3.4 Meta Shift Report — Delving into the Meta!

There's a summary at the bottom!

 

 

Introduction

As with my previous entries, this is a fairly relaxed and mathematically flaky look at the meta of Delve and how it compares to Incursion. All data are sourced (with permission) from http://poe.ninja/builds, meaning that there is an unavoidable bias towards builds that are fast and/or preferred by dedicated, experienced players. Unfortunately, unless you're GGG this is the best data set we have. Only the softcore trade leagues are examined (it's all I have time to do with my current methodology).

This is mostly just a bit of fun. I'd avoid trying to read too much into it, but please let me know if there are any mistakes.

 

 

Ascendancy Breakdown

Couple of minor ascendancy changes this patch, but most of the movement here is due to items and skills.

 

AscendancyIncursion %Delve %Diff ↓Fold Change
Pathfinder3.1%11.8%+8.663.75
Ascendant10.3%18.5%+8.151.79
Juggernaut7.8%14.6%+6.821.88
Occultist2.5%7.2%+4.712.86
Guardian2.0%4.2%+2.182.10
Necromancer2.9%3.7%+.811.28
Chieftain0.7%1.5%+.752.04
Berserker0.2%0.2%-.030.82
Assassin0.7%0.7%-.040.95
Raider1.2%1.0%-.260.79
Gladiator1.8%1.5%-.290.84
Trickster2.3%1.9%-.370.84
Inquisitor1.5%0.8%-.640.56
Champion3.4%2.4%-.930.72
Slayer2.4%1.3%-1.090.54
Hierophant5.3%3.3%-1.980.62
Elementalist16.7%11.5%-5.240.69
Deadeye17.5%8.9%-8.620.51
Saboteur17.7%5.1%-12.590.29

 

What's instantly cool to me is that the only three classes that suffered big popularity drops this league are still among the more popular (and arguably stronger) ones. As usual, it's hard to tease out what proportion of a popularity change is due to balancing, herd mentality, or just more people wanting to play other classes. But at a guess: Saboteur got brought into line by the substantial nerfs to traps in 3.4.0; Deadeye lost ground to Ascendant because of Elemental Hit; and Elementalist just got crowded out a bit by other classes.

Meanwhile, our big gainers for the league are Pathfinder (winning on two fronts thanks to new chaos bow skills and the ever-increasing popularity of Poet's Pen Pathfinders at high levels), Ascendant (versatile as ever but hugely buoyed by the popularity of Elemental Hit, which Scion is perfect for thanks to the spidery tree), and Juggernaut (thanks mostly to the popularity of Molten Strike — more on that later). Occultist is also doing quite well, at a guess because of her excellent survivability in the mines. Finally, Guardian also got a popularity boost thanks to new nodes and new skills targeted squarely at him. Unlike Pathfinder (the only other ascendancy to get big changes this league), Guardian is a very niche class, so the boost is correspondingly more modest.

By the way, here's something funny to note. The once-mighty Inquisitor, despite (because of?) barely being changed at all since his release, has slipped far from the peak of the meta and is now steadily approaching Berserker Tier™. Elemental penetration is just too commonplace for him to compete, it seems.

 

 

Primary Damage Skill Rankings — The Top 50 of Delve

We'll focus in a bit on some of the new stuff later, but for now let's have a look at the overall rankings. "Rank" here is based on popularity alone, i.e. rank 1 means the skill used by the largest number of characters. This is also using poe.ninja's criterion of only counting 5- and 6-linked skills, which is imperfect but about as good as you can feasibly get. Note that this does include links granted by items.

 

SkillIncursion RankDelve Rank ↑Rank Change
Blade Vortex21+1
Molten Strike92+7
Elemental Hit330
Frenzy104+6
Tornado Shot45-1
Arc16-5
Righteous Fire87+1
Toxic RainN/A8New
Barrage59-4
Reave1410+4
Scorching Ray1211+1
Consecrated PathN/A12New
Herald of AgonyN/A13New
Caustic Arrow7614+62
Blade Flurry1715+2
Glacial Cascade1516-1
Cyclone1317-4
Scourge ArrowN/A18New
Raise Spectre1819-1
Double Strike1120-9
Raise Zombie2521+4
Rain of Arrows22220
Herald of Ice2023-3
Ancestral Warchief2124-3
Power Siphon2725+2
Summon Flame Golem2426-2
Lightning Spire Trap727-20
Summon Skeleton1928-9
Summon Ice Golem7629+47
Shield Charge2630-4
Orb of Storms2931-2
Kinetic Blast632-26
Dominating BlowUnranked33+108
Blight3134-3
Spectral Throw3235-3
Sunder1636-20
Death Aura4037+3
Spark4938+11
Frost Blades3639-3
Leap Slam4339+4
Lightning Arrow2339-16
Assassin's Mark4742+5
Herald of PurityN/A43New
Ball Lightning3344-11
Freezing Pulse45450
Whirling Blades5645+11
Herald of Thunder4147-6
Molten Burst3747-10
SmiteN/A49New
Lacerate3750-13

 

Almost all of the changes here seem to be a direct result of buffs and nerfs, and therefore pretty easy to follow. Traps got nerfed, so Arc and Lightning Spire Trap dropped a bit. Caustic Arrow and Dominating Blow got huge buffs, so they're showing up again. Kinetic Blast got hammered hard by nerfs and has really dropped off. And so on and so on. The two standouts IMO are the rise of Ice Golem — partly due to Primordial Chain, but also just because enterprising build makers discovered that they weren't as crap as everyone thought — and Molten Strike rising to almost the top spot on the ladder, which I can only guess is mostly because it's a perfect fit for tanky builds that can survive well in the mines. I'm really not sure on this one though, so please tell me if I've missed something major (and no, it can't be accounted for solely by the Nebuloch buff).

Finally, Frenzy (i.e. Poet's Pen) continues to rise. The Poet's Pen archetype has really hit the big-time this league, leading to an ever-growing chorus of "NEEEEERRRRRF". We'll have to see whether GGG agree!

 

 

Skill Diversity by Ascendancy

 

Ascendancy ↓Number of Skills >1% Usage% Usage of Most Popular SkillMost Popular Skill…vs in Incursion
Ascendant1245.9Elemental HitElemental Hit
Assassin1520.9Molten StrikeHerald of Thunder
Berserker1120.0Ancestral WarchiefSunder
Champion1429.8Double StrikeDouble Strike
Chieftain848.5Blade VortexCyclone
Deadeye950.8Tornado ShotTornado Shot
Elementalist1049.5Blade VortexBlade Vortex
Gladiator1524.9Herald of AgonySunder
Guardian1055.3Righteous FireScorching Ray
Hierophant839.7ArcArc
Inquisitor1627.2Molten StrikeMolten Strike
Juggernaut940.2Molten StrikeRighteous Fire
Necromancer735.0Raise SpectreRaise Spectre
Occultist1533.4Blade VortexBlade Vortex
Pathfinder1144.8FrenzyFrenzy
Raider2018.1Tornado ShotBarrage
Saboteur552.9ArcArc
Slayer1430.5CycloneCyclone
Trickster837.0Toxic RainFrenzy

 

This has mostly stayed static. The historically versatile Ascendant has been knocked off her perch a bit, but that's more a quirk of the reporting rather than anything real. The huge percentage of Ascendants now using Elemental Hit means that there can't be as many skills left being used by >1% of Ascendants. The only other thing I'll point out here is that the eternally unpopular Gladiator's most common build is now...a summoner. Herald of Agony's peculiar scaling allows you to pretty much ignore damage on your tree and gear, which dovetails very well with the high-investment high-reward strategy of maxing out your block chance to create a build that is nearly unkillable and yet still deals good damage. Man this game is weird sometimes.

 

 

Unique Item Rankings — The Top 100 of Delve

There are almost 900 uniques in the game at the moment, so I dare not show them all. Here is how the top 100 most popular uniques are doing:

 

Unique ItemIncursion RankDelve Rank ↑Rank Change
Watcher's Eye110
The Wise Oak32+1
Tombfist63+3
Dying Sun84+4
Atziri's Promise25-3
Taste of Hate146+8
Headhunter47-3
Kaom's Heart158+7
Loreweave119+2
The Poet's Pen2910+19
Xoph's Blood2311+12
Might of the Meek4912+37
Wildfire5613+43
Kaom's Roots4014+26
Conqueror's Potency5014+36
Inpulsa's Broken Heart916-7
Bubonic Trail3117+14
Ventor's Gamble518-13
Queen of the Forest1319-6
Combat Focus2120+1
Starkonja's Head721-14
Unnatural InstinctN/A22New
Divination Distillate6423+41
Devoto's Devotion1624-8
Shavronne's Wrappings3324+9
Rumi's Concoction3926+13
Lion's Roar2627-1
Yoke of Suffering5728+29
Shaper's Touch5829+29
Lioneye's Fall1830-12
Goldwyrm1031-21
Sin Trek3732+5
Witchfire Brew5533+22
Mark of the Shaper3034-4
Pyre6335+28
Sadima's Touch1736-19
Zerphi's Last Breath9237+55
Rigwald's Quills3338-5
Windripper2839-11
Presence of Chayula3240-8
Prism Guardian4341+2
Healthy Mind8442+42
Kaom's Way6043+17
Essence Worm1244-32
Fevered Mind6245+17
Energy From Within46460
Indigon7347+26
Conqueror's Efficiency5148+3
Inspired Learning2749-22
Forbidden Taste6850+18
Dream Fragments8051+29
Blood of the Karui6152+9
Incandescent Heart13153+78
Grelwood Shank7754+23
Hrimsorrow3655-19
Saffell's Frame6756+11
Lightpoacher4257-15
Quill Rain10258+44
Alpha's Howl5459-5
Aul's UprisingN/A60New
The Overflowing Chalice8961+28
Belly of the Beast4762-15
Lavianga's Spirit2463-39
Cyclopean Coil10564+41
Astramentis9665+31
Sin's Rebirth9366+27
Lightning Coil18567+118
Lioneye's Remorse8768+19
Atziri's Step5969-10
Ephemeral Edge8270+12
Pure Talent6671-5
Atziri's Foible10372+31
Intuitive Leap4873-25
Bisco's Collar2274-52
Call of the Brotherhood2575-50
Nebuloch26176+185
Grand Spectrum8177+4
Impresence8878+10
Bisco's Leash4179-38
Drillneck10080+20
Command of the PitN/A81New
Vessel of Vinktar6582-17
The Pariah7283-11
Memory Vault11384+29
Hand of Wisdom and Action16185+76
Clear Mind3586-51
Thief's Torment9087+3
Mark of the Elder11988+31
Bated Breath7789-12
Chin Sol5390-37
Doon Cuebiyari12891+37
Spreading Rot15892+66
Fertile Mind14593+52
The Vigil9594+1
Atziri's Reflection12695+31
The Taming10796+11
Victario's Influence8697-11
Darkness Enthroned7598-23
Cloak of Defiance99990
Hrimburn71100-29

 

As usual and expected, very generalist uniques dominate the top ten. Poet's Pen at #10 is the highest on the list that can't fit into hundreds of different builds. What's initially surprising to see is that Atziri's Promise, for years the most used unique in the game, has been knocked all the way down to the 5th spot! This fairly Avatar of Fire-heavy meta clearly doesn't suit it so well. Speaking of which: between Elemental Hit and Molten Strike, the ultra niche, ultra expensive Xoph's Blood is doing very well! And those two skills have dragged not one but two threshold jewels (the definition of niche!) into the top 20 uniques.

Now let's zoom in on the biggest movers in the Delve meta. For clarity, I'm sticking to items that were in the top 100 in either Delve or Incursion, but an honourable mention has to go out to Hopeshredder. Despite rising nearly 400 places in the rankings after its buff, it still didn't break the top 100...

 

The Biggest Unique Movers and Shakers of Delve

 

Unique ItemIncursion RankDelve RankRank Change ↓
Unnatural InstinctN/A22New
Aul's UprisingN/A60New
Command of the PitN/A81New
Nebuloch26176+185
Lightning Coil18567+118
Incandescent Heart13153+78
Hand of Wisdom and Action16185+76
Spreading Rot15892+66
Zerphi's Last Breath9237+55
Fertile Mind14593+52

 

Unique ItemIncursion RankDelve RankRank Change ↑
String of Servitude97374-277
Shimmeron19158-139
Piscator's Vigil44182-138
Tinkerskin38133-95
Brightbeak20114-94
Soul Catcher83176-93
Esh's Mirror45127-82
Frostferno52129-77
Berek's Grip74144-70
Mind of the Council70132-62

 

We have three newbies to the table this time, which is a nice change from Incursion! I'm sure Unnatural Instinct will be hovering around the top ranks pretty much forever unless a nerf comes along. Otherwise, the big winners here share a common theme: DEFENSE. The mines clearly did a fair bit to promote builds that combined tankiness and high damage (often at the expense of clear speed).

Meanwhile in the losers' bracket, it's mostly stuff that's been hit by nerfs or is no longer easily available. Frostferno crashing even though Elemental Hit is on top of the world might seem counterintuitive. However, it has been hurt by the lack of double corruptions in this league, and fossil crafting has made + gem level bows much more readily available and much stronger in the best case. All the Elemental Hit players socket it in their bow instead now. On the other hand, I am genuinely confused by Berek's Grip and Mind of the Council showing up on this list. Both are strongly associated with self-cast Arc — not exactly a meta build, but still a fairly common one, and one that is actually more popular this league than in Incursion. So I'm baffled. If you have any ideas, leave a comment!

 

 

Spotlight on...

 

...New and Reworked Skills

 

Skill% Use (Main Skill)% Use (Any)
Consecrated Path2.28%4.35%
Smite0.21%2.22%
Scourge Arrow1.64%1.87%
Toxic Rain3.74%4.07%
Herald of Purity0.29%10.65%
Herald of Agony2.25%3.70%
Summon Holy Relic0.02%2.73%

 

SkillIncursion RankDelve Rank% Use (Main Skill)% Use (Any)
Ancestral Warchief21240.98%7.92%
Dominating BlowUnranked330.49%0.54%
Static StrikeUnranked790.07%0.26%
Caustic Arrow76142.07%2.16%

 

This looks like you'd hope it to. All the new skills have been well adopted, and the new Heralds are even seeing success as damage skills as well as utility. Most of this batch of reworks also went well, although it doesn't look like Vaal Ancestral Warchief changed the minds of anyone who thought the skill was boring.

 

...The Mine Meta

I've alluded a couple of times already to the azurite mines' influence on the meta this league. Here is a bit more information on that. In each table, I've shown how much each class or top 50 skill is represented at solo depths 500+ and 1000+ compared to the total population. Just keep in mind that at the time of writing, only 75 characters have reached solo depth 1000. I'm not going to provide much analysis of these figures, because it's pretty much all just confirmation that being very tanky or one-shotting enemies from off the screen are the best ways to succeed deep in the mines, and relying on squishy minions or totems is not a good idea.

 

AscendancyRepresentation @500+ ↓Representation @1000+
Pathfinder167%271%
Occultist150%239%
Saboteur108%130%
Ascendant106%65%
Juggernaut96%46%
Inquisitor94%0%
Gladiator91%86%
Assassin86%0%
Hierophant85%203%
Raider82%0%
Berserker81%0%
Elementalist77%12%
Champion75%0%
Deadeye74%120%
Trickster65%71%
Chieftain63%0%
Slayer57%0%
Guardian49%32%
Necromancer46%73%

 

SkillRepresentation @500+ ↓Representation @1000+
Frenzy199%249%
Ball Lightning186%584%
Glacial Cascade162%287%
Scourge Arrow159%79%
Molten Strike144%248%
Orb of Storms130%0%
Blight127%0%
Blade Vortex127%101%
Death Aura121%0%
Herald of Thunder120%0%
Herald of Ice118%0%
Blade Flurry113%71%
Elemental Hit108%53%
Leap Slam105%0%
Consecrated Path98%58%
Kinetic Blast97%0%
Spark97%0%
Whirling Blades96%0%
Power Siphon94%0%
Spectral Throw92%0%
Lightning Arrow90%0%
Rain of Arrows89%0%
Assassin's Mark87%0%
Smite83%0%
Reave83%42%
Herald of Agony82%61%
Tornado Shot79%133%
Double Strike77%187%
Lightning Spire Trap75%0%
Frost Blades75%0%
Shield Charge73%0%
Herald of Purity72%0%
Cyclone71%77%
Arc71%40%
Righteous Fire67%0%
Sunder64%0%
Raise Spectre62%88%
Ancestral Warchief57%0%
Barrage57%42%
Scorching Ray54%0%
Dominating Blow53%0%
Toxic Rain52%35%
Caustic Arrow51%0%
Raise Zombie46%104%
Summon Flame Golem45%0%
Summon Ice Golem43%0%
Summon Skeleton31%0%
Lacerate22%0%
Molten Burst20%0%
Freezing Pulse19%0%

 

 

...Ascendants

At the request of Discord user DaniConD, let's finish off with a quick look at how the Ascendant's mini-ascendancies stack up. After all, she is the most popular ascendancy class now so there's a hell of a sample size!

 

Node% Use ↓Count
Slayer72.58%1705
Pathfinder31.08%730
Necromancer17.45%410
Juggernaut17.11%402
Guardian16.82%395
Raider15.79%371
Elementalist11.41%268
Deadeye6.51%153
Trickster3.45%81
Inquisitor1.70%40
Champion1.53%36
Assassin1.19%28
Occultist1.11%26
Chieftain0.77%18
Saboteur0.64%15
Hierophant0.34%8
Berserker0.21%5
Gladiator0.04%1

 

Oof. Not exactly the most diverse thing in the world, is it? Ascendant is mostly used for attack-based builds these days (after Elemental Hit, Reave is her next most popular skill), and it shows. I wonder whether the real Slayer ascendancy would see similar popularity with some buffs, or whether Scion's flexibility on the tree is still the key?

The balance line must be really tricky here. After all, a Scion mini-ascendancy has to be distinctive and powerful enough to be worth taking, but ideally not overshadow the ascendancy class it's drawn from. See you all in 2028 for Scion's fourteenth rework?

 

 

Summary

  • The meta hasn't shifted all that much, especially compared to the 3.2–3.3 shift.

  • Pretty much all the new and reworked skills in 3.4 appear to have found niches.

  • Delve has promoted a more survival-focused meta than previous leagues. It will be interesting to see whether that continues in 3.5 and beyond!

  • Damage over time changes appear to have been warmly received, but it's difficult to untangle those from the new skills they were partnered with.

Goodness me. I complained about the last report being long, but this one was longer still. I hope it was at least somewhere interesting. As always, please let me know if there's anything you think I've got wrong, could improve upon, or should add for next time! Also, if you're a data analyst and/or programmer and want to help me out with these, please get in touch with me! There's so much more I want to do with these that I don't have the know-how to accomplish.

Thank you for reading!

Posted Dec 2, 2018, 10:38 AM UTC · edited

1.3K221
Loading comments…