Okinawa vs Sapporo in November

Advice

Hi all,

I'm going to Japan for the second time next month (last 2 weeks of November). I've previously been to Tokyo, Osaka, Kyoto & Hiroshima (as well as a Ryokan and Fuji) and I'm flying to Tokyo this time but want to also visit another area of Japan. I definitely want to spend some more time in Tokyo as I feel I didn't see as much as I wanted to last time so I'm thinking of spending about 4 days in either Sapporo or Okinawa. I might be able to arrange it so I can visit both and leave 6 days for Tokyo but due to expenses I might be able to only go to one of the 2, if you had to choose where would you opt for? Any advice would be great!

Posted Oct 24, 2017, 3:20 PM UTC

15
RealArc•

Okinawa is an island, Sapporo a city. Not that comparable. 4 days is not enough for Okinawa, 4 days too much for Sapporo only. Why not explore Kanazawa + Takayama? Gifu? Tohoku?

Okinawa might have pleasant 20 degrees celsius westher but I bet the sea won’t be that nice. Renting a car in Okinawa is pretty important.

3
mithdraug•

4 days too much for Sapporo only

If you consider the metro area (including Otaru), 4 days is reasonable enough.

Thus said, I wouldn't go to Hokkaido for 4 days, especially not in November (due to high possibilty of sleety pre-winter phase). As you suggested, 4 days is enough time to explore Hokuriku (Kanazawa/Takayama/Toyama), or Nagano, or southern parts of Tohoku (Sendai/Yamadera/Nikko).

4
Himekat•

I've been to both. It depends on what you want to do, really.

Okinawa (the main island) is actually rather large with somewhat poor public transportation options (especially compared to other parts of Japan). You'd almost definitely want to rent a car in order to get anywhere (that comes with associated costs and hassles like getting an International Driving Permit). Okinawa is beachy. It has lots of resorts. It will be quite warm still -- probably high 70s (F) and sunny. Naha (the main city) has some stuff, but most of the attractions are scattered all around the island. Lots of people go there for a relaxing beach vacation and that's sort of what the vibe is like. The food will be quite interesting -- it's a pretty cool cross of Chinese and Japanese food. There are lots of great food specialties.

Sapporo is a great city. Most of the major attractions can be done in a couple of days, and there are a couple of reasonable day trips you can take either by train or bus (or renting a car). Sapporo has mostly Japanese city attractions -- shopping, temples/shrines, museums, markets, etc. It also does have some nature/mountainous stuff, and the aforementioned day trips can put you in onsen towns or other somewhat remote places. Winter will be starting there -- depending on the time of the month, it could be like mid-50s (F) or as low as mid-30s (F) during the day. Depending on the time of the month, there might be skiing available in parts of Hokkaido, if that's your thing. The food is great -- Hokkaido is all about seafood, and the seafood in winter is some of the best seafood you can get.

3
OTASIM•

Like other people say I'd also recommend you to explore Hokuriku area. Matsumoto - Takayama - Shirakawago - Kanazawa You can see more places in 4 days.

2
PrideOfTehSouth•

I've been to Okinawa prefecture (it's not just an island) in November and it was stunning: tropical vibes, and nice and warm, but not hot. We travelled to Ishigaki (From Tokyo/Haneda via Naha airport) and Hateruma, without a hire car. Highly recommended!

1