Hey all,
I've been re-reading the Silmarillion and noticing the fairly liberal stance Tolkien takes on the roles that both Elven and Human women played in war and leadership in the First Age. Characters like Haleth, Melian, and Galadriel are shown to play parts of equal significance to that of the sons of Feanor throughout the Silmarillion, and the theme seems to follow through into the Lord of the Rings with Eowyn and others. Why is this such a stark contrast to The Hobbit? There's so much of a lack of any female presence in that story that they even wrote in that weird side-plot in the films with Legolas and that other elf just to bring a woman into the narrative. Could the fact that its







