r/StarWars•
Frando3

[Spoiler] Question about Luke in TLJ

Spoilerspoilers

What was the point of the force projection to fight Kylo, when Luke just dies anyway? Why couldn’t he just fly there in his x-wing, confront Kylo for real, then die? I just don’t understand the reason for the force projection at all. No other heroes had trouble getting to the salt planet on time...

Posted Feb 7, 2018, 6:40 AM UTC

126

There is a very good reason for this. Luke still believes Kylo can be saved. But he knows that Kylo has too much resentment for him in particular, so Luke also recognizes that he cannot be the one to save Kylo.

So, if you still want to give your nephew a shot at redemption, it’s probably not a good idea to let him murder you.

Edit: also, the x-wing was crashed at the bottom of the ocean. This was shown in the movie.

12
Frando3OP•

I was thinking the x-wing was just submerged and could be lifted out with the force, ESB style.

2

No I’m pretty sure it’s busted. Luke would make sure of it. He really did not want to ever leave the planet.

3
Frnklfrwsr•

Luke was using the X wing door as the door to his hut. I don't think that thing flies anymore.

3
Hatherence•

If you look closely, the door to his hut is a piece of metal ripped from the X-wing.

2
Frnklfrwsr•

Well because becoming one with the Force like his masters before him while meditating immediately after pulling off the most badass Jedi power ever seen in any of the movies is badass as fuck. This way, he had hands down no question the absolutely coolest and most epic death of any Jedi in all the movies. He basically became Space Gandhi, using non-violence to save the Rebellion, rekindling hope in the galaxy and establishing the legend of Luke Skywalker again. A true Jedi, he won his fight without even attacking his opponent.

Flying to Crait in a broken X Wing only to be blown apart by Walkers is not so badass.

He was using the door from the X Wing as the door to his hut. That thing wasn't flying. Force projection was really his only option.

10
hijabikababi•

Yes!! Best answer ever!

3
epigenetic•

My issue is how has he rekindled hope? The only people who aren’t first order that saw what happened are on the millennium falcon? How has he rekindled hope? I get the sentiment but it doesn’t work with what was presented in the film.

3
wreckingballheart•

Somehow those kids in Canto Bight knew the story though, so that's how.

Unless they kill every officer who witnessed what happened the First Order isn't going to be able to keep the story from spreading within its ranks. The Supremacy was damaged, not destroyed, but would have to be repaired in place. They have to get supplies and resources from somewhere, probably bring in shipbuilders from whoever built it in the first place. People would start to ask questions. Eventually the story is going to get out.

4
Frnklfrwsr•

That's one of the purposes of the epilogue at the end. It showed that those kids all the way back on Canto Bight are all re-telling the story. If those random kids heard about what happened, you can bet the story has spread all around the galaxy.

The Legend of Luke Skywalker is reborn.

2
ADM_Ahab•

You need to imagine that Luke saving ~10 people made more of an impression on the galaxy than the FO murdering ~10 billion. If you can't do that, despite the fact that the movie tells you to, then you have a terminal case of logic and there's nothing the apologists can do to help you.

-1
Frnklfrwsr•

What made an impact on the galaxy was that despite the First Order being so powerful they wiped out an entire Solar System, all their power was insufficient to destroy Luke Skywalker, Jedi Master.

It creates just a spark of hope that maybe, just maybe, it may be possible to stand up to the FO.

2
ADM_Ahab•

Yeah, that and the fact that their planet-nuking superweapon was destroyed by a handful of X-wings on its maiden voyage. Which, when you think about it, is actually a lot more impressive. But this galaxy has seen the same sort of thing over and over again. I mean, did everyone forget about the destruction of two Death Stars and the overthrow of the Empire? The FO is just a less competent version of its predecessor, after all.

1
A-112•

If Kylo killed Luke, that would stay with him always. Just like when he killed Han.

6
Frando3OP•

So, Luke wanted to save his friends, but not let Kylo kill him? It doesn’t seem that different to me, because the end result is that Luke is dead and the rebels escape either way. Kylo tried to kill him, and got what he wanted since Luke is now dead.

0†

It’s completely different because Kylo didn’t get the kill. Like dying wasn’t his fault, so he’s not driven further into darkness by the act.

4
Aequitassb•

If he had really gone to Crait, how would he have survived the assault by the walkers? He never would have gotten to Kylo.

6
Hatherence•

By going as a force projection, he was able to save the day without actually committing any acts of violence. This is the most Jedi thing possible.

And he became one with the force, rather than totally dying. We'll be seeing him later on, I'm sure.

6
Vathez•

Luke's X-Wing was very much damaged beyond repair. He was using part of it as a door. So no, he couldn't just fly to Krayt.

4
TheMadWobbler•

Despite not being a Sith, Kylo is the closest adherent to Sith philosophy we've seen in the movies.

Peace is a lie, there is only passion. Through passion, I gain strength. Through strength, I gain power. Through power, I gain victory. Through victory, my chains are broken. The Force shall free me.

This is basically an instruction manual on how to grow in power in the dark side. To destroy all that holds you back and become your truest self. Killing Han actually makes Kylo weaker in the dark side because he is so burdened with guilt. It only made his chains heavier. Killing Snoke made him stronger, because he realizes Snoke is only holding him back from his true potential and Kylo cast him aside without remorse.

If Luke had gone to Krait, and Kylo struck him down, Kylo would break another chain, and grow stronger in the dark side.

By projecting himself, he not only denies Kylo the victory he needs, he denies him the possibility and tethers himself to Kylo in a way that can never be broken. "Strike me down in anger and I will always be with you."

And despite everything, Kylo is still Luke's nephew, and he loves him.

3
MRHBK•

Stop and read your questions very slowly to yourself and think about them.

2
flymordecai•

when Luke just dies anyway?

Why is Luke using a previously unseen, rarely known, jedi master technique coupled with a lightsaber fight less ideal than a saber fight that ends in his death?

No other heroes had trouble getting to the salt planet

They were all on Snoke's ship or being chased by Snoke's ship.

on time...

Projections are faster than hyperspace.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
coweatman•

because we don't know if luke could survive that kind of firepower IRL and now the empire/everyone else thinks that jedi are that powerful. it's a legend builder. kylo isn't going to tell anyone he got hoodwinked.

1