MatCauthonsHat•

It's efficient? I'm more interested in effective.

327
SeldonCrises•

It's strange that the chose that headline bc the first line of the story is:

The Hyderabad-based Bharat Biotech’s ‘killed Zika virus vaccine’ using an African strain has shown 100% efficacy against mortality and disease in animal studies, a study has shown.

Like you said, 100% efficiency (in economic terms) implies that they used the "socially optimum" amount of vaccines, which means that had they vaccinated a single more animal it would have cost them more than the benefit derived from that last vaccine, whereas effectiveness makes no assumptions about cost, and simply states that all animals were zika-free

146
tinnedspicedham•

Yeah I think the person who wrote the headline does not know the difference between efficacy and efficiency.

Not judging- but English is probably not their first language.

135
joblessnerd•

Yup. English is the 3rd or 4th language for many Indians.

22
commafighter•

For most indians english is their second language

10
kuck_kriller•

Ah so just like every single other country on planet earth. Nice

-31
hellotoronto•

Not knowing the difference between two words has nothing to do with their first language. It just indicates an incompetence for the job they are employed in. It's not as if western media never bungles up their headlines, with English being their first language.

14
keve•

This so much!

One author messed up the headline? English is probably not "their" first language

Wow

3
_Enclose_•

Aye, and even if English wasn't the writer's first language, its still his (or her) job to write it correctly. There really isn't an excuse for it either way.

1
MinionCommander•

One of the things I love about the scientific/multilingual community (I include science cause you work with tons of polyglots in science) is that everyone understands you have to try to interpret someone's words for the original meaning. Trying to trap people in gotcha's/misspeaks is rampant in politics right now and its just so disingenuous.

It's actually really refreshing to have people who are arguing work together to construct an argument in its best form, even when they don't agree with it. I know its not completely related to this thread but I was thinking about this earlier when arguing/discussing with my Chinese roommate about the physical properties of light and viability of a certain type of wire so it was on my mind. I was sad to see the top comment was exactly what I was expecting. Thanks for putting an end to it.

10
miliseconds•

I know there is a difference between efficacy and effectiveness (the former in trial, the latter in real practice). However, does efficiency in this case mean it was cost effective?

4
tinnedspicedham•

No. That doesn't make sense.

6
Electroniclog•

100% efficacy against mortality and disease

It specifically states how it is effective in the article.

2
rockus•

The Hindu is supposedly the flagbearer of proper English.

3
mannabhai•

Indian here, the person writing the report likely studied in English their Entire life. They dun goofed.

3
leafcutter64•

It's the first language for enough people in India (out of 1.3b), than the population of some developed countries.

1
BrandonMarlowe•

Look again. The headline is quoted. The author is probably quoting a scientist whose first language is not English.

1
evereddy•

Can confirm/conform as an Indian: Most of us who speak/write English do so terribly :)

1
thatfatgamer•

Bharat Biotech

I was a bit disappointed to find out that Sir Ronald Ross Institute of Parasitology wasn't behind this, this being related to mosquito and what not.

1
Bank_Holidays•

But...but...India steals our IPOs IPs that's why my medication costs 10k$/dose. /s

85
digitalsymph0ny•

I know it's sarcasm but I think you meant to say patents and not IPOs.

35
MatCauthonsHat•

Well, we stole their IPA's ...

33
WittyOriginalName•

Fun fact: India pale ale is named for the journey to India. British sailors were at least partly paid in beer/rum. The trip to India was so long that the beer would go funky. A prize was offered for anyone who could come up with a beer to make the journey without tasting like Budweiser, or Coors, which are nearly completely indistinguishable from cat urine. Someone had the bright idea of adding a crap ton more hops, and a higher alcohol content. This did the trick and created a type of beer which is far superior to any other variety by far.

26
zedoktar•

IPAs are terrible and I can't wait for that trend to die. I don't know why anyone wants to drink pine Sol beer. I work in a brewery and it baffles me why people like IPAS when there are so many better beers.

My theory on it is dipshit hipsters jumped on them to have something different, breweries picked it up because it was selling, and then more dipshits jumped on it because it was becoming common so it must be cool to drink it, so more breweries started doing it. It's an endless loop.

7†
4-20BlazeItMan•

I actually like Budweiser

2
JoJoWiCo•

Would they just call them PA's?

7
slickyslickslick•

Actually, he meant to write IP- intellectual property, which is basically patents.

4
jointheredditarmy•

Yeah, finally this is a chance to even it up a little because surely our government will void their patent protection and allow local firms to produce generic versions and sell for 1/10th of the price right? No?

3
Fatortu•

Well if American companies stopped to sell their medication to ludicrous prices because the US government doesn't care, that would be nice too.

7
jointheredditarmy•

Pharma companies yield low double digits ROE like most other companies lol. There is a problem but the problem isn't how much they're charging or making - it's how much they're spending on advertising.

Advertising drugs directly to consumer should be illegal, like they are in almost every other western country, and the problem will take care of itself.

6
ohnodapopo•

New Zealand shares this shame with us.

0
_Kaal•

Fun fact Indian firm can sell it cheaper in USA than USA produced generic versions.

1
tuuper•

Be wary of absolutes especially in real world science.

66
DFINElogic•

I too am tired of absolutes

22

I am a Sith, and I think absolutes are just fine.

53
DarkNinjaPenguin•

You must have heard the tragedy of Darth Plagueis the Wise.

17
wcctnoam•

I would think so. It's a story the Siths would tell.

14
bostonterrier22•

dammit.... beat me to it :P

1
tjondamik•

Be WARY of actually reading shit before you comment on it.

https://www.nature.com/articles/srep46375

Within the context of the study, 100% efficacy was achieved

20
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
nearedge•

Link to the published study.

26
Research2017•

Wonder how many are going to get excited seeing the article is in Nature, without realising it is in Nature Scientific reports

3
I_am_fed_up_of_SAP•

What's the difference?

6
Research2017•

Nature has an impact factor of ~30, Nature Scientific Reports has an IF of ~5.

2
hiimsubclavian•

Well given that Sanofi, NIAID and Inovio are already in clinical trials, Bharat's Zika vaccine candidate is falling behind.

2
THRAX6•

Thanks, I was about to ask for this.

2
maxwellhill•

100% efficiency or efficacy - what's the difference?

And how long before it's set for human trials?

18
NGEvangelion•

Efficacy = how good it is

Effiency = how much of a bang for your buck

14

It's in India, so probably set for human trials 2 hours ago.

-7
Nichinungas•

Efficient is very much not the correct word. It's like saying "my car is highly effective". What does that mean? I don't know... but what I do know is anything about vaccines will get upvotes on Reddit. And puppies. But not a combination of the two.

14
utmostgentleman•

"my car is highly effective". What does that mean?

It gets me to and from my job without fail. The fact that it's fueled by burning tires and gets two miles to the tire has no impact on its efficacy.

3
chillicheeseburger•

Do you drive a car that carries ghost rider?

2
darwin2500•

Reading these comments... all Trump has to do is publish a statement saying he collaborated directly with Russian agents to hack the election, but include a typo in the headline of the statement, and everyone will focus on that typo and ignore the content of the statement.

14
_pharaoh•

This is already what happens.

2
autotldr•

This is the best tl;dr I could make, original reduced by 82%. (I'm a bot)


The vaccine was found to confer 100% protection against infection caused by an Asian Zika virus strain as well as by the African Zika virus strain.

While all the animals that received the vaccine exhibited "Undetectable" viral load, the amount of virus present in animals that did not receive the vaccine peaked four days after being infected with either the African or Asian Zika virus strain.

"The vaccine was developed using the African strain of the virus. It is important to prove that the vaccine developed with the African strain also protects against Zika infection caused by the contemporary Asian strains of Zika virus."


Extended Summary | FAQ | Theory | Feedback | Top keywords: virus^#1 vaccine^#2 strain^#3 Zika^#4 animal^#5

13
morphinedreams•

I hope they charge developed nations 4000% markup.

12
Verrence•

In America we'll get that regardless. Even if the vaccine is donated from India for free it'll cost $10,000 here.

15
floyd007•

Well, even if they do, Indian government, if they feel so, has a right to manufacture the same medicine (even if it has patent protection) and sell it at a cheaper price so that the poor can afford.

4
senapanangin•

It's not as if western media never bungles up their headlines, with English being their first language.

5
pri123•

Sounds like we're on-to something!

3
KoncentrationKamp•

yeah and it will take 2-3 months before the vaccine is actually used

1
MrJekyll•

Good to know that someone is working on Zika

2
Mrpchristy•

"Contact (contract) research organization." Who is editing over there?

2
sunwoo-yang•

This is for cancer trials, but animal trials tend to not translate 1:1 to successful human trials.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3902221/

"However, the average rate of successful translation from animal models to clinical cancer trials is less than 8%. Animal models are limited in their ability to mimic the extremely complex process of human carcinogenesis, physiology and progression."

2
utmostgentleman•

So 8% of the time it works every time?

3
sunwoo-yang•

every time!

1
Yokies•

Still the best bet

1
hellosweeties•

Its not even the first vaccine to be successful in animal trials. It's hardly the best bet

2
mrdilldozer•

The narrative in this thread is that Big Pharma is keeping miracle drugs out of the U.S. because they don't want competition for their monopoly. The efficacy and safety of the drug in humans is irrelevant to people who choose to believe this.

2
Arctus9819•

I'd think the percentage would be much higher in this case. Cancer is a wholly different animal when it comes to diseases, since you are targeting your own unique cells, whereas zika would be common to both animals and humans.

1
GAndroid•

So what is your message, should we not get excited that someone has made progress? I mean I get it that you are trying to be pragmatic but you can at least put in a few good words to acknowledge the progress that has been made.

1
sunwoo-yang•

I'm just putting in a reality check for people viewing these articles. I'm in no way an expert, but it's good to point these things out.

2

Whoa..I was skeptical when last year they published that thsi firm got a working vaccine, knowing it takes nearly 10 years to develop something marketable, but this is very fast

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
donoteatthatfrog•

Off topic, Kind of really surprises me how did this country escape both Ebola and Zika !

2
haruharu1•

TBH the in airport screenings before immigration in India are quite stringent. During swine flu epidemic, immigration lasted almost 3 hrs as they screened person by person from every flight. The two African nationals that did test positive for ebola were deported back immediately. This was all because of cheap meds and med kits. :)

3
donoteatthatfrog•

That's good to hear.
3 hours? I would have gone hungry; did they give anything to eat ?

1
Reziothar•

Lol I feel like the universe is coming to us in the form of an advanced mosquito saying stop having so many fucking kids, *buzz buzz

1†
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
KVirello•

Yeah but it gives you autism, so..... (S)

1
curmudge_john•

Queue the "vaccines cause autism" nutbags.

1