r/canada•
Nilo30

How amazing it feels to be Canadian especially when watching US Politics

I just gotta say watching the news lately with America has really gave me an appreciation for our politics. When Harper was Prime Minister I didn't agree with him most of the time but I was NEVER embarrassed to call him our PM. Hell I was even proud when he all he told Putin was to get out of Ukraine and ended the conversation, this was all while not being a supporter.

All I'm saying is we may not agree on the little things but at the end of the day I'm so proud to be Canadian and see each other embody the Canadian values of acceptance, respect and saying sorry even when the other person bumped you <3

Posted May 14, 2017, 4:34 AM UTC

563
MoistIsANiceWordBritish Columbia•

I've been missing Harper lately... I voted Liberal (I identify as a classical liberal) and am so disappointed/mad at how Trudeau has been. Hate him if you may, but I've discovered over the past year Harper was actually closer to my values than Trudeau has shown himself to be, which is extremely regressive and non-transparent. I always felt I at least knew what to expect from Harper even if I disagreed on particular issues such as muzzling scientists, but he did have a solid backing of Ukraine's sovereignty, condemning Islamic extremism and fundamentalism and its accompanying barbaric practices (FGM, "honour" killings, forced marriages), a greater respect for upholding Canada's social fabric, and his desire to help the Yazidis escape persecution, for example.

I cannot really think of anything I've been proud to say Trudeau has done as a representative for Canada, and with him as the Liberal leader, I've been steered more right as a result, which I never thought I would ever say.

32
S5S5S55S•

I feel the same. Didn't like Harper but didn't realize Trudeau would be more of the same with worse immigration and Sjw nonsense.

11
Ingwiela•

Todays liberal is not the same type of liberal from say the early 2000s. Im actually proud to say I am no longer a liberal.

10
Nachtwacht1•

I do respect Liberals like John Manley who had a spine and could deliver. I am a Conservative and therefore supported and support Harper. My feeling is everyone should respect Parliament, but I have the impression that JT doesn't. That is why I don't respect JT. In addition, it appears that JT favours party before country.

3

A lot of people thought exactly just like you and subsequently voted him in. I was raised in a fairly conservative household and voting anybody besides a con would have been frowned upon.

0
GTAWOODENDESK1•

Militarism and Neoliberalism, but you want more Harper...so ill informed.

-3†
redditaccountiuse•

The number one cultural practice of Canadians: talking about how much better we are than Americans.

25
Jack-in-the-Green•

It's what defines Canadians; we're not Americans.

Woohoo, that's some strong cultural identity right there. /rolleyes

It's pathetic the way insecure people and the media grasp at any mention of Canada in international news and scour their sources to see what others think of us. It's pathological I'm sure.

11
MemoryLapse•

That's new. We used to consider ourselves as a little guy that punched above our weight., sort of pre 2001. Now we get bombarded with the idea that we're somehow better than the largest economy the world has ever known, despite many indicators pointing firmly the other way.

Canada, or at least it's media, has become boastful and it's very unbecoming.

12
LicencedtoStump•

Talking about how more polite we are too. I've been to Toronto and I've been to the American South and I can say with certainty that on average in that part of the country, Americans are much nicer and friendlier than Canadians. They're just too nice to say that about themself.

6
Siendra•

If you want to take solace in Canadian politics, take solace in the policies that make them what they are, not some abstract behavioral target. Blessedly short campaigns with reasonable finance legislation, for example.

A Trump-like candidate won't rise to popularity tomorrow in Canada, but there's nothing preventing them from doing so in the next election, or the one after, or in fifty years.

17
edimaudo•

It could also happen here.

15
SacredGumbyAlberta•

What scares me as an Albertan is the Wild Rose party are currently polling well above the NDP and PC parties right now. We could very well end up provincially with some back water, religious nut jobs in power sending us spinning back down the 50 year long hole we just crawled out of.

9
Siendra•

The Wild Rose has polled much higher than their actual performance in every election they've run candidates in. Which isn't to say you shouldn't worry, but you don't need to hold your breath.

7
LicencedtoStump•

And that excites me after years of NDP mismanagement. It's also this smug "oh he isn't as progressive as me, he must be some religious nutjobs" which will help the Wildrose win. For the life of me I have no idea how liberals can't learn from their mistakes and realize arrogantly insulting the character of the people you disagree with only helps lose elections.

1
SacredGumbyAlberta•

Years of NDP fiscal mismanagement? Really. Is that what you call the 50 years if the provincial PC party pissing away our future? Leaving us with nothing but a busted one horse economy.

2
Nilo30OP•

You're quite right, especially with some of the things Kellie Leitch has been saying but luckily she's polling a distant fifth in the Conservative race

Source

6
NiagaraNY•

Daily Canadian virtue signalling thread.

That's all your country will ever be, a constant comparison exercise to America. Nothing more.

What a sad nation and culture to be a part of.

10†
MrRoboc0p•

Sort of like how Niagara Falls NY is always compared to the better version of Niagara Falls ON?

14
dank-salvia-hits•

That difference was used to justify a need for the national park system which gave the us Yosemite, yellow stone etc. So in the long run we even lost with that.

5
NiagaraNY•

There we go with the classic Canadian comparisons again. Pathetic. If by better you mean tacky shops on every street corner, skyscraper hotels and urban sprawl then sure, congrats on the "development" on your side of the Niagara Gorge.

Edit: Your housing prices are also insane and you are all being completely scammed. I can't believe people are dumb enough to pay that much money for a house in small city Ontario.

-2†

I can't believe Americans pay so much for generally shitty health insurance unless they're with select companies or state employers. God help you if you have a chronic illness.

Let's not even get on to how little Americans get back for each dollar they pay in state and federal taxes. No wonder smaller government on every front wins support. Whatever you guys do with state administration of anything, you manage to cock it up royally.

/A Canadian who has lived in the US long enough to recognize its strengths and weaknesses as well as think the general Canadian elitist circlejerk is sickening around here. Working and living in America did me well. I still think highly of Americans and a lot of aspects of the country.

4

Nah, within Canada we can have the East pissing on the West and the West feeling hard done by and bitter, Anglophone-Francophone bickerfests that go back generations, and all sorts of other regional spats. Canadians don't restrict themselves to constant comparisons with just America, we need to feel that we're better than other parts of Canada.

10
Semperi95•

I'm perfectly ok with being a constant comparison to America, because in almost every single instance we come across as far superior (except maybe in percentage of the population imprisoned, military spending and childish presidents, 'Murica has us beat there)

5
dubbsauce•

Idk what dope you've been smoking, but you need to lay off that shit bud... The only thing I believe we're currently "winning" against the US, is being being the new number one money laundering capital of the world...

Yay Canada...

5
Jack-in-the-Green•

Lol, smugness is our middle name. It's pathetic. If Canada had a face, it would be the smug type that you would want to smack.

5
essejhsif•

Oooh, especially those Québécois.

Redditor Quebecer in corner mumbles "... you do not know how to say it correctly..."

1
dubbsauce•

It is a sad nation to be apart of.. And I say this as a Canadian.. You pointed out what can only be described as "the great Canadian inferiority complex" but you have no idea how disgusting the crab bucket mentality is up here.

There's a reason why we can't get any major national infrastructure projects built, and there's a reason why all the young people (myself included) flee or in the process of fleeing this institutionalized nut house.

As a Canadian I don't get what there is to be so proud of these days... I really don't.

4
Atalantean•

So why are you here exactly?

2
critfistBritish Columbia•

He's an American with a bone to pick.

1
critfistBritish Columbia•

Man, you're a bitter person, aren't you?

0
NiagaraNY•

Nope, just like to put Canadians in their place.

2
critfistBritish Columbia•

So you're bitter and angry at Canadians? Got it, thanks for clearing this up.

0
NiagaraNY•

Nope, just want to inform people which country is actually the superior society. There's a reason why the majority of Canadians live near the American border: you depend on us. You survive off us. Without the United States on your doorstep you would be nothing. And here you are on this subreddit making topics daily about how you're "better" than the U.S.

Absolutely laughable.

6
cosworth99•

I rarely think of America as a country.

Never do I compare. I think of America as a collection of two types of people. It's a broken and unsustainable system. I'll see it's downfall in my lifetime. It will be harrowing to watch.

-1†
KekGratiaRex•

So broken and unsustainable that their republic has been around in current form for 241 years. France, which is a good comparison since it had its democratic revolution at the same time, has had 4 more government collapse and restructurings in that same time.

It's pretty fucking stable. You are delusional to think that it's collapsing anytime soon.

6
dank-salvia-hits•

This thread again

9†
S5S5S55S•

Why click it then? Just can't help yourself?

6†
dank-salvia-hits•

Yeah pretty much, I derive enjoyment from knocking smug ass Canadians down a peg.

3†
thats_the_minibar•

Canadians can jack themselves off thinking that we're a better country, but our joke of an economy cannot compare to theirs. I mean guys, their economy runs on multiple sectors that arnt just real estate and oil! It's amazing.

8
tarantadoako•

OP did you forget about the barbaric cultural hotline and his obsession with the niqab?. How about bill C24?. Muzzling of scientists?. Harper is not Trump but he was desperate to win and was slowly going to the dark side. We were lucky that we were able to kick him out because the alt right at that time didnt have the correct tactics. The same alt right supporters that put Trump in power are here in Canada. They have a lot of supporters and could EASILY take back the PM seat in the next election. They are experts in fearmongering.

7†
Jack-in-the-Green•

OP did you forget about the barbaric cultural hotline

Guess who voted in favour of the deliciously named Zero Tolerance for Barbaric Cultural Practices Act ?

https://votes.mp/#/profile/567

That's right, Mr Progressive, Mr Hugs and Sunny Ways, along with 29 other Liberal MPs.

6
tarantadoako•

FAKE NEWS.

-4
Jack-in-the-Green•
1
tarantadoako•

That is not the same act. LMAO. Quit spreading fake news.

0

it's another "xD so glad we're not Americans" thread

yeah so proud of our failing petrol state that's basically a vault for Chinese money

7
themaincopCanada•

2edgy4me

3
critfistBritish Columbia•

Our state is a million miles from failing. If you want to see a failed state look at Libya, not Canada.

2
magic-moose•

Canadian politics frequently seem to follow in the footsteps of U.S. politics. Attack ads. Cults of personality squeezing out the importance of platforms. Electing leaders for being the son of a previous leader. The devolution of political debates into sound-byte spewathons. These happened in the U.S. first and then a little while later in Canada.

The good news seems to be that we're still at the Bush Jr. stage (You know things are bad in the U.S. when people are united in nostalgia for the days of Bush Jr.!). The bad news is that, if we don't make a serious effort to avoid it, we're going to send a full-on populist demagogue to the PMO sooner or later. It's not guaranteed it will be a right-wing demagogue either. In Canada, the Left seems to be equally susceptible to being harnessed by such a figure. We might get someone more like Huey P. Long than Trump. While I don't think it's fair to call Trudeau a demagogue, many of his behaviors do lean in that direction already.

So what can we do to avoid a Northern Trump or Huey P. Long? Here are just a few ideas. I'd love to hear yours.

  • Insist on election debates returning to a more academic format, with strict moderation keeping leaders on topic and cutting them off without mercy if they start spewing off-topic soundbytes.
  • Further reduce the ways political campaigns can spend money and close the loopholes. Crack down on PAC's and force them to disclose the sources of their funding. Frankly, some of them look a lot like campaigns being run by proxy to get around spending limits and prevent blowback from attack ads.
  • Reduce the importance of the PMO and the importance of party leaders. Give candidates in every riding more free votes and more exposure during elections. We need to focus on electing good candidates rather than picking the leader we like best and voting for whatever name on our ballot matches his party.
  • We should recognize that people who hold views opposed to ours aren't necessarily wrong. I'm talking about Liberalism vs Conservatism, both fiscal and social. Economists vs Environmentalists. etc. Opposing sides increasingly tend to demonize the other in harsh terms. Look at how it is in the U.S.. If one side talks about the other side they characterize their opponents as degenerate, inbred, illogical, evil, scum. Just look at practically everything that comes out of Ann Coulter's mouth. Thanks to the internet and places like Reddit, people can now pick and choose where they get their news and where they talk about politics. When you're surrounded by like-thinking people and you're suddenly exposed to people literally calling you the devil, you simply don't try to understand their viewpoint. You retreat into your online echo-chamber and convince yourself you're right. e.g. The_Donald. There's no denying there are some scary people in that sub, but a lot of other people were gradually forced in there by ridicule. Nastiness isolates. We need to avoid this and respect the views of those we disagree with. The discussion of politics needs to be civil.
6
confusedtopher•

The older I get the happier I am to be Canadian.

4†
dank-salvia-hits•

Might want to get that checked out.

5
S5S5S55S•

Trudeau is a shill to the elite with a pretty face. The anti Islamic hate speech laws, the continued selling out to foreign money and all his broken promises are evident of this.

3†
ArkiasisOntario•

Then look at Dutch politics and notice how many political parties they have and with proportional representation.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Drew2248•

Do you have a spare room for the next four years? Please. - A nice American man

0
Nilo30OP•

Depends shall you accept hockey as the greatest sport and pretend the CFL is half as good as the NFL?

2