CMV: Politicizing a Tragedy
Whenever there is a national tragedy or crisis, lots of people say that now is not the time for politics and don't politicize the tragedy. These people are virtue signalling because they don't really care about what happened and all the thoughts and prayers that they extend don't do anything. Immediately following a tragedy is exactly the right time to politicize the issue as it's maybe the only time the people can be shocked into supporting real meaningful change that could prevent the next tragedy. The people who say to not politicize a tragedy are those who want to maintain the status quo until the next news cycle helps us forget what happened. To be clear, I am not advocating for Democrat or Republican. I am advocating that we try something and use the tragedy to shake our complacency.
Posted Oct 2, 2017, 12:55 PM UTC
Taking dramatic, legal action based on emotion is often not a good idea. To me it seems like the sending an angry email instead of sleeping on it, or breaking up with a significant other after a fight because you are mad at that moment. True there are maybe times it is the right thing to do, but a lot of times you will probably regret it later.
This is the reason a lot of the "name" laws are bad laws (imo). Something bad happens, everyone gets worked up and passes a poorly worded/thought out law, and later that law bites them in the ass with unintended consequences.
The problem is that once the tragedy has passed, so has the discussion. Half the reason that people will say "We shouldn't politicize a tragedy" is because the tragedy makes their side of the argument look bad. They aren't waiting to the next day to look at the email again. They are waiting so that people forget the email even had to be written.
If the tragedy is so fleeting it is immediately forgotten, is it really going to be solved by passing some slapdash Bill or law? Tragedies are relatively rare and in many cases unavoidable. This is why laws that do get passed in the name of a victim or tragedy often do nothing to actually address root causes, or have unintended consequences down the road. Others have mentioned the safe act, patriot act, and various gun laws that would not have prevented the tragedy even if they had passed.
Who said anything about immidiately? The thing about this excuse is that it is self affirming. You can pretty much just say indefinitely that emotions run too high for sober reflection. It is the most convenient excuse imaginable because you get to imply that your opposition are just over emotional AND delay things perpetually because of that.
One could easily argue that many of those policies were undermined by their compromise, rather than their implementation. Most American gun control laws, for example, are comparable to trying to prevent pregnancy with a broken condom. It is often a matter of only a few hours drive to get from places where things are illegal to where they are not and legal supply makes the illegal supply plentiful and cheap.
Setting aside the entire argument over whether gun control is a good idea, I don't think that ANYONE could honestly say that American gun laws are well written. Because the gun culture has taken the ability to address a central cause completely off the table. The idea that passed in the wake of a tragedy=bad is just ridiculous. Australia's ban followed a national tragedy and has been extremely effective. I am certain that you could find any number of examples. Legislation is often about public attention. Occasionally a single tragedy brings change, occasionally it is a more general tragedy. Healthcare reform in most cases is built on tragedies. It is just not built on large individual tragedies, rather a large number of smaller ones.
the safe act is a total disaster, and didn't seem to have much in the way of compromise. it was just poorly thought out, poorly written, impossible to execute without violating all kinds of rights, and a failure in basically every way. following the orlando shooting more hastily thrown together laws failed to pass(as they should have failed).
this is also illegal... so you think breaking a few more laws is going to bother the criminals in chicago who are already breaking laws to get guns they use to murder people? i doubt it.
i don't disagree that a lot of american laws are poorly written. gun laws, tax laws, marriage laws, auto laws, they are mostly shit. who do you think is going to magically appear and start writting good laws? republicans can't. democrats can't. who else is there?
i specifically said not all. some. probably a majority, but not all.
australia doesn't have a constitution like america. solutions implemented in a completely different scenario are not good comparisons.
I think this is strawmanning the OP's position. They don't claim they want immediate dramatic, legal action based on emotion. They just don't want people to depoliticize issues which are obviously political. Correct me if I'm wrong, OP...
I don't think you can separate them. Politicize a tragedy means, to me at least, using it to pass legislation to prevent said tragedy from happening again. Saying the Vegas shooting was terrible is not political, but also not helping anyrhing. Saying it was terrible and so we should pass xXxX gun law is usually called politicizing. I am not sure how you could politicize something without trying to pass a law?
Well, it might start the conversation that leads to legislation. But there's a difference between beginning a political conversation that will lead to substantial legislation months later and emergency legislation passed in the heat of the moment, right?
Yeah, and I am not arguing for immediate legislation, my point is that the conversation shouldn't be swept under the rug. We need to keep the discussion going and it needs to start now, because it won't start in a week.
How much longer does America need to sleep on gun violence?
what is your solution to amending the constitution and physically removing all 300+ million guns currently in america? how do you justify doing this in a democracy where the majority support gun ownership?