How has Linux improved since 2008-2013?
I've attempted to use Linux off and on around 2008-2013. Stuff like Ubuntu, Linux Mint, Debian and Slax. I haven't stuck with it for a few reasons:
1 - Things break too easily.
(Basically the tl;dr of this entire post - things break too easily for power users, or even basic users, and require needless, annoying troubleshooting.)
I constantly had problems when installing and running a Linux distro. Hardware doesn't get detected. Problems sometimes require manual fixes to config files. You're probably going to need to ask for help on a Q&A site when things don't work. Once you're up an running, glitches can occur, X11 can freeze and crash. You might have access to an F1-F12 terminal but you have no clue what to do, and you simply reboot. Hardware problems can persist even after installation, maybe Wi-Fi or Ethernet doesn't work, etc. USB devices may not work.
2 - Most software is distributed in source code, and is not guaranteed to work.
Unless the software you want to use is very common and in most package repositories, you're probably limited to source-code only. I've had an extremely high failure rate when attempting to build/run these programs. 99% of the time, it won't compile. Or you don't have the specific version of a dependency. Even a .deb binary file can tell you to fuck off with dependency errors. There are tons of obscure Linux software on Sourceforge/GitHub, that may be old, abandoned, etc, and aren't in package repo's. It's near to impossible to get them to run.
3 - User-interface inconsistencies
Sometimes when you open a program that has a GUI or 'window', it can glitch the fuck out. It won't close, or it won't show up in the taskbar, or the titlebar disappears, and you can't move the window. You might expect Drag/drop, box-selection or clipboard to work but it doesn't. I also remember being unable to revert changes I did, trying to customize GNOME2.
I like to think I know how to operate a PC, I am a decent coder (non-professional), I like to automate shit with scripts, make apps, but in my experience, desktop Linux is not that user-friendly. In Windows, I can do relatively complicated things and not have to worry about bricking or needing to reinstall my system.
I don't always want to troubleshoot, hit up Q&A, find guides, just to get an OS working and running, and getting software on it. Linux is supposed to be super 'stable', but I feel like it's only stable if you either know exactly what's going on, or if you don't touch anything at all.
I'd love to use Linux as a main OS, but it's more of a headache than a joy. Doing something even remotely involved requires caution, because things can go wrong and often difficult to know why. In order to know your way around it and be comfortable, you need training, practice, experience - a learning curve that most people aren't willing to take. I'd rather spend most of my time being productive, using the OS, instead of tracking down each problem that crops up.
So it's now 2017 and I'm wondering if there are any exciting advancements, or if there is a bright future over the horizon. I'd love to see a Linux distro come out that makes Windows pale in comparison, so that gamers, gurus and grandmothers alike don't have to be Linux enthusiasts or sysadmins anymore to get the most out of it.
Also as a side thought, sometimes I wonder if everyone worked together to make one amazing distro, it could truly be a Windows killer, why does there have to be so many distros, spreading everyone out, just to have so many of them end up abandoned, like Crunchbang etc. There's only so many variants of an OS that could be considered important/essential.
Posted Mar 18, 2017, 5:07 PM UTC
If you're on anything near common hardware, and using a well polished distro, the issues here won't be a problem.
This makes me suspicious you we causing yourself problems. As a linux newbie, don't install things from source code. Stick to things in the repositories. Use third party repos if you must. Only compile from source as an absolute last choice. I can expand on the reasons for this if you'd like.
Chances are the programs you were trying to install by source or downloaded deb files were already in the Ubuntu repositories or PPAs, but you didn't realize it.
What you describe here sounds like you broke something, or had hardware issues. I haven't experienced this type of thing except when I've done the same.
tl;dr: I think you fell into the windows power user trap: trying to solve problems by blazing your own trail rather than following the distribution's best practices.
my advice: install (x/l/k)ubuntu, and stick to the repos. Read the ubuntu wiki. Google your questions and learn the right way to solve problems. Linux gives you a lot of rope. Don't hang yourself with it.
edit: Oh, some good news though: Pulseaudio works now, and wifi is rarely a problem. There were some growing pains for a while there.
I second the "windows power user trap" possibility.
I went from Windows right into Arch. Because Arch was such a radical change (requiring me to start my Linux experience with a series of cli commands), I ended up forfeiting my habitual windows approach and just reading the wiki and following instruction.
I have never had any problems with troubleshooting things. It's seldom that I must, and when I must it takes less than 10 minutes. I'm certain that if I didn't tinker and experiment then I would almost never have to troubleshoot. If I started with a familiar GUI, I might have wasted hours digging through a file browser or settings menu to find solutions when they were only a couple commands away.
The best way to approach Linux at first is with a blank slate mentality, willing to follow written instructions without assuming you already know anything.
For me the best option was to slowly back into it. I first dual booted windows 8.1 and unbuntu (gross) and I slowly got more confortable in linux. Installing unbuntu was a challenge for me but I eventually got through it and I eventually upgraded to linux mint. I got a "new" laptop (thinkpad x61) and I first installed unbuntu on it. I eventually moved to debian and Arch and then finally gentoo.
My favorite operating systems are
*Debian
*Gentoo
edit formating
I was probably in over my head trying to run super obscure apps. mmsap was one of those programs.
Yep. That is a bit obscure.
I decided to try playing one. It seems to Just Work in VLC and mplayer in Ubuntu 16.04 without further configuration
Unity still has inconsistencies with scroll bars and stuff like that
Yeah totally, but that's not the kind of thing OP was complaining about:
Hell, I have a GTX 1060 laptop, which is probably as much of a pain in the ass as it gets (new <4mo Optimus NVIDIA GPU) and everything works other than multimonitor, and this can be done with configuration.