Antinatalism as a possible 'Great Filter'

First off; I'm sure this theory isn't unique, but I wasn't able to find much on this particular take. I've seen explanations of civilizations moving from the physical world to the virtual, erasing all biological needs in the process, as being an explanation for the Fermi Paradox. But the 'needs' part bothers me.

Punishment-reward system

For a biological being to continue to exist, there need to be some rules. Generally, actions that help the continuity of a species will be rewarded, actions that go against this result in punishment. Quick example; eating food results in a good feeling, not eating food results in a bad feeling. This can be scaled up to whatever the species does, however complex.

If you remove the reward from the actions needed to ensure the continuity, the system falls apart and the species will end. Example; if sex would't feel good, or would even feel bad, not enough animals would have sex to ensure procreation of the species. Same with eating, defending the young, etc.

So if both statements are true, then it follows that if you remove the punishments and rewards, the needs and urges also vanish. And if those are gone, then likely so is the motivation to continue key actions to prevent extinction.

Going against nature

We humans distinguish ourselves from other animals by the ability to go against nature. Things like rape and murder are considered wrong and punishable, although these things are prevalent in any other animal species. So even though someone might want to fulfill their urge to forcefully impregnate a potential mate or kill a rival trying to do the same, generally this urge never leads to action.

This means we have at least some control over urges dictated by nature. And because we have the ability to decide which of these urges are to be suppressed and which aren't, ethics and morality play an essential part in how we treat ourselves and other humans. Importantly, because it is demonstrated that we have this ability, we now also have a moral obligation to apply it in all aspects of our lives. We can't decide to apply ethics in one case and not the other. In the example of murder and rape, it would be immoral to judge murder as being ethically bad and not scrutinize rape by the same standards.

Antinatalism

So if every aspect of our lives is to be ethically and morally evaluated equally, so must the very impactful act of making a new human. If we look at procreation from the perspective of a yet-to-be-born human, no rational reason can be give for that human to exist. It's not as if he or she waiting somewhere to start living because of a need or urge to 'experience life'. Making a new human is solely beneficial to the parents and the society, and therefor the species as a whole.

So if we rule out a life of pure euphoria, which would still only be fulfilling a need to trigger that euphoria, anything less would be considered a worse scenario opposed to not existing an hence not suffering. This is the case even if nothing bad happens to a person living an entire life of bliss, except for falling from a bike once (that one fall from the bike, and the consequent punishment of pain, is not preferable to having no need to prevent pain). However, considering the punishment-reward system, it's far more likely there will be a lot of instances where emotional and physical suffering will occur. Suffering that can only occur when that person exists.

So if making new humans is deemed an ethically unsound and immoral act, and the human species evolve to a point where this is accepted to be true and either enforce anti-procreation methods, or intuitively halt procreation altogether, no new humans would be made, leading to the extinction of the species. This would thus act as the proposed 'Great Filter'.

Additional notes

For AI or uploaded human brains to thrive in a virtual world, there will need to be a reward system, which would lead to needs and urges. Without a punishment or reward, like failing or succeeding in satisfying ones curiosity, no motivation exists to do anything at all.

Humans could of course decide to stop procreation and extend their own biological lives instead. This would be an argument against what I stated above. However, I do think (but haven't thought this trough deeply enough) that suffering would be at the top of the list of things to eradicate. And without the context of suffering I don't really see how pleasure is experienced, aside from a continuous dopamine infusion. So as long as there is suffering, there's incentive to fight the things that enable the suffering, which is the human body and mind.

Disclaimer

I'm not a native english speaker, so please take into account some mistakes in nuance, spelling, etc. Also, I'm not well versed in any scientific or philosophical field. This is just armchair philosophy for me, no pitchforks please...*


TL:DR

If rape, a natural instinct fulfilling a need, is considered bad and can be successfully suppressed, then so should other bad natural instincts be suppressed, like making a new human to solely fulfill your own needs. This self-consciousness would lead to extinction of the species.

Posted Nov 18, 2017, 2:46 PM UTC · edited

86
TotesMessenger•

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

 ^(If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads.) ^(Info ^/ ^Contact)

2
giroth•

Very interesting perspective, not much written on it but I have thought about it a little.

A related idea seems to be the "blissed wirehead", euphoria delivered by neural interface. Might just be a step to your final endpoint.

My major exception was your contention that "Making a new human is solely beneficial to the parents and the society, and therefor the species as a whole."

I have suffered a great deal in my life, yet I am grateful to be alive. I believe in the fundamental value of life/existence. I guess this assumption/belief is where the true split with the anti-natalist position occurs. Of course not everyone feels this way, etc, but the "rational" anti-natalist postion has always seemed cold and extreme to me.

As an ESL writer your English is incredible, no worries there!

2
broccolisproutOP•

I have suffered a great deal in my life, yet I am grateful to be alive. I believe in the fundamental value of life/existence.

I've had a very interesting discussion with a friend of mine who's a talented mathematician. I couldn't convince him of the fact that someone who doesn't exist is better off than someone existing, because zero can't be a factor in this comparison.

I however am blessed with a tomato-soup brain, so unhindered by these abstract concepts I can only tell you that your notion of gratefulness only comes from a desire to live, despite the suffering. Maybe interesting to look at it this way; if given the choice, would you bestow your exact life on another human being, or would you rather have no-one have the same experience?

6

I am 5 months late to this discussion but I am hoping that you will expand a bit on you belief in the fundamental value in life/existence. I commend you on your belief, even though you have experienced great suffering. Personally my life has been relatively good, especially when compared to the hardships of others in the World. I'm referring mostly to third world hardships but there are millions of people in my home county; the US, who have experienced far greater tragedies than I have yet to experience. I am a white, male upper middle class US citizen whose most personal loss is that of my cat, who I was.very close to. And yet, I find life/existence to be hugely over-rated. I refuse to willingly procreate which is causing very significant problems in my marriage. To the point of feeling like I would be in the wrong in not taking our lives, should bringing a child into this world become inevitable. Am I just an ungrateful piece of shit? Im sorry, I just dont get it. Life is a series of negative emotions and physical pain lightly spruced with tiny moments of positivity. Sorry.

1
giroth•

Nothing to apologize for, everyone has different experiences and perspectives. Suffering is also a fact for absolutely everyone. Some of the Buddhist sects seem to think that meditation/enlightenment leads to non-rebirth after 7 lifetimes, and this is a good thing. But they also end up in a place of consciousness/non-consciousness, where words are probably failing us.

You are definitely not an ungrateful piece of shit, and philosophically you can find a lot of support for your position. But a lot of philosophers were pretty fucking miserable :) I'd be most concerned with your marriage, save that at all (most) costs. Talk with your wife about your anti-natal concerns, maybe a therapist, don't keep it bottled up inside. You're not a bad person for having these thoughts.

Anyways best of luck to you

2

Hey! Thanks for getting back to me. I appreciate the response. I can also appreciate the positivity of your attitude, even if I dont really get it.

I didnt know about the Buddhist beliefs. I incorrectly assumed that reincarnation went on infinitely, a belief that kind of sounds like hell to me. Glad to hear that some kind of Nirvana exists after 7 lifetimes.

Thanks for the advice about therapy. I am actually in the process of testing out a couple therapists and my wife has one that we will be seeing together in the near future. I think it will be beneficial for both of us but I just dont see a set of words or events that can make me feel better about creating a new human consciousness. That shit keeps me up at night. It just feels wrong, like I would be dooming a being to a lifetime of fear and pain. I had an excellent upbringing. I have a great relationship with my parents and they did (and continue to do) everything in their power to help me out. I shouldnt call myself a piece of shit but damn does that seem like the case given the shit that goes through my brain and comes out my mouth.

Enough about me. How are things on your end?

1
DarqEgo•

I think a flaw in your hypothesis is in the rewards/punishment assumption. While yes I agree some of our natural behavior falls under this category, life is not so easily thwarted. While our capacity for abstract thought has given rise to defined ethics and moral standards, those aren't actually an attempt to stop suffering. It's merely an attempt to control a large community that would otherwise be chaotic. Which is good for our species overall, but as you know there are many who don't subscribe or follow those. Also there have been studies showing the happiness of people drop drastically when having kids but increase as the children grow up and leave, so procreation is to deeply ingrained in our biology to override by mere thought, at least on a large scale.

1
broccolisproutOP•

You're describing how the situation is now. But in a distant future, moral standards could evolve to a point where ensuring the happiness of existing humans by making more humans (which fulfills the need to have sex, feel purpose, feel loved, giving in to social pressure, all things associated with having kids) is deemed an immoral act. It would fit on the curve that already contains things like murder, rape, pedophilia, etc., things that are no longer excusable now that we're able, and thus obligated, to do something about.

3
Firebrass•

In all dystopian science-fiction that I’ve read, when sexual reproduction was out of favor, the society compensated by a different method. Aldous Huxley’s book Brave New World might be an interesting read for ya. Speaking of behavior curves, I have no idea why it is so, but it seems to be an age old emergent property of human society, there is no great population that has ever been of one mind on anything, unless survival explicitly depends on it. We can all agree breathing is good, but we can’t even all agree that murder and rape are bad, as evidenced by the simple fact that they still occur. There’s a rabbit hole we could go down here about the impacts physiology and cognition have on behavior relative to one another, but the outcome is the same when you zoom out. Humans en masse spread out along a bell curve for any given behavior, ensuring no tradition will stand forever without extreme environmental constraints.

Further, this divergence of behavior is necessary for survival at any level of technological sophistication, and becomes more necessary as technological capacity increases. Imagine if we all wanted to make graphite pencils, every human on Earth; we’d eventually use up all the carbon in the plant and animal kingdoms, all the oil and carbon dioxide, and we’d wind up killing each other to suck the last drops of carbon out of each other’s biomass - with our current technology no less. Bell curves are key to understanding human behavior, politics, and history,

1
Uridoz•

Do you take account of the effect of natural selection on a genetic and mimetic scale?

Self-consciousness can be naturally limited if it does indeed lead to extinction at the scale of an individual, a family, a tribe, etc ...

In order for antinatalism to be a Great Filter, you need a situation where it can effectively affect the behaviour of an entire civilisation and in a short time span.

Either you need level of consciousness high enough to understand antinatalism (this sounds so fucking prideful holy shit ...) in the majority of the population BUT that wouldn't affect it until antinatalism starts striking everyone (unlikely considering it means having more and too much self awareness doesn't impact your ability to survive and reproduce ... we know it does. In a negative way.). Or at least you need it to exist within the individuals holding the power to end civilisation.

What if nihilism or antinatalism was a Big Filter for A.I.s? Humans make an A.I. that will end human civilisation, might end up being a hive mind, with a central unit, and then it might get to some nihilistic realisation that will make it stop doing anything, or perhaps it suffers in some way and it comes to realise how existing in suffering and creating other suffering A.I.s is evil. But again, I hardly see an A.I. developing empathy, so nihilism seems like a more likely Big Filter. Except if empathy is hardwired into it in an unmodifiable way, I don't see any reason for why you should have any when you can already get all the information you need through binary signals.

1
grenadesong•

So if every aspect of our lives is to be ethically and morally evaluated equally, so must the very impactful act of making a new human.

No one must do that. Human genes and most animals have some type of altruism and empathy for each other but there's still no must do anything. There are laws we will get punished for if we break them but that's it.

So, really, you can do whatever you want as long, just like you said, we feel good from eating, because it makes us full, and taste good... and in the same way, our genes make us feel bad if we do harmful actions towards other humans and animals. But it's apparent that the altrustic genes we're born with aren't powerful enough because there's a lot of evil in this world still. So you can do whatever you want as long you feel good about it.

1
broccolisproutOP•

No one must do that.

But that's exactly what we try to accomplish, as part of evolving morality. You really can't do whatever you want, not in a civilized society anyway, there are always consequences. Only when things go wrong, like in wartime, or when there's too much leeway, like the wealth inequality situation, will people do horrible things. That's because all animals will try to dominate for that provides safety and reproduction rights. That's the exact thing we try to negate.

And that's what I meant; if the human species is trying to raise the level of morality, then it has to encompass every aspect, including procreation.

2
benscottgood93•

I was watching a talk about the sherdinov scale (think that's what it's called), where they explained the levels of advancement of a species. We are type 0, a planetary species. The most advanced was type 3 (I think). This civilisation controlled the energy of every sun in a galaxy. They could do anything they wanted. Create new planets, never die etc.

Then the realisation hit me: maybe these civilisations have gotten to a point where they can do anything, and then figured there is no point in doing anything more. Maybe they know something about the afterlife or 'source' of the universe, where the whole point of it is to just experience earthly emotions and live life, and we are simply an infinite consciousness that can already do anything it wants, giving ourselves something to do. (Very alan watts I know)

Therefore, why would aliens tell us this and disrupt the illusion that we have inherently made for ourselves? Maybe they got bored and decided to kill themselves to 'start again '.

TL;DR

Aliens know we created an illusion of the 'universe' because we were bored, and therefore won't tell us and disrupt the illusion.

1
Firebrass•

Kardishev scale, I believe. It now has 5 recognized levels, so harnessing all the stars in the galaxy is nothing. But the scale is a tool for measuring something we aren’t sure exists, hence the Fermi paradox. Either way, nothing to worry about day to day.

1
benscottgood93•

Btw, sorry for disrupting your illusion.

1
edgeplayer•

From my understanding, this is NOT what the Great Filter is. You are discussing the situations where a species fails to reproduce. This may be for one reason or another, but it as a result of a sociological condition adopted by the species that means it no longer procreates. This process is effectively self-determined.

We are talking about an evolving species. This evolution also includes a possible transformation into some transhuman form. This transhuman form may not have procreation as we understand it , but may have the capability to copy any member at will. Each being may well be effectively immortal as long as resources are available to sustain the life of all the beings.

The Great Filter is more about the failure of resources to maintain the species no matter what philosophy, state of being, procreational process etc exists. The Great Filter is an environmental collapse. An example is what we are about to experience in roughly 1000 years when the Earth becomes a hot planet like Venus. (Stephen Hawking has been making public statements regarding this.)

Earth's tropo temperature is currently increasing at 1 degree Centigrade per 30 years. Although we are aware of the problem, we are not able to put a dent in this warming trend. (Cape Town's city fathers have not been able to put a dent in water usage despite the obvious consequences.)

Another aspect of the Great Filter is depletion of a resource necessary to become a galactic citizen. We do not yet know what the required resources are or whether we have enough of what we would need. A deficit means that we will never become an interstellar space traveling civilization. We could continue living on this planet but would never have any visibility in the galaxy.

1
broccolisproutOP•

From my understanding, this is NOT what the Great Filter is. You are discussing the situations where a species fails to reproduce. This may be for one reason or another, but it as a result of a sociological condition adopted by the species that means it no longer procreates. This process is effectively self-determined.

It was my understanding that self-anihilation (nuclear war, no procreation, resource depletion, pollution, etc.) counts as a filter too. Maybe I'm mistaken, but isn't a great filter just an abstract notion of something that prevents a species to thrive towards interstellar occupancy?

1
edgeplayer•

Yes but. The Great Filter is used to explain the Fermi Paradox. The implication being that it happens for every evolving species. But cases like nuclear annihilation and forgoing procreation are effectively choices that cannot be relied upon to hold in every case. Resource depletion and pollution are both examples of action in ignorance that could irreversibly lead to extinction. We are currently driving headlong into the Great Filter. But does every evolving species in the Universe make the same mistakes as us and end up extinct because of their ignorance and refusal to plan properly in advance ? Maybe. I have not read any psychological analysis that addresses this question.

1
broccolisproutOP•

I've often thought that you need a sufficiently complex society to achieve big goals like galactic exploration, but that this complexity simultaneously also causes the goal to be unachievable. Unfortunately that notion also undermines my antinatalism hypothesis.

1
edgeplayer•

I think when you discuss these processes with generality the conclusions tend to be vague.

Your "antinatalism" is a natural consequence in any evolving society. As planetary limits are reached for resources such as fresh water, population cannot continue to increase exponentially without disastrous consequences. Antinatalism is a natural way to live within a finite budget. A lack of antinatalism will certainly cause extinction. Measured antinatalism (birth control) will sustain the civilization indefinitely if it is managed well.

1
zarmesan•

So if every aspect of our lives is to be ethically and morally evaluated equally, so must the very impactful act of making a new human. If we look at procreation from the perspective of a yet-to-be-born human, no rational reason can be give for that human to exist. It's not as if he or she waiting somewhere to start living because of a need or urge to 'experience life'. Making a new human is solely beneficial to the parents and the society, and therefor the species as a whole.

I agree with most of your post, and I am unsure of whether this is the answer to the paradox. There are so many possibilities and we have very little info, but this does seem like a fresh idea. I am part of the ground wants for society to become antinatalist and for my biological life to be extended. As much as I agree though, I think you've skipped some steps here. A lot of your argument lies of the premise of a form of negative utilitarian, which not everyone is.

As an additional note, I always like to make the distinction between killing a living individual (against their will) and that of preventing a born (there is no will to go against).

1