Atheism Subreddit "Censorship"

user db2 has been down my (*edit: by 'my', I guess I mean "reddit's") throat about atheism dropping off the default subreddit list, and my name has been dropped a few times after some posts I made highlighting some traffic data, so I wanted to clear things up.

From the traffic data, and what the admins have told me, AskReddit was introduced back into the default list after having dropped out for a few weeks, based entirely on how much activity was in that subreddit.

Having seen the 'evidence' that others have brought up, showing an exclusion part of the code, and the apparent omission of the subreddit in the 'hot subreddits' list, I am left ambivalent about what is going on.

Regardless about whether or not the subreddit was manually excluded from the default list, there is a point that I want to make. I haven't heard a single complaint in any other subreddit in my time here on reddit about whether or not a subreddit is in the default list. Atheism, atheism, atheism. The meta political bitching and complaining is so god damn annoying. Don't take my opinion as a superior--mods are just janitors--I get rid of spam... but I'm still kind of amazed that somebody hasn't gone out and made a clone just for atheism, based on popular negative opinion about this subreddit from theists and atheists alike.

Here's my suggestion: spend a lot of your time in this subreddit for the next two weeks or so. Go out and find content to submit. Make lots of comments. Be very active. I want to see those traffic stats skyrocket. If it doesn't make it back into the default list, go and make a site. You can have Dawkin's penis as a logo, and all will be merry.

Posted Aug 26, 2009, 4:07 PM UTC · edited

79103
BadDecisionDino•

Thanks for creating an entire new submission just to feature your own vitriolic whining, while containing no relevant content of its own. If you're left ambivalent about the evidence, what grounds do you have to bitch about our questioning of the evidence, other than your distaste for the actual content of the subreddit? Given that all your points revolve around this ridiculous circular logic, I'm not surprised...

Your reaction to our call for transparency about how r/Atheism dropped off the front page is "Well no one has ever complained about a subreddit dropping off the front page before!" Of course not! That's the point! Until now, it was pretty damn transparent how subreddits dropped off.

You keep insist that our drop in traffic is why we dropped off the front page, even though we've presented enough evidence to make you at least "ambivalent" about the claim that in fact, our drop in traffic is a result of our dropping off the front page. Why the hell do you keep telling us to worry about traffic, if you have no conclusive evidence about what's going on? I mean, you're basically telling the Atheism subreddit, of all communities, to take the site's algorithm on faith, in spite of the facts? Heh...

Can't provide answers? Ok! Then stop putting yourself in the position to answer our questions. You don't know! That's the fact of the matter, you don't really know what's going on. We're not gonna spite you for it, but if you don't know, then you ought to be at least curious, rather than dismissive.

All right, I'll admit a few people made the mistake of thinking you knew something more than we did, but you don't, so this conversation isn't with you any more, it's with the admins. From now on, when we address a complaint to "Reddit" in general, realize that very few people are actually directing it to you. You don't need to make yourself a target. See, this is what we were worried about when they gave you guys those special little tags...

Feel free to have negative opinions about r/Atheism - we're used to it. But let's stop trying to crowbar the hate into a discussion on the mechanics of the site, as if it's some kind of fitting "justification" for why we got bumped down. The only possible justification would be the numbers. Otherwise, Reddit has begun moderating from a non-democratic perspective. If it has, then fine. It's owned by a corporation, and they have the right to do that. But if so, then we have the right to know.

62
tuberAtheist•

Disclosure: MMM is not neutral on this topic (screencap from r/modtalk, a non-public subreddit)

Update: MMM is banning discussion of this topic (from this thread)

65
borg42•

Why is MMM moderator of this subredit when he doesn't like it? I am sure there are people who can sympathize with the crowd in r/atheism and would have time to delete spam.

25
tuberMODAtheist•

He asked me for mod status and it is my habit to grant such requests. I don't think there should be mods at all, but that's not how things have turned out.

12
daonlyfreez•

I think it's more than inappropriate for someone who is obviously biased against the subreddit, to mod it. Maybe he could mod another subreddit instead.

18
[deleted]•

He likes the reddit. He doesn't like the assholes.

-5
crackduck•

The assholes don't like your comment.

7
[deleted]•

You should submit that as a topic all it's own.

19
tuberAtheist•

You can if you want. I just want to find a new site. It's over.

11
n0t_5hure•

let us know if you find somewhere good.

14
[deleted]•

We'll believe that when your profile page comes up 404.

4
MercurialMadnessManOP•

My opinion of the content of this subreddit has no influence on my moderating conduct, and my contribution of both traffic statistics and admin contact certainly added value to the discussions presented. I feel that I have contributed a level of transparency that I wish more moderators would happily provide in such a situation as this.

And, to be honest, the 'private' in 'private subreddit' is something I wish you would respect.

-24
TheCid•

Then why not remove him from the moderator list for r/atheism so he can't continue banning stuff, as well as unbanning those posts?

11
tuberAtheist•

He can do it himself if he wants, or skeen might do it if enough of you asked for it, but I won't do it. I am not a disinterested party in this discussion, and wielding moderator power would be, in my opinion, unethical.

7
MercurialMadnessManOP•

In terms of the banned comment, it was just the one. I'm not saying that "banning one thing is okay" but I didn't know where the user found the post, and again, I firmly believe that posting in the private sphere is giving some trust to the people around you that they will keep it private.

The comment that I made in Modtalk was a light-hearted joke, and I didn't post it in the hopes of it being seen by hundreds or thousands of people.

-14
n0t_5hure•

i would like to see MMM address this comment.

9
TheCid•

How the hell is fewer uniques a good thing?

7
col381Atheist•

His own screenshot seems to indicate this as well...

3
[deleted]•

Why exactly is MMM getting accused of banning discussion of the topic? I see that in your 2nd link the accusation was made, but that's not really proof. The reddit programmers have auto-spam-filters that do a lot of hiding stuff that isn't spam; I'm just curious how it was concluded that MMM was behind that?

2
tuberAtheist•

When you moderate a reddit, reports are highlighted in beige(?) and banned comments are highlighted red. If it says [banned] after the comment, then the spam filter did the banning. If it says [banned by User123], then User123 did the banning.

3
[deleted]•

Ah, I didn't realize that, thank you. But then who originally posted that image? One of the other mods? I just thought it had been edited by the person who made the image.

I really hate trying to catch up on these things at the end of the day; the timeline of all of this is so confusing right now. And r/atheism is back on the front page already anyways.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
aurisor•

You can have Dawkin's penis as a logo, and all will be merry.

This is not, in my opinion, a constructive contribution to this discussion. Moderators ought to be raising the level of discourse, not lowering it.

Furthermore, a bit of sensitivity to the situation would be appreciated. Slighting people in response to a (perhaps perceived) slight is always unwise.

30
n0t_5hure•

yes, it is a bit insulting having your subreddit's moderator make a disparaging remark trivializing user concerns.

6
MercurialMadnessManOP•

I agree and I apologize for the remark

It was a light-hearted joke, and I thought of it as an alternative to having dawkin's face as the logo, or something similar, which would also 'work' to make the place and reddit distinct.

0
[deleted]•

Not exactly sure why you're downvoted for an apology...

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Cookie•

So, if somebody in this forum makes a comment which is mocking and insulting towards religions or the religious, it all goes to prove that the community is worthless. The flood of responses to such comments, and the constant cries of circlejerk, from people who lose nothing by leaving this community if they feel it has no value, are an entirely proportionate and reasonable response.

Whereas if somebody makes a comment which is mocking and insulting towards atheism and atheists, and one person suggests politely that it is not helpful, this proves that the community has no sense of humour and is worthless.

I would suggest that the substance of your position is that you think this community is worthless, and that the things you give as reasons for this in each of your individual comments are simply whatever you can find just then with which to make this claim. I would suggest that you would lose nothing by unsubscribing from this subreddit, and that the community would gain significantly if you took such an action.

7
Gravity13•

Nobody here is saying to stop mocking religions.

4
ZeaLitY•

We just can't do so in a persuasive way that attracts popularity, or it's a "circle jerk", eh?

2
db2•

Down your throat? Hardly! I called you on posting an irrelevant image of graphs, but at no point was I even so much as impolite. See for yourselves.

24
Nougat•

Having seen the 'evidence' that others have brought up, showing an exclusion part of the code, and the apparent omission of the subreddit in the 'hot subreddits' list, I am left ambivalent about what is going on.

I'm frankly interested to hear the reason that r/atheism doesn't show up in the top list regardless of whether I subscribe here or contribute here, or am an atheist (all of which I do/am, for the record).

If it was the r/Creationist subreddit in the same position, I would be equally as interested.

Here's my suggestion: spend a lot of your time in this subreddit for the next two weeks or so. Go out and find content to submit. Make lots of comments. Be very active. I want to see those traffic stats skyrocket. If it doesn't make it back into the default list, go and make a site. You can have Dawkin's penis as a logo, and all will be merry.

No one should have to do this, because r/atheism appears to already be meeting the criteria for appearing in the default list, based on its placement in other indexes.

What I must not understand is that there must be a different set of criteria for appearing in the default list than there is for appearing in those other indexes. "Not porn" is probably a criteria, which would explain why NSFW and gonewild aren't there, and I think that's a fair one. All I personally want is an understanding of the criteria which allow a subreddit, r/atheism in this case, to appear high in popularity indexes, but not appear on the default list.

19
Wickedwiener•

How to calm the crowd: Let us read an official statement why r/atheism doesn't show up on the frontpage "subreddit-bar", whether on position 8,10 or 13, doesn't matter right now. That's all. Thanks!

16
daonlyfreez•

I've read most threads on this subject, and most of your replies.

Please answer this simple question:

Why is atheism in the exclusion list?

The meta political bitching and complaining is so god damn annoying

You are trying to shift the "blame". It is not you who decides what content is "worth it" or not. That is not how Reddit works. Your job is it to explain to us why atheism is excluded from the front page. You are trying to deflect with your "suggestions".

It's about complaints from advertisers, isn't it? Or not even that (yet), maybe management is simply scared they might lose revenue in the future if atheism postings pop up on the front page regularly.

You are turning into Digg.

12
Rhode•

Your job is it to ...

You are turning into Digg.

He's a mod, not an admin. He doesn't work here. He is a user, just like you. What part of that don't you get?

4
MercurialMadnessManOP•

That is not how Reddit works. Your job is it to explain to us why atheism is excluded from the front page.

Not having access to admin data, it becomes an initiative rather than a 'job'.

-4
daonlyfreez•

Ok, so you don't know.

That's fine, but don't expect anything else than what you got if you then still go posting "clarity".

We'll see, let's suppose it was a mistake that will be swiftly repaired.

5
redfishvanish•

Can you shorten and clarify this response, please? It appears that your answer is "Atheism might not be in the exclusion list." In response, I ask why might atheism be in the exclusion list.

2
MercurialMadnessManOP•

It appears that your answer is "Atheism might not be in the exclusion list."

Indeed.

why might atheism be in the exclusion list?

depends on what you mean by this. Are you asking for the mechanics/evidence to support the possibility, or are you asking why the admins would do that?

-5
[deleted]•

Why is atheism in the exclusion list?

Because you people are dicks.

-13
ZeaLitY•

Yeah? And the Jew mutilating a baby eight days after birth isn't; the evangelical telling wives to be submissive to husbands isn't; the Islamic imam commanding women to wear veils and burkas isn't; the Mormon helping to ban civil marriage rights for gays isn't; the Hindu rationalizing abject poverty in Indian society through the caste system isn't; the Buddhist condemning human nature and keeping women out of the clergy isn't; the Catholic supporting abstinence programs that spread disease and pregnancies isn't a dick?

Atheists, if anything, are anti-dicks. I didn't even bring up the more savage examples of routine religious acts, such as homicide and rape.

8
Grinyarg•

If you compare subreddit ranking to the order of the top bar, you can clearly see that atheism is missing from the latter. It is therefore not based on content. From the code we've seen, there are two flags which affect this list, one is for adult content, and one is specifically to stop a subreddit showing up. Can you do the rest of the figuring out now?

11
MercurialMadnessManOP•

I'm not taking either side at this point. It could have been manually altered. It could have been a traffic change that automatically changed the list. It could be a bug. That's not something that you or me can determine.

-7
[deleted]•

You clearly are, though.

12
MercurialMadnessManOP•

Am I? Please reference this using a post of mine from today. Thank you.

-11
[deleted]•

I would gladly redirect you to the original post of this thread, but you can just hit ctrl + home

9
snacktivity•
4
Brian•

This post does definitely seem to be weighting one side more than the other. For instance:

Having seen the 'evidence' ... the apparent omission

Quotes around evidence (and "censorship" for that matter) - why? And why the "apparent" - it definitely is omitted. There are no similar provisos on your statements on what you'd been told, or your traffic data information.

I haven't heard a single complaint in any other subreddit in my time here on reddit about whether or not a subreddit is in the default list.

Go out and find content to submit. Make lots of comments.

You give an complaint that's only relevant if it is traffic based, and a solution that will only work if this is the case. You make no such statements about the deliberate exclusion possibility.

Now possibly this is unintentional, but as it stands this post is clearly weighting one side a lot more than the other.

3
[deleted]•

You can have Dawkin's penis as a logo, and all will be merry.

I want you to know that this is neither funny nor endearing.

10
MercurialMadnessManOP•

Noted.

2
dearsomething•

I want you to know that I didn't mind. Nor did I really care.

6
[deleted]•

But you have to admit that it's pretty amusing.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Dude, everyday for the last month, there has been a post with Dawkins' name on it on the front page of r/atheism.

So what? Is that supposed to be a crime or something? He's a very popular author, a very bright guy, and the most famous atheist proponent their is. Go to the NBA reddit and mock people for making a lot of Kobe posts. That would be hilarious! And endearing!

3
Gravity13•

Except they'll laugh when you suggest putting Kobe's dick as their icon.

3
[deleted]•

Who wouldn't, only 14 year olds are allowed to see it.

5
[deleted]•

I don't know whether you are or not, but this post makes you sound like a twat.

10
n0t_5hure•

Having seen the 'evidence' that others have brought up, showing an exclusion part of the code, and the apparent omission of the subreddit in the 'hot subreddits' list, I am left ambivalent about what is going on.

seems pretty clear - r/atheism is being hidden in the corner. is there anyone you can ask to confirm/deny this? yesterday you came out with data that was intended to put this to rest. the censorship issue still festers. i would like an "official" response from the powers that be.

8
infinite•

I PMed spez about this yesterday, no response yet.

7
n0t_5hure•

no response yet.

i don't know that you'll get one. my guess is that either a sponsor (or potential sponsor) complained, or there was concern by management that this would happen, given all the posts whining about r/atheism being a default subreddit.

i recognize that conde nast has been pushing for $$$ from reddit lately ("sponsored" links, more ads), and don't begrudge their efforts, but when your core audience rails against corporate interests and censorship, don't be surprised that they get pissed off when censored.

3
Rhode•

Why do you think you're entitled to an explanation? What makes you think you deserve one?

-7
neilplatform1•

Common courtesy?

4
Rhode•

That's bullshit, we're dealing with private property. If you were to yell at some kids to get off your lawn, you wouldn't feel the need to provide justification.

Additionally, you just downmodded me even though my comment contributes to the discussion, a clear violation of reddiquette and a wee bit discourteous to boot.

0
palparepa•

Well, a simple "I don't like you" would suffice as an explanation.

1
neilplatform1•

I don't feel it does contribute.

0
[deleted]•

Revenue generated by our mere presence?

I mean, fuck you

-1
Rhode•

You think that puts you on the Board of Trustees or something? lol, that's ridiculous.

-1
[deleted]•

No, this entire situation is what's ridiculous. Questioning it is not. Calling the question (in light of evidence supporting the reasons for questioning) ridiculous is ridiculous. You are ridiculous. And also, fuck you.

1
n0t_5hure•

considering that they appear to be censoring a minority, i would think many would like an explanation.

-1
Rhode•

Atheists are a minority on reddit? News to me....

2
n0t_5hure•

in the real world, atheists are a minority.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
dearsomething•

Go make an r/atheism_uncensored, be the mod, that fixes part of your problem.

2
redfishvanish•

Regardless about whether or not the subreddit was manually excluded from the default list

In reading your responses, I am led to conclude that you do not know whether r/atheism was or was not excluded - manually or otherwise. We all have a regard for the facts of the matter.

3
MercurialMadnessManOP•

Indeed, I don't believe the evidence is strong enough on either front to either agree or disagree that censorship was involved.

-4
[deleted]•

Whaaaaaaaat?

You mean the site admin saying that r/atheism was manually excluded from the front page is not strong enough evidence that censorship was involved?

edit: http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/9efxf/an_explanation_of_why_the_atheism_reddit_does_not/

1
MercurialMadnessManOP•

Where did a site admin say this? Please link to it here.

2
MercurialMadnessManOP•

I see it now, nevermind. Interesting.

1
antiproton•

This is what we can expect from Reddit mods? To be treated like petulant children demanding candy?

Your little anecdote about other reddits was particularly helpful.

3
Brian•

Having seen the 'evidence' that others have brought up, showing an exclusion part of the code, and the apparent omission of the subreddit in the 'hot subreddits' list, I am left ambivalent about what is going on.

Looking at the evidence presented, I think you're doing a grave disservice by using scare quotes around 'evidence' and 'censorship' - that's making a rather stronger statement than "ambivalent". I initially thought the same - that this was overreacting to a traffic blip, but this theory is completely insufficient to explain dropping not just from the top 10, but from all 50 links on the default page. That shifts the preponderance of evidence away from traffic theories strongly into the realm of manual intervention - remaining ambivalent about this and giving solutions that will not affect the issue given the cause seems simply like a defensive refusal to change your mind given sufficient evidence. The most generous interpretation I can think of is a mistake being made (accidentally getting an exclude flag somehow applied), but the most likely by far does seem to be deliberate exclusion.

Now personally I'd rather the subreddit wasn't on the default links - given the argument sparking nature, it leads to something of a cycle of perceived attack leading to an insular siege mentality in some posters, raising the asshole quotient and resulting in a viscious spiral. (In fact, I think those links would be better put to use highlighting unpopular reddits than reinforcing the current norms). Despite this, this move I find very infuriating. The result is not the issue - the handling of such censorship - silently making such a decision without public notice or discussion is.

I haven't heard a single complaint in any other subreddit

Has another subreddit been manually censored like this? I for one would also be bitching about wielding of such editorial authority on any subreddit, and I doubt that that's something unique to atheists. The bitching is not about "not being on the default list". It's about heavy handed editorial intervention preventing a certain subject being on the default list.

3
[deleted]•

I want to take the time to thank db2 for initially pointing this shit out to everyone. db2 is my hero. Long live db2.

Make [db2 moderator of r/Atheism](http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/9egz8/make_db2_moderator_of_ratheism/).

This guy didn't deserve the position: MercurialMadnessMan

2
cazbot•

"If it doesn't make it back into the default list"

I don't understand how it could possibly make it back to the default list if it is being manually coded out of that list?

1
coogan607•

Man, are you in the wrong job.

1
unbibium•

MODS=GODS.

0
grsmurf•

"You can have Dawkin's penis as a logo, and all will be merry."

LOL ROFFL WMP !!!

-10