Need help tuning 40 meter whip

So recently I put a vertical antenna mount in my yard and connected it to 16 radials each about 16-25 feet long depending on how far I could stretch them out and put up an MFJ 40 meter whip. The antenna works well enough that I barely managed to work Canada from OKC, but while I was tuning I noticed something strange. I hooked the antenna analyzer up to it and it seems like being tuned to 7.350 which is obviously out of band. At that frequency it will give me a 1:1 SWR but if I let the stinger out a little and tune it to 7.200 the lowest I can get is 1.7 or 1.8. And if I try to tune lower than that it's at 2 and this continues the lower I try to tune it. My brother has a similar set up with more radials and the same antenna, and his tunes exactly the same. Does anyone know a fix to this or what the problem might be?

Posted Aug 6, 2018, 5:05 PM UTC

58
w9km•

I believe your cable is 50 ohm and a regular vertical antenna impedance usually around 35...38 ohm. Without the antenna tuner your vertical should have SWR around 1.4 on the resonating frequency. If SWR is not 1.4 - something is not right.

2
TCFlashback65OP•

Any idea what it might be or where I could start troubleshooting? I'm hoping it's not a matter of these antennas just being junk.

0
ChucklzKC2SST [E]•

I'm hoping it's not a matter of these antennas just being junk.

Sorry. A hamstick style antenna is very inefficient, even over a great radial field.

1
rock_vbrgAG5__ [E]•

If that is one of the hamstick antennas, did you trim the wire whip to make sure it does not go into the coil a few inches from the screw connector? If the whip is pushed into the tight coil to shorten the length of the antenna, it will change the inductance of the coil and change how the antenna tunes. I had to cut several inches off the whip to keep that from happening.

2
TCFlashback65OP•

Yep its a hamstick. That sounds like that might be the problem then. I'll try giving it a snip and seeing if that helps.

1
rock_vbrgAG5__ [E]•

This is the video I watched when I setup up my hamstick dipole antenna.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5YdTarpDHU

edit: added a word

2
mjjwo9b•

Can you provide a better explanation (picture?) of your antenna? I'm not sure exactly what MFJ product you've got and ergo what can be done to adjust tuning.

1
LordGarakVE1LX ADV•

What time of day did you give it a try? Sounds like the band wasn't quite open.

1