I Will Have a Son...and He Won't Be Circumcised

Parents & Family

I just found out today that my wife is expecting a boy (she is 5 months pregnant and we did a sonogram). Needless to say, he WILL NOT be circumcised.

Our family will be intact. Me with a restored foreskin, and my son with a natural one.

Posted Jan 10, 2018, 1:58 AM UTC

7550
-bonjour-•

Same here!! Seven months! He'll be the first in my (Jewish) family to be left intact, and I'm restoring.

24
MajorStylesOPRestoring | CI-6•

Congrats as well. My father is Jewish, but my mother Latina. So this will be the removal of that tradition on my father's side of the family.

8
MenDeserveRightsRestoring | CI-3•

What is your wife's ethnic/cultural background?

I'm a White American with a mix of Protestant and Catholic ancestors.

1
MajorStylesOPRestoring | CI-6•

My wife is Black (Dominican). They do not circumcise the men in the Dominican Republic, and there are very few Jews/Muslims there. So the practice is foreign to her.

2
MenDeserveRightsRestoring | CI-3•

I'm American. Hopefully the practice will be foreign to my grandchildren.

1
fedo10Intact•

Congratulations!!!!

Side note: It’s a good think you probably know a lot about foreskin. My dad is circumcised and I didn’t really have anyone to ask when I had questions growing up.

13

Congratulations. Questions for everyone: Is it in any way possible for your son to be circumcised in the hospital without your permission?

10
LucianFarsky•

It's definetly possible. And actually happens unfortunately often in some American hospitals. But it is still illegal

13

I would murder the doctor.

16
coipRestoring | CI-3•

Is it in any way possible for your son to be circumcised in the hospital without your permission?

This was my biggest fear when my son was born--that someone would screw up and cut him without our consent, or that they would catch my wife off-guard when I was temporarily out of the room and she would accidentally consent to it without understanding (she isn't a native speaker).

I was stressed to the max the entire hospital stay there. When the doctor came in the next morning and asked my wife, I roused from my nap and shouted, "No circumcision!" so loudly in response that the doctor kind of jumped back and said "Okay..." and then left the room.

After that, we were asked about circumcision an additional six times! (To be fair, I don't think they were asking us to do it, but were asking if it had been done, so they knew if they needed to check the area, at least that's me giving them the benefit of the doubt; perhaps they were actually trying to cajole us into it).

And then upon checking out, when receiving our parental counseling with the exit nurse, she gave incorrect intact care advice, telling us to leave his penis alone for now but that at age 2 we should retract it and wash underneath! I knew better, of course, so I just ignored the advice, but ever since I've regretted not calling her out on that misinformation, as I fear it has led to many intact boys being injured from forced retraction.

Anyway, we're having another boy in a few months, at the same hospital, and I'll be curious to see if anything has changed regarding how often they ask about circumcision and if they still give false intact care advice. We'll see. I'll definitely call them out on it this time.

8
LucianFarsky•

Could you please provide the correct intact care advice just for anyone that may not know. I personally wouldn't want it left up to the hospital to provide me with that information for any children I may have.

5
coipRestoring | CI-3•

Could you please provide the correct intact care advice just for anyone that may not know.

Definitely, check out this guide by Your Whole Baby but the key takeaway point is to never retract the foreskin; it is fused to the glans of babies and forcibly retracting it can cause pain, injury, or infection. The foreskin will naturally separate on its own after time, closer to puberty.

Studies show the average age of natural foreskin retraction is age 10, and by then your son will be cleaning his own penis, so at that point tell him he needs to gently retract while taking a shower and rinse (rubbing it with your fingers and warm water should suffice; many people believe using soap or rough washcloths and stuff can cause irritation since that area of the penis is technically an internal organ).

tl;dr to care for an intact baby / child, you really don't need to do anything; just gently wash the outside like its a finger; for an intact teenager, tell him to retract and rinse with water when he showers.

5
IAMA_Throwaway_SoulRestoring | CI-3•

for an intact teenager, tell him to retract and rinse with water when he showers.

Is this really a thing that has to be said? I've always wondered that. Who doesn't play with their dicks in the shower? How does that not involve retracting at least accidentally? And since it should only be rinsed with water.

o.O

4
genitalhat•

accidentally consent to it without understanding (she isn't a native speaker)

we were asked about circumcision an additional six times

My god, that's horrifying. Maybe parents should wrap a big cellophane banner around their infant that says "DO NOT CIRCUMCISE" with some legal documents threatening to sue stapled to it just to be sure.

5
coipRestoring | CI-3•

accidentally consent to it without understanding (she isn't a native speaker)

Yeah, this was a real possibility in my opinion, especially if I wasn't there. Think about it: the mother is exhausted from labor, the baby is waking up every hour hungry, and just when she's about to get some sleep the nurses and doctors are popping in the room constantly asking her medical questions, asking her to sign documents to authorize the baby get various tests, etc. Throw in non-native-speaker status and it could've happened.

5
MajorStylesOPRestoring | CI-6•

"Think about it: the mother is exhausted from labor..."

Also, note that many mothers are heavily drugged at that point. My wife was in La-La land from the anesthesia for at least a day after she delivered our daughter.

4
MenDeserveRightsRestoring | CI-3•

I'm still in college, but hope to have kids in a few years.

My biggest fear is that when I do, they'll sneakily cut him when I'm in the bathroom.

Hopefully I'll be able to find a wife who agrees with me on this. (I'm pretty sure that even if she doesn't, I can stop them from doing it by threatening a lawsuit if they do it without my consent)

2
fedo10Intact•

In this day and age very very very unlikely. There are safeguards against this, but it can happen. When my siblings had their kids they accompanied the baby everywhere. It’s a good idea for mom or dad to keep an eye on the baby at all times for various reasons.

In the past, yes it happened all the time. It happened to my dad. My grandma said they took him to “get him ready” and he came back circumcised. The doctor said they did it to all the babies because of health and cleanliness reasons. At that time doctors (or any other higher authority) were just trusted. She didn’t think anything about it until recently. My dad doesn’t even know the story himself. He was born in a military hospital so I don’t know if that makes any difference.

5

Thats fucked up but interesting. I would knock the doctors teeth in if he circumcised my son in this day and age.

8
fedo10Intact•

I think the bigger problem is doctors pressuring parents to do it. People tend to trust their doctor and if they recommend it, then the parents will likely be persuaded to circumcise their sons.

5
gooberboi2•

They pressure people/do it secretly because it's a payday to them. Foreskins are big business in the cosmetics world.

1
Ghostronic•

Might wanna think twice. Assaulting a medical professional is a felony in some states.

1
MenDeserveRightsRestoring | CI-3•

That's probably what happened to my dad too, because my grandfather was likely intact, given that he was born on a farm in the early 1930s.

My dad was born in a civilian hospital in a large midwestern city in the early 1960s, so I'm pretty sure they just circumcised him without even asking my grandparents.

My parents don't have the same excuse for doing it to me, by the time I was born in the late 90s, parental consent was needed.

2
fedo10Intact•

Yeah if you really think about it I'm sure almost all infant circumcisions were either done without consent or the parents were pressured to do it. From one generation to the next it went from near zero to pretty much every male being circumcised. Most dads want their sons to be the same as them yet circumcision status changed practically overnight.

As I said doctors or any other professionals were just trusted so parents either didn't think much about it or were convinced it was good. Even if they didn't agree, what were they gonna do back then? There wasn't even a way to do your own research, really. No internet, the culture wasn't as sexually open, and medical books endorsed and normalized it (they still do).

2
MenDeserveRightsRestoring | CI-3•

I agree when it comes to people circumcised in before the 80s or maybe 90s, but my parents should have known better, and unlike my father's parents, mine would have had to consent to have it done to me.

I know my parents didn't do it to be malicious, but agreeing to have half of the skin amputated from your infant's penis is stupid on so many levels.

I guess I'd say that I don't hate them because I know they weren't trying to hurt me, but that their egregious and life-altering bad judgement with regards to my penis means I do not trust them on any matters health or medical.

2
MajorStylesOPRestoring | CI-6•

My understanding is that this can happen in a US hospital. I know there was a case in Miami where a woman's child was circumcised without her consent and she ended up suing.

5
MenDeserveRightsRestoring | CI-3•

I wish that men could sue both their parents and their doctors for circumcising them without their consent...

3
troyan2Restoring | CI-6•

I was circumcised without any consent. I already confronted the doctor and told him that I will hate him for life. Next time I see him, I will stab him to death.

3

What did he say when you confronted him?

3
troyan2Restoring | CI-6•

He laughed in my face and said "usually we cut even more" and I was already cut low.

5
gooberboi2•

you should perform your own surgery on him without consent, see how he likes it

1
MenDeserveRightsRestoring | CI-3•

Of course he doesn't care, why would he care when he doesn't suffer from it and makes money off of your suffering?

I'm pretty sure that most people who become circumcisers have at least some psychological issues.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
waraukaeru•

You can request two free "Do Not Circumcise or Retract" ankle bands from TLC Tugger for your newborn.

https://tlctugger.com/product/infant-ankle-bands-2-do-not-circumcise-or-retract/

3
tman_1992•

Awesome! Congratulations! My son was born August 2017. He was born uncircumcised and will remain that way forever or until he makes the decision himself!

7
MajorStylesOPRestoring | CI-6•

Thank you, sir. And true...that's his decision to make (not mine).

3
StFunkJrRestoring | CI-2•

Congratulations!

7
Rngness•

I have the feeling that men/dads are more likely against circumcision/aren't real interested but also dont want it while women choose often for the knife. What are your thoughts and what about you op? Is your wife ok with this?

4
boxsterguy•

When my wife and I found out we were having a boy, we had the conversation (also, how disgusting is it that we even had to have a conversation?). My position was a hard "no". Her's was that she didn't care either way but probably would've just done it out of inertia. Because she didn't care, I "won". It was easier with our second boy because it wasn't even a discussion. The first wasn't circumcised, so why would the second be?

We did change pediatricians within the first ~6 months because of a bad experience with the one we initially chose. We took him in because he was looking a little jaundiced and we were right next door for my wife's c-section scar checkup anyway. Our regular ped was out, but her father (also a ped, working at the same practice) was available. The entire checkup was full of bad advice -- better get him circumcised before his penis has problems (nope!), better get him on a bottle or he won't ever figure it out (first was exclusively breastfed; second was on formula after a month for ... reasons), etc.

I noped out of there and told the wife I wasn't comfortable with the practice. She was looking for an excuse to switch anyway since the office was farther away from home than she wanted to go so that was an easy decision.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MajorStylesOPRestoring | CI-6•

I live in the Caribbean and most of the men here are uncut. So my wife is expecting him to remain intact.

But I agree with your sentiment. Many men simply go along with it, since the wife is hell-bent on the knife.

3
MenDeserveRightsRestoring | CI-3•

Why would the wife be hell-bent on it, given that she is not herself circumcised, and thus doesn't feel compelled to make him match?

1
MajorStylesOPRestoring | CI-6•

Many Western women adhere to the bandwagon appeal: i.e. everybody is doing it, so it must be right.

2
MenDeserveRightsRestoring | CI-3•

Hopefully, when I get married and have kids, I can talk my wife out of it.

1
MagentagenitaliaRestoring | CI-2•

Groovy

4
YesRebootRestoring | CI-3•

good

3
MenDeserveRightsRestoring | CI-3•

Congratulations!

Thank you for breaking the cycle of forced genital cutting and doing the right thing for your son.

2
MajorStylesOPRestoring | CI-6•

I did my small part. :)

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1