CMV: Given a dining table of 6 or more, whoever is first to the table can choose the middle most seat first.

Deltas(s) from OP

Depending on personality type, I think most agree that the closer you are to the middle of the table, the more involved you are in the situation and the more enjoyable it is, being as if you are on the end of the table you are limited to who you can talk to. Whenever I go out to eat with a group of 6 or more friends (has to be more than 4 to have a 'middle' of the table seat), my best friend always comments if I choose the middle seat first, if I am first to the table. Its not a jab or an argument, i think it just gets under his skin. He usually just sits on an end or close to the end. I personally think nothing is wrong with this. I subconsciously gauge how comfortable I am in the given group and if I am comfortable with talking to everyone in the group I will choose the middle most seat if I am first presented the opportunity to do so. If someone else gets the middle seat I don't think twice about it and just fill in starting from the middle out. I don't feel as if i am just seeking the limelight because I have no problem sitting on the very end of the table either. There's some situations where I won't take the middle seat, for instance with family or if I am eating with people I'm not that acquainted with. To me it's just like calling shotgun to sit in the passenger seat of a car. I just consider it first come first serve.

Edit: Let's assume the example is a completely accessible table from all sides and everyone gets along with everyone and there isn't any emphasis on a specific person or persons at the table/event. There are obvious situations where it would be conceited to sit in the middle if you're being an inconvenience to others or splitting up people that are only comfortable around each other. Im very conscious of these things.

Posted May 14, 2018, 6:34 PM UTC · edited

926
robobreasts2ƥ

Suppose there's a plate of cookies and you want the biggest one and there is one that is the biggest. Do you go grab it first? I mean, you might as well, right? Someone has to have the biggest cookie, might as well be you, right?

But the question is, do you grab the biggest cookie every single time?

Do you think anyone else wants the biggest cookie? Maybe let someone else have first pick. If they grab the biggest cookie, great, maybe you'll get it again next time. If they leave the biggest cookie, maybe it doesn't matter to them, and you can get the biggest more often in the future and no one is hurt because no one else cares but you.

But if you're hanging out with your friends, you shouldn't be competing, you should be sharing. The biggest cookie shouldn't go to whoever is fastest, it's not a race or a competition. Some people may indeed want the biggest cookie but prefer not to make a mad dash for the cookie table because while do want it, they don't want to take it at someone else's expense.

So, it all comes down to motive: do you think plenty of people have opportunity to take the middle seat, but they are delaying because they don't really care, in which case you can and it's fine, or they do want it but don't want to compete for it (which is what they see you as doing).

The fact that someone is commenting on it kind of tells you - they don't want to compete for the middle seat but other people DO desire it.

Your statement about getting there first is fine in a one-off situation, as long as you aren't seen to be making a mad dash or even briskly walking, because you get the middle seat but you are not perceived as having competed for it.

But that's not what's happening here - people have realized you're competing for it, and they don't want friendly gatherings to be laced with competitiveness like that, and so the polite thing would be to alter your behavior so the perception of competitiveness is eliminated. That would make the rest of the group (or at least your one friend that notices and comments on it) happier.

And isn't making people happier and more comfortable better than just getting what you want?

9
WizzBango•

I think something your cookie analogy isn't considering is that it's only applicable if OP is always the first one at the table.

This isn't the case - he says as much (I think, I may be interpreting incorrectly):

my best friend always comments if I choose the middle seat first, if I am first to the table. Its not a jab or an argument, i think it just gets under his skin. He usually just sits on an end or close to the end.

If the friend gets to the table first, and the friend also enjoys sitting in the middle, then this problem only exists because the friend is milquetoast.

If OP is always rushing to get to table first AND always chooses middle, then I agree with you.

2
mysundayscheming102ƥ

I mean, you absolutely can. Most people wouldn't care. But there are a few circumstances where it would irk me. Like if you choose the middle seat and now I have to awkwardly squeeze around you to get to the other side of the table. That is inefficient and unnecessary. Or if we're at an event to celebrate a particular person and they should be in the middle to be the center of attention but you hijack it just because you want to talk to more people--I would consider that selfish and rude. Or if there are groups of people who obviously want to be/would be more comfortable being near each other (couples, a shy friend being introduced to the larger group staying with the person who brought them, the friends you're not-so-subtly trying to set up, family visiting from out of town, etc.) and you sitting in the middle logistically impedes their ability to stay close to their person.

Ultimately it's profoundly trivial, but there are situations where your choice would strike me as inconsiderate. If the goal is to have a good night out with friends, a little conscientiousness would likely make for a better night than sitting right in the thick of things.

2
lifepatchOP•

I am very conscious of those circumstances. Like if one end of the table is up against the wall and people would have to squeeze around me, I will just sit by the wall to make it convenient for everyone. Also i gauge who is comfortable with who and make sure they are together. Im still considerate. Let's assume the example is an completely accessable table from all sides and everyone gets along with everyone and there isn't any emphasis on a specific person or persons at the table.

1
mysundayscheming102ƥ

Then the question is simply whether being the first in the door entitles you to the "best" (in your eyes, I'm with your friend lol) seat. These people are your friends, you all get along, and from this comment it seems you do value being considerate. What do we do with our friends? Share. Generously, effusively, without being asked. When there's only one glass of champagne left in the bottle, you offer it to them, or split it, you don't always keep it for yourself. Right? Why would the table be any different? It's probably pure accident you got there first. If your friends are late, whatever. But if you arrive together and one was just stuck in the bitch seat in the uber so couldn't get in the building as quickly as you? Why wouldn't you want to share with them?

2
lifepatchOP•

Going off the champagne comment, I would undoubtedly offer the last glass to anyone else before taking it myself. I enjoy serving my friends and always share. The seating situation is much more trivial than that circumstanc in my eyes i guess to the point where I don't think about it as much.

1
mysundayscheming102ƥ

That doesn't mean your friends don't think of it as much though, or don't mind. Your friend certainly noticed--what if he also preferred the middle instead of the end? Would you insist on using the shotgun method or would you have shared, as if it were champagne?

And yes, this problem is pretty trivial, none of us (and likely none of your friends) have any illusions about that. But being considerate about trivial things is still being considerate. Your friends, to the extent that they care at all, would likely think well of you for extending your willingness to share to this realm as well, and appreciate the opportunity to sit in the middle.

1
muyamable52ƥ

I agree with you in spirit that first come, first serve should work, but I also think there should be some balance. Running with the shotgun analogy, if you know multiple people in your friend group want to ride shotgun but you continue calling shotgun first a disproportionate number of times, you're playing by the rules but also being annoying. Similarly, if you know one of your friends would enjoy a middle seat but don't give them the opportunity to choose it sometimes, even though you're playing by the rules your behavior may start to get annoying.

1
lifepatchOP•

Δ

I can see where you are coming from. Since it's so trivial, others may not think of it until it's already called by someone else which can be annoying if it happens every time.

1
DeltaBotMOD∞∆•

Confirmed: 1 delta awarded to u/muyamable (50∆).

^Delta System Explained ^| ^Deltaboards ​

1
hellomynameis_satan1ƥ

Definitely seems like a limelight thing to me. Do you think your friend is jealous of you taking the seat every time, or just thinks it's weird? I can't say I've ever thought about seating position and the amount of attention a particular spot would get me, but if I thought the middle seat would get me more attention, I would avoid it.

I can only speak from personal experience here (as an introvert), but the weird part to me isn't that you take the middle seat every time, it's that you think being the center of attention is something people are actively competing over. That seems like a really self centered thing to think.

1
lifepatchOP•

Since you're an introvert you wouldn't want to sit in the middle so I can understand why you would think it's selfish. Like I said, it's relative to your personality. Depending on who I am around, I can be extroverted and these would be the situations where i would sit in the middle, if i were first to the table. But if I don't get the middle, I dont throw a tantrum.

My friend is not jealous, as he usually chooses to sit on the end if he is first to the table. There's no tension in this discussion, in fact this entire topic is trivial to both me and him. I don't think of it as a competition for attention. I don't mind if I only get to talk to one person at the end of the table the entire night.

1
svenson_263ƥ

When the table is rectangular, with one side against a wall, and booth-stlye seating, then if you if you pick a middle seat some guests will have to climb over/under furniture and people in order to get to the end. This is extremely inconvenient.

You can extend this concept to any table in cramped quarters. You should fill the table from least-accessible (typically the end) to most-accessible seat. An end seat at a table that initially may apear easily accessible, may not be so once the room fills up. Or it may be less accessible to a larger person, a person who is differently abled, or a person who might be leaving early or getting up often. Additionally, some guests may want (or need) to sit beside each other. If you select a middle seat first, then arriving guests are more likely to be split up and be forced to sit on either side of you instead of next to each other.

TL:DR; Accessibility should be the first priority (not first come first serve) when filling a table.

1
lifepatchOP•

I'm always conscious of accessibility, convenience, and social comfort. Should have specified this. See edit.

1
AnythingApplied26ƥ

To me it's just like calling shotgun to sit in the passenger seat of a car. I just consider it first come first serve.

Why should you get the best seat just because you were there first or you thought of calling it first? This is especially true if you're all arriving at pretty much the same time. Suppose I hold open the door for you, now you're in front of me and take that opportunity to take the most desirable seat? Every time?

When I'm going on a trip, me and my friends always switch shotgun. If I rode shotgun to an event, I'll just not take it on the way home. It's just like everything else, I believe in sharing and don't want to hog the best for myself, even if I can get away with it.

1
fixsparky3ƥ

Depends, if you all arrive the same time that's fine, but I often run into the case where we need to have 3/4 of our party arrive before we can get seated. If thats the case I think the people who arrive later should at least consider the others, after all getting to the table first does not mean you were the first one to arrive. Its especially frustrating if there's a divide like 3 guys, 5 girls, and the girls all sit in the middle. Then one guy is likely going to be shafted out on his own and perhaps not have access to the conversation he would prefer (does not have to be gender based, but seems a simple way to explain). Relationships can cause a similar issue, especially if significant other has not arrived yet.

1
pillbinge42ƥ

Seems like an easy method because people don't normally think of this stuff, but an unfair one. There are plenty of reasons someone won't be first. You aren't allowed to run, someone walking to the table might have to move for another patron, someone with a disability can't physically get there sooner, et cetera. I recently ate in a restaurant that had an upstairs but wasn't handicap accessible. Even without a wheel chair, some people have difficulty going up stairs. That same night while walking to the table I had to make space for another patron. The person I was with then went ahead. So either I'm an asshole to that patron or I move like a human, but now have less claim to a seat that takes 2 seconds to discuss.

1
lifepatchOP•

Situations like these are different. Of course the right thing to do is to cater to the convenience of others, especially handicap. In my edit, i proposed a situation where no one has disabilities, everyone got along fine, and the table was accessible from all seats.

1
electronics12345105ƥ

Sitting at the "head" of the table is traditionally seen as the most "powerful". If you want to negotiate, if you want to bargain, if you want seem intimidating - you should sit at the head of the table.

So, if its just you and your buds, there is a reason to be in the middle, but there are reasons to want the head position.

1
DeltaBotMOD∞∆•

u/lifepatch (OP) has awarded 2 deltas in this post.

All comments that earned deltas (from OP or other users) are listed here, in r/DeltaLog.

Please note that a change of view doesn't necessarily mean a reversal, or that the conversation has ended.

^Delta System Explained ^| ^Deltaboards

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
mysundayschemingMOD102ƥ

Sorry, u/oldMiseryGuts – your comment has been removed for breaking Rule 1:

Direct responses to a CMV post must challenge at least one aspect of OP’s stated view (however minor), or ask a clarifying question. Arguments in favor of the view OP is willing to change must be restricted to replies to other comments. See the wiki page for more information.

If you would like to appeal, [message the moderators by clicking this link](http://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2Fchangemyview&subject=Rule+1+Appeal+oldMiseryGuts&message=oldMiseryGuts+would+like+to+appeal+the+removal+of+[his/her+post](https://old.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/8jeno3/cmv_given_a_dining_table_of_6_or_more_whoever_is/dyzhf2o/\)+because...). Please note that multiple violations will lead to a ban, as explained in our moderation standards.

1