r/chemhelp•
Chemmqs

Good calibration curves but inconsistent data - what does it mean??

My experiment:

Put several soluble cations with a heterogeneous chemical able to undergo salt metathesis (ex. Chemical-Na+ + LiCl--> Chemical-Li+)

Monitor change in concentration of each cation in the mixture

get % removal (change in concentration over initial concentration)

I can monitor the release of Na+, showing the exchange happens. I see 90% exchange.

I can monitor the change of concentration, but some % removal are negative, as in I "gained ions"??

I can compare the total % removal of ions to the releasing of Na+, and the numbers are vastly different. Without taking the negative % removal into account, I get 72% removal, more than 18% unaccounted for.

The calibration curves I generated are all .995+ or higher in R2, with 5 points each. Why are the values I am getting so wildly different?? Does this mean the way I prepared the calibration curves are correct, but the concentration I think I have is wildly off? is this an integration of chromatographic peak issue?

Posted Jan 18, 2019, 2:02 PM UTC

45
the88thkaiser•

Are you using ICP or AAS? You can try to use ICP if you are currently using AAS to remove matrix interference which could be the cause of inconsistent reading.

2
woodsja2•

What happens when you add a known amount of your analyte to your sample?

Does the concentration of your analyte increase by the amount you added?

1
ChemmqsOP•

Do you mean knowing i added a solution containing ___ moles of ion, do I see a corresponding change of the anion I am kicking out?

1
RFlyer07•

A cal curve was done for each ion? I take it you're using IC? Are the standards you used to cal in the same concentration range as the samples from the expt?

If the stoichiometry of the reaction is what you state, there should be an equimolar amount of sodium produce with respect to litchium consumed?

1
dungeonsandderpPh.D., Inorganic/Organic/Polymer Chemistry•

Put several soluble cations with a heterogeneous chemical able to undergo salt metathesis

Does it remain insoluble? Does any of it dissolve under your metathesis conditions?

I can monitor the release of Na+, showing the exchange happens. I see 90% exchange.

How are you measuring this? ICP-MS? AES? Ion-selective electrodes? Chemical titration? Ion chromatography?

I can monitor the change of concentration, but some % removal are negative, as in I "gained ions"??

How are you measuring this, and are these unexpectedly negative changes occur randomly or do certain ions cause them but not others?

The calibration curves I generated are all .995+ or higher in R2, with 5 points each. Why are the values I am getting so wildly different?? Does this mean the way I prepared the calibration curves are correct, but the concentration I think I have is wildly off?

How did you prepare your calibration curve? Have you considered standard addition to compensate for matrix effects?

is this an integration of chromatographic peak issue?

You’re using chromatography here? What kind? What detection method? Lots of possible problems here.

1