Key signatures / modes reference
Since I couldn't find a similar chart online listing all key signatures in all modes, I made one, and I figured some people here might be interested: http://keyboardfire.com/s/keys/
Posted Aug 11, 2018, 2:13 PM UTC
Since I couldn't find a similar chart online listing all key signatures in all modes, I made one, and I figured some people here might be interested: http://keyboardfire.com/s/keys/
Posted Aug 11, 2018, 2:13 PM UTC
my only problem with this is that they aren’t listed in mode order, but that’s a small pet peeve. otherwise, good work!
that was intentional, because arranging them this way shows some interesting patterns; for example, if you move diagonally from the top right to bottom left, the tonic remains the same
they are not in stepwise relative order, but they are in a particular order. look up the order of brightness for modes. In that order the way the modes compare against each other becomes more apparent.
They are in order from least to most flats relative to major (starting at -1 for Lydian), which for me at least, is a more useful way of thinking of modes. It goes from brightest to darkest, Lydian being bright and floaty while locrian is dark and entrapping.
that’s an interesting order, but i just prefer the more typical mode order.
Mode order? What order do modes come in?
If you're going to start anywhere then Lydian comes before Ionian on the cycle of fifths. F is not adjusted sharp or flat, so make little sense putting it at the other end when talking about C Ionian.
When talking key signatures or modes the cycle is a great perspective which shows actual associations rather than just spelling things up in the same order as English language.
Ionian, Dorian, Phrygian, Lydian, Mixolydian, Aeolian, Locrian. it’s the only way i’ve ever seen the modes organized. they’re organized by Ionian being the 1st mode of the major scale, Dorian being the 2nd, and so on.
Both ways of organizing the modes are needed.
See here to understand the order you aren't used to yet:
https://www.reddit.com/r/musictheory/comments/91n668/what_exactly_is_a_key/e2zt09p/?context=3
thanks man i’ll definitely check this out
they’re organized by Ionian being the 1st mode of the major scale, Dorian being the 2nd,
That's the order of the Major scale. That is not so much the order in which keys are generated. Cycle of fifths is the way the are ordered (upper and lower tetrachords stacked in fifths, each defines the next key signature).
If you pay close attention to this chart you will start to see the relationship between key signatures and the cycle, along with how the cycle works with modes.
the only way i’ve ever seen
Not seen these types of arrangements?
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-rg0DWIXeNbw/UK0OJeOv47I/AAAAAAAAAi8/j4ZyyBxvZVc/s640/circle+of+fifths.png
i’ve seen the circle of fifths but never seen modes ordered that way. although i am just a high school kid with a minimal understanding of theory anyways. i’ll definitely check it out
It's the most useful order for modal interchange. In similar charts I've made on my own I use the same order. And when you think about it this makes sense, since the modes in this configuration are 5ths apart, so you could think of it as the not-circular circle of 5ths for modal relationship.
Not to beat a dead horse, since you've had so many other replies, but I find that as a guitar player the "order of brighntess" method makes the modes easier to practice since you're basically just changing one note at a time.
What an awesome use of lilypond! I think I enjoyed the source as much as the chart lol
The double flats and double sharps are a waste of time and space. Otherwise it's just a list of key signatures with the notes listed in 5ths instead of alphabetically.
The diagonal patterns formed are pretty, a natural result of the listing in 5ths down as well as across.
Not really much to do with modes. I appreciate the bright-dark listing (across the columns), but I'm not sure it really illustrates that concept very well.
Maybe some will find it useful, although I can't work what you mean by "going a half step up from the last flat gives the corresponding Mixolydian key." What last flat? How does it work for sharp keys?
For example, with 4 flats, the last one is D flat, so the key is E flat Mixolydian (I guess it's a whole step if you treat the note as D flat instead of D). It doesn't work for sharp keys, so you'd have to come up with something different, like "half/whole step below the third to last sharp."
(That part isn't intended to be used in practice; like the double flat/sharp keys, they're mostly just curiosities which I find interesting, even if they're not actually useful.)
As a reader of Lydian Chromatic Concept of Tonal Organisation -- George Russell. Nice that you started on F and not C.
Charts for modal tunes generally utilize the parallel major/minor key signature, then use accidentals for the modal color tones.
If you've got something in Bb Lydian or Mixolydian, put a Bb major key signature. Use E natural or Ab accidentals.
If it's a Bb Dorian or Phrygian thing, use the Bb minor key sig (Db major) and use G natural or Cb accidentals.
It's not how it's always done, but in my experience, it's the most common.
There's a reason you couldn't find one online.
haha, I'm aware that the keys with double flats/sharps aren't normally used, but I still thought it'd be interesting to have them all there, and the part of the chart with the "standard" keys with all 7 modes could still be useful