r/StarWars•
JSmart5

I decided to have some fun last night and write the first scene of A New Hope in my own words. Constructive criticism appreciated!

Fan Creations

Somewhere, long ago, in a distant galaxy, lies the tale of:

STAR WARS

Chapter I: Hope for Alderaan

It is a time of great darkness across the galaxy. A time of strife and despair, and a time where all hope seems lost from the eyes of the good and the just. But for some who remain true and bold, this means nothing. There are those who would see that the good in the world prospers, else see themselves leave the world, the galaxy, in an honourable death. Somewhere, in the far reaches of space, lies a starship carrying a message of the life of the truth. On this vessel there is a woman who holds the key to this truth. She is young but wise, strong but fair, and she seeks for a time where the galaxy can rest at peace.

Yet while the woman may not hold fear in her heart, the android C-3PO has only such emotion to hold him in reality. He is tall and proud, with a golden chassis to carry his long obtained knowledge of science and history. His companion, a stout, cylindrical astromech droid named R2D2 follows him down the winding corridors of the disguised Rebel ship as the enemy starcraft draws closer and closer. They hear the energy blasts of their predator, but this time the action is different. This time they feel their vessel halt in dead space. Then, a blast that seems so strong it seems to halt time itself. C-3PO is, once again, fearful for his life.

“Did you hear that?” He asks his stout metal companion in fear. “They shut down the main reactor. We’ll be destroyed for sure! This is madness.” The pair watch as Rebel troops bolt past them, a deep fear in their eyes.

The Rebels line up at the main airlock. In the eyes of some there is fear. It is their first battle for the Rebellion against the evil Empire, who seek to rule the galaxy through the conquest of worlds and tyranny over once free peoples. For others, they fear no death. They have survived longer than they should have, and they are grateful for it. But all know the terror that awaits them when that door falls. It is the terror of the Stormtrooper. Clad in white and black armour that conceals a cold and merciless heart, the Stormtrooper will slaughter for the Empire until he can slaughter no more. He is born and raised to do so. The Rebels will defend for what is right.

“We’re doomed,” says C-3PO. He is programmed for far more complex calculations than determining the outcome of this battle. “Why this side?” He thinks. “Why must we work for the Rebellion?” But he knows it is a futile question. He and his silver and blue companion have no interest in living in a world of unhappiness and dark hearts of men. Slaves though they may be, they would rather slave for greater men. Not to mention their precious cargo that brings passion and bravery into even the eyes of an android.

“There will be no escape for the Princess this time,” C-3PO says, waiting desperately for reassurance from his partner. “As much as I would like to despise him, the astromech has remained by my side through many battles,” thinks the tall droid. “What’s that?” he says aloud.

Throughout the spaceship the terrible sound of scraping metal can be heard. They are all tenured men and androids, as they should be to accompany a princess, and they know what that sound means: they have stopped completely and are now at the mercy of an Imperial Star Destroyer. The soldiers at the airlock allow themselves a second to revel in the horror of the situation, then ready themselves for death. They swore to live and die for the Princess. They have lived, and now they will die if they must. As if on cue of this thought, a blinding spark illuminates the doorway, tracing around it. The door falls. The Stormtroopers enter. At first the sides seem equally matched, and the Rebel troops are allowed a moment of brief respite from death. But only a moment. The Rebels feel the corridor grow darker. Not a darkness in sight, but in soul. They feel the hope of victory fade away in an instant.

“No,” they think. “This I have only heard tales of from distant worlds; this fate could not befall upon me!”

But as they fight, a shape in the smoke grows inevitably solid. It is a black, looming form, caped and masked. This is no man that approaches. This is death. His blade ignites in a scarlet fury, crackling and howling for blood. Darth Vader, the last of the Sith Lords, enters the battle. Hope is gone. He slices off the heads of, at most, three brave men before the rest attempt to retreat. They are gunned down by blaster fire within seconds. The Empire wins once again.

On the opposite side of the ship, however, Princess Leia of the planet Alderaan, the secret pride of the Rebellion, is talking to R2D2 in barely audible whispers. She gives him a disk, which is promptly inserted into his memory bank. Their heads turn, and find C-3PO in search of his comrade. She disappears instantly with practiced skill. C-3PO walks toward the astromech.

“At last I have found you! Where have you been?” he asks, relieved. “They’re heading in this direction. What are we going to do? We’ll be sent to the spice mines of Kessel, or smashed into who knows what!” R2D2 makes no response, but starts toward the further end of the corridor. The Princess Leia watches tensely from a hidden corner.

“Wait a minute. Where are you going?” C-3PO is not one to be lacking in questions, nor tire to answers.

Darth Vader, in his black might, strides towards Captain Antilles, the leader of this Rebellion vessel and close co-worker to the Princess. He grabs him by the throat and raises him off the ground to meet his metallic face.

“Where are the transmissions you intercepted?” He speaks with a calm yet stern baritone, but all in the room know that unspeakable anger is soon to follow. “What have you done with the plans?”

“We- intercepted- no- transmissions!” Captain Antilles struggles for breath and is afraid for his end, yet he still lies in the chance that it may help the Rebellion. “This is a- consular ship. We’re on a- diplomatic mission- to Alderaan!”

“If this is a consular ship, where is the ambassador?” Darth Vader’s patience grows short as Antilles talks. He seems to have reached the full potential of his usefulness. Throwing the captain aside, he turns to his subordinate, dressed in the grey trimmed and fitted uniform of an Imperial Officer. The officer involuntarily steps back from the infamous warrior, it as if a terrifying energy of rage and hatred emanates from his metal skin.

“Commander, tear this ship apart until you’ve found those plans and bring me the passengers. I want them alive!”

​

Edit: C3P0 -> C-3PO (Props to u/SpellsC-3POForYou)

Posted Jan 7, 2019, 7:08 PM UTC · edited

09
jdwiseauthor•

Have you ever seen Flash Gordon or Buck Rogers? The tone of STAR WARS has a lot more in common with those than anything else I can think of. The recent trend is to take STAR WARS much too seriously/dramatically.

I’d also recommend watching Akira Kurosawa’s The Hidden Fortress. A lot of STAR WARS (especially the early part) was lifted from this film.

All that to say I think the tone is a bit off for a start. STAR WARS has a tone that is difficult to define outside of Flash Gordon and Kurosawa films. I know the trend of the post-Lucas STAR WARS films is to be dramatic, dark, and edgy (and overly-didactic), but that just doesn’t fit. Even Empire Strikes Back fits the more campy (for lack of a better word) tone of STAR WARS than most people care to admit or remember.

But take all that as you will. Like I said, the more contemporary view of STAR WARS tends to be more serious.

3
JSmart5OP•

I completely agree. I think today we forget that Star Wars was so popular at its initial release because it was (as you put it) campy and fun, and easily connectable for audiences of all kinds. But, in my opinion, taking a darker/more serious approach allows the more thematic elements to be revealed in the story. (hero's journey, balance, technology and nature, divine forces, etc.) I also think that as the art ages it, in a way, has to be interpreted in new ways for it to remain relevant to the modern audience. Of course, there is always the risk of losing the original scope of the art in nuance. Thanks for the advice! Love Flash Gordon. Haven't seen Hidden Fortress but I have watched Seven Samurai, great film!

1
jdwiseauthor•

The irony of trying to “age up” STAR WARS is that’s exactly the opposite of what STAR WARS was: a return to a forgotten genre—a counterpoint to the cynical filmmaking of the 70s. Sometimes I get the feeling that if STAR WARS came out today, it would be largely ignored.

(Also, to clarify just in case, I don’t mean the Flash Gordon movie from the 80s. I mean the serials from the 30s and 40s. The STAR WARS crawl comes directly from one of those.)

3
JSmart5OP•

I agree with you on the point that Star Wars the film shouldn't be aged up. But I think it's also important to note that there are many other elements at play in the movie that make it untouchable as a work, such as the music, set design, or visual effects (Harmy ftw). I enjoy the original films because of the pairing of the story with those aspects, yet the story itself has a second life independent of film. I like to think that the Star Wars story is a myth on its own, and with Joseph Campbell being such a large inspiration for Lucas that may have actually been his thought as well, but that's just my guessing. As a myth separate from the film, I think there is plenty of room for it to grow and to be reinterpreted, just like the Arthurian legend or the Bible. Can you imagine what those stories would be like today if they were secularized from contemporaries throughout history "aging them up"?

Also thanks for clarifying, I don't know why I was thinking of the film. Probably because of Queen haha

1
jdwiseauthor•

I just don’t think there’s much value in it. STAR WARS itself is a retelling of older stories, but it is still something new. Tolkien did the same thing. So did Shakespeare. But it was still new. I certainly don’t see the value in “updating” stories. Shakespeare and Tolkien did not have that in mind. They respected those stories. (I mean, Tolkien is the main reason Beowulf is so studied these days.)

Also, I don’t think 21st century storytelling methods have much to add to these stories. The very fact that we feel we need to alter stories to fit us is part of the problem. As open-minded as we think we are, it seems we’re unable (or unwilling) to connect with the past. I believe this is a grave error. If we merely keep taking old stories and fit them to our current ideas and tastes, then we will be a very stale people indeed.

I mean do we need to “update” Beethoven? Or Picasso? Or Frank Capra? Or Tolkien? Or what about more recent things? Like Apocalypse Now? Or Back to the Future? Or Pulp Fiction? Or the Matrix? Or Firefly? Or Harry Potter? Not everything should be given the franchise treatment. Sometimes a story just ends.

1
MRHBK•

Fun lol

2
SpellsC-3POForYou•

C**-3PO***

2
JSmart5OP•

God damn I'm embarrassed, thanks for the clarification haha

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1