CMV: Politicizing a Tragedy

[∆(s) from OP]

Whenever there is a national tragedy or crisis, lots of people say that now is not the time for politics and don't politicize the tragedy. These people are virtue signalling because they don't really care about what happened and all the thoughts and prayers that they extend don't do anything. Immediately following a tragedy is exactly the right time to politicize the issue as it's maybe the only time the people can be shocked into supporting real meaningful change that could prevent the next tragedy. The people who say to not politicize a tragedy are those who want to maintain the status quo until the next news cycle helps us forget what happened. To be clear, I am not advocating for Democrat or Republican. I am advocating that we try something and use the tragedy to shake our complacency.

Posted Oct 2, 2017, 12:55 PM UTC

53107
caine269•

Taking dramatic, legal action based on emotion is often not a good idea. To me it seems like the sending an angry email instead of sleeping on it, or breaking up with a significant other after a fight because you are mad at that moment. True there are maybe times it is the right thing to do, but a lot of times you will probably regret it later.

This is the reason a lot of the "name" laws are bad laws (imo). Something bad happens, everyone gets worked up and passes a poorly worded/thought out law, and later that law bites them in the ass with unintended consequences.

22
ShouldersofGiants10034ƥ

The problem is that once the tragedy has passed, so has the discussion. Half the reason that people will say "We shouldn't politicize a tragedy" is because the tragedy makes their side of the argument look bad. They aren't waiting to the next day to look at the email again. They are waiting so that people forget the email even had to be written.

11
caine269•

If the tragedy is so fleeting it is immediately forgotten, is it really going to be solved by passing some slapdash Bill or law? Tragedies are relatively rare and in many cases unavoidable. This is why laws that do get passed in the name of a victim or tragedy often do nothing to actually address root causes, or have unintended consequences down the road. Others have mentioned the safe act, patriot act, and various gun laws that would not have prevented the tragedy even if they had passed.

1
ShouldersofGiants10034ƥ

If the tragedy is so fleeting it is immediately forgotten, is it really going to be solved by passing some slapdash Bill or law?

Who said anything about immidiately? The thing about this excuse is that it is self affirming. You can pretty much just say indefinitely that emotions run too high for sober reflection. It is the most convenient excuse imaginable because you get to imply that your opposition are just over emotional AND delay things perpetually because of that.

Tragedies are relatively rare and in many cases unavoidable. This is why laws that do get passed in the name of a victim or tragedy often do nothing to actually address root causes, or have unintended consequences down the road. Others have mentioned the safe act, patriot act, and various gun laws that would not have prevented the tragedy even if they had passed.

One could easily argue that many of those policies were undermined by their compromise, rather than their implementation. Most American gun control laws, for example, are comparable to trying to prevent pregnancy with a broken condom. It is often a matter of only a few hours drive to get from places where things are illegal to where they are not and legal supply makes the illegal supply plentiful and cheap.

Setting aside the entire argument over whether gun control is a good idea, I don't think that ANYONE could honestly say that American gun laws are well written. Because the gun culture has taken the ability to address a central cause completely off the table. The idea that passed in the wake of a tragedy=bad is just ridiculous. Australia's ban followed a national tragedy and has been extremely effective. I am certain that you could find any number of examples. Legislation is often about public attention. Occasionally a single tragedy brings change, occasionally it is a more general tragedy. Healthcare reform in most cases is built on tragedies. It is just not built on large individual tragedies, rather a large number of smaller ones.

2
caine269•

One could easily argue that many of those policies were undermined by their compromise, rather than their implementation

the safe act is a total disaster, and didn't seem to have much in the way of compromise. it was just poorly thought out, poorly written, impossible to execute without violating all kinds of rights, and a failure in basically every way. following the orlando shooting more hastily thrown together laws failed to pass(as they should have failed).

It is often a matter of only a few hours drive to get from places where things are illegal to where they are not and legal supply makes the illegal supply plentiful and cheap.

this is also illegal... so you think breaking a few more laws is going to bother the criminals in chicago who are already breaking laws to get guns they use to murder people? i doubt it.

I don't think that ANYONE could honestly say that American gun laws are well written.

i don't disagree that a lot of american laws are poorly written. gun laws, tax laws, marriage laws, auto laws, they are mostly shit. who do you think is going to magically appear and start writting good laws? republicans can't. democrats can't. who else is there?

The idea that passed in the wake of a tragedy=bad is just ridiculous.

i specifically said not all. some. probably a majority, but not all.

Australia's ban followed a national tragedy and has been extremely effective.

australia doesn't have a constitution like america. solutions implemented in a completely different scenario are not good comparisons.

2
Delduthling14ƥ

I think this is strawmanning the OP's position. They don't claim they want immediate dramatic, legal action based on emotion. They just don't want people to depoliticize issues which are obviously political. Correct me if I'm wrong, OP...

8
caine269•

I don't think you can separate them. Politicize a tragedy means, to me at least, using it to pass legislation to prevent said tragedy from happening again. Saying the Vegas shooting was terrible is not political, but also not helping anyrhing. Saying it was terrible and so we should pass xXxX gun law is usually called politicizing. I am not sure how you could politicize something without trying to pass a law?

-1
Delduthling14ƥ

Well, it might start the conversation that leads to legislation. But there's a difference between beginning a political conversation that will lead to substantial legislation months later and emergency legislation passed in the heat of the moment, right?

2
thoth1000OP•

Yeah, and I am not arguing for immediate legislation, my point is that the conversation shouldn't be swept under the rug. We need to keep the discussion going and it needs to start now, because it won't start in a week.

4
oorakhhye•

How much longer does America need to sleep on gun violence?

2
caine269•

what is your solution to amending the constitution and physically removing all 300+ million guns currently in america? how do you justify doing this in a democracy where the majority support gun ownership?

1
redheadredshirt2ƥ

I am very middle-ground when it comes to the gun control discussion because I think ultimately the zeitgeist in America needs to change, and once that changes we won't need the kind of gun control people want. I generally hate discussions right after a tragedy.

There is a formula to the way politicians make statements after a tragedy. It goes something like this:

This incident is terrible. It is part of a list of terrible incidents. The reason for these incidents is this issue that I had prepared legislation for months in advance because it is part of my platform. That is why I am now pushing for this change to be made with the aforementioned legislation, and I call on everyone who loves goodness to support me and anyone who signs with me, and to denounce anyone who disagrees.

It smacks of the song 'Ya Got Trouble' from The Music Man. It states a singular, linear, two-dimensional explanation for a problem and then sets the speaking politician as the one taking the credit for having the solution. I find this problematic because, firstly, no incident or issue is so two-dimensional as to be solved with a simple bit of legislation like they propose. Secondly, it demands that people choose sides and give credit for fixing society's problems in the black-and-white portrait they've painted with their explanation of the problem.

The combination of reduction and need for credit/lines in the sand are what I consider to be politicization. It doesn't help the situation. It creates enemies and negates the middle ground by framing the middle-ground as advocating for horrors like mass shootings. The reduction of the issue is rarely in contrast to the agenda the successful politician has already been putting forward, so the entire thing seems like taking a tragedy and using it to get credits for pushing their line. This doesn't cause people to 'shake their complacency', it causes people to dig in because someone is trying to manipulate them in a time of tragedy.


The following is my suggestion:

Now isn't the time for politicization. It's the time for information. The news needs to repeat the information and avoid speculation and narrative. How many guns? What types? How many bullets? What types? How were the guns modified? Where were they registered? How were they obtained? Who was this man? Just the facts. Saturate the discussion until everyone who watches the news can talk, from memory, about how this horror was achieved. Repeat that gun and ammo list until people can remember it like the 12 days of christmas.

Sunday night (Oct 8th) bring an expert on who is fully capable of stating, without misrepresentation, both sides of the gun control argument. Don't advocate for a position, don't demonize or draw lines. Just inform. No narrative. Now that everyone understands what has happened, this is the nuance of the law when it comes to these events.

Then, the following Wednesday, let the politicians begin having their press conferences. People have had time to understand and internalize the facts of what has happened. So when a politician says they want a ban on assault rifles, the public understands if those were used in the shooting. When a politician says any limitation is a slippery slope, everyone's been given a primer on how that's not the case.

As long as we treat the news as entertainment and politics as a way to gain emotional validation, we're not going to get anywhere and both sides will dig in deeper.

12
thoth1000OP•

∆ I like your explanation, you and I may have different understandings of what politicizing means, but I think your solution is a good start.

3
redheadredshirt2ƥ

Thank you. That's one down, around 323million to go.

3
thoth1000OP•

Please spread your ideas, because I am tired of waking up to people dying.

2
DeltaBotMOD∞∆•

Confirmed: 1 delta awarded to u/redheadredshirt (2∆).

^Delta System Explained ^| ^Deltaboards [​](HTTP://DB3PARAMSSTART { "comment": "This is hidden text for DB3 to parse. Please contact the author of DB3 if you see this", "issues": {}, "parentUserName": "redheadredshirt" } DB3PARAMSEND)

1
Jasader•

You probably only halfway agree with your statement.

Situation: (fictional)

Radicalized Muslim man runs over 10 people in an attack on a gathering outside a Christian Church.

Political Solution after tragedy:

Ban new Muslims. Make a watchlist of the rest of the Islamic Community here. Impose strict regulations on those seeking to own a car.

Political solution after thought and reflection:

Denounce terrorism. Caution against hating all Muslims for one crazy person. "See something, say something."

I think that you only want the political solution that you'd like anyways after a tragedy. You fail to recognize that a pendulum swings both ways.

7
thoth1000OP•

I said I wanted debate, not an immediate law passed the same day. I want there to be discussion, I don't want people to just try to shut down debate by saying it's too soon to politicize a tragedy, which is what seems to happen.

13
Jasader•

But you want the discourse to go your way.

What if the debate on the hypothetical situation I posed got laws enacted to watch all Muslims. That would be wrong, no?

Especially when reflecting on the tragedy later would let you make clear decisions, not ones on information that will likely change in the next day or two.

0†
thoth1000OP•

You don't know which way I want the discourse to go though. I want discourse. I don't want people to say that now is not the time for change, it's too soon, because tomorrow they'll have moved on. The point I am making is that we as a country need to stop hiding behind calls to not politicize something until the news cycle can distract us. We need to start talking about this now and keep the discussion going.

7
Jasader•

So whichever way the reaction goes would be alright with you?

Enacting policy or advocating for one based on emotional arguments formed before the dust settles on a tragedy means your arguments suck.

You can't drum up the support in an actual debate so you politicize something in the heat of the moment.

This is the thinking that lead to Japanese internment camps in WW2.

5
darwin250039ƥ

Of course everyone wants the discourse to go their way, that's what holding a belief means.

But that's a completely separate issue from whether you want the debate to occur or not.

By analogy: OP is saying 'I'd like to go play baseball,' and you're saying 'yeah, but you would also like to win, right? That means you don't really want to play baseball, you only want to win at baseball.'

Two distinct desires, not mutually exclusive.

1
Jasader•

I see your point. I just don't agree with you.

This same person would be yelling about not making this about Islam or some other violent thing.

Or if some violent North Korean came to the US and blew something up he would caution against war.

He doesn't want a debate to happen. He wants a debate to push the issues that he wants changed. And that is all.

1
PLZ_PM_ME_UR_BUTT•

Everyone wants discourse to go their way.

But on the subject of gun control in particular, one side doesn't even want to talk about it. They want to shut down the discussion by saying that the time isn't right because something just happened that is extremely relevant to the discussion they are avoiding.

Imagine if there was a plague. One side said we need to put people on house arrest to avoid further spreading, which may or may not be a reasonable idea, and the other side refused to discuss any solutions because they don't want to politicize the plague.

1
Jasader•

I don't agree. The right doesn't want to talk about it because the left won't stop until the 2nd Amendment is neutered.

There are many more killings by handguns than an AR-15 variant. So in a year after getting any sort of victory, they will push further. I would bet that if the Democrats pushed for a more strict background check, a ban on modifications that turn normal semi-autos into fully automatic weapons except at gun ranges, and then pledged to not touch the 2nd Amendment more than that, the right is more likely to agree than the left.

Because the left doesn't want you to have a gun. They want to control the only people with the guns.

In your plague scenario, imagine if that side said we should automatically kill everyone with the plague to stop it from spreading, while the other side said we should wait until treatment fails.

There is no tragedy great enough to take an innocent persons rights away.

1
hikikomori_forest•

You're saying stricter gun control laws make as much practical sense as a muslim ban? Not all problems and proposed solutions are equal.

3
Jasader•

I'm saying the logic behind limiting Muslim immigration is exactly the same as the logic behind gun control.

1
hikikomori_forest•

One is a policy against people and one is a policy regulating specific objects commonly used in violent crime. They're not the same logic at all.

3
Jasader•

One sometimes commits violent acts and the other is sometimes used in crime.

1
tunsku•

I know your political solutions were just exapmles, but those "thought and reflection"-led solutions have been enacted in pretty much every western nation, and terrorist attacks are still happening more and more frequently. I think the first set of solutions would work much better.

1
Murdergram•

A more logical solution to your hypothetical scenario would be to push for legislation that incentivizes research and development for autonomous vehicles that can at least stop and refuse to accelerate when a human being is in front of it.

Or budget money for barriers and retracting bollards that can potentially prevent a similar attack in populated areas. Or redesign streets and access roads in cities to prevent highly accelerated speeds from being reached.

There are practical solutions for these tragedies that are agreeable for everyone and don't involve kneejerk reactions that can potentially be regrettable in hindsight.

1
down42roads47ƥ

Immediately following a tragedy is exactly the right time to politicize the issue as it's maybe the only time the people can be shocked into supporting real meaningful change that could prevent the next tragedy.

The problem is that the change usually isn't meaningful, and it won''t prevent the next tragedy. Usually, its just an attempt to exploit a tragedy to shove through a tangentially related regulation. Additionally, those rushed changes can have big flaws.

For example: after Sandy Hook, New York rushed their SAFE Act. That law restricted firearms based on cosmetic features, increased background checks, passed magazine size restrictions, increased penalties for gun crimes, and some other changes.

It did not change any laws that would have prevented a young man from killing his mother, stealing her weapons, and killing children.

It also did not include an exemption for law enforcement, meaning that every police officer carrying a loaded service weapon with more than 7 rounds was in violation of the new law.

6
antmanschex•

Or course it won't prevent the next tragedy, if it did then it wouldn't be the next tragedy. Just because regulation won't stop all tragedies doesn't mean it won't help. I don't know what we should be doing but we can't keep saying that there is nothing to do.

3
down42roads47ƥ

Or course it won't prevent the next tragedy, if it did then it wouldn't be the next tragedy. Just because regulation won't stop all tragedies doesn't mean it won't help

They advocate policies in the name of deceased that are irrelevant to the way those people died.

If they are going to stand on a pile of bodies to advance a policy, they should at least have the decency to address the situation that led to their deaths.

1
antmanschex•

So we have to wait for someone to die to a rocket launcher for us to pass anything to do with them? It feels like we don't actually want change as much as we want acceptance that these things happen.

1
down42roads47ƥ

So we have to wait for someone to die to a rocket launcher for us to pass anything to do with them?

Did I say that?

My version of that would be someone saying "I can't believe that Timmy was killed with a handgun. Let's ban rocket launchers so it can never happen again."

1
earlybird94•

And not only were large parts put "on hold" it has a very low compliance rate statewide.

2
hikikomori_forest•

This is true, the SAFE Act had no real teeth. We need real, effective gun control.

2
down42roads47ƥ

Such as?

1
hikikomori_forest•

No more gun shows. No sales over the internet. Increase the waiting period. More effective and standardized background screening, including private sales. Mental health screening. Limit the number of firearms a person can own. No more hollow tip bullets. No more concealed carry. Limit all magazines to 10 bullets or less. Mandatory insurance. Mandatory licensing.

Strictest controls possible on guns that self-feed or are semi-auto. Possible GPS tracking that calls LEO if tampered with.

Anyway, that's the dream board. I'd be happy with 1/10th of that, some sort of actual shift.

2
down42roads47ƥ

What would each of those solve, and how would you balance that with the Second Amendment?

No more gun shows.

Why not?

No sales over the internet.

Internet sales are already highly regulated.

Increase the waiting period.

No statistical evidence that a waiting period for handgun purchases reduces violence, lawmaker says. Rated "Mostly true".

Mental health screening.

Please elaborate.

Limit the number of firearms a person can own.

Why?

No more hollow tip bullets.

Hollow point bullets are safer than other bullets. They flatten on impact, increasing surface area and reducing penetrating power. This means that the bullet is less likely to pass through a person or object and hit something behind them.

No more concealed carry.

Concealed carry permit holders commit gun crimes at a lower race than police.

Limit all magazines to 10 bullets or less.

Absolutely meaningless. As a twice-a-year shooter while in the service, I could reload a weapon in under two seconds.

Mandatory insurance.

Insurance doesn't cover intentional acts, so this is just a means to price gun ownership out of people's budgets.

Mandatory licensing.

Are we also going to establish free speech licenses and voting licenses?

1
Amp149712ƥ

A time of high emotional stress is not the time to push agendas and forward legislation. Discussion, yes. Anything beyond that would be irresponsible.

5
thoth1000OP•

All I am really advocating for in my post is to not sweep this under the rug under the guise of it's too soon to politicize a tragedy, until the news cycle changes and we forget it. So I guess you are correct in that, and maybe I should have made that clearer in my post.

4
feartrich1ƥ

No one is saying we need a knee-jerk reaction. But it definitely time to think about action. The sooner we start deliberating, the better.

Crime is incredibly political. When these things happen we're talking about law-and-order and/or national defense. It does good for politicians to think about how to stop these incidents from happening again, whether it's better policing or gun control or military action or intercommunity dialog or whatever. There is no "waiting time" if there's a shooting or bombing or other tragedy. From a pure public security standpoint, sitting around and praying is useless; I have nothing against regular people just observing and processing their feelings, but those who can act should start the process from day 1.

2
metamatic10ƥ

The problem is, when can we ever have a conversation about gun violence in that case, given that the USA averages one mass shooting per day?

1
Amp149712ƥ

Discussion and conversation is fine, as was stated in my response. But passing legislation so shortly after a tragedy is just playing off of people's emotions

1
metamatic10ƥ

But you can't schedule legislation to be more than a couple of days away from a mass shooting.

2
FSFlyingSnail1ƥ

You can schedule legislation a while after a well-known mass shooting.

1
llamagoelz6ƥ

thats a pretty non-colloquial definition of 'mass shooting' that they use to back that up.

1
hikikomori_forest•

When exactly would be the appropriate time to push a gun control agenda? Because we have a mass shooting every other day.

0
Judge_leftshoe•

I am in no way an expert in anything, I listen to some news on my commute. This is a lazymans perspective.

Tl;dr It's all about audience participation. If the audience can do something, donate, help, send care packages etc, it will be a "tragedy". If the event is over, and everything is being taken care of, boom. Politics.

I think the response depends on the tragedy. The politicization of the recent Las Vegas shooting, is because the tragedy is, for the most part, over. The dead are dead, and the wounded have been found, and are being taken care of. Aside from blood donations, and financial donations to cover the cost of surgery for those who cannot bear that cost, there is nothing I in Oklahoma, or CNN in New York, or you in wherever-you-are (unless you are near Vegas, in which case donate blood!) can do but try and digest what happened, and what can be learned from it, and what can be done to prevent it from happening again, which implies politicizing.

The tragedy of the Mexico City earthquake, or the recent devastating hurricanes Puerto Rico/Leeward Islands, went on for days, and continues to be felt. Cities and homes are gone, infrastructure collapsing, there is a dam about to burst in Puerto Rico, they are still looking for bodies Mexico City. There are many things you and I can do for those people, even though we are thousands of miles away, and our attention should be on helping those, and not politicizing them.

Using the specific example of gun violence, and the rising number of mass shooting events, I am of the opinion that the politicization of these tragedies are also out of exasperation. We, the public, see these events as becoming more and more often, and we, the public, expect that our legislators do /something/ about this issue, and each time, either nothing gets done due to groups blocking legislation, or half assed legislation is passed, that doesn't actually solve the issues. When we talk about the Vegas shooting in this manner, it's more about the concept of mass shootings, and our lack of progress in preventing them in any way, or learning from previous ones, and less about this particular example. We will learn more about what happened, and who it was that did it, but the conversation will be gun violence in general.

Other examples like Puerto Rico, or Mexico City are politicized for the personal gain of individuals, or personal loss in face of others. President Trump has been fighting an odd media war with the local public authorities in Puerto Rico about the aid, or lack thereof, that he has or has not sent. He is trying to show himself in a good light, and continues to talk about himself, while the people on the ground are screaming for food, water, truck drivers, aid. They are raising a fuss, because they know if they are "old news" they will be forgotten, and the rebuilding process will be harder. Especially since it has become apparent that most Americans don't even realize they are Americans too, or that they even exist. (At least, that's what I have seen, not paying much attention the that story, which just reinforces the point)

3
popfreq1ƥ

Tragedies are always used. Obama's Chief of staff, and current Chicago mayor Rahm Emmanuel used to say "You never let a serious crisis go to waste". That said it is a typically a bad idea.

When a tragedy occurs, emotions are running high, information is unreliable, rumors abound, priorities get blurred, and there are a million different conflicting opinions running around. Let's see what this means


  • emotions are running high

This makes people vulnerable to bad ideas, and they are to put it bluntly not thinking logically. Do you want mindsets to be set when they are in this state. WTC gets brought down by Egyptian and Saudis in an operation planned in Afghanistan -- Let's Topple Iraq!!!

  • information is unreliable, rumors abound

If you remember Reddit's Boston Bombers reaction, this needs little explanation. If not, look it up.

  • Priorities get blurred

Instead of firefighting, repair, recovery, the focus shifts to gaming the emotions. Optics take priority over action.

  • a million different conflicting opinions

I am advocating that we try something and use the tragedy to shake our complacency

Sounds great in theory, in actuality: Take this LV shooting. Lots of possible interpretations.

  • Gun Control Advocates - Take Action Now! Highlights need for gun control.

  • 2nd Amendment activists - Take Action Now! Highlights how gun control are ineffective, and can be easily circumvented.

  • R/politics sort of group - Take Action Now! Impeach Trump for creating atmosphere of fear

  • Trump supporters - Take Action Now! Country Music Festival - populated by Trump voters attacked! Stop taking all these attacks by liberals lying down


Do you want to add kerosene to a flame? That's what politicizing tragedies is likely to do

Edit: Formatting

3
wyattpatrick•

"I am advocating that we try something and use the tragedy to shake our complacency."

Relying on an emotional state to make sweeping changes is typically not a sound idea. When in an emotional state, often times your judgment is clouded, which is often why Doctors refuse to work on their own family members.

In a time of tragedy, the clearest and loudest points are going to be on the side of severe change because of the emotion that is felt. It is hard to take a step back and thing rationally and logically in these times.

2
Ohzza2ƥ

I mean, to the people who would be politicizing a theoretical event too soon.

Think about a theoretical election run entirely on emotion, where a guy who was completely unequipped to handle their position won purely on repeated emotional backlash towards his opponent.

2
wyattpatrick•

So we agree that it is not a good idea to make large decisions based on emotion

2
TonyWrocks•

I agree we shouldn't make large decisions based on emotion.

I also think we're moronic to discount big tragedies as major data points to be considered when making policy, out of some sort of deference to avoiding being "political".

Information should be gathered, rationally, and policy created accordingly.

1
SilenceOfTheClamps•

The main reason people say this is because it just happened. It is disrespectful to immediately try to use a tragedy as an example to further your political agenda. Imagine this, your mother dies from an undiagnosed cancer and an hour after someone starts proclaiming why cancer awareness is important. You probably wouldn’t be pleased because you are still grieving, but after a month or two you probably would agree with this point.

1
aristotle26002ƥ

I agree with this in spirit, but when it's a national tragedy I think the calculus changes. I don't know anyone in the Vegas shooting, and there's a really a good chance I don't know anyone that does. Short of directly attacking the victims (or defending the shooter), I can't imagine what I could do that would seriously make them feel worse. This stands in stark contrast to my role if a good friend of mine lost someone. My first duty at that point would be to provide comfort.

My, and the rest of the country's, distance provide perspective, and the freedom not to be as obligated to the victims. Instead, it is our duty as a country to provide more long-term support in the form of preventative action. Simply shoving everything under the rug called "political agenda" is disingenuous at best, demeaning to the victims and political in and of itself at worst. Technically, yeah, it's a political agenda by definition of the phrase. But it's an agenda driven by the desire to prevent more people from going through what so many have. Dismissing that fact is in and of itself political.

Now, none of this is to say that politics can and should go anywhere at any time. There certainly is a time and a place. The mayor or police chief getting on their soapbox while they're still counting bodies, yeah that would be repugnant. But our elected officials and news media have a duty to bring up these issues, and to be frank, OP is right. Anyone crowing about "too soon" always does the same thing: crow about it until people lose interest, and then do nothing.

2
SilenceOfTheClamps•

You have a point, but look at it this way. Waiting a couple weeks before. Change takes time, and a couple of weeks isn’t that long. Giving some grief time isn’t going to hurt anything.

EDIT: Didn’t see the last part of your comment. Even though people do lose interest, it doesn’t change the fact that the tragedy can be used as an example. No one has forgotten sandy hook, or even 9/11(even though this was much more extreme). If people desire change, photos and videos provide lots of reminders.

1
thoth1000OP•

But what has come from Sandy Hook, you say people haven't forgotten it, but nobody is using it as an example to enact change.

1
SilenceOfTheClamps•

Perhaps; but a lot of people were screaming for gun control immediately after as well.

1
pfabs•

Connecticut enacted the strickest gun laws in America that took away the right to own and carry nearly 80% of manufactured firearms.

The governor of Connecticut admitted thew new gun laws wouldn't have prevented Sandy Hook. This was virtue signaling.

So Sandy Hook was used to enact change. Pointless change that takes rights away from people and prevents nothing.

1
Celebrimbor96•

I always say, there’s nothing a politician loves more than a national tragedy.

1
wecl0me124ƥ

, your mother dies from an undiagnosed cancer and an hour after someone starts proclaiming why cancer awareness is important. You probably wouldn’t be pleased because you are still grieving,

This is what you're trying to show so you can't assume this.

1
VVillyD17ƥ

With regards to gun violence, I agree with you. We have let far too many of these tragedies happen while doing nothing to change the conditions that allowed them to occur. Every time one of these killings happens, people wring their hands, send out thoughts and prayers, but say we can't do anything because it would be politicizing a tragedy. Then, when the moment has passed, we forget about the problem and move on to other things. At some point, we should say, "enough is enough. People are paying attention now, so we need to do something now."

In general, though, I don't think this is a good option. The heightened emotions following extreme tragedy often prevent rational critical thinking or analysis. The perfect example of this is The Patriot Act, which was passed in the immediate aftermath of 9/11. It gave the President wide-spread, unprecedented powers in an effort to prevent another similar attack. Many have argued, though, that it restricts Americans rights to privacy, undermines the independence of the Legislative and Judicial branches, and allows the Executive to conduct secret wars around the globe. Had there been more of a push to not politicize tragedy in the aftermath of 9/11, we would not have gotten The Patriot Act.

1
aristotle26002ƥ

I agree with you in spirit OP, and 95% in substance. But as far as virtue signalling, do keep in mind that some people are undoubtedly virtue signalling so that they are not marginalized in their activism. If you seem too political, then no one listens. This is the counterpoint to your point, which is that if you're not political enough quickly enough, no one cares.

1
thoth1000OP•

What do you mean if you're too political? Can you elaborate on that please?

1
aristotle26002ƥ

Prioritizing politics above the personal, whether that be in emphasis or timing.

1
thoth1000OP•

Is there a difference?

1
thiazzi17ƥ

Very few tragedies actually fundamentally provide new information on a wider issue.

The issue is that when tragedies are politicised, it tends to amount to an emotional manipulation technique rather than contributing something genuinely valuable to the discussion.

Two examples from opposite sides:

  1. We know that Islamic extremism by minority groups in the West is a recurring problem, that can kill anywhere from 0 to 1000s of people in one go. One additional generic terrorist attack doesn't tell us anything we don't already know about the issue, so trying to use it to argue "won't you finally accept that we need to get rid of Muslims?" is nothing more than an emotive technique with no real validity

  2. We already know that mass shooters with a variety of motives are able to access guns in the US and kill scores of people. As in the last point, one more mass shooting doesn't really change what we know about the issue

Now, this doesn't apply to every single tragedy. Game-changers like 9/11 or Chernobyl should obviously lead to serious reevaluation of the previous orthodoxy on a particular issue. But most "common-and-garden" tragedies, callous as it sounds, don't actually tell us much we didn't already know.

1
Geometer_17292ƥ

These people are virtue signaling because they don't really care about what happened

It's never about not caring it's about having a different solution, or feeling that the solution being considered is worse than inaction.

ie in terrorist attacks it's not that democrats don't care about the people who died. They just have issues with approaches to curbing terrorism more important to them than the attack and or think the approaches won't work.

Similarly when mass shootings happen it's not that republicans don't care about shooting victims. They either believe that it's a tragically necessary price of freedom or more often they would point to the president of gun control not really curbing violence effectively.

I'm pretty sure your other contention is spot on. I don't think anyone says "don't politicize the tragedy." because they actually see that as morally wrong, but it's not really apathy it's not having a position that's easy to debate in the wake of a tragedy, for example saying "look 9/11 was terrible but more people died in car crashes that month than in the twin towers terrorism is awful but fighting it isn't an effective way to save lives compared to many other things we could do" is really unpopular right after 9/11. Similarly "look school shootings are tragic but having an armed citizenry is a vital guard against tyrants, we can try to find solutions to prevent them but taking away gun rights needs to be off the table." is really unpopular to say immediately following a school shooting.

1
Madplato50ƥ

Immediately following a tragedy is exactly the right time to politicize the issue as it's maybe the only time the people can be shocked into supporting real meaningful change that could prevent the next tragedy.

I'm not sure why we should just assume that people experiencing strong emotions are going to support effective and meaningful change. Isn't it just as likely that they'll enact sweeping and ineffectual policies? Anger and grief aren't the best counsel and tragedies alone aren't a good basis for action. All in all, I think that waiting for people to cool off before engaging with the issues at hand is a far more honest approach.

1
manumana10•

One of the biggest problems with politicizing the tragedy is that it appears disrespectful. Taking last night's tragedy for example:

A post calling for more gun control at this time or a post saying gun control laws don't work, says you don't care about the victims and their families, you only care that this is an opportune time for your voice to be heard. The people who agreed with you already, don't matter. The people you need to convince, may have just lost some respect for you, and are going to be even harder to convince the next time.

1
AnythingApplied55ƥ

Politicizing a tragedy CAN be a force for good. But at its best it can be used to pass a specific law pointed at making repeated events less likely (though aren't without their contraversy).

But often times political candidates use them as a boost for their campaign. If your solution to a tragedy is helping get a specific person elected, I just don't believe that is anything but shameless self-promotion and hope to gain off a tragedy.

1
sonsofaureus•

The people who say to not politicize a tragedy are those who want to maintain the status quo until the next news cycle helps us forget what happened.

Some people who say that want to maintain the status quo, and others who say that are genuinely offended by ancillary political conclusions being pushed from someone else's tragedy.

I think the latter can be a genuine stance that a lot of thoughtful people can have, since politicizing tragedy seems to be a national hobby. That said, some of the people taking this stance will do so because the nature of the tragedy doesn't suit their political agenda.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
DeltaBotMOD∞∆•

u/thoth1000 (OP) has awarded 1 delta in this post.

All comments that earned deltas (from OP or other users) are listed here, in r/DeltaLog.

Please note that a change of view doesn't necessarily mean a reversal, or that the conversation has ended.

^Delta System Explained ^| ^Deltaboards

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
Ansuz07MOD209ƥ

Sorry eddie1975, your comment has been removed:

Comment Rule 1. "Direct responses to a CMV post must challenge at least one aspect of OP’s current view (however minor), unless they are asking a clarifying question. Arguments in favor of the view OP is willing to change must be restricted to replies to comments." See the wiki page for more information.

If you would like to appeal, please [message the moderators by clicking this link.](http://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2Fchangemyview&subject=Rule+1+Appeal+eddie1975&message=eddie1975+would+like+to+appeal+the+removal+of+[his/her+post](https://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/73sl24/cmv_politicizing_a_tragedy/dnsu6uz/\))

1