Antinatalism as a possible 'Great Filter'
First off; I'm sure this theory isn't unique, but I wasn't able to find much on this particular take. I've seen explanations of civilizations moving from the physical world to the virtual, erasing all biological needs in the process, as being an explanation for the Fermi Paradox. But the 'needs' part bothers me.
Punishment-reward system
For a biological being to continue to exist, there need to be some rules. Generally, actions that help the continuity of a species will be rewarded, actions that go against this result in punishment. Quick example; eating food results in a good feeling, not eating food results in a bad feeling. This can be scaled up to whatever the species does, however complex.
If you remove the reward from the actions needed to ensure the continuity, the system falls apart and the species will end. Example; if sex would't feel good, or would even feel bad, not enough animals would have sex to ensure procreation of the species. Same with eating, defending the young, etc.
So if both statements are true, then it follows that if you remove the punishments and rewards, the needs and urges also vanish. And if those are gone, then likely so is the motivation to continue key actions to prevent extinction.
Going against nature
We humans distinguish ourselves from other animals by the ability to go against nature. Things like rape and murder are considered wrong and punishable, although these things are prevalent in any other animal species. So even though someone might want to fulfill their urge to forcefully impregnate a potential mate or kill a rival trying to do the same, generally this urge never leads to action.
This means we have at least some control over urges dictated by nature. And because we have the ability to decide which of these urges are to be suppressed and which aren't, ethics and morality play an essential part in how we treat ourselves and other humans. Importantly, because it is demonstrated that we have this ability, we now also have a moral obligation to apply it in all aspects of our lives. We can't decide to apply ethics in one case and not the other. In the example of murder and rape, it would be immoral to judge murder as being ethically bad and not scrutinize rape by the same standards.
Antinatalism
So if every aspect of our lives is to be ethically and morally evaluated equally, so must the very impactful act of making a new human. If we look at procreation from the perspective of a yet-to-be-born human, no rational reason can be give for that human to exist. It's not as if he or she waiting somewhere to start living because of a need or urge to 'experience life'. Making a new human is solely beneficial to the parents and the society, and therefor the species as a whole.
So if we rule out a life of pure euphoria, which would still only be fulfilling a need to trigger that euphoria, anything less would be considered a worse scenario opposed to not existing an hence not suffering. This is the case even if nothing bad happens to a person living an entire life of bliss, except for falling from a bike once (that one fall from the bike, and the consequent punishment of pain, is not preferable to having no need to prevent pain). However, considering the punishment-reward system, it's far more likely there will be a lot of instances where emotional and physical suffering will occur. Suffering that can only occur when that person exists.
So if making new humans is deemed an ethically unsound and immoral act, and the human species evolve to a point where this is accepted to be true and either enforce anti-procreation methods, or intuitively halt procreation altogether, no new humans would be made, leading to the extinction of the species. This would thus act as the proposed 'Great Filter'.
Additional notes
For AI or uploaded human brains to thrive in a virtual world, there will need to be a reward system, which would lead to needs and urges. Without a punishment or reward, like failing or succeeding in satisfying ones curiosity, no motivation exists to do anything at all.
Humans could of course decide to stop procreation and extend their own biological lives instead. This would be an argument against what I stated above. However, I do think (but haven't thought this trough deeply enough) that suffering would be at the top of the list of things to eradicate. And without the context of suffering I don't really see how pleasure is experienced, aside from a continuous dopamine infusion. So as long as there is suffering, there's incentive to fight the things that enable the suffering, which is the human body and mind.
Disclaimer
I'm not a native english speaker, so please take into account some mistakes in nuance, spelling, etc. Also, I'm not well versed in any scientific or philosophical field. This is just armchair philosophy for me, no pitchforks please...*
TL:DR
If rape, a natural instinct fulfilling a need, is considered bad and can be successfully suppressed, then so should other bad natural instincts be suppressed, like making a new human to solely fulfill your own needs. This self-consciousness would lead to extinction of the species.
Posted Nov 18, 2017, 2:46 PM UTC · edited
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
[/r/antinatalism] Antinatalism as a possible 'Great Filter'
[/r/greatfilter] Antinatalism as a possible 'Great Filter'
^(If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads.) ^(Info ^/ ^Contact)