[Meta] Looking for stories like "This has not gone well"
I am really enjoying his story. But I need my fix. He mentioned a story about a man bringing gunpowder to people?
Any other stories about humans from modern day leaving to a fantasy world would be cool. Most of the highly upvoted HFY stories are Si-Fi. While I like these stories I barley saw any fantasy HFY and would appreciate some.
Thanks!
Posted May 11, 2017, 8:07 PM UTC
A couple of Meta posts: List of good fantasy hfy stories and Request for 'thrown into fantasy' subgenre and Fantasy is welcome, but where is it?
ones listed therein:
A World Away from Yesterday - no magic, but the main character finds himself transported to another world inhabited by a relatively medieval species. It's ongoing at the moment with much more to come but what's there so far should tide you over for a bit.
The Bathroom Adventures - not at all serious
Burning/Building of Ashenvale - Novel length.
A Heros War - Morey is summoned to a fantasy world under siege by the forces of darkness, called a Hero by the natives. Unknown to them, they got two 'Heroes' for the price of one. Dumped into a strange and dangerous fantasy world, Cato struggles to find out what happened to him and where he is. And perhaps there are advantages to not being a Hero. And perhaps not all the legends are true...
JaketheSnakeBakeCake's Guide to Promt Jumping - Novel length. (also check out his Snake Report story, a bit different but still well received)
Harry Potter and the Nat 20 - Milo, a genre-savvy D&D Wizard and Adventurer Extraordinaire is forced to attend Hogwarts, and soon finds himself plunged into a new adventure of magic, mad old Wizards, metagaming, misunderstandings, and munchkinry. Novel length
the webcomic Erfworld
Blessed are the Simple - basically Zero no Tsukima if Master Chief was the one summoned. Novel length.
Blessed are the Simple: Lords of the Red Star - a spinoff set in the same universe written by a different author... possibly discontinued
Release that Witch - An engineer takes over the body of a worthless prince and tries to introduce industrialization. Novel length.
Stranded in Fantasy copied over 4Chan story. Novel length.
I love this story - A man gets thrown into an alternate world after what was supposed to a harrowing escape from death. Follow him as he uses his knowledge from his previous life of research to adapt and survive in a place that is void of human contact, only to find out later how absurdly ridiculous his abilities are. Journey alongside this man as he attempts to change the new world for a better place, to turn it into one that he loves. Novel length.
Spellslinger Series by RegalLegalEagle - he's not stranded in fantasy, but aside from that it's a lot like OTHNGW
Published books, try: (Lol, all of these are "Novel Length")
More general fantasy:
Dude, comprehensive. This needs to be archived somewhere.
Paging u/Hex_Arcanus
O great omni-mod! What say yee? Shall this be enshired upon the wiki to answer this oft-queried subject?
thanks!
there is actually a "HFY library" section on the wiki with book recommendations, but sadly it has no Fantasy books listed :( ...it could also use to have the sci-fi section expanded, there were some good suggestions here
sadly, without a tag bot it is really hard to keep up with the new stories in order to classify them as fantasy or not... squints guess that means somebody'll have to resurrect the bot then
Edit: the HFYLibrary now has fantasy!
Anyone have source for the old bot around? Sounds like a fun project.
Most of the bots have links to their source codes on their wikis, I believe. The tag bot is here
r/threadkillers, man. Thanks for making me stay up until 4am with Harry Potter and the Nat20.
Holy testicle-tuesday. This thread is now bookmarked.
^(t-testicle tuesday? ...is... is that a good thing?) ^^lol
Yes. Just like ballsack birthday.
Had to triple check this behemoth to make sure all my suggestions were there, and they were.
I read through Release That Witch in the past couple of days, and am now terribly disappointed that I have to wait for updates.
claps hands ah good, my evil plan is working! MWAHAHA!!
ok question, RTW obviously fits the "thrown into fantasy" genre, but does it qualify as HFY in your opinion?
In some aspects yes, but on the whole I'd say no. The church definitely gives me WH40K Imperium vibes and the MC is a good exercise of the power of the human mind. Unfortunately, too many of the characters are without depth or downright lacking in any kind of ingenuity, since the only demonstrably intelligent characters are there to be a foil to Roland. I feel like it hit hfy status during the first months of demons, and may again once Roland can begin to push out into the territory of the Devils.
Like I said, on the whole I don't think it really fits the spirit of hfy.
Holy wall of text Batman!
Well shit, I'm set for the next couple years with this...
Well, there goes my idea of doing something productive this weekend!
From this list, I've now read I Love This World, Bathroom Adventures, and Stranded In Fantasy.
All have protagonists from this world thrown into a fantasy world where they are ridiculously overpowered. Is it a Mary Sue Power Fantasy? Sure, but it's still FUN. Could not put them down. I'm glad they have endings.
Holy sweet mother of christ I was going to ask the same question as OP, thank you so much!
happy to help! I generally enjoy the fantasy submissions here, and I like this sort of "thrown into fantasy"/"modern human displaced physically/temporally" sub-genre in published works, so I'm always happy to push new reading material at others ^(then run away screaming like a lunatic to find more)
Yeah, much as I love a good sci-fi HFY story I've always been more of a fantasy nerd myself. I've been trying to wrestle one of my own stories into words for a while now but it's rather large scale and I don't think it'd do very well here haha. Thanks again!
if you ever get it out onto (e)paper, send me a PM