r/Amd•
chazzPrime

Not all AM4 mainboards might support Ryzen 3000 according to german tech press pcgh.de

Rumor

Translation (via Google Translate)

[...] However, AMD does not promise that all previous AM4 motherboards will support the Ryzen 3000 CPUs. For example, the BIOS chips on the 300 boards (X370, B350, A320), which only hold 16 MiByte and therefore can not contain the microcodes for all models, could cause problems. As a solution, manufacturers could offer parallel BIOS versions. The 400er motherboards (X470, B450) carry 32 MiByte chips. [...]

​

Source (German)

Posted Jan 11, 2019, 2:03 PM UTC · edited

88125
MC_chrome#BetterRed•

This is a fault of motherboard manufactuers being cheap than AMD not offering support. Larger microcode chips are not really that much more expensive than the smaller ones.

114
majoroutage•

Shortsightedness is the beancounter's superpower.

72
CashBamA10 [email protected] R7 370@850 -150Mv•

Definitely seems like an oopsdidntmeanto

19
COMPUTER1313•

"What's the minimal amount of functionality needed to get this to run?"

"What about forward compatibility?"

"DID I STUTTER?"

19
renegade_officer89R7 1700 from a 9370•

I almost thought that sounds like a Darkest Dungeon quote for a bit.

1
blackpearl1477•

Because those manufacturers want to see you buy a new mb. This gives them more revenue over time. These practices are very common these days.

19
ArcAngel071•

Jokes on MSI then. I hate their X370 board so bad I am upgrading.

They just aren't getting my money this time.

24
tolga9009Ryzen 7 2700 / ASUS ROG Strix RX480 8GB•

This. Write down all manufacturers, who don't offer Ryzen 3000 support for their 300-series motherboards and avoid them at all costs for your future upgrades. There is no excuse for short sight, when AM4 was obvious to be long-term supported from the beginning.

12
LikwidSnek•

So all of them?

3
RiddleGiggleAMD PILEDRIVER•

AFAIK it's a similiar case as with AM3 and AM3+. The only reason a move to AM3+ was necessary is that manufacturers cut cornerns and didn't make their boards up to full AM3 specs, most likely some pins in the socket were just not connected. Those mobos that were made up to spec had no problems supporting AM3+ CPUs with just a BIOS update.

6
thomasjjcR5 2600X | RX Vega 56•

However 4 lines above that paragraph is stated that "AMD promises, that all mainboard manufacturers will offer BIOS updates that will contain support for Zen-2-CPUs" (my translation).

38
adman_66•

maybe they will have separate bios for each series, or maybe they will have one for the 2000 and 3000 series have the 1000 series on a separate bios

14
UsePreparationHi7 [email protected]>R7 3700X | EVGA Gtx 980 FTW-->Navi•

They would need to do 1000/2000, 1000/3000, and 2000/3000 to make it work for anyone updating.

3
MWisBest2700X + Vega 64•

The old CPU only needs to work to flash the next BIOS though. Once it's flashed you don't really need the old CPU to boot anymore.

1
just_szabiRyzen 5 1500X + Nitro+ RX 580 4GB•

Or you can just take your mobo into a shop and ask them to flash it for you and install a new update.

1
ZazielAMD K6-2 500mhz 128mb PC100 RAM ATI Rage 128 Pro•

Or a lot of these boards have code for the Bristol Ridge AM4 chips that could be totally scrapped for compatibility and most people wouldn't care.

I bet that BIOS code is less applicable to the Zen series and is probably totally different.

1
chazzPrimeOPR7 1700X | X370 Taichi | F4-3200C15D-32GTZ | GTX 1080Ti•

Yeah, that is kinda weird.

2
zombykilr777•

That quote doesn’t say all mobo will be supported. It’s just saying that all the manufacturers will be offering bios updates.

13
blackpearl1477•

But probably with a cost of performance. Like in the past with pcie. I still have a pcie 2.0 mb but with a pcie 3.0 gpu. My guess this is simular with cpu's but on software level.

1
tdpthrowaway3•

PCI upgrades arent going to make much difference to people who arent buy at least 1 if not 2 of the highest gpus. I'm mostly looking forward to having fewer lane slots that are 4x4 and 4x8, so that those lanes can be used for other features like extra M.2, etc.

2
Xajel•

Some current motherboards & in order for them to support 2nd gen Zen+ CPU's removed the support for pre-Zen AM4 APU's...

1
neomerxR7 1700, Asus CH6 Hero, G.Skill@3466 C16•

I've got x370 platform. No probs if I have to choose BIOS that supports only Ryzen 1, 2 or 3 due to space restrictions.

30
parentskeepfindingmeRyzen 7 2700x, Vega 56, 32GB DDR4-3000•

Agreed. Thankfully I can flash the BIOS without a processor, since I'm gonna slowly upgrade my gaming rig and push everything over to my server to replace my Xeon X5650

Slowly not shower

1
Zok2000HD 7970 / 1080ti / Titan Xp•

Shower upgrade?

1
parentskeepfindingmeRyzen 7 2700x, Vega 56, 32GB DDR4-3000•

Slowly*

Damned phone

1
dr-finger•

Do I understand it correctly that once you flash ryzen 3rd gen compatible BIOS version you lose your current gen chip compatibility?

If that's correct I can already see people flashing wrong version that is incompatible with the chip they have by mistake.

18
armando92GB AB350 G3 l R5 1600 l 16GB 2800Mhz•

i guess they could first release a update that adds a failsafe that if you try to flash for example a bios that only works with ryzen 3000 cpus while you're runnning a 1600 or something it adds a extra prompt that says "This bios doesnt support your current cpu, after flashing you will no longer be able to boot are you sure you want to continue?.

of course this will not work with older bios versions, unless they somehow can trigger the prompt when you select the bios file

14
Allamuth•

Some people won't read this, like all the "yes I read and understand" checkboxes for the terms and conditions.... People are dumb. In our student network we are offering netinstall. Yes we had a user install Ubuntu and deleting all his files because he didn't read the prompt....

7
armando92GB AB350 G3 l R5 1600 l 16GB 2800Mhz•

and? they will have to deal with the stupid shit they do for just clicking next next. And if they go around updating your bios without reading stuff or just doing it for the lulz they kinda deserve the brick (well not really a brick since they will just need a new cpu, or depending on their mb they will be able to reflash or boot into a backup bios)

3
Allamuth•

You're totally right. But if there's a shit storm it will be directed against AMD and not the dumb user who's clicking next all the time.

3
majoroutage•

It's possible that is the route some take, but I'd venture they would start by eliminating the oldest and/or worst selling SKUs first.

9
fullup722200G / RX 470•

I'd say that since all boards currently support Gen 1 + 2 they would offer the remaining combinations with one BIOS doing either 1 + 3 or 2 + 3 so that you can always select your current chip and whatever you are upgrading to.

11
majoroutage•

That sounds like a sensible way to go too, if they even want to bother supporting them at all.

3
easy90riderXeon E3-1230v2 | SAPPHIRE Radeon™ RX 480 NITRO+ 4GB•

This is why I like MSI... They have something called BIOS Flashback. You can update BIOS without CPU, GPU or RAM installed.

2
Dan23023•

update BIOS without CPU, GPU or RAM installed

Dumb question: How does that work? How do you see what you're doing?

1
MWisBest2700X + Vega 64•

You put the update on a flash drive, stick it in a certain USB port, and hold a button when you boot up. It's all automatic after that.

2
easy90riderXeon E3-1230v2 | SAPPHIRE Radeon™ RX 480 NITRO+ 4GB•

Work blind and hope that it works. It's fun! 😉

Plug in the USB drive with the BIOS on it and you press a button or turn on the pc.

2
DarkomaxGimme Zen 2•

What motherboards have a 32MB BIOS chips? I checked Gigabyte and all have 16MB (128Mbits). And if it's true, I don't think you really need your motherboard to be compatible with all CPUs in existence at the same time.

​

Edit : Asus seems to have 32MB on X470.

17
majoroutage•

If I'm understanding this right, 32MB was mandated for gen 2 (400 series) boards.

18
DarkomaxGimme Zen 2•

Well no X470 Gigabyte board have 32MB.

7
majoroutage•

Then this article is dead wrong.

12
anonlymouse860K + GTX 770 | 2300U•

That depends. Due to poor punctuation, there's two possible interpretations of the comment.

1
LikwidSnek•

Whenever this weird German site gets linked it is some shitty, flawed benchmarks or some misinformation.

As long as I do not get information from serious publications or channels like Anandtech, GN or HWU I won't bother with these rumours I guess...

1
salrr•

fuck...

1
ionlyuseredditatworkR7 2700X - Vega 56 Red Devil•

MSI X370 all have 16MB as well

2
GhostOfJimLahey•

At the same clock rates, the 7-nm process halves the power consumption, which could achieve twice the core count with the same core clock and TDP.

Maybe for simple devices clocked within the optimal frequency range of TSMC's process, but not for a full power 4GHz+ CPU.

16
majoroutage•

Yeah, I thought it was pretty obvious that power consumption would be an issue on low-end boards.

4
[deleted]•

This is why I replaced my dying Biostar X370 board with an overkill MSI X470 board. VRMs/power delivery in general is fucking insane. Zen 2 probably won't be past the TDP of most motherboards honestly, but if it does end up being that way, I'm ready for it. 2x 8pin CPU power cables. Crazy.

3
majoroutage•

Biostar

say no more fam

2
[deleted]•

The sad thing is it supposedly had very good VRMs, and most reviews were like "yeah it doesn't have all the features you might want but it's good value and performs well", yeah well it ended up where it would shut down randomly at random points throughout the day. Sometimes it would shut down 5 times in one day, and sometimes it would go 1 or 2 weeks without shutting down randomly. I replaced my RAM first because it was crappy micron die TEAM brand ram, that didn't fix it. Bought a new motherboard and all problems are solved.

I initially RMA'd my power supply because I thought that was it, but it turned out not to be.

1
markole•

So that's what I get for buying a premium motherboard. Ah man.

9
zJordanR7 2700x (16GB 3200MHz), RTX 2080 Gaming X Trio•

This feels more like AMD being lax in certification or whatever.

AMD should state that "Every motherboard must have sufficient VRM cooling, or it won't get certification, blah blah - every motherboard should have a 32MB BIOS flashrom"

Instead we saw some CRAPPY B350 boards, so much so that buildzoid said "don't put a damn 8 core in this unless you have active VRM cooling".

ASUS by choice elected to put 32MB flashroms in some of their X370 boards.

7
MrAlagos•

Oh yes because manufacturers act based on Buildzoid's words and not their ability to suck as much money from their customers through the cheapest shit possible that will function. AMD needed every single AM4 board, if anything they needed even more given that you can count the MicroATX ones on your hands.

7
zJordanR7 2700x (16GB 3200MHz), RTX 2080 Gaming X Trio•

At what point did I mention they act based on Buildzoid's words?

I clearly stated that "AMD should state". I was using buildzoid as an example because he has reviewed most of these boards.

And I stand by my statement, AMD should have stricter certification standards. FreeSync monitors just need VRR to meet the certification. It just seems like AMD are Okay with sub-par products being released.

Manufacturers do act based on AMDs word.

8
MrAlagos•

A substantial amount of people who upgrade an old motherboard with a new CPU on their own won't have any problem flashing a BIOS, for the rest the manufacturers and AMD will put out instructions on how to do it simply and safely.

7
RaidSlayerx370-ITX | 1800X | 32GB 3200 C14 | 1080Ti Mini•

Most likely a typo, but ASUS put a 128Mb Flash ROM on the x370-I ITX (https://www.asus.com/Motherboards/ROG-STRIX-X370-I-GAMING/specifications/)

Edit: And a 256 Mb Flash ROM on the X470 ITX (https://www.asus.com/Motherboards/ROG-STRIX-X470-I-GAMING/specifications/)

1
redupp44Ryzen 7 2700X; RX 580 8GB Red Dragon v2•

128 Mb (megabits) ÷ 8 = 16 MB (megabytes).

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
radonfactory•

I might be mis-remembering what he said, but Adored speculated (or rather has sources) that the high-end Ryzen SKUs won't be compatible due to higher power requirements? That would line up with this, should still work with any other Ryzen 3000 though. Sorry I'm at work and can't watch the whole vid to find the quote so pls correct me if he didn't suggest this.

Adored vid

If true it might lead to some confusion and disappointment over whether people can upgrade to the "R9" or not.

6
majoroutage•

I concur with this. The new 12-core models should have a low enough power envelope to work on boards that currently support the 8-cores. But the 16s probably not.

4
piitxuRyzen 5 1600 @ 3.9GHZ, 1.35V | GTX 970•

well AMD already confirmed that the highest SKU will be 105W as the 2700x, so 95% of mobos will be able to run it power wise

4
spiderman1216AMD Ryzen 5 2600 and GTX 1070 Ti•

did they I can't find anything about that I mean they are releasing a 16 Core CPU for Ryzen desktop after all.

1
piitxuRyzen 5 1600 @ 3.9GHZ, 1.35V | GTX 1070Ti•

There was a slide on AMD's presentation at CES with a line saying that zen 2 would be the same TDP as current gen. That means a max of 105W which is the 2700x TDP.

This can mean 3 things:

-The leaks were wrong all along (they have been so far) and there's no 16 core part planned for launch.

-The 16 core part is actually a 105W part. This is a long shot considering the 8 core they demoed at CES supposedly was a 75w part (according to all the backseat engineers on the internet) I guess it could be a 16 core with no SMT?

-AMD said there was room for another Core die in the CPU they showed at CES. But they NEVER said it was going to be another 8 core die, so we could see a 12 core part that would fit nicely the 105W TDP

1
spiderman1216AMD Ryzen 5 2600 and GTX 1070 Ti•

The leaks were wrong all along (they have been so far) and there's no 16 core part planned for launch.

The leak I would argue got more things right than wrong the 12 core 105W tdp part is accurate, the CES stuff was on Jim, and the I/O die thing the leaker wasn't sure.

I should also add that Steve from GamerNexus he said he got a source saying 16 Core parts were coming when is unknown.

1
SocketusPopetus2700X|CH7|RX580 & 2500U x360 envy•
2
tolga9009Ryzen 7 2700 / ASUS ROG Strix RX480 8GB•

I never expected my 50€ ASUS A320M-K to support 16C. No hurt feelings here. I've been waiting for an AMD-manufactured chipset (like X570) instead of ASMedia.

The ones, who might be disappointed, are probably people like who bought high-end motherboards like ASUS C6H for 200€+ (or any other brand / mobo), only to find out, their manufacturer comes with a cheap ass excuse to not support Ryzen 3000 CPUs.

Hurts much more, as the higher priced products lose value over time much quicker than budget.

1
sharukins•

I can already imagine the complaints on the support forums:

"my PC isn't working anymore after I flashed the Ryzen 3000 BIOS. I read that flashing this would upgrade my CPU. [insert OEM name here] is shit, I will never buy again"

6
excalibur_zdRyzen 1600 / GTX 1060 6GB / 16 GB DDR4 2400Mhz RAM•

How do they know it cannot contain microcode for all models?

5
Ecmaster76•

I think some existing boards already started dropping support for Bristol Ridge (dozer based) chips to make room for the 2000 series

19
excalibur_zdRyzen 1600 / GTX 1060 6GB / 16 GB DDR4 2400Mhz RAM•

Didn't know BIOS was that limited. Although I suppose they can always make a version of "upgrade BIOS". For example if you're going from 1000 to 3000 a BIOS without 2000 support.

6
tolga9009Ryzen 7 2700 / ASUS ROG Strix RX480 8GB•

Or, they could just remove their graphics, images and animations (back to oldschool "blue" BIOS screen) and fit all of them in the single BIOS.

8
ZazielAMD K6-2 500mhz 128mb PC100 RAM ATI Rage 128 Pro•

I'd honestly like that. Some manufacturers have some insanely convoluted and cluttered BIOS screens.

1
LoneSilentWolf•

From testing IMO. They must have found that and told the manufacturers.

2
AshamedGanache•

My B350 only supports up to 65 Watt CPU. Don't think it needs the microcode for chips higher than that.

Regardless if it's 1xxx, 2xxx, 3xxx series...

For boards that support the full watt range with 128Mb (16MB) might have issues.

Maybe gut the "GUI" and have it text only BIOS, old school style. ;-)

4
INITMalcanis•

I'm pretty sure that there will be 65W TDP Ryzen 3s.

1
AshamedGanache•

And 3xxx 5's.

3
Barracudka•

They will probably just start different branch of bios for that so I would say its fine. They just need to document it properly so people can make sense of it :D

3
brandonshRyzen™ 1700X | Radeon™ Vega 56•

Uh... my B450 has 128Mb/16MB.

3
fainas1337Zen+ 2600 | GTX 980 TI•

same on B450m Mortar

3
CDFisBAGRyzen 2600 / RX 570•

Great, my B450 motherboard has 16MB. I hope they find a solution, I would like to have the option to upgrade to a 4600X a few years down the line.

3
LikwidSnek•

None of the X470 have 32 MB either. This article sucks.

Literal definition of fake news. I can guarantee you that 500 series chipsets won't have more than 16 MB either.

2
[deleted]•

On overclock.net, some people who knew what they were talking about reacted to this article saying it was basically BS. Everyone with an X470 and most people with an X370 should be good to go. Probably B450 too.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
crownvics•

X370 Taichi user, praying to the AMD gods for this one. Really don't wanna shell out another couple hundred for essentially the same board

3
metodz•

Yeah, this thing has the best and coolest running power delivery out of pretty much the entire AM4 lineup.

1
criccardo•

They can drop the support for the old crappy Bristol Ridge APUs and save some kilobyte

2
Newcdn•

Where do you check this information? Specifically for Asus Rog Strix B450-F?

2
fainas1337Zen+ 2600 | GTX 980 TI•

If you have the board you can check it on HWinfo section Motherboard SMBios - Bios - Bios size

2
Newcdn•

I just got it, haven't installed it yet

1
PantZerman85•

Asus Rog Strix X470-F Gaming has 256Mb(/32MB) Flash Rom listed on their web page (lucky me I guess).

Asus Rog Strix B450-F Gaming has 128Mb(/16MB) Flash Rom listed in the manual (find it on their page)

1
lightofhonor•

Dead thread, but that's weird since the B450-I has a 32MB chip and the larger F model has 16MB.

1
DHJudasIntel 3930K @ 4.3GHz|2x Sapphire RX 580 Nitro+•

Or you know, they could offer a bios update that doesn't include any of the APUs/cpus that predate the ryzen models so that the new ones could be included... i'm sure they could fit the new cpus in place of.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1