r/shacomains•
Rinith

Tested new Q duration - fails to deal damage even with 10-15% stealth duration left (level 1 Q)

5 min of testing in practice tool was all it took to confirm my suspicions that 0.25 seconds was too extreme, mechanically speaking. It needs to be increased to a minimum of 0.5 seconds it seems, though a full 1 second might be required for it to feel smooth. I can agree with Rito that 2.5 seconds is a bit too long, but this is plain stupid.

Will be testing higher levels of Q next.

Edit: Higher levels of attackspeed does make it possible to gain the bonus damage and reduced cd when attacking with only ~5% duration left. Higher levels do not change anything except gaining a slight boost in attack speed. If stealth breaks before you attack, Q damage and cdr will never apply.

With lower attack speeds (early game) we need at least 0.2 seconds of stealth left if we want the extra damage from Q.

Posted Apr 4, 2018, 4:52 PM UTC · edited

4938
callmerandy•

Leave it to riot to just throw in an obscure nerf last second without even testing it lmao

63
PyBroPlays•

expect another nerf soon meanwhile other champs that dominate the meta will still be untouched for another patch

14
Xaraku•

Or buffed.

10
Patrick_Sponge•

Dont say that. Janna cait xayah and others are getting nerfed, a rioter said.

2
PyBroPlays•

oh right, cuz when they say something it means they will do it, my bad :/

1
Patrick_Sponge•

??? Nerf is coming at patch 8.8 btw.

2
PwnageEngage•

Maybe the mods or someone can DM the Rioter who came asking about the Shaco buffs? Just to let him know that the 0.25 second change makes Shaco feel clunky and is not good.

12
RadiationSeason208,300 GET OFF OF ME•

remember, duskblade got nerfed so we're basically gonna be even worse than pre-dusk nerf

10
RinithOPhttp://euw.op.gg/summoner/userName=rinith•

I've played a couple (normal) games already, and I haven't really noticed a loss in damage, rather, fewer non-tanks are picking up ninja tabi, so it's been rather easy finding targets to assassinate.

Shaco's still in a good spot, but we just need Rito to fix this random duration change, preferably, revert it completely. I'd say a 0.75 second duration should be enough to keep it from being clunky and feeling awful. A full 1 second duration sound fine imo if they really want to go through with this change. Thoughts?

-2
RadiationSeason208,300 GET OFF OF ME•

I'm honestly ok with the nerfs to just .4 scaling but if we cant even get the damage off in the first place until we get AS, thats a huge problem. Because these buffs were supposed to compensate duskblade, if there is no damage, thats a big disadvantage.

0.25 seconds is way too short. I don't even know why they changed it in the first place I agree, it's gotta be at least 0.75 to make it fluid.

Also, those were normal games so it might not be too acurate on how these changes are, especially if people don't build ninjas.

Guess we gotta wait a bit more and see how it plays out.

3
RinithOPhttp://euw.op.gg/summoner/userName=rinith•

It's fully possible to get the damage off without attackspeed, just need to have more than ~0.2 seconds of invisibility left.

2
RadiationSeason208,300 GET OFF OF ME•

Oh, pardon me. I haven't tried out 8.7 Shaco yet. But still, that does mean we can't just auto at the end of invis and keep the damage which actually sucks

1
VexingRaven473,321•

I honestly don't see why a duration nerf was needed. If you can see Shaco for an entire 2.5 seconds before he attacks you, and you still manage to die, either he's fed to shit or you are just plain bad.

2
ChiefSalvaje•

I just don't understand how Kha'zix, who's much, much stronger than Shaco, gets no nerf whatsoever. Yet we have Shaco who finally got a buff gets nerfed literally a patch later.

7
ObsidianLion•

Kha doesn't have a 56% win rate. Although I hate Kha, we have to talk truthfully if we want this to go somewhere.

2
WcCannons742,906 March March March•

u/rinith,

Is this because while you might initiate the attack within the .25 second window, the damage doesnt actually register for the AA until the animation completes?

If so, WTF Riot. They should know Shaco's low attackspeed backstab is one of the worst AA's in the game.

3
RinithOPhttp://euw.op.gg/summoner/userName=rinith•

Well, I did break the invisibility with the autoattack, just at the very end, it should behave as it would if I were to attack instantly after Q, but it doesn't.

1
WcCannons742,906 March March March•

You would think they would also ensure that any auto attack started while in stealth would apply the damage regardless of the lack of attack speed. It sounds like they didnt compensate for the actual swing speed.

I'll probably test tonight.

1
ChaosShadowClone1,456,858 ChaosParadox (NA)•

shacos base attack speed is one of the fastest xD

1
WcCannons742,906 March March March•

Attack speed and attack animation =/= same thing.

1
SuemDude309,046 Fuck you Duskblade•

I thought the duration to get Cdr on hit was still 2.5 secs though

3
VexingRaven473,321•

Wasn't that removed entirely?

1
SuemDude309,046 Fuck you Duskblade•

Yeah just bad reading from my part

1
NoremacEnrobso•

I guarantee the riot employees that nerfed him were getting detected by him in solo que and this is a vengeance nerf. I agree 2.5 secs is too long but it should be 1 sec not .25

2
sleepless_elite•

TLDR: you need attack speed to "activate" the Q damage LOL

2
ChaosShadowClone1,456,858 ChaosParadox (NA)•

I dont get it, all you need to do now early is make sure you Q from a close enough distance to AA the enemy before you appear out of stealth... and i mean most of the time you do that anyways and if you dont USUALLY the enemies flash away while they can lol I

2
Rot_Trunks583,184 Monster mode•

Shaco is probably still one of the best junglers out there though cos he does so well with Dark harvest without much risk

2
N1izmo•

Well isn’t that just fucking Great...

1
gkrooswhy always me?•

good topic

1
ShacoinaBoxrip titanic bug i miss u•

i think it's just dumb because of how easy it is to walk out of melee heroes autoattack ranges in this game. it happens at least once almost every time i play shaco, sometimes way more, so .25s guarantees if they walk out you're doing no dmg even if you do catch up (since you unstealth at the beginning of your auto animation)

i'd be REALLY surprised if anyone actually played him on pbe or internal testing, to be honest. i mean look at poor aatrox, hes had that "red passive bar" bug that happens every game guaranteed for 3-4 1/2 months now. they just don't care unless your champs new or pushes a lot of skins.

1
sSariuSs509,918•

There is one thing that i dont understand on this change. Riot stated multiple times on different champions that oneshotting is unhealthy for the game. That was the reason i.e. Leblank got changed and needs to wait out her spells.

So now to the thing im curios about: Why does rito force us into oneshotting from stealth, what basically means least counterplay possible for the target, instead of nerfing the dmg harder but give more potential to counterplay by having the dmg duration up longer. It might even be better to lower the stealth duration overall but prolong the dmg duration afterwards.

1
vindybg•

So that's why my Q auto was doing 0 dmg that last game, when i tried full ap shaco without precision or any attack speed item. Not only the jungle clear feels horrible, but now you also dont get Q dmg half the time if you dont build any attack speed.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2