch anything at all.

I'd love to use Linux as a main OS, but it's more of a headache than a joy. Doing something even remotely involved requires caution, because things can go wrong and often difficult to know why. In order to know your way around it and be comfortable, you need training, practice, experience - a learning curve that most people aren't willing to take. I'd rather spend most of my time being productive, using the OS, instead of tracking down each problem that crops up.

So it's now 2017 and I'm wondering if there are any exciting advancements, or if there is a bright future over the horizon. I'd love to see a Linux distro come out that makes Windows pale in comparison, so that gamers, gurus and grandmothers alike don't have to be Linux enthusiasts or sysadmins anymore to get the most out of it.

Also as a side thought, sometimes I wonder if everyone worked together to make one amazing distro, it could truly be a Windows killer, why does there have to be so many distros, spreading everyone out, just to have so many of them end up abandoned, like Crunchbang etc. There's only so many variants of an OS that could be considered important/essential.

Posted Mar 18, 2017, 5:07 PM UTC

3050
electricheatGentoo + Ubuntu + Debian + CentOS•

1 - Things break too easily.

If you're on anything near common hardware, and using a well polished distro, the issues here won't be a problem.

2 - Most software is distributed in source code, and is not guaranteed to work.

This makes me suspicious you we causing yourself problems. As a linux newbie, don't install things from source code. Stick to things in the repositories. Use third party repos if you must. Only compile from source as an absolute last choice. I can expand on the reasons for this if you'd like.

Chances are the programs you were trying to install by source or downloaded deb files were already in the Ubuntu repositories or PPAs, but you didn't realize it.

3 - User-interface inconsistencies

What you describe here sounds like you broke something, or had hardware issues. I haven't experienced this type of thing except when I've done the same.


tl;dr: I think you fell into the windows power user trap: trying to solve problems by blazing your own trail rather than following the distribution's best practices.

my advice: install (x/l/k)ubuntu, and stick to the repos. Read the ubuntu wiki. Google your questions and learn the right way to solve problems. Linux gives you a lot of rope. Don't hang yourself with it.

edit: Oh, some good news though: Pulseaudio works now, and wifi is rarely a problem. There were some growing pains for a while there.

22
SirNanigansGlorious Arch•

I second the "windows power user trap" possibility.

I went from Windows right into Arch. Because Arch was such a radical change (requiring me to start my Linux experience with a series of cli commands), I ended up forfeiting my habitual windows approach and just reading the wiki and following instruction.

I have never had any problems with troubleshooting things. It's seldom that I must, and when I must it takes less than 10 minutes. I'm certain that if I didn't tinker and experiment then I would almost never have to troubleshoot. If I started with a familiar GUI, I might have wasted hours digging through a file browser or settings menu to find solutions when they were only a couple commands away.

The best way to approach Linux at first is with a blank slate mentality, willing to follow written instructions without assuming you already know anything.

9
legend6546Glorious Gentoo•

For me the best option was to slowly back into it. I first dual booted windows 8.1 and unbuntu (gross) and I slowly got more confortable in linux. Installing unbuntu was a challenge for me but I eventually got through it and I eventually upgraded to linux mint. I got a "new" laptop (thinkpad x61) and I first installed unbuntu on it. I eventually moved to debian and Arch and then finally gentoo.

My favorite operating systems are

  • Linux Mint

It just works, and I have never had any problems with it.

*Debian

Debian is extremely stable, it can take a little work to set up but it is stable once it is set up.

*Gentoo

it is a cool os that can be very minimal but requires a lot of work to set up.

edit formating

1
massReducedOP•

This makes me suspicious you we causing yourself problems. As a linux newbie, don't install things from source code.

I was probably in over my head trying to run super obscure apps. mmsap was one of those programs.

3
electricheatGentoo + Ubuntu + Debian + CentOS•

Yep. That is a bit obscure.

I decided to try playing one. It seems to Just Work in VLC and mplayer in Ubuntu 16.04 without further configuration

5
amyyyyyyyyyy•

Unity still has inconsistencies with scroll bars and stuff like that

1
electricheatGentoo + Ubuntu + Debian + CentOS•

Unity still has inconsistencies with scroll bars and stuff like that

Yeah totally, but that's not the kind of thing OP was complaining about:

Sometimes when you open a program that has a GUI or 'window', it can glitch the fuck out. It won't close, or it won't show up in the taskbar, or the titlebar disappears, and you can't move the window.

1
trashcan86Graphics Driver Hell•

Hell, I have a GTX 1060 laptop, which is probably as much of a pain in the ass as it gets (new <4mo Optimus NVIDIA GPU) and everything works other than multimonitor, and this can be done with configuration.

1
_vargs_Linux Mint•

About me: I like getting things done and dislike having an OS standing in the way.

The following remarks are Linux Mint-specific. I do not know how things stand in other distros.

  • Things break too easily -> Things work out of the box

It's been a year since I installed LM 18 and so far I haven't had a single hardware-related problem.

I have my laptop connected to an external monitor via a DisplayPort cable. The only configuration I had to do was opening Settings -> Display and setting the monitor as my main screen. It was a dead-simple process.

In order to transfer books from my computer to my Kobo e-reader, I just have to connect the two devices via a USB cable and drag-and-drop the books in Calibre.

If I want to open a .pdf or a .torrent file, I can rest assured I have the necessary software installed.

  • Most software is distributed in source code, and is not guaranteed to work. -> Most software is packaged and all you need to install it is double-click the .deb file.

On the rare occasions I have to install something that isn't in the Software Manager, I just download a .deb file and double-click it. This way all the dependencies get installed too.

Afterwards, the program will be found with the plethora of others in the Software Manager and if I decide to uninstall it I just have to click the 'Remove' button.

  • User-interface inconsistencies -> Standardised interface

Of all the programs I run on the computer, all of them (with the exception of Chrome) share the same interface in regards to window borders. I am yet to experience the issues you described.

why does there have to be so many distros, spreading everyone out

This is a real problem. Also, users of lesser-known distros tend to be very vocal (See this). My mantra about this is: Start with Linux Mint if you have work to be done, experiment with other distros afterwards.

TL;DR: Things just work now.

18
OpenSourceSocialistGlorious Solus•

In Chrome, I think you can right-click on the space at the top of the program and press "Use system window something".

10
_vargs_Linux Mint•

You are correct about this. I have it disabled, though, because it makes the window frame twice as wide.

2
yourhardboiledSolus•

Yeah, that works, but you still have the ugly user-switcher button and a full titlebar above it.

1
massReducedOP•

I think most of my problems either came from hardware incompatibilities/inaccuracies, sound, or me just getting in over my head trying to install custom themes or random ass programs from source that won't compile without making a sacrifice to the moon god.

This is a real problem. Also, users of lesser-known distros tend to be very vocal (See this). My mantra about this is: Start with Linux Mint if you have work to be done, experiment with other distros afterwards.

Haha. Arch was actually one distro i was recommended as far back as 2010. Said I wouldn't encounter any compilation errors since it always had the most up-to-date libraries, but no way was I going to take the time to set everything up from scratch. Nothing against Arch as I'm sure its good for learning/projects.

As someone pointed out, despite all the distros, a lot of the work is concentrated on the kernel, desktop environments, which is shared between them usually. But an OS is more than just a kernel and DE.

3
S-O-What•

Haha. Arch was actually one distro i was recommended as far back as 2010. Said I wouldn't encounter any compilation errors since it always had the most up-to-date libraries, but no way was I going to take the time to set everything up from scratch. Nothing against Arch as I'm sure its good for learning/projects.

If you like to compile random shit on the internet, the best distribution is Ubuntu since it's the most common distribution and therefore the most likely to be tested.

2
rubik3x3x3•

It sounds like you don't actually like Linux at all. Maybe you're better off with Mac OS. It's the same general idea but more user friendly.

I've not experienced any of the issues you described. Perhaps you're over complicating your utilization of certain tools and resources.

If your question is, "is it better now" then the only person who can answer that is yourself. Load up a live USB, virtual box, or spare hard drive and find out for yourself.

12
massReducedOP•

I often get motion sickness when riding roller coasters, doesn't mean I don't like them or won't ride one again.

I just couldn't get past the problems (in Linux). Sound was another thing, it never worked consistently, Jack/Pulse/OSS/ALSA etc.

Sure I could install somewhere and see if anything is different/better, but I am wondering if others had similar experiences or problems, and if they ended up being resolved as distros received more updates and stuff.

Perhaps you're over complicating your utilization of certain tools and resources.

Well, seeking out some of the most obscure, outdated linux programs out there was probably asking for trouble. mmSAP for example hasn't really been updated since 2012.

Also, fuck Mac OS X and Apple, they are garbage.

4
rubik3x3x3•

Well sound was a big issue a few years ago, but it's quite a lot more stable now. You should watch the newest "Linux sucks" video on youtube

https://youtu.be/SMKeWTVYBUo

5
wotaniiGlorious Ubuntu•

It sounds like you don't actually like Linux at all.

how did you come to this conclusion?

1
tiduxArch in production•

Unless the software you want to use is very common and in most package repositories, you're probably limited to source-code only. I've had an extremely high failure rate when attempting to build/run these programs. 99% of the time, it won't compile.

This is a "git gud, fagget" problem and not a "Linux" problem.

6
killerstorm•

A lot of problems you mentioned boil down to hardware support. There are many thousands of devices on the market, and it's simply not feasible/possible to support all of them. Sometimes a company releases a Linux driver, but it only comes in binary form/is shitty/etc.

You will enjoy Linux much better when it happens to support hardware you use. In that case it is even grandma-friendly, more so than Windows.

As for software, well, Debian/Ubuntu repos have something like 10000 packages, which are incredibly easy to install. If you happen to need something unusual which isn't in these packages, then you might have bad luck...

Also as a side thought, sometimes I wonder if everyone worked together to make one amazing distro, it could truly be a Windows killer,

Important work which is done on kernel, desktop environments and applications is shared among all distros.

Most distros are only different in superficial detail and do not require a lot of work. So I really doubt we'd get much progress simply by cutting a number of distros.

5
aaronfrankeXubuntu 16.04 + Windows 9 (and Arch in a VM)•

Linux has changed A LOT since 2013. If you haven't tried it since, you basically missed all of the awesome improvements caused by Valve getting the ball rolling with Linux.

  1. Most things don't need any configuration at all these days. The Linux kernel has a metric ton of drivers and popular distros like Ubuntu keep everything working well.

  2. 99.9% of the time it's either in the repos or available as a .deb. I very rarely compile anything.

  3. Don't have that problem on XFCE. I assume that's a DE-specific thing.

I can pretty much just direct people to this page or at least my Linux-tools repo and they can be good to go.

Linux definitely is better for automating shit with scripts, you just need to learn what script you need.

Generally speaking, unless you have a specific need for another distro, it's pretty universally accepted that you can just pick up an Ubuntu flavor and be done. What's nice is that software is almost always intercompatible with Ubuntu variants so you can choose whatever one you like without worrying about compatibility.

4
massReducedOP•

DE

Probably. Either that or WM, or conflicts between Qt/GTK etc etc. It's been a while.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Deliphindistrohoppapotamus•

patience*

3
ArmedMilitia•

The latest version of Linux mint has way better driver support out of the box, I noticed I didn't have to fuck around with anything when I upgraded.

3
SweetBearCub•

And yet, Linux Mint was throwing up fatal errors for me about being unable to install GRUB, and it seems for many other users as well.

For example, here: https://forums.linuxmint.com/viewtopic.php?f=46&t=241379 - Screenshots showing the error are at the bottom of the 1st post.

TL;dr - Linux Mint is clearly not bug free.

For what it's worth, Xubuntu 16.04.2 LTS installed just fine. This is not to say that any Linux variant is bug free, though.

1
5had0w5talk3rI reject your desktop and replace it with my own.•

I''ve never really encountered any of your issues in the 6+ I've used Linux, but you might want to give ElementaryOS a try since they focus a lot on UX. It's based on Ubuntu so there's a ton of software pre-compiled for it and available either through the repositories or through PPAs.

2
massReducedOP•

Weird. A lot of people only have positive experiences. Have you switched between window managers before, like metacity/fluxbox? That's how the titlebars fucked up and disappeared for me.

0
5had0w5talk3rI reject your desktop and replace it with my own.•

At some point I had constructed my own DE (hence the flair) and with some careful tinkering I got it all working pretty much fine. Modern WMs are perfectly fine and you'd be hard pressed to have a reason to actually switch whatever the desktop ships with.

1
massReducedOP•

I believe I was trying to install certain themes that used stuff like fluxbox/emerald and getting it to work wasn't as easy/stable as I'd hoped.

1
5had0w5talk3rI reject your desktop and replace it with my own.•

I see. Plenty of great and varied themes for Qt and GTK+ though, which largely work on most DEs default WM just fine. If you're still after that kind of look, I believe Zorin ships with something visually similar to that. I've never used it though, so I can't tell much more about it than that. :P

1
KlipperKyle•

Since 2013 (and especially since 2008), hardware support has improved a lot. Even wifi drivers work out of the box most of the time. Open source graphics drivers for Intel and AMD have become really good, and Xorg works out of the box.

And sound just works now because everything is routed through PulseAudio.

3 - User-interface inconsistencies

This is the one area that has actually regressed quite horribly. There is a lot more fragmentation now than a few years ago because nobody can agree on a common way to do things.

  • Gnome 3 was developed in a completely different direction from Gnome 2. Users revolted and migrated to XFCE and LXDE. The MATE project was started to continue Gnome 2 development and continues strong to this day.
  • Circa 2008-2010, there were two big desktop players: Gnome and KDE. However, Gnome 3 completely fragmented the desktop space by initiating a mass exodus from Gnome to smaller oddball desktops.
  • There used to be two main toolkits: GTK and Qt. Now, there are two versions of GTK (2 and 3), and they are completely incompatible with each other. Themes rarely work across both versions of GTK. Qt now has two versions in wide use (4 and 5). And now other oddball toolkits (such as Electron) are popping up.
  • Because of the fragmentation of toolkits, creating a common visual theme across everything is very hard, if not impossible. Creating a readable visual theme across everything is even harder.
  • GTK3 development is heavily influenced by Gnome 3. GTK3 applications frequently draw their own window captions, which break most window managers (because traditionally window managers were responsible for drawing window captions).
  • LXDE (the GTK2 version) is almost dead. The author is busy rewriting the whole desktop in Qt because he would rather maintain Qt applications than GTK3 applications.
  • XFCE and MATE are rewriting their applications in GTK3. The result: some applications use GTK2, and others use GTK3.
2
ZweiffelTux•

I think a lot of things have changed since 2013. That's when Steam came to Linux. Hundreds of games are now on Linux, drivers have improved a lot, etc. But I think nobody can tell you if you'll like Linux now, only way to find out is to try it. I didn't have major issues like you and I never had to build a program I needed from source. Maybe a bit of luck is needed for the hardware to work out of the box, if it doesn't, there may still be a solution, but it depends on whether you're willing to put some effort into trying to fix it.

1
aaronfrankeXubuntu 16.04 + Windows 9 (and Arch in a VM)•

Hundreds of games are now on Linux

Thousands.

5
massReducedOP•

As someone who dealt with fucking Tux Racer and Frozen Bubble, that is good news

3
smog_aladoGlorious OpenSuse•

Dude, don't treat Frozen Bubble like that!

2
doc_brietzDnf update your life!•

Back in 2000 or so I tried Mandrake Linux for my Gateway PC. Nothing much was supported and it never even installed. I thought Linux was for nerds who enjoyed a painful experience. Anyhow, Around the end of 2015 I decided to try Linux again because I was going to school to learn PC and networking repair and I needed to expand my knowledge base. I installed OpenSuse Leap on the Lab PC that I used for work at school, an older Opensuse VM for my Linux class, and setup a dual boot with 8.1 windows and fedora 23. I made myself use Linux and for the most part everything I did in windows I could do in Linux.

Linux is getting to the point where you don't have to do everything in terminal. Most hardware is supported. I think if you pick between Ubuntu, OpenSuse, Mint, and Fedora you will be fine. You can probably throw debian, zorin, elementary and deepin in there as well. You want something with a broad support base. I think right now there are between 5-10 solid linux Operating Systems that are good for every day use and will do everything you need them to. Out of those 5-10, I feel very confident with 3-4 of them.

If you need any more info, just ask.

1
EvalelynnGlorious Fedora•

I'd hazard against Fedora if only for things breaking more often then I'd like (particularly if you have NVidia), and SELinux (and don't you dare disable it).

1
doc_brietzDnf update your life!•

You can disable SELinux and it works fine. I just said fedora because I liked it and ran it for a while. I may have had a few issues here and there, and the learning curve is a little steeper (not archlinux steep) but it works fine. Of course most everyone's experience is different.

1
stevwillsCause Its Fun and the aur works well•

I may sound like a complete douche but arch isnt that hard to use. Yes i agree that the install is hard compared to next next install. But once youve finished installing everything, it becomes easy to maintain. Pacman is by far my favorite package manager and the aur removes the need to add repos. Cause pretty much everything is in the aur. Yes the install is steep but using it as a system is less tedeous than ubuntu in some regards.

1
InconsiderateBastardGlorious Ubuntu GNOME•

Kind of hard to answer the question. My mom was on Linux for years and loved it. She bought herself a new windows 10 laptop and tried that and had things change and freak out so many times she made me install Linux on that too.

For her, Windows is too easy to break, too inconsistent, too hard to get good hardware support (out of the box wifi and touchpad issues).

I'm in a similar boat. My daily driver machines run Ubuntu GNOME LTS with i3wm. I spent an hour styling and setting up the different programs I wanted to use and it's rock solid right down to old flatbed scanners with no windows drivers past xp that run out of the box on any modern Linux distro. Windows had just become too much of an inconsistent and poorly performing mess for day to day usage.

But I have cobbled together a gaming PC from hardware with hazy Linux support. I run the most recent versions of software and distro, opting to compile the latest versions of many things instead of relying on the repos. When everything works it runs great, but it's not a user friendly setup.

My point with all this is that your usage will dictate a lot about how your experience goes.

Edit: and regarding the windows killer comment, I don't think it's going to ever happen. Windows is built on a foundation of shoving new stuff in haphazardly, breaking it's API with new releases, and then manually tweaking things to cater to the important programs. It's a recipe for the mess we get with Windows 10. Linux isn't going to operate that way and it's part of what I like about it. I think their way caters to getting the newest games and graphics hardware now, but it's not worth the baggage it brings.

1
EvalelynnGlorious Fedora•

Windows? API Breakage? Pffft, their problem is that they /don't/ break APIs, even to the point of keeping security vulnerabilities from 9X series.

1
InconsiderateBastardGlorious Ubuntu GNOME•

They keep some parts forever, and then other parts they inexplicably change or get rid of. My favorite example is getting the version of Windows a program is running on. If it could be running on 9x and up you jump through hoops to figure out what it is using getversion because they had to change behaviour of that over the years and now it's just deprecated and will show NT 6.2 on Windows 8.1 or later unless you manifest the program for a specific version.

I believe changes to the API are why there are application specific shims in the application compatibility toolkit. To keep important programs working across big changes to the OS from version to version.

1
wotaniiGlorious Ubuntu•

1 - Things break too easily.

2 - Most software is distributed in source code, and is not guaranteed to work.

For me the old "clone, make, make install" seems break a lot of things under the hood. I don't care very much for trouble shooting so I just format once or twice a year.

3 - User-interface inconsistencies

yes. This became a nightmare when I switched to 4k. For me the worst offenders are proprietary ports like steam and teamviewer. And also everything wine related. Everything based on gtk seems fine though.

To avoid those issues I try to stick as close to the mainstream as possible. And whenever I do a "make install" I schedule the next format in a couple of months.

1
malt2048fstab is the best!•

Use Checkinstall, and never worry about being unable to remove a source-built package ever again.

2
utdconsq•

With respect, when something glitches out horribly on Windows or Mac, how do you solve your problem? Because I have to use both those operating systems for work and while MacOS practically never falls over badly, any serious issue I usually just reboot. Why? Because having things work again I'd more important for my time and sanity than trying to figure out what crazy small thing went wrong.

1
muffinstatewide32M'Linux•

Full discolure, I became a user in 2011, so Im not really sure about how far we've come since '07. But I can surely say that we've come a very very long way since 2011.

1 - Things break too easily.

the only breakages I can report are NVIDIA GPU related and most likely because the graphics stack underneath changed massively and DKMS didnt help. Other than that, on desktops and servers everything seems rock solid. I no longer have random breakages after kernel updates

2 - Most software is distributed in source code, and is not guaranteed to work.

Before I answer, I need to get ths out of my system. There's no garauntee an exe works, the fact that there is an exe for Windows merely means it compiles, there's absolutely no garauntee that a .rpm (or any other package for that fact) works, the same is true for an exe or dmg.

One aspect of your gripe is actually being addressed, although rather slowly (from a user facing perception), and that is dependencies or the need to compile. to add to the chaos that is packaging, we now have appimages, snaps and flatpaks. all of these packages come with all libraries necessary and are sandboxed so that they dont mess with the rest of the system, this solves the obscure dependancy issue, but still gives no garauntees that things work.

3 - User-interface inconsistencies

I've not had that since I used an AMD card and then Unity circa 2014. the most inconsistent my desktop gets now is whether the app uses CSD or regular titlebars.

So it's now 2017 and I'm wondering if there are any exciting advancements

To be blunt, aside from seeing working Flatpaks and maybe working snaps that give a GUI. It's pretty boring at the moment.

why does there have to be so many distros?

why does there need to be more than one version of windows? It's essentially the same thing in each version. The same is true for distros and the answer is very similar. The intended audience is defferent in each case.

OpenSUSE - Our distribution focuses on stability and flexibility, providing you a platform to Get Things Done.

Fedora - The Fedora Project's mission is to lead the advancement of Free and open source software and content as a collaborative community.

Ubuntu - The vision for Ubuntu is part social and part economic: free software, available to everybody on the same terms, and funded through a portfolio of services provided by Canonical.

See, three different goals and ideas, but they can all achieve the same thing.

1
stevwillsCause Its Fun and the aur works well•

Arch linux's motto is keep it simple stupid.

2
S-O-What•

I constantly had problems when installing and running a Linux distro. Hardware doesn't get detected.

The fundamental reality of running Linux hasn't changed since 2013. You should still buy hardware with Linux in mind if you want to run Linux. The promise of "install it on anything!" still hasn't borne out in reality. If you really try to run it on any random piece of hardware, you're likely to have one or two components with a bad or nonexistent driver. While there is usually some way to work around these problems, it can still be frustrating if you don't buy hardware with Linux compatibility in mind.

What's changed is that finding solid Linux-compatible hardware has gotten much easier than it was back in 2008.

Problems sometimes require manual fixes to config files.

And always will. Linux users as a whole would actively revolt if developers started moving away from config files. Config files are a better way to do configuration anyway--it's more portable, easier to work with, and more flexible than having a billion different configuration dialogs. It might seem archaic, but there's a reason the practice sticks around.

Once you're up an running, glitches can occur, X11 can freeze and crash.

There shouldn't be much of this if you follow the advice in the first part of my response about buying Linux-compatible hardware. As with Windows, the majority of show-stopping bugs have a root cause in shitty drivers or shitty hardware.

Unless the software you want to use is very common and in most package repositories, you're probably limited to source-code only.

Run some Ubuntu variant. Almost everything you're likely to need has a package in the repository, and if it's not in the main repositories it'll be in a PPA.

Seriously, as a normal user you should never need to step outside of Canonical's garden. You won't be forced to compile squat.

There are tons of obscure Linux software on Sourceforge/GitHub, that may be old, abandoned, etc, and aren't in package repo's.

There's a ton of obscure Windows software on Sourceforge and Github too. It might also be old, abandoned, not in NuGet, etc. Do you make a habit of running that on Windows? If not, why would you do it on Linux?

Sometimes when you open a program that has a GUI or 'window', it can glitch the fuck out. It won't close, or it won't show up in the taskbar, or the titlebar disappears, and you can't move the window. You might expect Drag/drop, box-selection or clipboard to work but it doesn't.

I've not had anything like that happen on a Linux distro in a long while, though GNOME 2 is long since dead. Long live GNOME 3 and MATE.

but in my experience, desktop Linux is not that user-friendly.

Its user base would revolt if it was made as 'user-friendly' as Windows. If you want a user friendly Unix, go buy a Mac.

Linux is supposed to be super 'stable', but I feel like it's only stable if you either know exactly what's going on, or if you don't touch anything at all.

Linux won't prohibit you from doing stupid shit, so in that sense it can be seen as fragile. That said, it's way more straightforward as a platform than Windows ever thought about being. Windows has a million moving parts in the background, and anything can go wrong. When it does, it's often hard to narrow down what the problem really is, and sometimes impossible to actually fix it.

In contrast, Linux is like an open book. Everything is obvious, the software stack isn't nearly as deep, and because everything is done via config files you can backup configurations easily. Linux is very 'old school' compared to Windows.

In order to know your way around it and be comfortable, you need training, practice, experience

Same as any platform. Listen to some hardcore Linux folks talk about their problems with Windows or MacOS sometime. They're either grossly incompetent, exaggerating for effect, or have the worst luck in the world. Expertise requires familiarity, which requires time and effort.

I'd rather spend most of my time being productive, using the OS, instead of tracking down each problem that crops up.

Believe it or not, those of us raised running *nixes feel about Windows like you do about Linux. Windows is needlessly complicated, byzantine, and cumbersome. It's also extremely opaque to the user--practically everything is hidden.

Figuring out how to be productive in that environment takes a huge amount of time and effort.

So it's now 2017 and I'm wondering if there are any exciting advancements, or if there is a bright future over the horizon.

Linux on the Desktop has stagnated a lot over the past few years. It's reached a point where there's now a critical mass of grognards who don't want things to change, and that's making it hard to push boundaries or advance the platform into the modern era. What's worse, it's become so fragmented that moving the platform forward is now akin to trying to get a product through a committee process. Everyone has their own vision of where it should go, and few of the loud voices can agree on a direction forward. Even something as seemingly benign as fixing the shitty old sysv init system sparked a firestorm of criticism.

All of this is great if you like the way Linux on the Desktop works. It's frustrating if you want to see it get better.

Also as a side thought, sometimes I wonder if everyone worked together to make one amazing distro, it could truly be a Windows killer

No, nor would that be a future I'd like to see happen. Linux on the Desktop advances best when there are a reasonable handful of driven groups cranking out steady improvements, not when one group tries to dominate the others, or when everything shatters into a thousand distributions.

There will never be, nor should there be, 'one distribution to rule them all'.

1
ajpikoGlorious Gentoo•

tldr;

0
FaattoriGlorious Ubuntu•

K.

0†