My girlfriend reported her rape- does she have to tell detectives that her rapist sold her drugs previously?

(This is in Portland, Oregon)

Last year, my girlfriend was in a really bad place, smoking crack and heroin with a rough bunch of people. As she was getting her life back together and was getting sober, she spent some time one-on-one with her previous dealer, just chatting and having some drinks. He drugged her, she doesn't remember anything after accepting a shot she didn't see him pour around 11 pm and then waking up naked and bruised the next day with holes in her walls and her house showing signs of a serious struggle. Her bedroom had mace sprayed on the wall, and a security guard at the senior home next door called the cops that night to report a woman screaming for help and a man shouting at her, around 5 am that morning. She had come to with the cops knocking on her door, but was disoriented and sent them away. The police have a record of coming to her door, but wrote nothing further and did not try to investigate the screaming/arguing. The rapist must have left around the time she was hollering and macing things.

The next day, while not at all hung-over, she had patchy/limited memory, called him, and he said they'd had consensual sex after she became crawling-down-the-hall drunk (his words, which I would say count as rape, but whatever). Later, after some therapy and getting completely sober, she is certain that it was not consensual despite his repeated assurances, and this week she filed a report.

Does she have to inform the detectives on her case that he was her dealer? They want to download the contents of her phone, which may well include that information. Does she have any chance of her case seeing justice if the police know she is a former addict? Is there anything we can do should they try to drop the case on account of both parties being involved in criminal activity?

Thanks in advance; I tried asking the nice folks at RAINN and they just said 'ask a lawyer'. I'm really worried for her- she's a good person, and I don't want her to be shoved aside because she's not a 'perfect' rape victim.

EDIT: Thanks so much, you guys! You really steered us in the right direction. She contacted a rape crisis center and a local program for victim's advocacy, and is considering delaying her interview with the detectives until she has some kind of law professional to sit down with her and plan her course of action and the possible repercussions. She and I both really appreciate you all taking the time to respond.

Posted Apr 12, 2017, 8:06 AM UTC · edited

13947
Leprophobia•

She needs to retain her own attorney prior to discussing anything else with the police. Even if she doesn't incriminate herself, the defendant may very well bring up the nature of their relationship as part of his defense.

Additionally, if she is not able to provide detailed and truthful testimony for fear of incriminating herself, the DA will have a more difficult time making a case against her attacker.

The sooner she can retain counsel, the better she will be able to provide helpful testimony while also protecting herself from possible charges down the road. *Also, don't discount the emotional aspect of having a proffesional in her corner whose sole interest is her well being .

209
Red_MischaOP•

I think having a lawyer would definitely lift her confidence and help her make these decisions. It's just going to be such a difficulty paying for it. I couldn't tell from googling whether plaintiffs have a right to public defenders (I'm guessing they don't?). Guess I'm headed to the courthouse tomorrow to try to get some resources! Thanks for responding.

45
Leprophobia•

She wouldn't have the right to a public defenders unless/until charges were brought against her. Try searching for legal aid in your county/city. The state or local bar association can make referrals and may have legal aid resources.

Its not super important, but she wouldn't be a plaintiff unless this was a civil suit. She is a witness, however, and may need to testify in court against her attacker.

54
ninjette847•

There are probably groups that help rape victims get lawyers in your area. You can try looking online or calling a woman's shelter or rape victim support organization like RAINN.

15
StringOfLights•

You could look into the resources offered by RAINN. There may be a local center that can offer you guidance as well.

9
AtariBasicQuality Contributor •

Her local Rape Crisis Center will be able to direct her to an advocate who can help her make sense of all this. They're trained and experienced in handling sexual violence matters, and exist solely to make sure her wishes and concerns are addressed -- even if they conflict with what others want.

RCC advocates usually enjoy privileged confidentiality, but she should double-check with the RCC before assuming this.

6
derpydore•

Try women's shelters/planned parenthood and other organizations like that. They can probably direct you to a legal network for rape victim advocates

1
reebokzipper•

so, her disclosing the nature of her relationship with the guy is dangerous because it jeopardizes the case. can there be charges brought against the guy if he tries to use this as a defense? he would have to also essentially admit that he committed a felony (considering its crack and heroin). hows this work?

4
Pulr7•

She doesn't have to. The 5th amendment protects her from having to self incriminate.

But it will almost certainly affect her credibility if she doesn't.

55
Red_MischaOP•

Thanks for this. I kept thinking 'but the 5th amendment! That's what it's for!' but I had a feeling it couldn't be that easy.

7

Yeah the issue is that if this goes to trial she should expect to have to be extremely forthright in front of the court about basically everything in her life. That's one reason these cases often don't result in convictions - the trial is extremely painful for the survivor because the defense tries everything they can to impugn the survivor's credibility/character so that the testimony and charged against the client seem unreliable. So, your girlfriend should be prepared potentially for her drug use to end up a matter of public record because it's extremely relevant to the relationship - that's another reason prostitutes, drug users, illegal immigrants or other people breaking the law are often unwilling to report assaults, because they know their recourse will likely implicate them in whatever they were doing illegally. I hope she gets the closure she wants but I also hope talking with a lawyer will allow her to be knowledgeable about what the likely effects on her life will be if this goes to trial.

36
ferret_80•

exactly why drug USE should not be a crime and be treated as a health/mental health issue.

25

Agree, completely.

3
TriggeringEveryone•

That's one reason these cases often don't result in convictions - the trial is extremely painful for the survivor because the defense tries everything they can to impugn the survivor's credibility/character so that the testimony and charged against the client seem unreliable.

Rape cases often don't result in conviction because the key element -- lack of consent -- is tough to prove beyond a reasonable doubt, and our system of law requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt to convict someone of a crime. Even a super bad crime like rape.

11
didyoudyourreps•

I would say especially for super bad crimes like rape.

15

I totally agree, but I stand by saying that what I said above is one reason. It is a BIG decision to be willing to have the details of one of the worst moments of your life as well as any indiscretions the defense can dig up entered into the public record, and many survivors choose not to go forward so they don't have to publicly go under the microscope. Many detectives/attorneys also treat survivors very badly, and much evidence that could've proved consent isn't gathersble or is time-sensitive and difficult to collect - there are a ton of reasons, but what I wrote is one reason as to why sometimes a survivor would choose not to see the investigation to trial.

5
cld8•

She needs to tell the detectives everything. Otherwise, the defense attorney will show that she withheld information and portray her testimony as unreliable.

To be honest, the fact that she is a former drug addict who bought drugs from this guy is going to make prosecuting the case hard. But it's going to be even harder if she doesn't give them the whole story.

Ideally, she should be talking to a lawyer about this. There is the possibility that she might accidentally confess to a drug-related crime while giving testimony.

45
Red_MischaOP•

I don't know why someone downvoted you; this seems like perfectly relevant information.

6
reebokzipper•

because she absolutely should not tell detectives anything until she has a lawayer. the bottom part of the post is good. get a lawyer

32
tommmyboy7785•

It's good advice.

2†
ChemPossible•

I'm totally sympathetic to her situation, but I'm going to be realistic here as someone who has been on the other side--she needs to prepare herself to be crucified over this.

If she doesn't disclose, it's going to come out anyway and she will be seen as not forthcoming. If she does disclose, there's going to be a lot of suggestion that she went there for drugs and had it coming, in addition to possible threats of legal charges.

If she wants to see this through, she will NEED a lawyer and a ton of support. If she decides to drop this, she will still need a ton of support.

When it comes to sexual assault, the justice system leaves a lot to be desired if you're a victim.

31
Red_MischaOP•

Yeah, I'm pretty sure if they bring it to trial, the defense will argue that is was a simple sex-for-drugs thing, and of course she doesn't remember the sex part, what a dumb junkie, never mind the 911 call from a neighbor saying a woman was screaming for help.

1
beanchuuu•

She doesn't have to, but if it goes to trial, "she was trading sex for drugs and she is a junkie" is probably going to be the defense's argument against rape. I think she should consult with an attorney. Is she in college? They may have legal services for her.

15
AtariBasicQuality Contributor •

Need to? No. However, this will almost certainly come up in trial, and the DA can better deal with it if they know about it in advance. It's also unlikely that the DA would charge her for the drugs if she disclosed. And most states either don't recognize consent when one or more parties are under the influence, and/or have specific charges for sexual assault when someone is under the influence.

Consider this:

Defense, to victim: "So you claim you were raped, but isn't it true you were smoking crack with the defendant that night?"

Victim: "Yes"

DA, to victim: "So you were smoking crack? Who gave it to you?"

Victim: "The defendant."

DA: "So the defendant supplied you with drugs before having sex with you?"

Also, memories of traumatic events are rarely coherent -- regardless of whether drugs are involved. The DA will be able to take this into consideration, and may even call an expert witness to testify to this fact. There is no such thing as a "perfect" or even "typical" victim; she shouldn't be concerned if the details are sketchy or blank. However, it is IMPERATIVE that if she doesn't remember something, she says "I don't remember". She should NOT attempt to "fill in the blanks".

9
MMABouncer•

"Later, after some therapy and getting completely sober, she is certain that it was not consensual despite his repeated assurances, and this week she filed a report."

Statements like this will prevent a prosecutor from even pursuing. You don't 'sober up' and then decide it wasn't consensual.

7
Red_MischaOP•

I could have worded that better. She knew it wasn't consensual sex from the start, but it took therapy to wrap her head around the idea that, yeah, non-consensual sex /IS/ rape, even if it's someone you knew and no one was holding a gun to your head or dragging you into a dark alley, etc. She waited until she was several months clean to report it, presumably because she was concerned they police wouldn't take an interest in a case between a drug dealer and his current client.

2
MMABouncer•

Now they're not going to take a case from a drug user that waited months to report. There is zero physical evidence.

2
Spacemonkey420•

I know some here are advising to retain an attorney but let me offer a different perspective. First of all, I am not a lawyer, but I do work with special victims cases from a prosecutorial perspective, about 500 felony cases a year. In my (admittedly fairly liberal) jurisdiction I can tell you that no prosecutor I've worked with will give half of a shit about her drug use or that the defendant was her former dealer. No charges would ever be pursued against her, in my jurisdiction, for any drug use for 2 very important reasons.

  1. she does not currently possess any drugs and was presumably a user not a dealer herself so any past history of purchase or use would be difficult to charge her with and ultimately low level compared to the rape

  2. image how bad the PR image of "rape victim charged with prior drug use" is.. and that's besides the fact that were they to attempt to charge her she would likely become uncooperative with her sexual assault case AND any further communication with her would have to be through her attorney or with her attorney present due to the pending charges

With that set aside.. the part that I could see a prosecutor caring about is the foggy/incomplete memory of the incident itself. This was not reported as a sexual assault right away, there was no tox screen to corroborate him drugging her or any other physical evidence collected at the time. That's okay, she doesn't need to have a rape kit done at a hospital to prove she was raped, but the prosecutor will likely want an explanation for her blackout and in that sense you're far better off being truthful about the drug history than being cagey and hiding things from them, especially in that it's a shared history between the 2 of them so his defense attorney will know about it.

I have routinely asked victims to allow my office to download the contents of their phone, I have NEVER seen those contents used for any other purpose than as evidence against the defendant on their case and I can't see that happening unless their was abundant evidence of ongoing felonies.

My point is.. Her biggest obstacle to prosecution of this case is her lack of memory of the incident. That blackout is best explained truthfully and any other explanation will make her seem (at best) untruthful and inconsistent, if not now then down the road when the defense attorney and I'm sure the prosecutor on her case will want to get out in front of that information rather than be blindsided by it.

Edit: a word (on mobile)

7
here-we-stand•

image how bad the PR image of "rape victim charged with prior drug use" is..

I'm concerned that in most places, the PR could well end up being "junkie pays dealer with sex then cries rape." I would imagine Portland being more like your area, but it might behoove OP to look into what that culture is like.

9
lawgrl718•

Similar situation happened to me about a year ago. My advice: don't fucking bother. It will just be more frustration and hurt when the DA chooses not to file the charges and she is let down.

6
Irishjuggalette•

Telling a rape victim to not come forward is stupid advice. Beyond stupid actually. Yes it might not always work out for some, but it does for others. In the end you know what happened. But to tell someone not too because it might not work, especially in something like this is just wrong.

0†
BoochBeam•

This is legal advice, not personal advice. Don't get the two mixed up.

7
lawgrl718•

Legal advice doesn't tell you everything. You really care that much that I commented my thoughts... jeeze

1
BoochBeam•

Did you respond to the wrong person? I never replied to you. Just the the guy below you.

1
Lehk•

If she was screaming and fighting he probably didn't drug her drink, it was probably the booze, alcohol blackouts are retroactive to a while before your BAC got to blackout drunk, and blackout is not the same as passed out.

Date rape drugs incapacitate their victim there would have been little to no struggle. This sounds like forcible rape to me.

4
rainman_95•

Aren't there drugs that just impact the memory but can make people do crazy things if misused, like ambien?

2
Red_MischaOP•

She says her last memory of the night is around 11 pm, coming back from the bathroom to him offering her a shot, and taking it. The screaming and breaking things happened around 5 am, when she woke/came to.

1
Lehk•

That's entirely consistent with an alcohol blackout, which makes sense as alcohol is the #1 date rape drug by like 100:1

3
AtariBasicQuality Contributor •

Also, multiple have suggested that she contact RAINN. This is excellent advice, but she should also contact a local Rape Crisis Center. Here's a link to Oregon RCCs:

http://oregonsatf.org/help-for-survivors/

The RCC will be able to provide her with a no-cost advocate. This is a person whose sole purpose in life is to look out for the victim and make sure her rights and wishes are respected -- especially if they conflict with what others (including law enforcement) want. The advocate will also be able to explain her options, how things work, what to expect next, etc. This includes her process through the legal system. In most states, conversation between the victim and their RCC advocate is confidential and can not be called upon in court -- she'll want to ask the RCC if this is the case.

It's also possible that the court will provide a victims' advocate. This is entirely different from an RCC advocate. The court-supplied advocate is more focused on helping the legal process run smoothly, whereas the RCC advocate is entirely focused on the victim.

Source: am an advocate in another state.

4
Red_MischaOP•

Thanks! I'm forwarding the RCC info to her. This looks very helpful.

2
here-we-stand•

Reaching out to RAINN is a great first step. I think it's really important for her to have some really solid supports in place especially if she's going to go anywhere from this.

You might ask a more local organization if there's a particular lawyer or legal route they recommend.

Congratulations to her on going sober, also.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

-4