Survivor,a great epic story- Part 2 (still very long, apologies)
A year and a half ago i wrote my last post to date on this subreddit, and i felt compelled to do it because of what the game made me feel at the time about every single one of the returning players in Cambodia. And it boiled down to this. This show is a saga. Whether you like it or not, returning player’s seasons are where this amazing long epic construction of 30+ seasons gets lyrical, poetic, builds up legends and takes down heroes (or villains) with no predictability at all, by giving you a great redemption or culmination story, or an anti-climactic fall. Sure, all new players is always good, sometimes outstanding. But for some of those players that moment in the story is only the first chapter, and what really matters is the character arc that unfolds 3,4,8 and sometimes 15 years later. And it is only because of great character building that we can achieve this greatness. This show has a baffling capacity to give its characters more depth than most scripted shows ever could.
The love that this show, mostly through its editors, displays for its players, is in my opinion what makes us hardcore fans. This wouldn’t be the show that it is if it was imagined any other way from a production/editing standpoint. Even after a controversial idea for a tribal like the one we just witnessed, most of us are left in awe of the guts it took to try it, of the reaction of a host to basic insubordination happening right in front of his eyes (isn’t moving around in tribal against the rules ? Maybe, but what are the rules really ?), and with the feeling that every piece of the puzzle we had from the 33 past seasons made sense after all based on what we just saw.
One giant concept comes to my mind, watching this season, but also most Survivor seasons, all stars or otherwise: History always repeats itself in Survivor. To quote BSG: “All of this has happened before, and it will happen again”. And again. And again. And you simply can’t ignore the history of a character, or you will never understand his actions in the present. If that isn’t a perfect metaphor for how an individual is or should be perceived in society i don’t know what is. So here i try to go again myself.
“If you don't know history, then you don't know anything. You are a leaf that doesn't know it is part of a tree. ” (M. Crichton)
This is an ode to the Nuku tribe. The very naive Nuku tribe. A tribe that watched a young buck, 16 seasons ago, come at the merge with terrible numbers and terrible odds. Destined to go home. But, through his charisma, his strength and his charm, was able to overcome it all, to infiltrate the other alliance, exploit its flaws, create divergences, and use one very important ally to swim to the end like the uncatchable Fishes that they were. And through all that, the young buck also worked with the other side, always making sure that he knew what “the others” were doing or thinking, always using any valuable piece of information he could get out of them to advance. Two seasons later the young buck came back, this time a lonely fish, but history put him, in spite of everything, in the same exact position. This time he wasn’t facing massive numbers, but he was facing some of the biggest players this game ever saw. And so, unable to fight this urge to know the other side, even when he didn’t know what the other side really was, he pulled a move that gave the enemy a weapon. A weapon that was used to end his own game.
Almost 14 seasons have passed, and if you are the Nuku tribe, facing a new twist in the game that entails going to tribal with an enemy tribe, you need to worry about J.T.. J.T. works with the other side, always. Not always unloyally, not always by being the best strategically, but always finessing his way in their hearts and minds to try to get that thread of information out of it, sometimes making a blunder and revealing more than what he is getting in return. You can’t ignore who J.T. is, if you do then you ignore this game, this epic story he is a part of. You rely too much on the fact that a behavior is supposed to be unpredictable, and gloss over the simple truth that the road most travelled is the safest road for any human being. All other roads are way too scary, so J.T., like all of us, plays and lives like he knows. And the Nuku tribe should have known. So, in a way, even if we love you, blame yourself for this Mr Malcolm Freberg. You sat next to a player that you knew, but chose to sit next to the idea of the player that you wanted.
“History will be kind to me for I intend to write it.” (W. Churchill)
History has not been kind to Brad Culpepper.In his first appearance, everyone just saw what they wanted to see in him. A villain, an arrogant man and husband, a celebrity-sport star-jock-villain who will crash and burn because of his big ego, a bully. Both the players and (some) of the audience only saw that, his character type, what he was supposed to be on paper, and didn’t see what he actually was. A decent strategic mind, a kind, educated man, with a nice family, a solid head on his shoulder and a lot of respect for his fellow human being. Both in and outside the game, people were belittling him because he didn't really live up to his character type, they didn’t understand. There was a lot of prejudice that had to be confirmed (and, we have to admit, the edit helped too somewhat), otherwise Culpepper’s character wouldn't make sense both to the players and to the audience. So, even if he showed all of his good side the first time around, most of us are only realizing it’s there now.
What makes sense now is that we are facing an all around good, if not Great, player. Physical beast, obviously. Very talented socially in building up teamwork and making wavering people stick to the group and stay loyal. Able to work strategically with anyone and end up with the best outcome for him and his alliance. Able, with his charisma alone, to sway Tai last time, and J.T. this time into revealing to him the most important piece of information in the game, saving a strong fellow tribesmate and checkmating out of the game one of if not the biggest threat. Doing all this in a kind, smooth, tranquil way, with a gentle tone of voice, without any big splashes. Well, you all wanted to see who Brad Culpepper really was. He probably wanted redemption after his first chapter. Something tells me by the end of this chapter, all of us will have what we want out of it.
“History doesn't repeat itself, but it does rhyme.” (M.Twain)
I don’t know if there is a more lovable character than Jeff Varner in Survivor history. Every time he is on screen, a smile appears on your face, and you cannot control it. In Cambodia his time was cut way too short, and many agree. He was a little too much too soon, certainly. A little too enthusiastic about the game, obviously. But what would his story be without his happy, excited, over-the-top personality, and funny mannerisms ? Jeff Varner exemplifies what is great about a well developed, well thought-of character arc in Survivor. You just cannot ignore the fact that he came back after 15 years of not playing, being way more flamboyant and extravagant than the first time, but always being the pillar of his season when it came to tell us, the audience, the story of both his and the other player’s game. Jeff Varner is the narrator this show should always have, never letting you down, always finding a way to find sparkle, magic and funny in any situation.
But Jeff Varner is also the story of shortcomings. The first time he was playing a great game, but a rule that doesn’t exist anymore saw him out. An unfair twist maybe, similar to the one that saw Malcolm out this time. The second time around, he was wounded, stuck in a losing tribe, with a few outlandish allies, and he just couldn’t perform in a challenge that was vital to his survival. This time he is back, and is morphing into this hybrid between Australia Jeff and Cambodia Varner. A little bit more calm, still lippy, still enthusiastic but trying to be more poised in a tribal or strategic setting. He is in a tribe that wins more than usual, but still somewhat goes to tribal too much. He is a reliable ally, but a very aggressive narrator in confessionals. Has Varner found the magic balance ? It may seem so, but it is oh so fragile. One of the most important moments in his Survivor history was in this episode’s challenge. Facing the stress of not winning immunity, put under pressure with the faith of his tribe in his hands, you could see in his eyes the flashback of his past shortcomings. The peanut butter. Getting a vote for being a bit too visibile pre-merge and having that vote cost you the game. Not performing well enough in Cambodia, getting injured, not being able to sway Abi-Maria. He is holding to those handles, managing that ball in the maze with the fear of god in his eyes that he might fall into one of those holes. Again. And Again. And when that ball fell, he sobbed. Because he knew that in that moment, he was running the risk to fall back into his old ways again. He is to blame along with the rest of the Nuku tribe for what happened afterwards at tribal, but if he can convince himself that this was just a bump in the road, he might not get swallowed into the hole again.
“Remember, remember always, that all of us, and you and I especially, are descended from immigrants and revolutionists.” (F.D.Roosevelt)
There once was a returning player named Kelley Wentworth who had no business being back in Survivor given her past performance. But she was given a chance, both by production and the audience. She took that chance and turned it into an outstanding history of adventure, redemption, phenomenal gameplay, and ultimately disappointing loss. There is always a place for a story like this in Survivor. And we might be getting hints as to who has come to take on the role of the revolutionary this time.
Well, given her love for America, America’s history and its constitution, she certainly would love to be called just that. Hali’s arc is only starting to appear. She once was a player who had no business being back, she was not that memorable in her first run, but she was certainly a joyful and enthusiastic player. Now she is proving that she may be worthy of sitting next to the big names that surround her. She is willing to take Wentworth’s torch, using her own specific quality: mainly her ability to convince people or lie to them through her oratory skills. A lawyer in spite of everything, willing to stare down even Jeff Probst by “not consenting” to the show moving on to the vote (what a moment). She has managed to showcase exactly why she was more useful than a challenge beast like Caleb and to save herself by just inserting the seed of doubt into people’s mind, and willing to do just the same with the Nuku tribe this time at tribal. At the same time though, she knows that she is making her own tribe have doubts about her. And she was not convinced of having swayed the vote the way she wanted this time. She knew Nuku where making a mistake. She tried to resist, but ultimately couldn’t. This is where her arc needs to move further now if she wants to become a part of Survivor’s revolutionary history: she needs to stand up and say “i don’t consent”, and this time stick to that position. She needs to make sure that next time people will do what she wants. This is how you take down the usurpers and the dictators. After all, isn’t that what the constitution is all about ?
“There's an old saying about those who forget history. I don't remember it, but it's good.” (S. Colbert)
Be a little, skinny, funny and agile gay Vietnamese man. Be loyal to those who treat you well, loyal to those who treat you bad. Act shy, be indecisive. Scramble, come to terms with your ambiguous feelings towards those you have to stay loyal to but can’t and those you don’t want to stick with but have to. Look for idols, climb on trees, dig, find an idol. Play it for someone else, or refuse to play it for someone you don’t like. Keep an erratic style of play. Get swayed by more experienced or more game-savvy players into voting against a potential ally of yours. Get swayed into playing or not playing your idol for someone else by more experienced or more game-savvy players than you. Keep an erratic style of play. Repeat. Repeat. What was that saying again ?
“History is written by the victors” (W.Benjamin)
Even the unique gems of Survivor history, those who don’t belong into any of the previously known categories, be it character type, player type or winning style, have a way of fitting into the grand scheme of the (hi)story. Even when the immensity of their triumph can only compare with the enormity of their collapses. Even when your name is Tony Vlachos. How can you behave in a story where you have already won despite all indications/signals that you wouldn't, where you are a war machine, a bouncing ball of energy never stopping and never taking the time to sleep or sit down before you decide anything or vote for anyone, when your arc and love for the game forces you to play a second time ? How to play when you just couldn’t stay put and wait for a season far, far away, where maybe you wouldn’t have been one of the few victors, but one of many ? Well, a winning story is a winning story. And you just can’t change what you know within yourself is good for you. You just can’t stop. It has to go your way. After all, it always did so far. Never mind the fact that winning the first time around with this crazy personality and this insane style of play was a small miracle, a magnificent anomaly in the history of the game. So when it doesn’t work a second time, sure you may reflect on what might have been wrong, you may have regrets, you go and taste the foreign and strange bitterness of defeat. But mostly what you do is you let nostalgia take over, you bask in it, and remember the splendor of a man standing in a pond with an idol on his heart, needing this, wanting this, having this, winning this.
“And the queen stays queen, Adiòs” (S. Diaz-Twine)
So you are a cheeky, agressive, cocky, playful, borderline insolent, irascible, funny, smart, brilliant, not so good in challenges but somehow great socially woman, who likes to get into fights with arrogant male villains. And you think you can win Survivor ? Please. Ok, well you survive the first vote only because this one strong guy in your tribe decided to lose a challenge on purpose and the tribe decided to punish him. Ok well you survive the next few votes because of your social standing with some of the people in your tribe, but you are constantly fighting with that Fairplay guy, so that will get you noticed. Also, you suck at challenges so why keep you. Ok well now it’s the merge and two players have returned from the dead, obviously you start pagonging the other tribe, but they’ll get to you soon enough. Ok well they decided to blindside your friend Rupert and you didn’t know about it. You are throwing away the fish in anger ? Certainly now it's your turn to go... Ok well somehow nobody suspects you for the fish but they suspect your best friend, what are you going to do without her ? Looks like it’s time to go ! Nice try swaying Tijuana by the way ! Ok so now you swear on your kids that there is no women’s alliance, i’m sure secretly you’re not swearing to blindside the men. Ok well you blindsided Burton…well played. Ok now Jon’s got a million dollars that says you won’t be the sole survivor, and Darrah is a challenge beast, obviously you are not able to win a single challenge, better get rid of her and take you to the end. Ok well you got lucky Jon lost the final challenge and you ended up with a goat at final tribal (might not want to eat this one btw), enjoy your lucky million dollars !
Ok well this time everyone has played before and there are like a million Survivor legends on this season, you have no hope this time, especially as a winner ! First one out anyone ? Ok well the Heroes suck…lucky again to be on a winning tribe. Ok well you get into the majority alliance. Well done, now you’re protected by Rob, not like his alliance is going anywhere this soon. Randy easy vote… now Russell, easy again. Haha! Tyson messed up ! Now you are on the bottom, getting voted out anytime now. Sure Russell is a stupid ass, but he’ll come for you, after Rob goes home first though… Ok well he believed your lie about Coach gunning for him, well played…Ok well you managed to vote with the majority against your best friend Courtney… Ok well now it is the merge, again ! How the hell do you do this ? Pagonging again… Wait you want to switch to the Heroes tribe ? Oh that’ll cost you…Especially since J.T. didn’t believe you about Russell, your betrayal will get you voted out ! Ok so you still want to switch ? Sucks to be you Candice flips as well ! Ok, somehow no one noticed your scheming with the enemy so Russell votes out all the untrustworthy women in the game including the ones in his own alliance, but clearly you’re not one of them for some reason. And you are useless according to him, so he’ll take you to the end… Ok how do you get so lucky ? Rupert, Colby and Jerri out for being bigger threats, no way you win this time with the grand-schemer Russell and the so-called queen Parvati sitting next to y…Ok well i guess we had the wrong queen…
Third time around, you’ve won twice already, biggest threat in the game, you must be crazy to play again ! It’s time to be first boot, for sure. Ok this time you go to tribal twice in the first two rounds, so bye bye ! Wait why the hell are they targeting Ciera and Tony instead of you ? Not that you had anything to do with it… Ok you had a good alliance going, i’ll give you that, but now you are swapped, and oh there is a twist in the game ! Two tribes, one tribal ! You just know Mana will target you and not a random male challenge threat !
One day this great story will end, and we will all wonder: how the hell didn’t anyone vote Sandra out before today ? What does the greatest player of all time have to do to be voted out ? What does it take ? And who will pull the trigger that hasn’t been pulled in almost fifteen years ? Sometimes history is just embodied in one person. The Queen.
I tried to stick to Mana and Nuku this time, i do have a lot to say about Tavua but i didn’t want to make this too long a post. Thank you for reading if you got this far, i hope you liked it. I certainly loved writing again.
Posted Mar 26, 2017, 9:22 PM UTC
I wish i had the mental stamina to read all of this