1st Gen SMG Balance

The Eridani and Armistice arguably are subpar compared to the Cyclone, and also there are also 3 upcoming ES Smgs. Knowing this, would you nerf the Cyclone to be on par with the other two, or would you buff the Eridani and Armistice to the Cyclone's level?

Posted Oct 28, 2017, 8:25 PM UTC

222
PastalavistaBabeLight Assault > M40 Fury-F > Archer > Titan-AP•

Anthing compared to the Keklone is subpar. They'll probably nerf the Keklone before releasing the 3rd Gen SMGs so people will have a reason to buy them.

15
GamerDJ•

arguably

100% not arguable, the cyclone is the best smg in the game hands-down

11
AvalancheZ250Miller•

I'd rather see the other 2 SMG's buffed than the Cyclone nerfed. Just got the Auraxium today and going back to LMG's was quite painful, I admit, but I like being able to ADS and kill properly >15m. The Armistice either needs more ammo or better recoil, and the Eridani is quite balanced IMO (source: I've been killed by them a fair amount of times) but maybe a magazine size buff wouldn't be too out of order.

The fact is you can't really nerf the Cyclone without killing it. It already has the lowest RPM of its catagory, poor maxiumum damage range and a damage model that only just touches on 3-shot headshot kills that simply cannot be nerfed, even by 1 point of damage, without massively changing the gun. Messing with the accuracy would be horrific because the low RoF means that missing would be even more punishing considering the small magazine size (or lack of ALS if you chose to forfeit it for extended mags).

After all, you generate less salt from buffing weapons to be competitive than nerfing their competition.

9
VipersVenomX•

Cyclone's already been nerfed. I think people unduly bitch about it since more NC heavies use it than VS or TR heavies use their SMGs. This isn't because "Cyclone OP" though, it's because NC don't have a 750/143 LMG with good hipfire like VS and TR both do. NC instead gets lesser DPS LMGs with crappier hipfire. So they will naturally consider using an SMG of any kind sooner than VS or TR would. Thus, Cyclone gets used more.

If NC didn't have Blitz or Cyclone, and instead had TR or VS SMGs, they would be using those instead and people would be complaining about it. It really isn't what the problem is though; some NC players just feel forced to use SMGs on their heavies.

I mean you can call them shitters for doing it, and you probably wouldn't be wrong, but there's the main reason Cyclone HA is so prevalent. Not because Cyclone is so good compared to other SMGs.

Though from your post it seems like you don't necessarily think the gun is all that OP.

As for buffing the other two SMGs. . .5 rounds more in each of their magazines is the most I would consider doing to them to make them "buffed but fair". Eridani already is really good (and is underrated if anything), Armistice basically just needs a slight accuracy buff.

6
Iridar51Iridar.net•

Eridani is a fine weapon, but it suffers from overly restrictive magazine for no reason whatsoever. It should have 29-30 rounds per mag to be on par with Cyclone.

Armistice suffers from being not better enough than Blitz and Sirius. Gaining 51 RPM is not worth losing 20 rounds per mag. Armistice already deals 1900 DPS, it's hard to find a way to buff Armistice without making it too annoying to deal with or nerfing high capacity SMGs.

8
PastalavistaBabeLight Assault > M40 Fury-F > Archer > Titan-AP•

Maybe buff the Failstorm instead? Nah, who am I kidding? Somebody wearing a green bandana wouldn't buff a TR weapon which collects dust since it's release.

Actually, both Armistice and Failstorm needs some buffs. It's funny that the dakka faction has the worst SMGs.

8
Iridar51Iridar.net•

This thread is about 1st gen SMGs, so I didn't mention it. Yes, Failstorm needs a rework. There's no sense in just buffing it, it's too similar to Armistice. I've already posted this a couple of times. Hailstorm should be reworked into something like 112 @ 937 damage model, which would give it DPS on par with other high capacity SMGs. And Lynx-ify its recoil pattern, with emphasis on controllable vertical recoil and sensible horizontal recoil and CoF bloom.

6
PastalavistaBabeLight Assault > M40 Fury-F > Archer > Titan-AP•

Yeah, that's a good idea (I myself suggested it ages ago, but people cried "TR OP"), but we're still waiting for a TORQ LMG. So I doubt that they'll rework a 3 year old weapon which won't earn them any money just when new SMGs are around the corner.

6
VipersVenomX•

Uhhhhh, the Eridani is actually extremely good. It has better range, better accuracy, and higher max damage range than Cyclone.

Armistice is good too, but yes, it is a little worse than the other two. The only way you could really buff it is to make it slightly more accurate. Any more DPS and it would be unreasonable.

The real SMG thing to complain about are the attachments on the directive SMGs. For some reason they opted to not put the most important attachment on them (laser sight), and instead put forward grip on there, which no one in their right mind would ever use over an advanced laser sight.

6
Leftconsin[SOLx] [CTA]•

Obviously nerf the Cyclone to be clearly worse than the other two.

3
ItsJustDelta[oNRo]It's arms combining time!•

I think buffing the Eridani and Armistice would be more interesting than nerfing the cyclone.

3
KosViikGD 54l7 "NaCl spewer"•

Buff the two. I think the Cyclone is somewhat okay now, as it's been nerfed not too long ago. The other two are lackluster. We want more useful weapons and not more useless ones.

1
TheKhopesh•

Everyone always overstates the value of the cyclone.

It's quite good, but it's not AMAZING like everyone claims.

As far as the other two, the Armistice should have an extra 5 rounds per mag (total ammo pool up from 240 to 280 as well).

And the Eridani should have 28 rounds per mag (total ammo pool up from 200 to 224 as well).

-2†
PastalavistaBabeLight Assault > M40 Fury-F > Archer > Titan-AP•

Cyclone is the single best weapon in the game.

4
AnuErebus[00]•

Hardly. SMGs are heavily outclassed by Carbines, and an AR or LMG is going to give you a lot more range flexibility. The Cyclone is good at close range and easy to use, but it's far from being the best weapon in the game. If it was you'd have every NC vet using it exclusively instead of using the SAW, Anchor, Reaper, ACX, GD-7F etc.

9
Stormsh7dow[ZAPS] ProrionLOL•

The cyclone is easily the most powerful weapon in the game, sure i wouldn't use it in a field fight or out in the open. But since the majority of bases and fights are around enclosed areas it out shines everything else including shotguns.

2†
miniux[DA] I See Through Walls•

In certain situations

3
TheRandomnatrixBusy padding shitpost ratio•

Bandit is pretty much a better Cyclone after the LA CoF buffs, but nobody realizes it yet luckily

2
TheKhopesh•

Shotguns are better for CQC/close range.

The ONLY times that the Cyclone is the (trivially niche) "best" weapon in the game is if you've got a literal 100% headshot accuracy rating, AND ONLY when the target is LESS THAN 6m away...

...or if you have NO LESS THAN a 100% accuracy rating while firing FULL AUTO, in which case you have a small advantage.

But in any fight where you cannot consistently land 100% full auto accuracy on the chest (AKA, all fights ever seen in the history of planetside 2 that weren't against non-AFK players), then the advantage of the slightly faster on-paper TTK is utterly destroyed by the advantage of other faster firing CQC weapons which are more forgiving for those missed percentage shots. Even a missed shot or two compared to an equal number of missed shot(s) from a 143/750 standard damage/fire rate weapon is enough to put the advantage solidly in the hands of the person not using the cyclone.

-1
R4z0rbee•

Sure, just give the prowler and vanguard side strafe capability and fully stabilized guns on rough terrain. Also give NC and TR a hitscan rocketlauncher. While you are at it, scale down the hitboxes of TR and NC ESF's along the z axis so it is more in line with the scythe. Couldnt hurt to remove bullet drop for all TR and NC weapons as well. Actually, I also suggest to make the TR ripper as quiet as the NC/VS knife and maybe the godsaw and butcher should also get infite magazine heatmechanic.

Afterall its not fair that VS has something better in those categories that the other factions dont, am I rite ?

-9
swclone1OP•

I dont think you understand my question, I'm simply asking how someone would tune faction-specific qualities for the 1st gen smgs so they can be "equal" in the sense that they can all preform the same job (close quarters combat) on the same efficiency level while they retain their faction's flavor. I do though understand where you're coming from, yes some weapons are impossible to fine tune without nerfing them to hell, buffing them to hell, or removing what makes them special due to the weapon's mechanics IE: AV Mana Turret, but the three smg's do have a decent amount of wiggle room stats-wise and are not that overly seperate giving daybreak the ability to nudge them a bit in either direction.

3
R4z0rbee•

Sure I understand your question, nerf cyclone or buff armistice and eridani to equalize all the smg's performance in question. With my retort i tried to stress that these differences in performance are not just restricted to submachineguns. So does you question also entail how we buff every single NC and TR piece of equipment that is not performing just as good as VS in every single category ? Otherwise your post could be viewed as somewhat biased.

-6