CMV: Postmodernism is toxic and built on fallacious reasoning
I'm going to say outright that there may be some semantical issues here regarding classification, as postmodernism encompasses such a massive body of work over quite a long period of time, and, like many genres, has no official criteria as a definition.
That being said, I hope the definition and explanation I'm providing here are sufficient enough to warrant categorization.
People often cite authors like Foucault, Derrida, and Boudrillard for being the major influencing voices that shaped postmodernism. Ideas like Foucault's view of insanity as a social construct, or Derrida's deconstruction of the dominant discourses on Western culture, are both concepts that have quite obviously been integrated into postmodern thinking.
I don't want to dismiss this origin story, but I want to add to it by saying that what was happening in the painting world leading up to the emergence of this philosophy was also important, and, perhaps more importantly, grounded in a very practical impetus for change. This being the development of photography in the late 19th century.
Photography was especially detrimental to the continuation of painting art because it threatened to make a lot of the purpose of this kind of art obsolete. History paintings could be replicated, portraits instantly taken, and genre paintings recreated without even trying. There was a real need for this industry to adapt, which is how we got the flurry of art movements that emerged as part of general heading of modern art. Whether this meant venturing where photos couldn't take us, like dreams, or reality that's distorted by emotion; abandoning the illusion of depth, as the fauvists and cubists had; deconstructing shapes; or throwing out representation altogether, there was a real effort being made to redefine the purpose of painting art as an industry.
This is where postmodernism comes in. People started looking at this change and adopting the view that since people were essentially just making up the rules as they went along, the rules themselves must not count for very much. This was in line with a manner of thinking that viewed value systems as being inherently ethnocentric, and interpretation of values as being ultimately groundless.
This philosophy has been compressed and distributed through a seemingly innocuous and insightful question: what is art?
The implication here is that there is no category that could be defined for which we could reasonably describe what 'art', or especially 'high quality art' was. This is especially apparent when we look at how often artists have been ridiculed for breaking seemingly immutable rules in one generation, only to be praised as innovative in the next. Moreover, the philosophy goes on to champion this idea that theories that describe what is required to make a piece of art great have inherently been non-inclusive for reasons that are defined only by false and hegemonic ideas of cultural absolutism.
Now, this is why the philosophy I've sincerely tried to accurately represent is a pile of bologna.
Let's talk about it on a purely rational level first. I know that experience talking to people about this may not statistically significantly represent the whole, but I have been repeatedly confronted by baffling beliefs regarding art. People I've spoken to who hold that 'anything can be art' unironically defend every single item I throw at them as potentially being art. This has been everything from an atom to a dustpan full of dirt that you might have accidentally knocked over. I will concede ahead of time to any argument that claims that these views do not accurately represent the whole of the movement, as the sample size I have for them is admittedly small, but if you believe this, let me tell you why you're wrong. Words are like containers for meaning: when we have a word, we place certain definitions in that title that come to define it's meaning. This is called operationalizing. When you have a container that is so large that it literally excludes nothing; that word, by definition, becomes meaningless. You can not argue that 'art' can be anything, because as soon as you do so, you are creating a word that has no meaning. People have argued with me over the semantics that they only say it can mean anything, but lacking any qualifier to distinguish 'can' and 'does' is a functionally useless argument.
The second point here is an accusation of hypocrisy that is lazily built into this system. The fundamental tenant of postmodernism seems to be that all interpretation of value is inherently unfounded and that the only real narrative is one of power dynamics and exclusion. This, if you haven't picked up on it, is inherently contradictory, since the idea that the only force governing relationships and institutions is power dynamics is, in itself, a narrative.
Finally, and perhaps most damningly, the entire proposed issue with definitions, categorizations, and narratives of value is based entirely on fallacious reasoning. The idea that you cannot define the parameters of what makes a work of art more competent and valuable, based on the premise that no matter what parameter you define, there will be an exception that can be found, is called the Bald Man's or Continuum Fallacy. This fallacy causes one to erroneously reject a vague claim simply on the basis that it is not as precise as one might like. The reasoning works like this: Say you have a man with 5,000 hairs on his head, is he bald? What about 4,999? If you keep counting down from here, what number would you stop on to say that 'Yes, a man with 893 hairs is bald?' Since you obviously can not define a number with this level of precision, we have to conclude that baldness does not exist in men.
The reality here is that in virtually all categories, there exists a certain coninuum between two states that becomes blurred and ambiguous around the edges. One should not conclude from this that the two states do not exist.
I feel like I'm really pushing the length that any reader will tolerate here, so I will try to be a little more brief on the practical and negative impacts of this kind of philosophy.
Very few people really see this type of thinking as a problem, and this is presumably because they don't generally particularly care about art, or painting, very much. Keep in mind here though that the soundness of this reasoning is not exclusive at all to the realm of art. Imagine that instead of asking "What is art?" and pointing out all possible outliers to your definition, the question was, instead, "What is medicine?" Is it something that cures you? What about tylenol? Is it something that cures you or makes you feel better when you're feeling sick? What about opium, or getting a pleasant text from someone?
The problem here is that this philosophical system inherently undermines competence and quality in favour of nihilistic meta-commentaries, narratives of privilege and power, blatant careerism, and snake oil salesmanship.
This is a footnote from the CMV moderators. We'd like to remind you of a couple of things. Firstly, please read through our rules. If you see a that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views**! Any questions or concerns? Feel free to message us. Happy CMVing!
Posted Nov 27, 2017, 7:02 PM UTC · edited
Okay, first, you’ve entirely mischaracterized Baudrillard, who hates everything about postmodernism and postmodern art. His philosophy is postmodern in so far as it tries to explain what postmodernism is leading to, and if you believe Baudrillard, it’s leading someplace really really scary. You might do well to read a little of him.
Second, nowhere do postmodern theories of art say that all art (or anything) is of equal value, or that art can not be valued. Check out the Stanford encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on contemporary Definitions of Art. There are basically three schools of thought in contemporary/postmodern aesthetics here.
Institutional- This is the one communists and cynics will get behind. Art is an institution run by museums, galleries, collectors and critics. Art is anything this institution says it is, and its value is whatever they can get paid for it. Your six year olds doodle is not art because the institution will not pay anything for it, even though it may look just as good as a million dollar work of art.
Historical- Art is a conversation with previous art. Marcel Duchamp’s fountain (a urinal placed on its side) is valuable because it changed the conversation in an interesting way. Manet’s dejeuner sur l’herb is valuable because it copied it’s poses straight from an etching by Raphael (whose style of painting - no evidence of brush strokes, idealized forms - was then in vogue) but put a proto-impressionist spin on it, and changed the conversation. All the big movements, ab-ex, pop, minimalism, conceptual - comment on the movements that came before, and can only be understood in context. What art is valuable will be determined by history, because later artists will reference it and critique it through their art.
Functional- Art is whatever works to give you an aesthetic experience. It is valuable based on how valuable that experience is. While everything can be potentially art using this definition, most things will be bad art. If someone is using the Functional theory to say all art is equally valuable, that may be true for them, but they are only demonstrating they have no aesthetic judgment at all. Take food as an example. You’re not going to listen to a food critic who says “I love all food equally! If it’s edible, I will eat it and like it! Who is to say this hunk of mold I found under my sink is any better than a Kobe steak! Aesthetic experience is subjective!” Yeah, it’s subjective, but that doesn’t make your opinion any good. Your opinion is good if it’s functional as well, if it’s capable of convincing others. (Note also that this kind of approach isn’t postmodern so much as it is pragmatist, dating back to William James’ Varieties of Religious Experience, around the beginning of the 20th century, where he says beliefs are valuable not based on their truth, as belief implies something is ultimately unknowable, but based on how useful it is to believe that. So believing in free will is good because it’s a useful way to think.)
I think all three theories have their points, and I approach art using all three.
I've got to give you a point right off the bat for correcting me on Baudrillard. I have to admit that I'm unfamiliar with his work, only his association with the movement, and what I was able to read before posting seemed to oddly align with my thoughts. I was likely unequivocally wrong on this point, have a Δ. Any recommendations on specific works?
On your second complaint, I am far more skeptical. As atrocious as I think postmodernist thought is, in general, I don't believe that it has completely subsumed philosophical thinking on the topic of art. The website you linked me to specifically outlines 'traditional definitions', and while I realize the potential futility of going down this rabbithole of an argument, I do not immediately agree that the definitions described here are exclusively espoused from a postmodern worldview.
I mean, ultimately we risk just butting heads on semantical issues here. I am drawing my basic view of what postmodernism is closer, in general to statements made earlier on in it's history. Statements like "The one object of 50 years of abstract art is to present art-as-art and as nothing else, to make it into the one thing it is only, separating and defining it more and more, making it purer and emptier, more absolute and more exclusive - non-objective, non-representational, non-figurative, non-imagist, non-expressionist, non-subjective. the only and one way to say what abstract art or art-as-art is, is to say what it is not." – Ad Reinhardt (1963)., and "Any branch of philosophy that dealt with “beauty” and thus, taste, was inevitably duty bound to discuss art as well. Out of this “habit” grew the notion that there was a conceptual connection between art and aesthetics, which is not true." - Joseph Kosuth (1969)
Whether my views of the definition have not caught up to it's current incarnation, or yours are more representative of a more rational and integrated view, I mean, who can really say? If we can't agree on a definition though, we're not likely going to find a way to productively discuss this.
What Baudrillard book to start with depends on what you’re reading him for. For philosophy, start with Simulacra and Simulation. For social critique, The Transparency of Evil. For aesthetics, he had essays collected in The Conspiracy of Art.
And I agree, postmodernism is a broad, vague term and we won’t get anywhere unless we agree on semantics. I was assuming you were talking about contemporary philosophical views on aesthetics, and was trying to argue that the philosophy was sound and is often very mischaracterized.
But I guess your talking more about the turn towards minimalism and conceptualism around and after the late sixties?
With your two examples, I’d argue they do fit in with the three basic views I outlined. Reinhardt is working in a Historicist framework. I see Reinhardt as someone painted into a corner. At the time, the historical conversation had kind of painted itself into a corner. Only abstraction was taken seriously, and anything that was remotely “illusionistic”, suggesting form or depth, was ridiculed. Reinhardts black paintings brought this conversation to its logical conclusion. People began to declare that painting was dead, so minimalism became popular, but that allowed painters to quietly return to representational painting, now-expressionism for example. This wouldn’t have happened if Reinhardt, Joseph Stella and that gang hadn’t exhausted the critical framework. So if you don’t appreciate their paintings aesthetically, you can appreciate them for that at least.
Kosuth’s quote is more functionalist: art is just an aesthetic experience that need not be connected to ideas of beauty, form or taste. I like some conceptual art because they often function like puzzles or mental experiments or illustrations of philosophical ideas, but I totally get that most people probably wouldn’t enjoy that.
Are you arguing that Kosuth and Reinhardt make bad art or had bad ideas or that what they did should not be considered art?
Yes, conceptual art in particular; minimalism at least has some corporate function. Also purely abstract art, as Reinhardt describes it.
As for Reinhardt's conceptual ideas, you have a point about them, I just feel like they're not particularly innovative or interesting. I will always defer back to Duchamp's Fountain when a point like this is brought up. Granted, the meaning is not identical, but it's so close that the endless variations on the theme that followed are just something I can't see as anything but intellectually lazy and cynical. Moreover, where it was bad with Reinhardt, it's kind of disgraceful this late into the game.
Beyond this though, I have to apologize, as I haven't articulated a point which is really quite fundamental to my overall perspective regarding postmodernism, so I can see now that I kind of left a gap in my interpretation. The argument that I'm launching against Kosuth and Reinhardt, and indeed against postmodernism on the whole, is that these clever sounding philosophies are nothing more than vehicles for endorsing laziness and incompetence.
I don't think it's a coincidence that the holdovers from the modernist movements that became more or less absorbed by postmodernism are those movements that required a minimal baseline of skill and effort to execute, namely minimalism and abstract expressionism. I won't say that what either of those artists made wasn't art, but it certainly was at least extremely low quality art, as is reflective in what their philosophies endorse.
So I guess you’re arguing for an essential connection between craftsmanship and aesthetic value?
I hope you would agree though that art is more than craftsmanship though, that painting a work of art is different than just painting well, and that art can be technically well executed yet fall flat.
I see conceptual art as an investigation into what this other element is that exists beyond craftsmanship, and the investigation was done by jettisoning everything they could that wasn’t essential. I personally also prefer art that has both good craftsmanship and good ideas. However, I appreciate conceptual art in a museum as it makes me consider works of art that I like in a different light.
For instance Kosuth’s One and Three Chairs: a real chair, a photograph of that chair, a photograph of a dictionary definition of a chair. It’s a basic lesson in semiotics stated with a startling degree of clarity. It makes me think immediately of cubism: looking at the same object from multiple angles, trying to get at the platonic essence of its subject, it’s chair-ness. On its own it’s just a semiotics lesson, but t in a museum it makes me look at the cubist paintings differently, and so I value what it adds to the conversation running in my head.
Reinhardt’s black paintings, meanwhile, immediately make me think of Rembrandt, of what a Rembrandt painting would look like without the figure, just the dark background. You go up close and you can see all these subtle differences. So next time I see a Rembrandt I can compare the technique.
Confirmed: 1 delta awarded to u/kublahkoala (59∆).
^Delta System Explained ^| ^Deltaboards [](HTTP://DB3PARAMSSTART { "comment": "This is hidden text for DB3 to parse. Please contact the author of DB3 if you see this", "issues": {}, "parentUserName": "kublahkoala" } DB3PARAMSEND)