The Justification of Linear Pokemon

Edit: Recent brought to my attention that my title is not the best for what im trying to explain so a better title would be

WHY THE MODERN POKEMON MECHANICS CAN'T TRANSLATE OVER TO OPEN WORLD WITHOUT ALOT OF CHANGE

So recently a user made a post In defense of Open-World Pokemon(Go throw them an upvote alot of effort went into that post!) and why the core mechanics of the game are not benefited/complemented by the linear nature of how the games play out. However, contrary to popular opinion, Pokemon (with the current battle system) actually benefits a lot more from linear gameplay than a supposed open world. I’m going to do my best to try to break down each of their points and expand what can be changed and how. So to start off just so you know the central idea of this entire post. I believe Linear Pokemon suits the current formula best, and it would benefit far more from making parts of the game less linear vs making the entire game open world. This will be a long post so I will try to break up the section into parts.

1) The Core Mechanics of Pokemon

As mentioned Pokemon can be broken up into three main mechanics. Catching and training Pokemon, exploring the Pokemon world, and battling Pokemon. Each of these mechanics create a loop of gameplay. You explore -> leads into battling (wild Pokemon or Trainers) -> gives the option of capture of Pokemon or information on the Pokemon to build teams -> repeat. I will further elaborate on these points a bit, but if you feel you get the gist of these mechanics feel free to skip to 2.

a) Exploration

This is more of less the most emphasized trait in Pokemon game. Everything is a result from exploring, exploring leads to battling trainers, exploring routes leads to new items or wild Pokemon encounters, discovering mon evolutions, and even talking to people in the town can lead to new information. Most would say that games that focus heavily on exploration would heavily favor a vast open world to explore. Which is true, if the game revolved more around action combat than numbers. Due to the fact that combat plays so much off of the number and stats it makes this aspect a bit hard to balance around in an open world (Will elaborate more on further down). Most people also only breakdown exploration to discovering new places, thus they feel like a bigger vaster world would tend to better suit that. However exploration incorporates more than you think. In Pokemon alone, learning the encounters on routes, exploring possible team abilities, and evolution lines are all various types of exploration as well.

b) Battling

Pokemon has a very deep battle system that doesn’t ever really get to see too much of the light of day in the games. Battles are turn based and take into a account a variety of factors and can introduce a lot of interesting strategies for battles. Such as weather effects, items, status conditions, etc. As you progress in the game you battle stronger and stronger trainers and encounter stronger wild Pokemon. Wild battles and Trainer battles serve 2 purposes, to train your Pokemon and to influence you to possibly catch a new team member. Fighting wild mons and trainers give you experience which levels you up and allows you to learn new moves to experiment with. Fighting the wild mons also gives you the option of capturing the monster after doing battle with it. Before I said Trainer battles opens up the ability to catch a new team member, some of you might be confused by what I meant. Often times in Pokemon you will encounter a trainer that owns a Pokemon you have never seen before, the result of this is it registers it in your Pokedex as a seen Pokemon and gives you a vague location of where this Pokemon is on the map. This in turn incentivizes you to explore to find this monster thus returning back to the gameplay loop.

c) Team Building

In Pokemon you build teams based around the Pokemon you encounter or are given. Generally, for most veteran Pokemon players team consist of a variety of types of mons that tend to cover each other weaknesses. However, it is also just as viable most of the time to be able to progress in the game with Pokemon you just like. This allows the player to experiment with their team and set their moves up on their mons to get them to complement each other. To get even more moves you level up and train (exploring and finding battles) or you explore to find TM’s thus back to the gameplay loop.

2) Open World vs Linear

The post earlier brought up many interesting points and I would like to take the time to also elaborate on each point and my point of view (All points I am making are extremely subjective and I am going to try my best to give the best reasoning for my logic as possible). For examples I will being primarily be using kanto region (Specifically the remakes) due to them being the most well known regions. Also for the sake of a fair comparison, we must also assume that this is everyone’s first time playing this game (will make sense later)

a) Implicating a system of HM’s or event based barriers (such as gym leaders or fighting team rocket I would assume) do not benefit the above mechanics at all.

So as stated before the 3 main mechanics are exploring, battling, and team building. Now the first major event based roadblock Fire Red and Leaf Green (aside from the drunk old man and first rival battle) is Brock. You cannot progress to Mt.Moon before beating Brock.

Prior to Pewter city you are given several routes and areas to encounter wild Pokemon. [Route 1] ( https://cdn.wikimg.net/strategywiki/images/thumb/c/c9/Pokemon_FRLG_Route01.png/300px-Pokemon_FRLG_Route01.png), Route 2, [Viridian Forest] (https://cdn.wikimg.net/strategywiki/images/thumb/d/de/Pokemon_FRLG_ViridianForest.png/440px-Pokemon_FRLG_ViridianForest.png), and Route 22. On these routes you can capture a Pidgey, Spearow, Ratatta, Caterpie, Weedle, Mankey, Metapod, Kakuna. So for Brock everyone who has played knows he is the rock type gym leader and the majority of the starters trump that and will be able to easily advance. Now each of the starters learn their first respective type move at lv.7. Brock’s Pokemon are a lv 12 Geodude and lv 14. Brock trumps literally all the wild Pokemon in this section except one, Mankey which will not be found unless you decided to try progress off the intended route (Exploration) and still will have to be raised to not get one shot by Onix in a fight (Battle/Team Building). Brock shouldn’t give too much trouble to people who chose Bulbasaur or Squirtle too much trouble due to type advantages. However, more than likely they will either have to train their Pokemon up to around lv 10+ to get access to withdraw and leech seed (Battle/Train) to counter being slower than Onix on top of possibly having to buy items (Battle to get money), finding items to use or sell (Exploring) or experimenting with the Pokemon in the surrounding area in order to come up with a strategy for Brock (Team building).

Now for Charmander on the other hand, it is almost impossible to beat Brock with just Charmander until you are at least level 13 ( I believe you learn Metal Claw here) and possibly stocked up on tons of items. Regardless on whether or not the trainer chooses to grind or catch Pokemon, both require Exploration, Battling, as well as Team Building. Now grinding you may think doesn’t technically count as exploring because the purpose of you getting encounters is to grind and get experience. However, since grinding requires getting encounters, you are unintentionally exploring and discovering the possible Pokemon that can appear in the area. The same alternative can be said for catching mons, obviously they will go back into Viridian since they have the type advantage there and more than likely will catch some mons and raise them (which once again requires exploring and battling) they can encounter a new mon similarly.

Brock poses as an obstacle to overcome and players are given a set of tools in order to get that job done. This encourages the character to battle to get stronger, or to explore to see which mons are in the area and build teams to take on this challenge. Simply grinding is an easy way to overcome it, but as time progresses grinding starts returning minimal results. Even if they do decide to just grind it more than likely will take a lot of trial and error and experimenting with how the battle should flow, they will know what Brock can do and build a strategy against that and plan out an attack (team building). Thus by providing an event such as a gym leader or Team Rocket actually provide an easy identifiable goal for players to work towards.

Now in reference for HM’s. Obtaining HM's were usually broken into 2 parts, obtaining the ability to use them (by battling gym leaders) then by exploring the world to find the HM (most of the time). In concept, HM’s complement the core mechanics of the game. They reward the player with a tool that allows them to explore the world even more. However the way they messed with the games is in how they implemented them in. HM’s are generally required to progress and require you to take a move slot on one of your monsters. While it is true that by forcing Pokemon to learn a move that you cannot get rid of most people will either put it on a regular mon or force themselves to catch another Pokemon to become an HM slave, which encourages the player to catch more Pokemon to see which is suitable to learn the move as well as try to make the pokemon work with the team chemistry (Team Building). Also by making some HM’s required to progress it can take the bit of an adventure out of the game. The only HM I think I can agree with using like this is Surf, just because of how much it opens up the map. HM's like strength, and cut (in my opinion) should have just been used to open up secret areas for one to explore.

b) You aren’t going to new areas because you want to, but because the game wants you to thus detracts from the other two mechanics

This point I agree with somewhat. Pokemon has been handholding and leading players where to go for too long. However, this can be fixed without it ever becoming open world. Look at games like Dragon Quest or Xenoblade, which all feature a very vast world to explore, but at the core are all extremely linear games. If Pokemon decided to have routes branch out a bit more, alternate paths and have more hidden off areas as well as opening up the map after acquiring a certain amount of badges it would help immensely. However, even leading the player from new area to new area still doesn’t go against the core mechanics. They still give you a new area to explore, more Pokemon to encounter and thus more team possibilities for you to try. In fact by limiting the previous routes to only certain types (like normal or flying) and then opening up a new route with different ones (like dark/ghost etc) actually encourages the player to catch and experiment with Pokemon of a different type and see what type of strategies one can employ. Another point I saw brought up was you often abandon weak Pokemon you get from the beginning, however that is one of the biggest thing with Pokemon. Aside from those mons being beneficial and strong early game you do not know what is weak and what isn’t because Pokemon evolve. The fact that that early on you learn as your Pokemon get stronger they can possibly take an entirely new form is an even bigger incentive to catch and experiment with the majority of monsters. For example the most infamous is Magikarp, which is useless until it evolves into Gyarados. Abandoning that pokemon you would have never learned that without outside knowledge. You are left with this sense of mystery and wanting to explore and see what Pokemon will evolve into. So actually by limiting which Pokemon you have access to, and funneling trainers through a route that forces them to battle to make them stronger gives the player a good enough time to decide if they like this Pokemon as a team member and possibly gives that mon the chance to evolve to propose a refreshing new look at this previously acquired Pokemon

c) Linear progression results in grinding

This is a hump that even in an open world format it will have to overcome with the current battle system. Specifically with low level mons. Regardless of whether you can do gyms in any order or if they make areas harder to get through with stronger mons. The beginning part of every Pokemon game will revolve heavily around leveling up. For a frame of mind lets look at BOTW’s open world. At the beginning of the game you are given all the tools you need in order to explore the world and the success in exploring lands with stronger enemies falls all on you and your skill to combat them.

Now compare this to Pokemon. When you start your adventure you are given one Pokemon, which has 2 attacks usually a normal type attack like scratch and a status move. Now if we set the same trainer off into a world where monsters reflected their environment and stronger mons resided in stronger areas, due to the nature of low level Pokemon battles you are pretty much constrained to a linear path for a good bit of the game. Low level Pokemon emphasizes too much on stats and type advantages in order to be able to have that same type of open world.

You may be slightly confused. So here is an analogy to try to make it as clear as possible. The equivalent of obtaining the Shiekah Slate powers in BOTW is the equivalent of raising a Pokemon to around lv 25+. The majority of Pokemon, do not learn the stronger attack moves, status moves, or have the appropriate stats in order to be able to take on a lot of circumstances until they are around level 25 or higher. This is roughly around the 2nd or 3rd gym battle in Pokemon. Some Pokemon are the exception to this, however due to the pace of moves Pokemon learn by level up you are extremely limited in the amount of strategies you can come up with in early game. Due to this limiting factor, introducing a world where you can challenge anything at anytime still requires the player to get roughly around that level to fully be able to find work around for most challenges thrown their way. So eventually in this open world you will come across a trainer that completely outclasses you with higher level mons than you, thus you essentially hit a wall. This trainer is just strong enough that you have to grind to beat him. You are introduced to the first barrier of the game and will either have to acquire a bulk of monsters or grinding. You will have to form a strategy in order to beat this trainer in order to progress. Does this sound familiar, that’s because what I described is essentially the same as a gym leader. Without access to the majority of stronger moves like thunderbolt vs thundershock or status effects moves etc, low level Pokemon are completely outclassed at a point to where they can’t progress that even in an open world setting you would be forced into a linear progression from the get go.

3) Ending thoughts

One issue I have seen recently since BOTW dropped is that a lot of people feel that games that seem to emphasize a lot on exploration can only be properly realized in an open world setting. However this is not true. A game can be linear and still be a great for exploring. What it comes down to is how you lead the player and how they allow the player to stray from the path intended for them.

Now another subjective topic to touch on which I feel alot of people tend to have trouble figuring out is what exploration and adventuring means to them. Some people feel that its being given this vast world to explore and the ability to explore any area whenever you feel like. Some argue that its being led on a journey and as these major events play out you get to see and interact with the world as it is exposed to you. Both of these are true to exploration, and one is not better than the other. When a world is too open and the content isn't there to go out to find then exploring isnt fun. When a world limits you too much on how much you can stray off the path, then it feels like you dont ever get the chance to explore. The key to this is moderation and balance of freedom of choice and providing content to explore. Givng to little of one or the other, then the game either feels not fun to explore or too limiting. Recently pokemon is falling heavily into the latter of the two.

The current issue for Pokemon (in my opinion) isn’t that they are linear, but the recent lack in world design to hide the linearity along with the fact that they aren’t giving us as much to explore anymore. Making more complex routes that branch out, making fights a bit more difficult so we can delve into the battle mechanics more, and possibly give players a bit more choice are all manageable without going open world. Now when people ask for open world I believe most are confusing that with just less linear. Look at Skyrim and Botw, both are truly open world games where progress is determined entirely by you, you can touch the story or just explore if you want. Pokemon can’t really pose that option due to the leveling curve of early game so it essentially starts off as a linear game from the get go. It is possible for a less linear Pokemon, however a completely open world Pokemon seems nigh impossible unless they vastly change the current combat and level up system

TL;DR

Open World Pokemon seems near impossible with how the current battle and level up system is set up. It is possible for Game Freak to give us a less linear Pokemon game, but without changing how quick it takes for Pokemon to learn the more applicable moves, and somehow reworking that trainer battles to no longer be essentially road blocks, the possibility of an open world experience from the start of the game is very small.

I am not saying i do not want open world pokemon or a change in mechanics. Im simply trying to show how with the current mechanics linearity benefits from it more than open world would.

Thanks for reading if you actually read it, and if you didnt thanks for reading the TL;DR, and you didnt read that, thanks for reading the title I guess! I'd like to hear your thoughts since I'm sure i overlooked alot since i was typing this up throughout my commutes today!

Posted Feb 2, 2018, 12:59 AM UTC · edited

9082
ben9900•

I don't think Pokemon should be open world, but I think it should feel less linear and have more vast areas to explore.

81
SaiXelBR•

Add fewer tutorials and less dialogue padding and I'm game.

36
QcSlayer•

Doing USUM was torture, that tutorial... Why can't we get an option to skip the tutorial, it's been 20 years, I know how to play GF!

12
Cthuguu•

The tutorial ended?

1
SaiXelBR•

I just dropped the game and started playing Crystal for my pokemon fix. I will try to come back to it later, but if the new pokemon game is released this year for the Switch... yeah, not coming back.

1
QcSlayer•

Maybe Pokemon Switch won't have move tutors, so you may be force to play it like me lol.

1
Bizzerker_Bauer•

I tried to get into XY and just couldn't stand it. It was just constant pestering from the NPCs to come and do stuff with them or contrivances keeping me from being able to go places that I wanted to go. I think I quit when the girl looking for her seashell told me I couldn't go past because she was looking for it. Maybe I just didn't notice it at the time, but I swear the previous games didn't railroad you quite so hard. I know they took a bit to set things up, but IIRC they just let you go do your own thing relatively early.

3
SaiXelBR•

I don't quite remember how XY handled that aspect, but I don't doubt you. This is a thing in every pokemon game, but it's gettingout of hand, in my opinion. If I learned how to play during Gen 1 with no knowledge of english, kids these days don't need so many tutorials.

2
TSPhoenix•

I liken it to Ocarina of Time and Skyward Sword, both games are largely linear, there are a couple times you can choose to do one area before another, but that's about it.

But which game feels more linear? Skyward Sword by a mile.

Good design is making the player not feel railroaded regardless of whether they really are.

12
QuantumElectronicsDuHey Einstein, I'm on YOUR side!•

The difference between Ocarina and Skyward Sword is that the hand-holdy tutorial is super short, and the rest of tutorial stuff is invisible. You learn to talk to NPCs, learn about Z-targeting, and are told to get a sword and shield and then you're free to roam a little mini playground where you teach yourself all the basics of movement. The BAM you're in your first dungeon, which introduces you to the whole idea of this puzzlebox design. The design itself is teaching you how to think.

Skyward Sword? It's like an hour and a half or longer of being told where to go next and having condescending step-by-step explanations of the mechanics of movement.

1
TSPhoenix•

The question was rhetorical, but yes that's the gist of it and its pretty obvious which of the two Sun/Moon is more similar to.

1
AlexJonesesGayFrogsWould you go gay for Ghirahim, though?•

I honestly think that a Link Between Worlds format would be even better for Pokemon than Zelda. Being able to go to the area of the world you want, to get the Pokemon you want, would GREATLY increase the amount of variety you could have with your party. Usually in Pokemon games it's best to get certain Pokemon because your options are limited and you need to take on a gym to even progress (Sable eye in gen three before the fighting gym, Butterfree if you picked Charmander for Brock, ect), but there's no real reason for that to remain completely static. If levels in areas is out of whack just have a tiered system based on which ones you visit first or something. I think FO New Vegas did this, or at least one of the Fallout 3D games did.

Also, thinking back, it was pretty lame that you had to wait until the second to last gym in gen one to get a fire type if you didn't pick Charmander.

5
1338h4x#FreeProjectM•

I think Kanto had the perfect balance. The first half of the game is linear, then it opens up with a couple branching options. There's an obvious intended route that'll guide you along the level curve, but you're given some room to do things out of order if you want.

2†
UltraRainbow•

Whether it's open world, opener world or something else, the main thing is that the series needs to evolve at a fundamental level.

We are now on powerful home console hardware. It's not acceptable to be making the same game again.

Pokémon fans seem to be way too strident in not accepting any deviation from the rigid formula.

22
1338h4x#FreeProjectM•

Why would hardware necessitate a change in mechanics?

5
UltraRainbow•

It's not the hardware that necessitates the change in mechanics, it's the exhaustion of the formula. The hardware upgrade simply removes the excuse of technical limitations.

4
Bucky_Jibak•

Thankfully the formula isn't exausthed as the game's high sales, popularity, active communities and even the dozens of people who played the games posting here proved you already. I'm glad nobody fell for your lies but it's really a shame such a good formula, that has so much to add yet is attacked.

3†
UltraRainbow•

It's lucky I was talking about something that is subjective, and can't be proved or disproved isn't?

. I'm glad nobody fell for your lies

Lies? I'm stating my own opinion?

Why would I lie about not enjoying a series lately?

such a good formula

It was a good formula in 1996. After seven generations wanting a core change is not unreasonable

that has so much to add yet is attacked.

It wasn't 'attacked' it was criticised.

6
[deleted]•

[removed]

3
livelifelove123•

A fine example of the Pokemon fanbase refusing change and attacking people for suggesting it. Pokemon needs to change, or it will die. History tells us that companies who refuse innovation will wither. Pokemon is running on fumes--brand name alone is selling it; no one is buying it for an exciting new experience, they're buying it because it has the Pokemon name attached to it.

2†

We are now on powerful home console hardware. It's not acceptable to be making the same game again.

You still buy Uncharted, Fifa, CoD, AC, GTA5 and so on. All franchises that did 0 to change.

The same thing, for years.

I want good games. DOesnt matter if its linear or "the same".

4†
UltraRainbow•

You still buy Uncharted, Fifa, CoD, AC, GTA5 and so on.

I own one of those games.

All franchises that did 0 to change.

They're already on the most powerful hardware. There was no radical upwards potential.

DOesnt matter if its linear or "the same".

It massively matters if it's the same.

4

I own one of those games.

But the market doesnt. The market loves reashes of the same thing.

They're already on the most powerful hardware. There was no radical upwards potential.

Ahhh, yes, because Rockstar using the same models for 10 years couldnt be prevented. Same for Fifa, using the same engine for 3 years in a row, with minimal graphical improvements. Nevermind the last AC, that looks and runs like a 2015 game /s. Nevermind the fact that they still look like shit on PC, and PC is miles away from consoles in terms of power. Poor developers, cant do more than 1080p/30 fps on such powerful hardware, lmao.

It massively matters if it's the same.

Sales prove you wrong.

2†
UltraRainbow•

But the market doesnt. The market loves reashes of the same thing.

Do didn't mention the market you referred to me. I simply needed to correct the baseless assumption you made.

Ahhh, yes, because Rockstar using the same models for 10 years couldnt be prevented. Same for Fifa, using the same engine for 3 years in a row, with minimal graphical improvements. Nevermind the last AC, that looks and runs like a 2015 game /s. Nevermind the fact that they still look like shit on PC, and PC is miles away from consoles in terms of power. Poor developers, cant do more than 1080p/30 fps on such powerful hardware, lmao.

I was not talking about models, graphics, resolution or frame rate, I was talking about gameplay.

Sales prove you wrong.

It's a good thing I wasn't talking about commercial performance.

5
ShockerG52OP•

Agreed. They need to take this chance to push pokemon further.

3†
semiconductress•

Absolutely. As the OP of the referenced post, I'd definitely want a radical shift towards openness. But really, any major change would be very very welcome.

-1
QuantumElectronicsDuHey Einstein, I'm on YOUR side!•

IMO, linearity isn't so much a problem in and of itself -- having a specific set of events to complete in order, and a set of challenges with set bars to overcome, and a focused world design with established levels, etc. is fine.

I'll make the point that it doesn't complement the generally open-ended feeling you're supposed to get from having options for team building, but that's ok.

The problem with Sun/Moon is that there's pretty much no explorability -- rather than letting you go the wrong way to discover there's a dead end all on your own, it blocks off every possible branching path so it's literally impossible to end up going the wrong way (unless you're just being stubborn and going nowhere).

impossible without changing the battle and leveling system

Hmm... the simplest solution is level scaling wild encounters and applying the exp. share method, where the experience given to each team member gets individually scaled. But I do see your point, in that it doesn't lend itself to focused design (not that I've seen that since Black/White 2, but I do see your point).

16
1338h4x#FreeProjectM•

Level scaling always feels awful, I've never liked it in any game. Most of the time the optimal way to play is to stay at as low a level as possible.

10
luke4ario•

Level scaling could work but then breaks as soon as you reach the post game.

8
mb862•

While also an appreciated quality post, both seem to be aiming for two extremes. On the left you have this go-anywhere-at-anytime open world like Breath of the Wild, and on the right there's this gated corridor with constant little branching to find out how to open the gates.

There is an in-between here people.

Take a game like World of Warcraft. Forget the endgame and expansions and level boosts, you're starting fresh level one Elwynn Forest. Mechanically, you can go anywhere. But if you take off down to Duskwood, you will quickly find you are not prepared and this is a bad idea. The game teaches you that it is open world in technical only, but your actual progression will be a mostly linear route down branching pathways. From a narrative standpoint, Blizzard knows that if you're in Duskwood, you probably did Westfall before it, they can link a continuous story together through these seemingly disconnected parts of the world.

World of Warcraft and Pokemon are ultimately, in the math, more similar games than not (equating gear and a team), so I suspect that kind of linear-open-world is ultimately what both posters are after in the end, and what might probably be best for the franchise.

16
QuantumElectronicsDuHey Einstein, I'm on YOUR side!•

I might also make the suggestion for game design format of old Squaresoft RPGs like SNES/PS1 Final Fantasy or Chrono Trigger. The early game is very linear in order to make you feel at home with the game's world and concepts, but over time the world expands and becomes much more explorable.

3
moonlightbeamu•

I would be happy if my ability to move around the map were less restricted. That's really all I want. Just let me walk around and see each city without an NPC stopping me because I haven't beaten x gym leader yet. Like, okay, yes, I haven't beaten Brock- but why should that determine whether or not I can walk into Mt Moon? Let me go in, get my shit stomped, and rethink my plan. It would feel a lot more natural than the current method of inventing a power outage or some nosy NPC who holds you hostage.

6
Aurikine•

Some of the story barriers are fine when it's not happening every time you reach a new city, I think. Having more points of interest outside a city with a gym or major plot point there would be nice, and it could go a long way in opening things up while still keeping players from progressing too much out of order. Sun/Moon are a good example of how not to do this, as there are literal roadblocks all over the region and practically no side-areas worth visiting ever, making the experience feel very on-rails (in spite of things I did like in Sun/Moon, the world structure felt really lacking to me.)

1
semiconductress•

I'm the OP of the thread you referenced, and thank you for writing this! I'm glad that you're engaging on a mechanical level, not on personal preference, because after all there's not much to debate about. People will prefer what they prefer.

One of the most interesting points you bring up is the fact that exploring team composition, wild encounters, etc., constitutes exploration as well. I definitely agree with this, but I hadn't considered it in my original post. There, I was mostly focussed on traversing the game world.

However, I would still say that one more dimension of exploration is better than one less. I don't think that opening up the game world will be detrimental to the other types of exploration. So, given infinite development resources and talent to make the ideal Pokémon game, I do think that expanding exploration in all possible ways is the best option.

Now I want to respond to each specific point:

2a) Your analysis of Brock's effect in terms of game mechanics is pretty good. But I wonder how much of that is just him being a challenge, not necessarily a linear challenge. Ultimately, Pokémon is not a bad game-- it still manages to develop its core mechanics pretty well. So here it could just be Pokémon being good, not because it's linear, but because it's good in other ways. In an open-world version of Gen 1, you would still have the options to grind or strategize, but you'd also have the additional option of coming back later. I don't think that being able to come back later is actively detrimental to the other options.

As for HMs, I actually agree with you completely. I can see Cut and Strength being used to unlock minor areas in an open-world game (I think that would still qualify as open-world? If the vast majority of it is not blocked?), and I think that would add more layers and replayability to the game.

2b) I suppose that I should qualify my original claim and say that linearity prevents the maximal development of the core mechanics. So, yes, there is still exploration in linear segments, otherwise I don't think we would think of Pokémon as a game in which exploration is important. But, there could always be more. Training a Magikarp is, possibly, an exciting gamble. Wouldn't it be more exciting if you're choosing Magikarp, not out of the few Pokémon available in the beginning, but out of hundreds? For exploration games, I do think that more content is always better, because exploration is driven by the joy of finding new things.

2c) Yeah I'll admit that an open-world game doesn't solve grinding in itself. As I stated in the other thread though, I do think it'll go a long way, just because you get the extra option of coming back to a difficult challenge later. Purely statistically speaking, if you're choosing between strategizing vs grinding, and strategizing vs grinding vs exploring, and you had an equal chance to choose each, you'd have a smaller chance of choosing to grind. Of course, the chances wouldn't be equal either, because presumably the exploration would be fun, while grinding, most of the time, is not.

However, I think you're completely right about the necessity of linearity in the early game. It would probably be a good idea to have a BotW-esque "plateau," a relatively self-contained and linear segment until players reach that 25+ level point where they do have a wider set of tools. I'd say that's a situation where, like 2D Mario, linearity definitely benefits the game. But there's no reason that the game shouldn't open up afterwards, I think.

  1. Conventionally, adventure games tend to be exploration-focused, so that's what I'm basing my definition on. But I can see how people would have different opinions about what "adventure" means, and I could've been much more precise in what I meant.

I think that to explore in a video game is to encounter parts of the game out of the one's own curiosity or ambition. An adventure game is one that combines this exploration with a narrative, whether that be an actively unfolding plot or an environmental backstory, to motivate and connect different parts of the world. This also means that the exploration and narrative must not be strictly tied to each other: the narrative should not control or limit the exploration, but merely complement it, so that both exploration and narrative develop by their own rules, leaving the player to choose between one, the other, or both. This is always good, since different players always have different preferences, and having more options will be enjoyable for more people. BotW and GTA are good examples: you can follow the story or you can muck around, depending what you desire at any given moment. If either exploration and narrative were tied to the other, the player would be robbed of that choice. I think that this is what happens in Pokémon. Except in the early game where linearity is important, too much of the world unfolds based on plot, and too often the player is forced to do the plot to get to new areas.

I agree that a Pokémon game with more branching paths would help alleviate these problems, but taken to its logical end, an open-world would be ideal. Emptiness is not an issue either: given that there are currently 720 unique Pokémon, 728 different moves to be made into TMs, HMs, and Move Tutors, 233 abilities, 64 berries, and a lot of useful items, I don't think it'll be hard at all to fill an open-world to the brim with content. Also, the difficulty and risk involved in developing such a game are... somewhat outside the scope of my original post. It would be hard to adapt Pokémon to an open world, for sure, but nigh-impossible? I don't think so at all. (Unfortunately, I also don't really think that Game Freak will take that leap.)

Finally, regarding world design: yes. This is huge. I think this happened when Pokémon transitioned to 3D. 3D assets are inevitably harder to develop, and repeated assets are easier to notice. When you're playing on a tiled 2D world, you'll ignore repetitions and treat them as abstract representations of the world. You'll use your imagination to fill in the gaps, so that Littleroot doesn't actually have only two houses of two rooms each, or that Viridian isn't actually only 50 meters away. In a 3D world, that imagination is less effective, because everything looks more real. This wouldn't be a problem if there were simply more assets at a larger scale, like if they filled cities with more buildings or buildings with more rooms. But, so far, the level of detail has not grown to match the corresponding decrease in abstraction. This is why the prospect of a Switch Pokémon is so exciting for me, because more power could mean a more fleshed-out world. If they choose to remain at the level of detail of USUM, however, I'd honestly rather they go back to a Gen IV or V style.

6
ShockerG52OP•

Yo thanks for replying! So personally think Pokemon in concept lends more in favor to an open world than how it was implemented. Having the beginning of the game purely restricted due to not having capable enough mons is an obstacle to overcome and i think really hurts an open world which is why i think linear benefits best from this since you can account for this. To get the most out of an open world you should be able to pretty much what you want very early into the game not after like 5+ hours (which is about how long it takes to get around 2-3 badges or so)

2a) Personally i see Brock as a linear challenge. For example the Charmander trainer ( Using him. Because if you are struggling with Bulbasaur or Squirtle we got a problem) challenge stems from the fact that he is at the type disadvantage and he needs a mon that beats it or a new strategy. The fact that the area is only limited to 1 monster (which is off the intended path to pewter) that has a type advantage against Brock creates that challenge. Its hard to find thus if you really want to find it you have to explore.

Brock himself is not a hard fight, but due to limited options of pokemon you can catch (with most being weak to rock) he poses as a challenge. Introducing the ability to catch almost any mon (of course limiting legendaries, 2nd and 3rd evo, and starters) brings a ton of pokemon that have the advantage over Brock. because all you need is a water (26 mons), ground(8 mons), grass(13 mons), or fighting(10) type to combat Brock.That is 57 mons already to pick from, not counting pokemon with two types, starters, pokemon that learn a water/fighting/grass/ground move early while not having the respective typing, or pokemon that are in the 2nd or 3rd evolution forme.

Introducing this wide pool of mons to pick from actually takes away from the challenge in finding the monster in the first place, because there are so many options given to you. Its like a multiple choice question in a subject you never studied for. There are 4 answers but only 1 of the answers is wrong and the right answers all clearly stand out as correct. Would the question be harder if you cut down the number of correct answers. I personally believe so.

2b) I actually couldnt disagree more. The way pokemon is now mechanic wise an open world would not bring out the best of it. The concept of pokemon however, does lend extremely well to an open world format.

The only real current core mechanic that benefits from open world is the team building from wild encounters. Everything related to wild encounters benefits from an open world ( exploring new mons, battling new mons too strong run away) can be brought out to full in this setting. However, Battling trainers with no indication of how strong they are without the ability to forfeit or run is very detrimental imo. Because your progress in exploring is gone if you lose and you get reset to the last rest area. These roadblocks are just as bad as the cut trees since there is no way around unless you have the stats and moves to back it up.

Also opening the world up wouldnt really change too much in exploring towns and routes, you would still get the same amount of exploration by just making the game less linear where after a point you can just tackle the gyms you want in the order you want (like in kanto)

In terms of the Magikarp statement (for me personally) the excitement doesnt come from the gamble. Choosing magikarp over many other options doesnt make it anymore exciting because it not like you lose the option to choose the other mons. You arent stuck with the mon in your team forever because you can swap out your team at will. The excitement comes from learning that a weak mon turns into something strong and seeing that work you put in payed off, not from having picked a secretly right mon out of the bunch imo.

I also agree, more content is better for exploration. Which is why i liked how old pokemon game would add in all the old pokemon in for you to find and legendarues for you to capture. The regi puzzles were probably some of my favorite legendaries to find.

2c) So actually in Fire Red Leafgreen the game does open up after that midpoint. Most people dont try but in reality badges 4-6(possibly 4-7 im not sure) can actually be tackled in any order you want, the game just naturally leads you in the correct order.

I personally feel like if you allow the player freedom (or give the illusion) no matter how organic it actually is, its fine. Alot of people constantly say games are open world like ffxv or things of the sort. But in reality these games are actually linear but the fact they give you so much to explore it creates the illusion that it is an open world.

The ideal open world pokemon (for me anyway) would mean from the start you should be able to go wherever. However like we agreed with the current system the linearity at the beginning detracts from thus which is why it needs to change to accomodate that. The first couple gym badges is about a rough 5-10 hours of gameplay depending on how good you are. So can we say that this long linearity at the beginning is ideal in an open world pokemon? Personally i feel like if it takes that long to open up it doesnt count fully as an open world game but more so semi linear which is why i said its near impossible with the current formula. Also im not worried about them filling the world with content lol, that was just more of a general point.

I didnt get too much time to read over what i sent sincee im kinda making this while commuting between campus but lemme know if i made my self clear enough

4

Dont fix what's not broken.

Not every single game has to be a boring open world with nothing to do. We already have western games for that.

5
prestonbark•

People keep saying "if it ain't broke don't fix it". But that's what kept me from buying Sun and Moon, along with Skyward Sword yet being hyped as hell for BotW. I didn't become obsessed with Pokemon as a kid because it wasn't broke, I loved it because it was revolutionary. I'm sure that's not what your against, I'm just saying in general, cries for certain series to be open-world is more of a cry for fresh air in the series.

4†
ShockerG52OP•

I completely agree, pokemon has gotten a bit stale. Im certainly not against open world or a change in mechanics. In fact im more in favor of a soft reboot like monster hunter got. It just seems that if we keepthe level up and combat the same, they cant really get the most out of open world because it still keeps the beginning of the game extremely linear due to hlow long it takes for pokemon to learn moves.

4
bixer25•

To be fair, if anything I think Sun and Moon just further back up the 'if it ain't broke don't fix it' mantra. They're probably the first two games in the series that I felt changed a significant amount from before, but are also by far my least favourite Pokemon games.

3
UltraRainbow•

Sun and Moon only changed surface features that aided the promotional strategy and made no revision of the core mechanics.

1
XenoPathV•

That's too bad, Sun and Moon did many things to shake up the formula, it's a shame you thought it was the same and decided not to buy it because of that misconception.

3
UltraRainbow•

It didn't. It only changed surface features which conveniently looked good in promotional showings. There was no evolution of the core gameplay.

2
XenoPathV•

Maybe, but taking away gyms completely was a huge change that definitely made it feel fresh!

5
UltraRainbow•

They were working with the traditional Pokémon formula, which is good, the only issue is that it's been completed exhausted.

This formula will work when applied. Gyms are a safe point of progression in it. I would be totally in favour of removing gyms, but you need an adequate replacement. Trials were way too easy and a bit weak.

-1
Superflaming85I punched darkness so hard it EXPLODED.•

If it wasn't obvious by my arguments in the other thread, I very much agree with this. Too much of Pokemon would have to change to be completely open-ended.

However, I do agree that a Xenoblade/Dragon Quest/Final Fantasy/MMO take to region design would be a fantastic compromise between the two. Instead of the routes and areas being straight lines, they're basically giant nebulous clouds instead. You still have the freedom to explore what you can explore, and there is a lot to explore, but you don't need to do something flawed like level scaling to balance the game as much. That, and larger worlds and more diverse areas means larger Pokemon selection, and larger team diversity.

That being said, if there's one thing I want Pokemon to do in a future game, it's adapt the Field Moves from Xenoblade 2 instead of HMs and maybe the Ride Pokemon. Instead of needing Rock Smash, you just need a decently powerful Pokemon with a fighting type move. Instead of needing Cut, you just need a Pokemon with a move similar to slashing. While it's not fantastic in Xenoblade 2 due to the random nature of Blades, it feels like a perfect fit for a Pokemon game, since it's much easier to get what you need. Plus, it encourages keeping your team diverse.

Honestly, I would love to see Monolith Soft either take the helm of a Pokemon spin-off, or come in to help with a main-series game like they did for BOTW. I think they would have some very interesting input.

4
simmuasu•

Yeah, Xenoblade scratched the exploration itch I had after playing newer Pokemon games.

1†
Dr0ck129•

Pokemon needs to remove IVs and EVs from the game

3
QuantumElectronicsDuHey Einstein, I'm on YOUR side!•

Hmm...

I'm not sure they need to be removed, but what does need to happen is the whole thing needs to be made much more transparent.

2
upgamers•

EVs are good but IVs need to go.

1
UltraRainbow•

Only people who want to keep IVs are gatekeepers it seems.

-3†
Aurikine•

It's really interesting how this has become one of the biggest and most divisive topics for Nintendo fans lately. Just goes to show how passionate people are for the series.

I think I agree that the main series is best when left largely linear, but I will say that recent games have become a little too much so. There's a nice balance that I think can be struck, and I'd love to see the game world set up with larger open ended areas that aren't always a path with one destination. The structure and pacing of Pokemon often times necessitates the nature of routes being blocked off until a certain point or only having one start and end point, but I think they could stand to explore more winding and interesting layouts.

Full on open world in the way Zelda is doesn't fit the series in my opinion, but I'd be on board with a more "semi-open-world" like what you can see in Xenoblade 2. Also big, pretty, lively and real-feeling cities please! Sun/Moon had nice building designs and presentation but once you really started to look at them they felt small and unrealistic.

2
SuperDragoon978•

Am I the only one here who likes modern Pokemon?

2
joe-is-cool•

Linear? Like Unown?

1
simmuasu•

From Black/White onwards, they've been wanting to have as many people as possible be able to reach the Pokemon League and made the routes linear. So I doubt they'd make an open-world Pokemon game as long as they want that.

I wish they would do more routes like the post-game routes of BW. They were a great balance of open and linear. There is a main path you can follow but not all the way through, there is a good amount of side paths to take and the routes are never too long. This seems like the best compromise between the long, twisty maze routes I love, and the simple paths that the kids supposedly need to be able to finish the games.

1
strategywiki•

Nice images!

1
GorgonMK•

Other than that, open world is an excuse to make bad games. Just look at Assasins Creed, Watch Dogs, Breath of the Wild.

Linearity is a good thing in video games.

1

>bad games
>Breath of the Wild

u wot

1
ActivateGuacamole•

An open world Pokemon game could be a lot of fun but I am not demanding one. I disagree with you because I actually do think it's possible, even if you'd have to change certain "fundamental" parts of Pokemon games. I don't mind making big changes to Pokemon, I actually think it's time for some major changes.

Even though I don't demand or expect (or even know if I really want) an open world Pokemon, Sun and Moon are way too linear and it really hurts the replayability compared to older Pokemon games.


Now I think one problem regarding Sun and Moon's map needs to be addressed regardless of how linear the story is in the next games: the routes and maps. They are so simplistic in Sun and Moon and leave very little to be explored. I think this is partly because of how close the camera is to the player, which is partly because of how detailed the character models + environments are compared to before. With such a low-res screen, I can sort of understand why they had these problems. But it won't be a problem any more, on the new hardware.

The routes and dungeons in Sun and Moon feel like they don't have much to explore when compared with the ones from older Pokemon games and generally just feel smaller. Look at route 6 in Unova, route 205 in Sinnoh or route 214, route 119 in Hoenn, or route 32 in Johto. Kalos also has some great routes to explore, but I can't find any nice pictures.

I think a lot of it is because of Alola's archipelago structure, but its routes just don't feel as vast and sprawling as the routes in the rest of the series's games. And I miss that. You can traverse them all really quickly, and they also aren't as densely packed as the routes I listed above. In Sinnoh's route 214, there are many ways to get across and lots of things to discover. The same for route 119. And many routes from older games contain hidden pathways to optional areas like Fuego ironworks that you can only discover later in the game, which really fleshes them out and adds more mystery and excitement to the region as you explore.

Part of the problem is how many loading blockages there are in Sun and Moon. It really makes the routes feel smaller when they're so cordoned off from each other...

0†
ShockerG52OP•

Hey thanks for the replay. You say you disagree but from what im reading from your reply it seems like you dont? I never said open world pokemon is impossible. I said it is near impossible with how the games work now. If you propose they have to change the fundamentals of pokemon then we are saying the same thing. The entire post is about why with the current formula doesnt benefit an open world and that adjustments need to made in order to compensate the ability to go anywhere at anytime. I think my title might be worded too weirdly and is throwing off peoples perspective on where i stand on this matter. I am totally down for a reboot of pokemon, the point i was trying to make is that if we want an open world pokemon we have to let them change the core because it complements linearity way more than an open setting

1
UltraRainbow•

If that's the main point it doesn't really reflect well from the title.

'The Justification of Linear Pokémon' sounds like you just want linear games.

Most people who advocate for open world Pokémon aren't opposed to core revision.

1
ShockerG52OP•

Can you change titles on mobile?

1
UltraRainbow•

I don't think you can do it at all I don't think. Probably doesn't matter at this stage

1
ActivateGuacamole•

Then yes, I agree with you. I didn't read your whole post, just skimmed and read the bolded parts IIRC. But IDK why people downvoted my reply. It was well thought out and backed with examples.

1
platinumpuss88•

Hint: other mechanics would change when the series goes open world.

“Justifications” like this, along with low expectations from Pokemon fans, keep Game Freak from evolving the series.. as the series continues plateauing. Ridiculous.

0†

Did you not read the post and just read the title. The entire premise of the post is that to achieve an open world pokemon they would have to change the mechanics and adapt. No where did they say that they shouldnt change the formula, but simply gave reasons why using the current formula in an open world setting would still make part of the game extremely linear thus not truly doing an open world game justice.

6
platinumpuss88•

“using the current formula in an open world setting would still make part of the game extremely linear thus not truly doing an open world game justice”

Hence my comment..

-3

So are you saying that the game should change to open world and change the formula to make it actually suit it? Or are you saying they shouldnt try to change the formula and find a way to make it open world without taking into consideration what mechanics work best with it? Or are yoy saying they shouldnt change at all?

0
GelatoCube•

More options on where to go when is best. The original games you could go out of order with multiple gyms and go places you arent supposes to early

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1