r/cade•
vrpc

Need opinions on fightstick layout with ITX. Should I make it thin and real long(3"x26") or thick and short(4.5"x20")?

Need opinions on fightstick layout with ITX. Should I make it thin and real long(3"x26") or thick and short(4.5"x20")?

Posted Apr 30, 2017, 6:38 PM UTC

615
arcade_newbie•

Best advice I can think of is to, mock up the positions on cadbaord and get one of your mates to stand next to you.

Work out the furthest you think you'll throw your elbows, where your wrist is going to sit etc and work out which of the two layouts is best.

3
vrpcOP•

The long one would mean not stacking anything and having room for the ITX board and the PSU (The current location will not work). I could use a picoPSU but would rather not so that I could add a low power GPU if I needed to later (I have a GT640 and HD6570).

The other way is to make it around 4 1/2 inches high allowing the motherboard and PSU to be mounted below the buttons and making it much narrower.

1
Eagle19991•

if you are worried about height for the video card, you can always use a PCI-E extension and stick it pretty much anywhere you want as long as you have the length: https://www.amazon.com/PCI-E-Express-Extender-Flexible-Extension/dp/B008BZBFTG/ref=sr_1_7?ie=UTF8&qid=1493920597&sr=8-7&keywords=pci-e+extension+cable very cheap and easy fix, can get them in all kinds of lengths too

1
vrpcOP•

I already have multiple pcie risers from other projects. There is no way a GPU would have fit without one. There is also the concern of powering and cooling a GPU as well.

edit: Already planning on making two holes on the bottom on opposite ends for an intake and 80mm exhaust.

1
Eagle19991•

Could also use an SFX power supply like this one: https://www.amazon.com/SilverStone-Technology-Factor-Modular-SX600-G/dp/B00MO675S8/ref=sr_1_8?ie=UTF8&qid=1493920710&sr=8-8&keywords=sfx+power+supply 600W would be overkill I'm thinking, but that would slim down the box size, they come in lower wattages and cost, and SFX is a standard Power supply size so replacement later if it goes will not be an issue. You could also go all the way up to 800W and install a GTX 1080 ti if you really wanted to and make this a full on gaming beast if you wanted, but that would be silly. But, hey, there's no Kill Like Overkill.

1
vrpcOP•

I already sized everything to an ITX PSU at 1.5" height and that would still require the taller box so I could fit it either under the buttons or above the motherboard. A SFX power supply is even larger at 2.5" height and would require the box to be much taller or wider. I might not even use a GPU and use the iGPU as I don't plan to play demanding games on it.

In the image the ITX PSU is on the right.

1
Eagle19991•

Nice, ITX PSU is great too, figured maybe you might want to put the filters on the MAME games, usually needs a separate graphics card for that, but iGPU should do the job for the most part, I always overengineer, I'm a bit of a more power type of guy.

1
Eagle19991•

only question I would have is are you planning on using spinning storage? if so a shock mount of some kind is gonna need to be in order, stick and button pressing will jar the hell outta the platters. I would vote for the wider, gets a little cosy with 2 people standing too close, I've actually been toying with using a coffee table or something that sits a little higher.

1
vrpcOP•

I was planning on a 3.5" drive as I don't want to waste a large SSD to this project. It will also have some rubber feet on the bottom that are for speakers. I have a bartop that is at 24" so I agree about the width. Just means more material and heavier. I ended up going with the wider version partially because the wood slab I have is 8" wide so makes since to just chop it straight down the middle. I have wider wood slabs but don't think my wife would approve of using it for this.

1
Eagle19991•

If using speakers and a 3.5" drive make sure they are shielded, or the drive will die prematurely. Magnets and hard drives do not get along very well.

1
vrpcOP•

Not using speakers so not worried about that. HDMI output

1

The wider the better in my opinion, if you're space can handle it.

Here is a link to the plans I made up and the overall width was 30": http://imgur.com/gallery/cYrVi

Giving the players more room is better. Giving the left player some room for his left hand helps. Also, a slight angle on the panel helps (like 4 ish degree slope).

1
vrpcOP•

Really nice work. I like the frontend too. I use Launchbox on my bartop currently and was going to just mirror the HDD. I might still have to as this will be mobile and moving from place to place and I won't always be able to setup WiFi. Plus I might just need it to work locally to minimize issues or to allow easily bypassing issues.

I already decided to go wider as the wood I was working with more easily allowed it. Also not going to be able to easily put a slant on it either as the panel will be inset into the wood sides and I don't have the tools or jigs to get the angles right.

1
Eagle19991•

Could always just stick taller feet on the back of the box. Easiest way to angle it.

1
vrpcOP•

That's a good idea

1