r/Stellar•
O2plant

Concerns with Wallets and Stellar Account Viewer

First of all,

When creating a wallet on your desktop or your phone, you generate a secret key. With this key, you access your wallet. My concern is the fact that ANY account/wallet is accessible in the Stellar Account Viewer! ( https://www.stellar.org/account-viewer/#!/ ). Just try it for yourself.

  1. Wallet/Account created on desktop/phone, even though it is password protected is accessible in the Account Viewer with your secret key.

  2. Vice versa, an account generated in Stellar's Account Viewer can be used to login in a Desktop/Phone wallet, if you create an account with an existing secret key.

.. That's an interesting design I thought, for example, when you aren't home and want to send some Lumen, you login in the online account viewer with your Secret Key and voila, you can send your Lumen, quickly, from any pc in the world.

Now my Concern. This https://www.stellar.org/account-viewer/#!/ isn't protected with an additional password. It isn't protected against bots. There is no captcha, no key puzzle, no "I am not a Robot" checkbox. You can try to spam as many secret key combinations as you want, there is no timeout whatsoever.

Do you see where I'm heading at with this? Bots can spam key after key, until they login in some random account. Even though you created a wallet on your desktop, this is still accessible online with your secret key.

I hope you guys can share my concern about ANYONE's account safety.

Posted Jan 7, 2018, 8:49 AM UTC

310
xzbition•

I understand your concern, I agree there should be a limit on the number of failed attempts one can make, or indeed an authenticator for genuine attempts.

That being said, mathematically the secret key has 64 variables (and an S at the beginning). That's 36^64 combinations. That's almost 10^100. Although not impossible, but even spamming random combinations would take longer than the existence of the universe to guess 1 correctly with the current computing power...

8
A_Stoned_Wookee•

I understand that the possibility is going near zero but I think a small captcha á la Binance like ‚you defeated 99% of users‘ or so would still... maybe secure someone in the case.

4
O2plantOP•

Agree!

1
philtrem•

It's totally not needed. They can simply block the ip of anyone trying to brute-force, but this is not a security issue...

1
cryptobrant•

Since it’s open source that would prevent nothing. There are many other websites or apps that give you the possibility to access a Stellar wallet with secret key. Actually this is exactly the same as any other crypto.

1
O2plantOP•

Absolutely, luckily there's an immense amount of possible combinations. What I'm saying though is that a bot can spam a combination every second, 24/24 7/7 with no repercussion. I agree that it would take very long though to find just 1 hit.

1
crypto_or_bust•

It's not really possible to throttle such queries. The thing is, finding a private key that's already in use is so extremely unlikely that it will practically never happen even if you start spamming now and spam for years. This is the same thing for all the cryptos. It may change in the future when computing power increases, but the chances of somebody finding YOUR key are even more slim.

1
tuzhi•

This is how Stellar and almost any cryptocurrency works: once you have someone's private key, you can access their funds. Adding a rate limit on the account viewer wouldn't help; if you really want to try to a brute-force attack like the one you are describing, you might as well run an instance of stellar-core on your own PC and query the balance of every private key you generate. It's really the enormous amount of possible private keys that we rely on for security.

1
hollisimo•

Exactly. An attack like this would be faster and more efficient on a local computer than trying every combination over an HTTP connection, lolz.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Satomushi•

What happen if stellar account viewer website goes down? How can we access the wallet using ledger nano s?

1
philtrem•

It's protected by math...

0