Raiders; experienced and inexperienced; how difficult do you find raids?

[Question]

This might seem like a bit of a stupid question but one thing I've wanted to ask to many is how difficult they find raids.

To me, a very inexperienced person still training, and likely to many others they seem extremely difficult, barring maybe WvW or PvP due to the nature of those modes, with almost no margin for error, especially compared to Fractals and their CMs, which are much more forgiving and much more doable (Arkk CM is just Vale Guardian but easier after all).

But how difficult do you find them?

Posted Sep 11, 2018, 11:05 AM UTC

050
Xhundor•

I would really not agree with Arkk in CM being easier than Vale guardian, you have to be a lot more aware of whats going on constantly.
If you are doing overheal strat on VG and the druids are on top of their game for example the only mechanic a DPS really needs to be aware of are the blue fields while on Arkk there are constantly mechanics going on. On experienced groups with lot of DPS it is not noticeable as much anymore because a lot of mechanics are outright skipped but when you are trying to learn that boss with a full group from scratch it can be really hard tbh.
That aside i think raids are all about class and mechanic knowledge not so much about being able to react fast which makes them differ from fractal CMs in a certain way even tho you will be able to predict the bosses attacks there too after a certain amount of runs.

13
IvaliaGuild Wars•

Raid mechanics are usually more predictable and fairly easy to do if you know how to do them, but have a little more severe consequences if you fail them

2
Photoloss•

Only the newer raids. VG basically requires 3-5 people to know what they're doing and literally not a single mechanic can kill you outright. Even on Matthias most the the mechanics are pretty forgiving on their own (except for sacrifice) but things spiral out of control very quickly. Compare that to Cairn who is pretty much designed to knock you off the platform or W5 where getting hit by pretty much anything will kill you.

Arkk CM is somewhere in the middle having a lot of mechanics of which only a few are truly dangerous on their own. MAMA, Ensolyss, Skorvald and Artsariiv are almost as predictable and far more punishing than the easiest raid encounters (compare VG green to Nightmare bubble shield)

3
LucianTheAngelic•

You lost me at "Arkk CM is just Vale Guardian but easier afterall"

11
TryToBeNormalOPInternally, and sometimes externally, screaming•

On Arkk you get Aegis on a 8 second cooldown and you have mistlock singularities, and in general you can resurrect defeated players. You don't have any of that on VG, or any raid boss really.

-6
CeraunosProtect the smile!•

You have two healers full time healing you.

4
TryToBeNormalOPInternally, and sometimes externally, screaming•

Unless you're going for super fast and with very experienced people, you also have a Druid alongside the aforementioned Aegis

0†
Fractal_Hype•

Which is completely irrelevant to a beginner experience.

2
Spyritdragon•

The thing with Arkk is that it is ridiculously more punishing. You dont get the unstable spirit down in time, TPK. You miss an explodey dome, TPK. You don't get a glowy orb to its pillar, TPK. You fail a CC, TPK. And on top of all that, the amount of damage you yourself take or have to dodge is much more intense. VGinterrupts you for greens if you're doing them, about half a second for a woefully overtelegraphed blue, and during the final phases a bit of running. Arkk is a constant dodging of tonnes of AOEs that he throws at you again and again and again, needing significantly more focus to keep your health up and DPS going.

3
TryToBeNormalOPInternally, and sometimes externally, screaming•

VG puts out way more damage than Arkk does especially with no greens, every attack of Arkk's that does meaningful damage is very telegraphed. Meanwhile VG pretty much passively puts out lots of damage.

-1
Spyritdragon•

Not really, imo. If you do your greens properly (no greens is a meta/speed learning strat for the advanced if you ask me), don't stand in front of it and you keep the seekers out, it's possible to take very little damage at all from VG beyond its pulse, with relative ease. Meaning to say, the amount of your focus it takes to avoid VGs damage is quite low. Green damage - low if greens done properly. Blue damage - loud, obvious noise. Seekers - someone's job to keep them out. CC - very short moments. VG itself - don't stand in front of it, unless you're the tank, in which case... Yes of course you take damage/have to immune damage. The only difference is that it's somewhat less telegraphed, and that VG has a constant pulse you'll need some healing from. But with the druid doing his job, you won't even notice that unless you're far out of position. VGs damage is quite easy to avoid, whereas for Arkk you genuinely need to be quite nimble on your feet to not get caught by something very heavy every now and again.

2
LucianTheAngelic•

The amount of mechanics and personal responsibility on Ark is considerably higher than VG. The ability for one person to fuck something up and ruin the entire Arkk run is also higher. The overlap of orbs + anomaly + green circle is already more involved than the majority of VG's mechanics, and that's really only touching the surface. VG is really faceroll in comparison, honestly, and can be made considerably easier just by adding a 2nd or 3rd healer to the group, whereas you don't really have the option to do that for Arkk and even if you could it wouldn't mitigate the fact that a single person can still ruin the run regardless of healing output.

2
Cuddles_Galore•

I don't think there is any difficulty in the raid content itself. The biggest difficulty to me is in our attitude towards raids, "getting into raiding is hard", "its hard to find a static", "getting kills can take forever", "its really hard to find good people to play with", "the meta is crap and I refuse to play with meta freaks".

​

I see so many people who waste more of their life pondering raiding and little to no time actually doing it. I promise that if you try, each time you try it will become easier until one day you'll be surprised that it ever took you more than a few hours to get a full w1-5 clear done.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
yayuuu•

Umm, for me raids are mostly easier than Arkk CM. There are some bosses who are harder (Dhuum, Mathias, not sure if Sabetha or Xera if you have low dps squad), but most of them are easier, especially if you skip mechanics (no-green VG, no-updraft Gorseval, instacap escort, etc). For me they are just DPSfest, but maybe I just did them too many times...

Back to main question: Overall I think raids are not easy, especially for starting players. I have been playing few games before and in all of them raids were easier (but more gear-oriented). I personally like this kind of difficulty, but it can be frustrating if you see people failing the same mechanics over and over again. Having a reliable (not neccessarily top DPS) group helps a lot (which I don't have at the moment).

5
poosheckMobility Fractal Potion is ruining my rotation.•

Right now the balance is in the state where raids are extremely easy to go complete. With PoF release and recent changes we got a lot of options to secure safe clear.

Especially support roles are so OTT with everything now you can carry entire squad with heal necro or firebrand that knows what to do.

Clearing is easy. Clearing with style is not.

5
PhoenixOfTheFirePyromancer Snarff•

Even clearing with unsafe compositions is too easy. Due to the lack of DPS checks, DPS players don't even have to perform well at all.

2
poosheckMobility Fractal Potion is ruining my rotation.•

That is correct. Just go with 10 hammer dragonhunters and you can clear most of the bosses

2
PhoenixOfTheFirePyromancer Snarff•

Yup. It won't be fun for most people, but it can be done.

1
derd4100making friends the improper way•

finding them is easy, staying is the hard part

3
NanaItaliaNyyyyoooooommmmmm•

If you start with 10 people who never raided, still have to work on rotations and are overwhelmed by mechanics, it is difficult and requires some training. But once you got used to your class and roll and also got to know the boss mechanics raids are quite easy.

Also, if you start with a group where some players have already experience and can stabilize the group, inexperienced players can first focus on mechanics and get better at their rotations over time. This way getting into raids is quite easy.

In general I think most raid encounters (exept those with instant-wipe-mechanics) are more forgiving then fractals 99CM. Also I find 100CM more difficult then most raid bosses.

3
TryToBeNormalOPInternally, and sometimes externally, screaming•

In general I think most raid encounters (exept those with instant-wipe-mechanics) are more forgiving then fractals 99CM. Also I find 100CM more difficult then most raid bosses.

This part I have to massively disagree with. Mistlock Singularities make CMs way more forgiving, on top of CMs being Fractals so by they're very design they're not as difficult, and in raids it doesn't really matter on the boss, one person dead is 10% gone immediately and I don't see how that doesn't quickly snowball into a wipe.

-4
NanaItaliaNyyyyoooooommmmmm•

One dead person in raids is easy to carry in most encounters. We often finish matthis with only 5 or 4 man standing, because others die to mechanics.

While in fractals CM one dead player means 20% gone, so carrying one dead is much harder on the group.

2
TryToBeNormalOPInternally, and sometimes externally, screaming•

In Fractals you can still resurrect the dead, it's not too difficult to take some time to resurrect a person at Arkk for example.

1
NanaItaliaNyyyyoooooommmmmm•

So your point is basicly, that the possibility to ressurect dead players makes fractals 100CM easier then raids?

1
HxhFlint•

Essentially both are really easy if you play with ppl who know the mechanics and know how to do DMG. I'm doing cms+t4 with my static every day so imo it's easy on raids when you are unlucky with pugs you can wipe pretty often. So it all depends on who you play with

2
Peechez•

Dude give this up. We went through this 2 weeks ago and you've been harping on it forever. So many people have given you completely valid points. Let it go

2
TryToBeNormalOPInternally, and sometimes externally, screaming•

I admit defeat and let it go, but I think it is variable on role.

1
Hajiishere•

I don't think raids are overly difficult but getting 9 people together who know what they are doing is.

1
Christmaspoo1337•

Amen

1
Photoloss•

The most difficult part definitely is coordinating the group. The vast majority of people have numerous work obligations and other hobbies limiting their available free time. With PuGs you have to re-list after each boss/wing and double-check everything because you can't trust random people to know mechanics, nor do you personally benefit from educating/training them.

Next some mechanics are incredibly frustrating with non-perfect allies. There's nothing you can reliably do to stop people from blowing you up with Sabetha time bombs or Matthias' Well of the Profane. Add the odd technical glitch preventing instakill mechanics from rendering for certain people and you basically feel like you're RNG grinding the wipes. Matthias and Dhuum are very prone to general mechanics mishaps, as are SH wall spawns, Xera leylines and occasionally Sabetha flamewalls.

Then you run into PuGs who don't/cannot/refuse to read your LFG description and I don't mean "anti-elitist I don't need no KP". I mean people joining a listing for a Deimos handkiter as a dps ele with no other spec to swap to.

While not nearly as bad as sometimes claimed there are also quite a few people who join kill runs ("exp", LI, KP, doesn't matter), do not communicate, clearly have no grasp of even the simplest mechanics and immediately cause a wipe when they are picked by RNG (e.g. Sloth aggro). Not knowing mechanics is one thing, maybe you just need a quick refresher on how that specific time bomb can screw the team compared to all the other ones. But openly and visibly failing basic mechanics and still refusing to admit your lack of knowledge, or in rare cases even acting offended when called out, is a no-go.

Then, a long, long, loooooong way down the "difficulty" or "frustration" hitlist, you get a few who would fit the stereotype of "dirty casuals" or "toxic elitists". Both are pretty much the same using different words: they make unsolicited and unhelpful demands expecting the rest of the group to cater to their preferences while refusing to make any personal concessions because "play how you want" or "muh dps". As long as the commander has half a brain this is not much of an issue, "comply or kick" and move on.

Now if you made it this far you might wonder why I ranted about a slew of social and technical issues rather than actual gameplay mechanics. The thing is, in my experience at least, the vast majority of wipes and squads disbanding is caused by these rather than inadequate gameplay.

Matthias, Xera and Dhuum are legitimately difficult and require a decent performance from most/all participants. To a lesser extent Sabetha, Slothasor, Deimos, SH (RNG/AI issues) and for low-dps groups Gorseval pose a decent challenge. Usually W1+Sloth+trio+escort+KC+W4 you can breeze through and even tag in a few guild newbies in exotics if you don't mind a wipe or two. Arkk CM is definitely harder than any of those due to the sheer number of mechanics you have to pay attention to.

1
Aemius•

Raids are more of an orginazitional challenge. Getting 10 people to play certain classes ánd have them do mechanics is the real struggle. The actual mechanics aren't that difficult and requires some practise. I find the most fun in raids to be how to make everything go by super smooth and how to guarantee success.
 
CM has been practised to death by doing it daily, so it get's a lot easier because of that.

1
Spyritdragon•

Raids are honestly quite easy to me. Desmond and Dhuum felt more like a challenge, as do most of the CMs, but most raids are - while definitely not easy - in a place where they pose little significant challenge to anyone but a new player. They're simply so cheeseable and people have enough top end DPS that to get them done you don't need to be very good or skilled, just get used to it. Most of the challenge lies in learning not to mess up the meta strats rather than the completing of the encounter itself. If you use the full length of mechanics and time offered to you, most raids are quite easy for any raider with some experience.

The most difficult part is coordination - and I'm happy that takes some effort. Raiding genuinely feels like a 10 man experience here, not just 10 X 1 person, and I love that.

1
PhoenixOfTheFirePyromancer Snarff•

Raids are too easy IMO. They completely lack proper DPS checks, leading to groups being able to do them in such significantly safer compositions that pretty much all skill gets sucked out of them. Scourge, Tempest and Firebrand can make fights complete jokes. The reason people here say DPS is the easiest role, is because DPS classes never get pushed to their limit in this game. Pushing them to actually perform better and not make raids doable in under half their enrage timers would improve the experience for DPS players by a lot, since they actually have to perform well instead of being there and pressing a few buttons.

Fractal CMs, while on the easy side, are okay in difficulty. They're (IMO) easier than most raids (except for stuff like escort, river and trio or Cairn/MO/Sama), but with RNG instabilities you'll never be able to properly tune them anyway.

1
tffiadBelieve in Pantsu•

70li, i dont consider myself as exp raider, but i consider myself as good pve player generally. i think they are not hard, cant say that they are easy, they just all have weird mechanics which u need to understand how they work. aside of that there is nothing hard.

possibly dhuum maybe hard, because it requires so much stuff to do.

what i consider as hard content is that joko's fractal. fighting amala with poison trail and last laugh and vindicators is really hard. because there is nothing about knowing mechanics of boss, its just all about how good u are at positioning, dpsing and survivng at the same time. and personally i really like to do that fractal with those instabilities, this is really crazy and fun. its muuuuch more funny to wipe not because hadouken killed u or because one jerk didnt step to green circle, but because u player but and failed or positioning/dodge/heal/cc

1
CMothVERY fast holosmithing at incredible hihg speed•

Thing is, the difficulty of raids depends so much on the other 9 people. You can practice and become competent and consistent at them yourself, but if your allies are inexperienced it's still going to be difficult no matter how good you get. On the flip side you can die early in a fight and get carried by a good group.

Certainly being communicative on your VOIP service of choice is a big help and taking the time to explain things gives people a bit more confidence to do the mechanics, which will make it easier for everyone. People can also get into bad habits like clicking skills instead of tapping keys, focusing on maxing their DPS and ignoring all else around them, using skills in a bad order because they haven't thought consciously about their rotation, or they have bad settings like double tap to dodge, camera shake, auto-target, etc.. There are lots of little things you can do to optimise that might make the difference between a successful run and a night of feeling very negative about the whole thing.

1
Fractal_Hype•

I'd say most range to about a 6-7/10. I'd give both Fractal CMs about an 8-9/10 until you're experienced wherein the difficulty drops pretty immensely as you've figured out the major phases and attack telegraphs. I'm a 700 LI raider and around a 120-150 essence CM player -- there's far more going on in the Fractal CMs that would cause high stress beginners to panic and have anxiety attacks than there is in raids -- they're just not a good comparison to use.

If you think they're easier than raids then you're pretty much down the rabbit hole in terms of perspective. The vast majority of the GW2 community isn't clearing T4 Fractals -- that entire level of difficulty, and accountability for learning various phases and attack animations just isn't there in the grand scheme of things. Just because something is easy for you or your friends does not in fact mean that it has a flat learning curve because it compares favorably to most raid bosses. 99/100cm are still very difficult pieces of content for the "average" player.

Something isn't automatically easier simply because it has big telegraphs. Telegraphs mean nothing unless a player is conditioned to react to them, and most players lack the stubbornness to try and fail several times. The parts of the encounters that make them easy come down to repetition and habit -- something a newer player will not have.

1
P3RrYCHSnow Crows [SC]•

Raids have to few personal responsibilities for my taste mostly its just 3 people doing mechanics at max while the rest does dps, fractals offer more fast paced gameplay unless you burst through everything so fast that nothing even gets to attack making it easier again

1
Zman1719•

I would put 99CM and 100CM as harder than some raids and easier than others. They are much harder than MO, Cairn, Samarog etc. but much easier than Dhuum, Xera, Matthias etc. Fractals, in general, I find more frustrating due to the instabilities. Not difficult just annoying/frustrating. I hate doing things that have mechanics that are just annoying or unfun. Raids don't really have any of these type of mechanics save for maybe pushing TD's on Desmina. Raids and Fractal CMs are super easy if you have a group of people that know the boss and know their class. Some raids and fractal CMs are easy in that they have such a low amount of actual mechanics that you can go in not knowing the fight and still have a high chance of success. The CMs have a lot of damaging stuff being thrown at you but very little in terms of actual mechanics while Raids tend to be the opposite. Most raids have very little that damages you but a lot more mechanics that need to be handled.

1
TerribleTransitNice goggles•

Raids are easy.

Finding nine other people who find raids easy is extremely difficult.

1