r/RWBY•
devilkingx2

Was Blake burning down her own house then blaming the white fang the single most hilariously clever character moment in the series?

DISCUSSION

To this day I still can't believe she actually did that, it was awesome.

I was literally thinking about how stupid the white fang are for attacking when they already know blake and ghira are struggling to get support and this could easily backfire and get them sympathy support, vindicating their cause.

Then I thought it was stupid for her to burn her house down to fight ilia rather than just break open a window or move the fight to a brighter location or use dust or super hearing like daredevil (she has 4 ears). Until it dawned on me that she might be trying to fuck shit up to frame the white fang and get more support later, which would explain why she doesn't care about destroying her house or endangering her family. And then, just for a second I doubted the RWBY writer's ability to be this clever...

Until Blake blamed the white fang for something she did and i was like... "Yeah, exactly like that" before bursting into laughter

Just for that one moment, blake was an 11/10 character, surpassing even the greats like Vegeta.

Posted Aug 27, 2018, 2:30 PM UTC

7935
winklemBashing the writers =/= criticism | V6 hype train has started.•

Got to say, burning her house down to gain vision while also trying to frame the WF sounds clever indeed.

Anyways, IMO the point she was trying to make is "This whole mess was caused by Faunus going against other Faunus", not just "That fire was caused by Faunus".

EDIT: a word.

80
Golbi54•

Anyways, IMO the point she was trying to make is "This whole mess was caused by Faunus going against other Faunus"

Precisely

The whole point of this speech was to show that Faunus are just capable of violence and hate towards other Faunus just like humans and if they will remain passive and don't speak and act for themselves this may be the future that awaits them..

Also, she didn't mention WF in any single word We = Faunus

45
devilkingx2OP•

You see the thing is... They didn't accomplish anything at all and the only mess is blakes house. Aside from that the WF just got stomped, that's why she has to frame them in the first place imo

-4†
drazticoPrimal Hiatus Buster•

Even though the WF got stomped, guards did get killed, and the mere fact the WF even attacked at all (despite not succeeding) was still something for Blake to legitametly call them out on.

29
CluelessAtol•

I don’t think this was necessarily intended (she needed light or she wouldn’t have been able to fight Illia) but I do think she took advantage of the fact that they forced her to do it.

28
devilkingx2OP•

Fair enough. That's good and i didn't think of it that way. You're probably right but it's still very clever of her

5
DarkPhoenix142Calm down son it's just a drawing•

but

there were light switches tho.

just turn the lights back on.

1
LameJames1618Ozpin's a Dumbass•

What? Why would she need light to fight Ilia? Faunus have night vision, and Ilia turning her skin black doesn't negate the fact that the walls in the house are yellow. She stands out if you can see in the dark.

-1
JauneBlackSmudge•
26
Mrfipp•

That's it, that's the image, along with the one where Blake's head is photoshopped onto the picture of the one with the firefighter, is what made that whole scene lose any seriousness with me.

8
Sirshrugsalot13bi the way•

I really wanna see Blake on the firefighter pic, d'you know where I could find that?

4
Mrfipp•
9
Sirshrugsalot13bi the way•

That's fuckign amazing I love it

7
devilkingx2OP•

Damn that's good I love it XD

3
Fuzunga•

Somebody asked about favorite moments at RTX and Arryn Said "I liked it when Blake burned her house down and blamed it on everyone else" and that cracked me up because I didn't even think about it.

17
angster_krisShe was meant to be a dual-wielder•

It was neither stupid nor clever. Like, I believe neither.

Animators just wanted to test some new lighting. There is no need to get too deep into it, IMO.

12
devilkingx2OP•

I dunno it was a really major and pivotal part of the volume, one of the only 5 or 6 episodes were anything happens, one of the only scenes that affected the plot at all, I'd say it was supposed to be something and the details are surely worth looking into

6
angster_krisShe was meant to be a dual-wielder•

Blake is not some kind of schemer. I doubt she could be planning that many steps. Not to mention that she still didn't know about the fate of her mother when she put the house on fire. Kali could be dead - like, even Ghira and Sun could be dead (at least, there was a possibility). So she just could not know that all this is going to work.

I guess, it was a combat-wise move at best. It still irks me that Ilia's weapon seemed to be glowing in a whip form (so she could not make a sneak attack from distance), and for fighting face-to-face Blake didn't even need that light.

IDK, that scene was kinda weird for me, but as far as there were even more other weird scenes in V5 I just ended being ok with it.

6
drazticoPrimal Hiatus Buster•

I think ilia's whip only glowed when she did the electric thing, so she might have had that feature turned off when she was in camouflage.

6
angster_krisShe was meant to be a dual-wielder•

Like, I get the idea, but it seemed to me that the whip without an electricity wasn't shown even once... I guess, I have to rewatch it. Some day...

1
Hyakkihei1•

I'm still wondering why she didn't just switch the lights on again. I guess this master plan works.

11
devilkingx2OP•

Ilia could just turn them off again so that wouldn't get them anywhere

12
YellowLantern15419•

Plus, Ilia’s camouflage negated the natural advantage of Faunus’ night vision. Blake didn’t want to fight while she was at a disadvantage knowing that she could be covering the switch.

She actually did do something that would be a smart (but admittedly a bit destructive) to get a camouflaged foe out of their element. If they are bending in with the light or dark create a second source of it so that their camouflage could be exposed.

13
chaos_vulpixCeltic's Five | Preparing for the upcoming Ship Survivor•

proceeds to imagine Blake & Ilia on opposite sides of the room turning the lights on & off

10
RWYned5evertoo little too late•

Some sort of "outtakes" bonus feature with stuff like this would actually get me to buy the Blu-Ray.

5
ScottPilgrim2013Dr. Merlot's Number 1 fan•

That's exactly what I was thinking of too! And then one of them pretends to flick the switch/mimics the noise of the switch and catches the other off guard.

5

It wasn't the house burning down, it was the attack as a whole.

The white fang attacked Faunus. Period.

It's not like Blake thought, " I'll burn down the house to gain sympathy during my speech that I'm totally planning on making right after I definitely survive this assault."

8
devilkingx2OP•

I don't know why she'd be thinking anything else unless adam showed up personally lol

-3
chaos_vulpixCeltic's Five | Preparing for the upcoming Ship Survivor•

Blake plays 4D Chess

7
PNDLivewire•

I mean...I don't think the house was like burnt down to the ground outside of massive damage to the living room. Like...I thought the fire department or whatever got there at the end part of the episode, lol.

Either way, it was amusingly clever even if it was pretty clear the "Faunus did this" thing was referring to the senseless violence that just took place more than the property damage.

6
Bionicman76•

“Humans didn’t do this, Faunus did” r/technically the truth

5
RandomName3064#GiveTyrianMoreScreenTime•

surpassing even the greats like Vegeta.

now hold on just a minute, here....

5
CombatReadyRubyNeo for end game boss | Acolyte of NPL•

It was clear they were trying to have Blake say some really insightful shit with the whole "We did this" thing, but it ended up kinda stupid because she was the one who caught it on fire. I highly doubt this was something they thought of when making the scene.

4†

As far as the White Fang goes, it wasn't meant to make sense. Adam isn't the most rational when it comes to Blake. It's hard to say, if forced to choose, whether he would prefer to advance the Faunus cause or make Blake suffer. The attack certainly wasn't meant to gain support for Adam's cause.

3
devilkingx2OP•

Oh yeah I know that they retconned/flanderized adam into a useless dumbass, i was just surprised that they acknowledged it by having the characters cleverly take advantage as opposed to having the story/narrative pretend that it made any sense at all

4