Election in April/May - Sheriff

In April (for early voting) and May, we'll have our primary elections. We'll be voting for several offices and I'd like to ask folks their opinion about our options.

In this case, the office of sheriff.

Here's what little I know about the office of sheriff in Knoxville:

A few years ago Tennessee voters approved term limits for several offices. Incomprehensibly, the Knoxville leadership simply ignored this missive and stayed in offices they were supposed to step down from. So the state government stepped in and kicked them all out in what we locally call "Black Wednesday".

The sheriff at the time, Tim Hutchison, was forced out of office on Black Wednesday.

Hutchison's hand-picked his successor, J.J. Jones, was elected to succeed Hutchison and J.J. Jones then hired Hutchison as a "top deputy" (according to this Knox News article).

Now J.J. is term-limited and has to step down. J.J. has now hand-picked Lee Tramel to succeed him. This can be construed positively as "constant stewardship and consistent leadership" or "good ol' boy cronyism", depending on your reading of the tea leaves (and I'm out of tea).

Info from these guys' websites about themselves:

= Tom Spangler =

  • Trained Tramel when Tramel was a cadet
  • Air Force Sergeant
  • Patrolman
  • Narcotics Division
  • Director of Training
  • Established regional training academy
  • Established regional aviation unit
  • Interim sheriff when Tim Hutchison was evicted until J.J. was elected.

Main reason to vote for him: experience doing every job you can imagine in the local police force

Main reason to vote against him: Has been leading a training academy for several years, hasn't been "inside" the force recently.

= Lee Tramel =

  • Joined Knoxville PD in 1987 so he's clearly well-established there
  • Has been in the Knoxville force working directly with current-sheriff J.J. Jones for "several years" (I can't recall the exact number of years he said, but implied it was in the same cruiser even)
  • Graduate of the FBI's National Executive Institute
  • Started a senior citizens awareness program
  • Is focused on addressing the opiate addiction issue in Knoxville
  • Has apparently raised significantly more money than Spangler
  • Has some kind of influence at my work as indicated by the recent tour (perhaps he just had the ambition to knock on the front door and ask, but it's note-worthy in any case to escort a public office candidate through the office)

Main reason to vote for him: J.J. Jones, the current sheriff, picked Tramel to succeed him

Main reason not to vote for him: J.J. Jones, the current sheriff, picked Tramel to succeed him

...

As you can see I don't enough to go on beyond these folks' histories on their own websites.

Do you Knox-Redditors out there feel like standing up for one of these guys and letting us know why?

Posted Mar 8, 2018, 3:06 AM UTC · edited

5714
LucentThe Fort•

Local politics drives me crazy with its absence of policy discussion. You kind of have to hunt for clues. What would be most telling is which wants a "war on opiates" and which wants more widespread access to that antidote nasal spray. If they differ on that, that'll be all I need to know to decide who I'll vote for.

18
inanutshellusOP•

Exactly how I feel! I have no idea how to differentiate these guys, policy-wise, and I suspect they don't either. They both just want the job. :/

10
swbcjkbDowntown•

Tramel is part of the “stack ‘em like cordwood” style of Knox Sheriff-ing. Probably as close to a policy statement as you’ll get out of him.

6
BesnastyWest Hills•

Can we do this for all elections around here? I would love to hear everyones reasons for voting for/against someone in our local elections.

12
Corey_Howard•

Really like your work, u/inanutshellus and I look forward to future editions of it. Betty Bean wrote a piece for KnoxTNtoday.com about the race that seems, well, a bit slanted towards one of the candidates. That being said, Betty brings up a lot of good points about both of them.

10
inanutshellusOP•

Being able to raise money isn't a sin in my book, so that doesn't sway me overly. Betty's article mentioned that 24 deputies had endorsed Spangler, which is a positive note. I wonder how many endorsed Tramel...

3
MidgardDragon•

Money in politics is one of the biggest issues of our time. You have to care where the money comes from or you'll never know what their real intentions are.

2
inanutshellusOP•

Betty's article mentioned real estate folks having donated to Tramel. How am I to differentiate "we believe in you, here's some dough" from "since we've agreed you're going to OK my plan to develop condos in protected marsh lands... Here's some dough."? I don't really understand how a sheriff would affect real estate deals and/or real estate legislation and would love some insight if anyone has it, but more generally I just don't know what I'm supposed to make of donations beyond face value.

5
Corey_Howard•

Just a guess, but keeping Sheriff's Office spending low, which in-turn keeps taxes low. Another guess is they think he may run for another office sometime in the future (like former Sheriff Tim Hutchinson, who ran for County Mayor).

1
Angieelaaa•

I have not met either, but the Sheriff's department has been "stuck in the mud" for a long time. Every time someone in the social service industry talks (we had a speaker yesterday) they talk about how well the city police work with them, and how hard it is to work with the Sherriff's office. I have been hearing these same things for well on 15 years or more. (As a tiny example, the city police have a policy stating if an officer is talking with someone (suspect, etc) that speaks a language other than Spanish or English, they are to use the "Language-Line" interpreter service (where you call and there are interpreters that speak pretty much every language out there). The Sheriff's department has no such policy and as such, potentially could be denying people of their rights. I said all that to say, I would vote for Tom Spangler, if nothing else but to hope that things would change. It also sounds like his experience in running large-scale projects (starting a regional training academy is a huge job), and having the backing of fellow officers is also huge.

6
MoreBBQWings•

Great concrete example. Thanks!

3
bigwhammy•

Lee came to my work as well. I gave a short stump speech on the opiate crisis and Knox County's focus on treating the issue.

4
inanutshellusOP•

He mentioned his passion for it but from the articles I've found he doesn't take credit for leading any initiatives on it, instead only citing the progress that has been made while he's served, so I considered that bit "fluff".

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Dragonlass•

I took my conceal and carry class from Tom Spangler. I liked him as a person and appreciated his experience. I am tired of cronies so Tom gets my vote.

2