Sam Vimes vs. Judge Dredd

Casual

Stoneface vs. Stoneface.

There's no question Dredd would win in a fight. Unarmed, or armed, he's stronger, better trained, and far more ruthless. No, the competition here is this:

The two lawmen are transported to a town with high medieval technology, roughly analogous to Ankh-Morpork's. However, it is a vile place, with a population that makes Hub City and Mos Eisley look like idyllic country villages. There's roughly a million people, so there's likely a few honest ones in there, but the guys who'd sell you their mother's molars vastly outnumber them.

They each receive half of the city. With no outside help, though they can use whatever they came with (so sword, crossbow, armor, piss, and vinegar for Vimes. Traditional Judge layout for Dredd.), who can create the most law-abiding community and raise the standard of living the most in the period of six months?

Posted Jul 23, 2018, 10:37 PM UTC

198
bibliophile785•

Dredd sterilizes a substantial portion of his half of the city. He is far too ruthless to raise the standards of living in such a corrupt place. His lack of reserve or hesitation, coupled with his sheer invulnerability against his new subjects, cows most of the ones that survive the first couple of weeks into leaving. The ones left are those who are too timid or too stupid to escape. Every citizen follows the law any time Dredd could possibly be nearby. Standards of living bottom out somewhere around subsistence, though, as terror is not conducive to running a functional city.

Vimes turns his half into a slightly seedier Ankh-Morpork, because...well, because this isn't too different from his native setting and because it's all he knows how to do. It takes quite a while, because much of the stability of that city is the result of Veterinari. Nonetheless, Vimes is wise enough to make deals with established entities in this new city, and that goes a long way towards maintaining civilization. Crimes are much higher on his side of the city, but so are standards of living.

I don't know who wins - you didn't rank willingness to abide by the law versus standards of living for import.

4
garbagephoenixOP•

He is far too ruthless to raise the standards of living in such a corrupt place.

I should point out that Dredd has actually taken control of anarchistic areas before, but not with so many people at once. Usually about 50,000 citizens. When he does move in, he tends to recognize that comfortable and safe citizens are less likely to break the law. When he was building the Mutant Townships, he logged constant complaints and fought to get better housing and medical care. When he was touring the Mutant Camps and saw that the vehicles they used were prone to breaking down and leaving the muties exposed to the desert heat and radiation while repairs were done, he immediately ordered them all to be declared obsolete and replaced with high end transports. In Gramercy Heights, the first things he did was order new maintenance and cleaning droids to clear out all the crap in the lower levels because a mess like that "fosters crime". He's used city funds to pay for repairs and the medical needs of citizens.

I'm not saying that you're wrong about him being ruthless, but he has a history of acting in a benevolent manner, though not friendly, towards citizens. In most of the places he takes over, he ends up being a figure of admiration, with citizens smiling at him in the halls and going as far as wanting to name towns after him.

1
bibliophile785•

I suppose my assumption of his belligerence was based off of how shitty the people of Hypothetical City are. OP really amped up how bad most of the people in the populace are. And that's as part of a fully functional city, to boot.

2
garbagephoenixOP•

That's a fair assumption to make!

I was just clarifying that he's not mindlessly ruthless. Sorry.

2
FactsAndGrammar•

Does Vimes have access to the Summoning Dark?

3
garbagephoenixOP•

Sure, but I don't see what difference that would make. The Summoning Dark has a limited utility.

4
FactsAndGrammar•

It provided a significant physical buff, and if the people react to it like the dwarves did, they will consider Vimes the avatar of an avenging demon, which would certainly change the dynamic.

Either way, I doubt either contestant will have much success; they're both dependent on the established systems in their respective worlds. Vimes relies heavily on his staff and Vetinari. Dredd relies on a near-universal level of poverty, and a totalitarian government skilled at distracting and dehumanizing the populace.

2
garbagephoenixOP•

Those're good points for both.

2