3.3 Meta Shift Report - Last Minute Edition

Link to the 3.2 report

I was hoping to have more detail in this, but it's nearly 3.4 and learning to code is hard. So here is what I have!

There's a summary at the bottom!

 

 

Introduction

This is a fairly relaxed and mathematically flaky look at the meta of Incursion and how it compares to Bestiary. All data are sourced (with permission) from http://poe.ninja/builds, meaning that there is an unavoidable bias towards builds that are fast and/or preferred by dedicated, experienced players. Unfortunately, unless you're GGG this is the best data set we have. Only the softcore trade leagues are examined. The Incursion data were also gathered some weeks ago, so won't exactly match what you would see on poe.ninja right now.

This is still mostly just a bit of fun. I'd avoid trying to read too much into it, but please let me know if there are any mistakes.

 

 

Ascendancy Breakdown

Let's start with the basics — how did ascendancy class popularity shift this league?

 

AscendancyBestiary %Incursion %Diff ↓Fold Change
Saboteur3.4%17.7%+14.35.22
Elementalist2.4%16.7%+14.36.84
Deadeye14.5%17.5%+3.11.21
Ascendant7.7%10.3%+2.61.34
Hierophant4.5%5.3%+.71.16
Gladiator1.6%1.8%+.31.16
Trickster2.1%2.3%+.11.05
Berserker0.5%0.2%-.30.37
Occultist2.9%2.5%-.30.88
Chieftain1.6%0.7%-.90.45
Assassin2.0%0.7%-1.30.37
Inquisitor2.9%1.5%-1.50.49
Pathfinder5.7%3.1%-2.60.55
Slayer4.9%2.4%-2.60.48
Champion6.1%3.4%-2.70.56
Raider4.8%1.2%-3.50.26
Guardian6.2%2.0%-4.20.32
Necromancer7.6%2.9%-4.80.37
Juggernaut18.5%7.8%-10.80.42

 

Shocking right? Saboteur obviously benefitted hugely from the trap rework (even though many now argue that other classes are better for traps). Elementalist is mostly riding the back of Blade Vortex, but it's interesting to note that her usage was rising quite substantially for the duration of the Bestiary league. This is likely because almost no one actually understood her mechanics until Bestiary had already been released. I imagine she would have placed highly on this chart whether or not Blade Vortex had been changed.

The classes dropping seem to mostly be people swapping to Saboteur and Elementalist, rather than actively avoiding any particular class. Juggernaut hasn't seen any nerfs, either to the class or to any of his popular skills, so it's somewhat interesting to see it crash so hard. My guess would be that many people flocked to him last league largely because he was meme flavour of the month, rather than because they thought he was super strong or enjoyed the playstyle.

(Poor, poor Berserker...)

 

 

Primary Damage Skill Rankings — The Top 50 of Incursion

First let's look at overall percentages, then we'll spend a lot of the rest of the report going through this in more detail. "Rank" here is based on popularity alone, i.e. rank 1 means the skill used by the largest number of characters. This is also using poe.ninja's criterion of only counting 5- and 6-linked skills, which is imperfect but about as good as you can feasibly get. Note that this does include links granted by items.

 

SkillBestiary RankIncursion Rank ↓Rank Change
Arc391+38
Blade Vortex282+26
Elemental HitUnranked3New
Tornado Shot24-2
Barrage15-4
Kinetic Blast116+5
Lightning Spire TrapN/A7New
Righteous Fire38-5
Molten Strike79-2
Frenzy1510+5
Double Strike10911+98
Scorching Ray412-8
Cyclone613-7
Reave514-9
Glacial Cascade1015-5
Sunder1316-3
Blade Flurry817-9
Raise Spectre918-9
Summon Skeleton1819-1
Herald of Ice2620+6
Ancestral Warchief1221-9
Rain of ArrowsUnranked22New
Lightning Arrow1623-7
Summon Flame Golem1724-7
Raise Zombie2225-3
Shield Charge2526-1
Power Siphon9127+64
Warlord's MarkUnranked28New
Orb of Storms5029+21
Flamethrower TrapN/A30New
Blight1931-12
Spectral Throw2732-5
Ball Lightning5733+24
Essence Drain2034-14
Fire Trap9735+62
Frost Blades1436-22
Molten Burst2437-13
Lacerate5138+13
Flicker Strike3439-5
Death AuraUnranked40New
Herald of Thunder3241-9
ConductivityUnranked42New
Ice Shot2143-22
Leap Slam3744-7
Freezing Pulse4045-5
Burning ArrowUnranked46New
Assassin's MarkUnranked47New
Incinerate11648+68
Spark6449+15
Earthquake8750+37

 

The top of the charts is dominated by 3.3's reworks and some perennial favourites. I'm going to talk more about the reworks later, so for now I'll just note a few other things.

Kinetic Blast is gaining some ground! It does seem to have become much more widely considered as a competitive (and perhaps superior) alternative to bow builds for MFing and other fast clearing lately. You can also track a few skills pretty closely to the ascendancy they're commonly paired with — Molten Burst and Chieftain, for example, have fallen together. Finally, it's always fun to see what hipster builds are jostling for position near the bottom (there are 191 skills in the game by the way, so the top 50 leaves quite a lot out). This time it's Death Aura that's the strangest big winner (although to be clear, that does correspond to only 37 high-level characters using it). Wonder what it will be next time?

By the way, despite the strangehold it feels like they have on the meta, Arc and Blade Vortex only account for ~20% and ~10% of builds respectively. A lot, for sure, but no more than other flavour of the months skills have had in past patches. I think it just feels like they're even more popular than they are because both are versatile skills that fit into multiple different build archetypes.

 

 

Skill Diversity by Ascendancy

 

Ascendancy ↓Number of Skills >1% Usage% Usage of Most Popular SkillMost Popular Skill...vs in Bestiary
Ascendant1632.4Elemental HitMolten Strike
Assassin1720.2Herald of ThunderHerald of Thunder
Berserker1225.9SunderAncestral Warchief
Champion1348.1Double StrikeReave
Chieftain1219.7CycloneCyclone
Deadeye728.9Tornado ShotBarrage
Elementalist961.5Blade VortexSummon Flame Golem
Gladiator744.9SunderSunder
Guardian650.6Scorching RayScorching Ray
Hierophant966.5ArcGlacial Cascade
Inquisitor2025.8Molten StrikeMolten Strike
Juggernaut1229.4Righteous FireRighteous Fire
Necromancer636.0Raise SpectreRaise Spectre
Occultist1626.8Blade VortexBlight
Pathfinder1132.5FrenzyBarrage
Raider2020.1BarrageTornado Shot
Saboteur665.7ArcGlacial Cascade
Slayer1236.5CycloneCyclone
Trickster1325.7FrenzyEssence Drain

 

In most cases, it's looking like the more generalist ascendancies have more skill diversity as you'd expect. The major exceptions are Chieftain (surprisingly diverse for such a narrow class), Elementalist (who you'd at least naively think would be more diverse, though an experienced player probably wouldn't be surprised) and Ascendant (not the most varied class!). The dominant skills are generally either pretty similar or locked to a popular rework skill. My one note would be that both Trickster and Pathfinder are showcasing the increasing popularity of crazy Poet's Pen mana builds at high levels of play.

 

 

Unique Item Rankings — The Top 100 of Incursion

There are over 800 uniques in the game at this point, so let's have a nice fat table showing off the top 100 most popular!

 

Unique ItemBestiary RankIncursion Rank ↓Rank Change
Watcher's Eye110
Atziri's Promise220
The Wise Oak133+10
Headhunter144+10
Ventor's Gamble105+5
Tombfist660
Starkonja's Head770
Dying Sun38-5
Inpulsa's Broken Heart1009+91
Goldwyrm1110+1
Loreweave5711+46
Essence Worm4312+31
Queen of the Forest913-4
Taste of Hate1214-2
Kaom's Heart515-10
Devoto's Devotion1816+2
Sadima's Touch1517-2
Lioneye's Fall1718-1
Shimmeron16319+144
Brightbeak3120+11
Combat FocusN/A21New
Bisco's Collar2622+4
Xoph's Blood4823+25
Lavianga's Spirit6124+37
Call of the Brotherhood30525+280
Lion's Roar426-22
Inspired Learning6627+39
Windripper1928-9
The Poet's Pen5029+21
Mark of the Shaper18230+152
Bubonic Trail4531+14
Presence of Chayula2832-4
Shavronne's Wrappings2133-12
Rigwald's Quills5334+19
Clear Mind6435+29
Hrimsorrow16436+128
Sin Trek2937-8
Tinkerskin34538+307
Rumi's Concoction2539-14
Kaom's Roots2440-16
Bisco's Leash5241+11
Lightpoacher3442-8
Prism Guardian3043-13
Piscator's Vigil3944-5
Esh's Mirror7045+25
Energy From Within3746-9
Belly of the Beast1647-31
Intuitive Leap10248+54
Might of the Meek2049-29
Conqueror's Potency3650-14
Conqueror's Efficiency5451+3
FrostfernoUnranked52New
Chin Sol17653+123
Alpha's Howl5654+2
Witchfire Brew855-47
Wildfire3556-21
Yoke of Suffering17257+115
Shaper's Touch3258-26
Atziri's Step7759+18
Kaom's Way2260-38
Blood of the Karui3861-23
Fevered Mind9262+30
Pyre24263+179
Divination Distillate6964+5
Vessel of Vinktar4665-19
Pure Talent6566-1
Saffell's Frame2367-44
Forbidden Taste2768-41
Shroud of the Lightless6369-6
Mind of the Council27070+200
Hrimburn20871+137
The Pariah8372+11
Indigon15073+77
Berek's Grip23374+159
Lycosidae3375-42
Darkness Enthroned5576-21
Soul Mantle8077+3
Bated Breath9378+15
Grelwood Shank14479+65
Dream Fragments10880+28
Grand Spectrum18681+105
Ephemeral Edge7682-6
Soul CatcherN/A83New
Healthy Mind4784-37
Choir of the Storm21085+125
Victario's Influence8786+1
Lioneye's Remorse12487+37
Impresence7988-9
The Overflowing Chalice7589-14
Thief's Torment11090+20
Lori's Lantern13091+39
Zerphi's Last Breath11692+24
Sin's Rebirth10693+13
Doryani's Catalyst4094-54
The Vigil11595+20
Astramentis5896-38
String of ServitudeN/A97New
Self-Flagellation9598-3
Cloak of Defiance18999+90
Drillneck138100+38

 

Unsurprisingly, the top of the list is mostly filled with uniques that fit into many different types of build, headlined by the king and queen of versatility in Watcher's Eye and Atziri's Promise. A few quite specialised uniques have made their way to the highest ranks on the back of massively popular meta builds though — the powerful but super-niche Inpulsa's Broken Heart even broke into the top ten!

Now let's zoom in on the biggest movers and shakers in that list. I'm only including uniques included in the top 100 above, cause let's be real, no one cares that Unstable Payload shot up 300 places.

 

The Biggest Unique Movers and Shakers of Incursion

 

Unique ItemBestiary RankIncursion RankRank Change ↓
FrostfernoUnranked52New
Tinkerskin34538+307
Call of the Brotherhood30525+280
Mind of the Council27070+200
Pyre24263+179
Berek's Grip23374+159
Mark of the Shaper18230+152
Shimmeron16319+144
Hrimburn20871+137
Hrimsorrow16436+128

 

Unique ItemBestiary RankIncursion RankRank Change ↑
The Scourge82243-161
Oskarm84174-90
Bloodseeker94173-79
Vis Mortis44122-78
The Sorrow of the Divine86159-73
Bones of Ullr41113-72
Abyssus42112-70
Atziri's Disfavour96165-69
Unending Hunger74141-67
Rise of the Phoenix71135-64

 

The biggest risers are very simple. Each of them can be explained by Arc, Blade Vortex, Elemental Hit or Traps. Nice. The losers though, I'm actually a bit stumped on. Spectres obviously dropped in popularity, as did Righteous Fire. The rest are pretty much just generic melee uniques. While melee did drop in popularity simply due to the biggest flavours of the month not being melee, I didn't expect it to have an impact this big on some of those items. Is it just fatigue? If you have any ideas, let me know!

 

 

Spotlight on...3.3 Content

3.3 brought with it a host of high-profile balance changes. Tons of skills got reworked, Vaal skills were rebuilt from the ground up, and traps and ignite received heavy buffs. There were also a few brand-new skills released, all traps. So how did they all do? Let's take a look.

 

New Skills

 

Skill ↓% Use (Any)
Explosive Trap0.23%
Flamethrower Trap1.98%
Lightning Spire Trap12.50%
Seismic Trap0.15%
Siphoning Trap3.42%

 

This is a difficult batch to judge, as only one of them (Explosive Trap) could potentially carry a build by itself. Siphoning Trap is strictly a utility skill, and the other three are seemingly intended to provide a boost of extra DPS in tough encounters. As such, I've listed their total usage here rather than just 5-links and up. Lightning Spire trap has clearly nestled into the popular Arc trapper build, and Flamethrower trap seems to be successfully filling the same niche in Fire Trap builds. Both are also showing up occasionally in otherwise non-trap builds, which is cool. Unfortunately it doesn't look like the physical traps have hit the mark in the same way. If I had to speculate, Explosive Trap seems completely outclassed by Fire Trap and Seismic Trap is just lacking a build to call home.

 

Reworked Skills

 

Skill ↓Bestiary RankIncursion Rank% Use (Main Skill)
Arc39120.99%
Ball Lightning57330.46%
Blade Vortex28212.54%
Bladefall73620.10%
Blast Rain76510.14%
Blight19310.47%
Burning ArrowUnranked460.25%
Charged DashUnranked740.06%
Cold SnapUnranked600.11%
Double Strike109112.73%
Earthquake87500.16%
Elemental HitUnranked39.58%
Fireball110550.13%
Fire Trap97350.41%
Flameblast65990.02%
Flame Surge111650.09%
Freezing Pulse40450.25%
Frost Bomb90870.04%
Ground SlamUnranked520.14%
Ice Trap1001200.01%
Incinerate116480.19%
Lacerate51380.38%
Lightning Strike49640.09%
Lightning Trap83540.13%
Magma Orb46630.09%
Orb of Storms50290.52%
Power Siphon91270.61%
Rain of ArrowsUnranked220.81%
Righteous Fire383.99%
Storm Burst1201290.01%
Storm Call55930.03%

 

This is a big batch with a lot to pick over, much of which I will leave up to the reader. I'm sure most of you will have already been well aware of Arc, Blade Vortex and Elemental Hit's positions as the first, second and third most popular skills overall in the league. They're all contentious skills for one reason or another, and based on feedback last time I won't take a position on them here. But for interest's sake, the main things I've seen people debate are:

  • Is Arc itself overpowered or is it just traps?

  • Was Blade Vortex too strong even before it got buffed? Its state of balance been argued over pretty much since it was released, even though it has since seen numerous large changes.

  • Are Elemental Hit's mechanics reasonable? Is it appropriate that 97% of Elemental Hit users take Avatar of Fire?

Vaal Double Strike has also done very well for itself, shooting up nearly 100 positions thanks to its buffs and shiny reworked Vaal version. A very impressive performance for a single-target melee skill. After that, it becomes a lot more of a mixed bag. Many of the updated skills show substantial increases in popularity, while many others stayed static or even went down in the rankings. The most extreme example, Flameblast, lost 34 positions despite getting buffs to the base version, the Vaal version, Vaal skill mechanics, and ignite. Yikes. It isn't really possible for me to analyse which of these movements (or lack thereof) are due to power level, fun, curiosity, or just awareness. I'll leave that to you folks. (But pssssst, Ball Lightning is sleeper OP. Don't tell anyone.)

 

Vaal Skills

I don't really have data on this! The changes to Vaal skills completely changed how they are used and made counting them very different, so it's pretty much impossible to make useful comparisons between Bestiary and Incursion data. I'll just leave you with the fact that about 80% of Incursion builds are using at least one Vaal skill, compared to about 50% of Bestiary builds, and 30% of Incursion builds are using a 5- or 6-linked Vaal skill vs basically no one in Bestiary.

 

Traps

About 15% of surveyed characters in Incursion are using traps, whereas almost literally no one was in Bestiary. On the surface that's a big success! However, a whopping 92% of Incursion trappers are using Arc traps. So the question is, what contributes most to this stat? Is the carrying component Arc, the new trap mechanics, or the Trap Support? Again, I'll have to leave this one up to you to discuss. I'd love to see what the trapper meta would look like in the absence of Arc, but I would guess it would just be 90% Glacial Cascade like mines always used to be...

 

Ignite

This is an area where I would really love to have a more complete set of stats, rather than being limited to the highest-level characters. I suspect they would tell quite a different story. However, with what we have, 0.45% of builds are ignite based (defined as a build using both the Burning Damage and Deadly Ailments supports to support the same skill, because that seems fairly all-encompassing). Fireball is the most popular delivery skill, followed by Burning Arrow, Elemental Hit and Incinerate. Flameblast is bringing up the rear with one solitary representative. Hardly flavour of the month, is it? This is stepping outside the stats a bit, but from what I've observed the changes have really solved clearing and ignite delivery issues, but damage remains a problem for most builds.

 

 

Summary

Whew, that was a long one.

  • The meta has changed very heavily compared to the 3.1 – 3.2 shift.

  • The majority of skill reworks of 3.3 have attracted more people to the skills. The majority of the data in this article are consequences of the most popular reworks (Arc, Blade Vortex and Elemental Hit). Some have proven less popular, though it's difficult to determine why.

  • Traps were the runaway system change success of the patch, but are they really responsible for their own success? Is it just Arc? You decide!

  • The new skills of 3.3 mostly aren't that popular, but were they even meant to be?

  • Vaal skills are cool now, but it's really hard to back that up with data.

  • Ignite buffs seem to have fizzled.

  • We've just started to get over minion fever, so bring on 3.4 and round two: Guardian boogaloo!

I hope you've found this interesting or entertaining. As always, feedback and suggestions are much appreciated! Would more detail be good or would it send to you sleep? Is there anything lacking? Anything I can tweak? Any requests for next time? Thank you for reading!

Posted Aug 26, 2018, 11:48 AM UTC · edited

728282
Loading comments…