r/nier•
babelmatrix

[SPOILER] Crackpot Theory re: A/B, Need Help [ENDING SPOILER]

SpoilerEnding B

[So I keep trying to look for this being discussed, and if it already has been then I apologize for my search failure.

Can't say it enough: though the title says Ending A/B, it's really about what we learn after C/D/E. So 'uge spoilers... or crackpot theories. One or the other.

...

Right.

So I want to explore what I think is a key point about the 2nd playthrough and game design, which might be total bollocks or a delightful twist I never saw coming thanks to my expectations re: video games:

The first playthrough is not the same as the second playthrough.

Yes, you play as 9S, and the ending has a bit more than it normally does... but I believe that the entire playthrough leading to Ending B actually takes place AFTER the entire playthrough that leads to Ending A, either directly after... or centuries after. Once Ending B occurs, however, we have a linear timeline: Ending B, into playthrough/ending C/D/E.

Maybe everyone reading this is like "yeah, duh" because of how obvious it is, but I shot up in bed this morning (the morning after Ending E) thinking about it, and folks at GameFAQS (the few that remain there) doubted it. If there are obvious problems that can't be explained away (Emil has memory problems, etc.), point them out, please!

So why and how does it happen? We learn through documents and occasional plot points that:

  • android black boxes are actually made from machine cores
  • machines will always act the same way in cycles, no matter how many times it fails
  • androids and machines are both capable of memory wipes, and both have evidenced a tendency for repetition of whole chains of actions (The Wandering Couple, 9S post-prologue, etc.)

From this we can derive how and why every Resistance android, every Operator, every 9S, every Adam and Eve, every single iteration thereof all behave the same way, over and over, until the events of Playthrough B... the only exceptions being 2E, who must suffer it all, and possibly the Commander, who thinks she's in on everything.

This explains why they repeat the same behavior and, in Ending E, why the pods worry that despite the new circumstances that this new chance may "simply lead to the same conclusion as before". It also explains 2B's quote about it being the same every time, killing 9S as she befriends (or falls in love with) him every time, only to choke the life from him.... every time. The ending change in B, with the girls from the tower looking over this event, explains why the second act suddenly follows: this is the last cycle. The time has come.

There are also gameplay implications:

  • 9S' playthrough has the battles involving 2B end mostly thanks to hacking. Rather than being forced to hand-wave this as "just a game thing", it's actually because 2B did the heavy lifting in that earlier cycle.
  • Carrying over your loot and levels is because 2B always survives, always returns to the Bunker after every cycle's end, always carries out the same mission to attack Goliaths, and always gets preserved by 9S in his self-sacrifice to only upload her data. The reason he benefits from it all is thanks to the exchange between their pods, as painstakingly pointed out in those cutscenes during 9S's playthrough.
  • Your side-quests being complete are not merely a sweet mercy for which we are all grateful: the fact is, since you the player made it happen, that means that's what will ALWAYS happen. Helping the "peace" parade, and that leading machine losing all of his faith in his cause, means they'll always help them, and always crush his dreams. Every side-quest you skip simply means 2B and 9S never bother, every time. Side-quests in subsequent playthroughs are because that's the break in the cycle.
  • 2B's dialogue seeming a bit disconnected, distant, or uncaring is all because she's "in" on it, and the player can't be allowed to know it, contrasting to her emotion when she despairs. In another thread on this sub, someone points out an example with the Wandering Couple, which I won't summarize here.

Finally, something someone else mentioned that I suppose needs clarification: the Bunker is only destroyed once. The documents found later in the game show that some TOP SECRET archives were actually kept from her as well, which include the eventual destruction of the Bunker once Yorha's mission is complete.

The biggest hole in this theory, so far, is the giant hole in the earth. I can't come up with an explanation for that which doesn't require absurd lengths of fan crafting.

Please, help me realize this explanation or kill it like a stubby in a crib.](/spoiler)

Posted Apr 3, 2017, 2:40 PM UTC

910
radiosimian•

A and B are definitely set at the same time from different perspectives. I'd be willing to concede the machines might do the same thing years later but the geographical differences (the whole finding aliens / massive structure propelled into the stratosphere) is a one-time event.

6

You're wrong. Machines don't always act the same way. That's a red herring. The machines probably can't even be said to be purely machine at this point, but you'll find out more about that bit.

The "cycles" aren't like a time loop where everything stays the same. It's always changing in new ways. Such that even the war between the androids and the machines can be seen as a continuation and repeat of wars between humans.

2
Kumivene•

Yeah, time doesn't repeat, just the cycle of war. And only Yorha get wiped, the androids in the resistance keep living

1
babelmatrixOP•

So 2B has only ever killed 9S... how many times? Twice? Or does this mean we're just not privy to all the other times he got too wise and had to be killed, as described by A2?

1

We're not privy to all the other times.

4
babelmatrixOP•

Also, the idea of governments repeating among the machine life-forms, even when they fail, has no purchase or anchoring in the story then, except as a presumption of what happened before... and yeah, he CAN do that with his story. It just seemed nicer to tie it up by saying the Forest Kingdom would always return, the desert people would always birth A&E, Pascal would watch his village die time and time again... ah well. Red herring or tell-not-show it is.

So why are the girls there in Ending B and not Ending A, when they're otherwise visible holograms in subsequent playthroughs? Is there a reason 2B couldn't perceive them when 9S and A2 can?

1

I don't recall A2 ever perceiving them.

9S is the latest model of scanner. Detecting stuff is his job. But even he doesn't react to them in ending B. So it's mostly for our benefit, really.

1
babelmatrixOP•

She's perceiving and attacking them in virtual space, at least. But we can handwave that as "easier to hide yourself in real space than cyber space".

0
postswithwolves•

i'd even go far as to say that the idea of a 'time loop' is used to throw us off because the realization of the truth of 2B's relationship with 9S is more dramatic carried out in real time rather than a dinky time loop.

"why does it always end like this" seems like an intentionally ambiguous line when it's delivered, as a set-up for a minor subversion of expectations

1
babelmatrixOP•

Yeah, I'll just concede on this... was really hoping the "game-y" aspects of NG+ had canon explanations, but that hardly dents the joy of playing.

1