Thijs plays against a questing rogue
Posted Apr 8, 2017, 8:47 AM UTC
Posted Apr 8, 2017, 8:47 AM UTC
Real question is was it Turn 3, Prep-->Core?
even better if he had the counterfeit coins in hand and played the quest turn 2 as well
I'm wild it's possible (but unlikely) to play quest, activate quest, play reward, and then deal 30 damage to the enemy on turn 1 going first (so your enemy doesn't get to even start their turn 1). (Only works vs druid so you can steal intervate).
You can't have 2 swashburglars, 2 shadowsteps, quest, 2 coins and before turn 3. It's six cards (without auto coin) and at turn 2 without draw you're getting only 5 cards.
no he coined it out turn 4
Prep into core is so broken. Make core cost 7 or 8 at least.
Or maybe not a spell? Maybe a 5 mana 0/1? I mean sure, it becomes a 5/5 when you play it... but I'd rather that than being able to Prep.
They should have made it a permanent like the warlock quest reward
From my experience if people can't kill me in 1-2 turns after core (at turn 5 or 6) and doesn't have huge board advantage, they can't really do anything. So 5 mana minion would change situation. Prep>core doesn't change situation most of the times, mostly just speed up results.
5 mana 0/1 that can't attack could work. But then again it is probably too confusing because you shouldn't be able to silence off the global effect.
If it is a Battlecry, then silence doesn't matter.
I think Blizzard undershot the requirement for this quest -_-
4 is just such a low requirement, especially when you can have 2 copies of a minion and then you're given a pile of bounce mechanics. It should either be upped to 6, or there should be a minimum mana requirement for the bounced minions (play 4 minions with the same name that cost 2/3 or more mana).
I've played the quest rogue a lot and I feel like upping it to 5 would absolutely kill the quest, because you would have even less board presence early on because of the extra bounce, you have to wait longer for the double battlecry (since you can't play the minion before you have a bouncer + the mana for it) and it's +3/4 mana because you have to play the card again and another bouncer.
The real problem with the deck is shadowstep, whenever I finish the quest with one or even 2 shadowsteps its absolutely disgusting and completely out of control, however if you finish it with only ferrymen/pandas it is reasonable, because you need to pay 1 mana for the quest, 6 for bounces and then 4x minion cost, so overall at least 11 mana. So with 1 copy of a 1 mana minion and no coin/shadowstep you literally cannot finish the quest before turn 5.
In comparison, finishing it with 2 shadowsteps requires 5 mana, doable on turn 3.
how about the fact that crstal core is prep-able? I think making it a permanent like warlock quest would tone it down considerably but not kill it.
The Warlock reward is a spell still.
I think so too, but my reasoning why that won't happen is because blizzard doesn't want to make it too confusing :/ You can't silence it even if it's a minion, so it would have to be a battlecry, but battlecries usually don't affect summoned minions, while this one would, also why doesn't the minion itself become a 5/5.
I think they should make it unable to be prepped, but I doubt blizz is doing it because they think we are stupid.
Welcome to druid's world then
play three of the two different card.
Not sure about that second part, but I completely agree that 4 is too low. If you think about it, you always play a minion once to get it out anyway, so the quest is more like, play any minion 3 more times. Increasing it to 5 might be a bit more balanced but I think 6 would be near impossible, maybe not to pull off, but bouncing a minion that many times or using mimic pod for the duplication destroys any board presence or tempo and would be an auto loss against anything but control decks.
The deck isn't really that good though. It's all I've been playing since release. It has huge flaws and isn't as consistent as it appears. It loses to any aggro or mid range.
You're right it gets rekt by aggro. I'm sure a lot of people on this sub complaining haven't even played it.
Nope. They just see the crazy god hand openings and scream OP! If it doesn't get the god hand then you do nothing for 4-5 turns just waiting to draw something worth bouncing. By that time all your 5/5s won't matter since you have no healing, taunts, or hard removal.
I played 4 times against rogue and the 4 times they completed the quest by turn 4 and had prep to cast the spell right away. It really surprises me how they can consistently do that
yup i think the latest i saw getting finished turn 4, honestly i think the quest needs a nerf ASAP, but knowing team 5 it will probably take 4 months, and considering the only counter is the brainless pirate warrior i don't think i'll play much of this meta, the rogues are already spreading like wild fire, i also don't think the mage quest is particularly healthy but at least that one takes time to finish and you can get some lucky dirty rats to draw their antonidas.
Worst part of mage quest - it pops Ice Block.
I think Pirate Warrior is gonna keep them in check... can't believe I said that
oh yea that 4 game samplesize tho
Half the time I think perhaps the guys over at Blizzard don't even test their product beyond debugging.
How this quest was deemed fine is laughable.
Just like pirate warrior being so easy to craft and fast and constant thus destroying the meta now we will have this dumbass quest destroying the meta. All other decks have to tech around it or risk utter domination.
So dumb
Nah they just test is with awful cards like Thistle Tea
That Gang-up Patches Rogue is insane!
You joke but it's actually in the new caverns deck recipe
I wasn't joking lol
The rogue quest is (probably) not OP, it's pretty bad against aggresive decks, we will see once the meta settles.
it is op, from my experience usually the first strong decks to pop up are always the most simple and also the strongest, and the thing with decks such as pirate warrior and rogue quest is that they are extremely fast, while rogue quest does lose to pirate warrior it wins against everything else.
ah sure thats why miracle rogue was like tier 1 first week of wotog and then dropped down to tier 3 over time
first strong decks are just the best
It was because druid was more consistent, renolock can't be simply killed with 30 damage to the face and pirate warrior is just faster. In other words everything that can rapidly heal, taunt or be faster is better that miracle rogue.
Looking at the past, decks that lose hard to aggro never stay tier 1 for long.
I know it is popular to hate on Blizz right now, but it does make you wonder, doesn't it?
They should hire some of the top "HCT" players. Sign an NDA, and then give them two weeks to "break" different decks against each other on a special server. Maybe they'd have to wait 2 weeks after release before playing, something like that. Could allow for some last minute "tweaks" before cards are unveiled.
The thing is the amount of games too HTC players could get through would be a tiny slither compared to the amount played by the rest of the community in the first day of release.
Probably should be nerfed to playing 5 cards of the same name.
Now someone please tell me that is ok design and should 'just be countered.'
The design is good. Really good, in fact.
The balance, however, its off.
Yep, my mistake, was referring to balance.
so much fun
quest-rogue is the new inconsistent reno, only worse. either you draw a good hand or you get rushed down and lose.
yea thats pretty much it
you can highroll. complete the quest on turn 3/4. prep it turn 5 and still play 3 chargers or moroes or smth with it and win. or you dont get that insane opener. dead draw 2 preps off of mimic pod and not a single bounce effect in the first 5-8 cards and just lose
and you can also draw patches on top of that to make it even more of a high/low roll
Lol how is it like Reno in the slightest
Mulligan/draw RNG; if you get a nut draw of cards, there's not much other decks can do to stop it, much more so than other decks (hence why you see people mention "high rolling" when talking about it).
I mean any deck is strong when it gets the nut draws, but an aggro/combo deck like quest rogue is nothing like Renolock or Reno Mage. Both of those decks look to stall out and win in the late game.
YouTube Mirror, Credit to https://www.twitch.tv/ThijsHS & OP - I am a bot. BEEP BOOP
I love how proud the Rogue is.
Turn TwoOoOoOooo??
I just realised that the name "Questing Miracle Rogue" got a whole new meaning now..
But did he have Prep?
[deleted]
[removed]
If you do the math you'll realize it's not inconsistent.
Youtube mirror: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7A9LLMXfRgM
^^Doo-Woo ^^| ^^Creator ^^- ^^Github ^^- ^^Subreddits
Durr tu???? Durrrr Tuuuuu guys! Without de Con !!
He still won.
I don't think he did, was pretty close though.
Ah ok I was playing so mostly listening, at one point he was saying he was gonna win I guess he lost in a very narrow fashion.
"too inconsistent to see play" "effect is probably not even that good" "super slow to activate" "worst quest"
it IS super slow, shadowstepping your minions doesnt do a whole lot vs pirate warrior
"It is slow against the quickest deck in the game!"
Everything is by that standard.
Most decks that are slow against aggro have means of stabilizing/recovering given the right draws.
Quest Rogue does not.
Well infinite 5/5s is pretty good for stabilizing the board, but you can't do anything about your life total
5/5 charge for 1 mana is a pretty good comeback, even if it doesnt heal you
Except if they have a card generating battlecry... he just drew 4 cards turn 2. That's huge against pirate warrior since warrior had so many taunts available to steal.
To be fair, Rogue winrate is actually really bad right now across all ranks, even though Quest Rogue is by far the most played archetype: https://www.reddit.com/r/hearthstone/comments/646yna/vs_has_a_live_meta_tracker_rogue_has_a_47_winrate/
47% winrate is one of the lowest.
I bet due to the popularity, more player using it, so winrate not really telling the whole story.
Plus keep in mind lots of free to play players may be playing it with non-optimal decks too.
It is fairly incosistent. I've had tons of games where my hands don't come together at all.
yea because of a clip where someone has the most highroll opening you can get the quest is suddenly consistent.
i guess those other times where you dont draw 3 bounce effects in the first 5 cards you also finish the quest turn 4. oh wait you dont.
there is the murloc tinyfin + shadowsteps edwin meme deck where you can get like a 20/20 edwin turn 3 if you highroll. that deck is still inconsistent and bad
It is pretty inconsistent. He super high rolled. 2 shadowsteps is basically never happening along with drawing 2 of a 1 drop.
Any one minion requires you to draw 3 of a total of 7 cards in your deck. Getting lucky with mimic pod can increase odds. You see how that looks terrible on paper? Well it actually is that bad in real world too. You are just going to remember the times a rogue high rolls more than the others where they do nothing.
Elementals make the deck so incredibly more consistent though, which I don't think people really foresaw
To be fair, considering Blizz's talk about combos that give advantages for one turn and bouncing, I assumed it was worded one way and just meant you have to summon 4 in one turn.
:D