5e3 + Humbuckers = speaker "thwacking"
I am looking for some guidance troubleshooting the Fender 5e3 Deluxe circuit to work well with humbucker pickups. In short, the amp sounds great with single coils but humbuckers make the speaker ‘thwack” which does not sound good. I have the amp volume set at 10 and the guitar volume set at 5, there is yummy tube distortion, but always a little “thwacking” from the speaker when a bass heavy chords are played. (This is an amp that I built from the 5e3 schematic from scratch)
I understand that the circuit was designed for fender guitars in mind so maybe this is a futile objective. From my reading it seems like the “Lo” impedance/gain input should accommodate for the higher voltage generated from the humbuckers. But I get the same speaker "thwack" from either input from the humbucker. To reiterate, single coil sounds absolutely great, and even louder than the humbuckers which is surprising, and the speaker does not “thwack” when bass heavy chords are played.
I am looking for some guidance on how to troubleshoot and correct this. Here is my current thoughts on the issue.
- Currently I feel that the quiesce voltage may be too high, and so the humbuckers put high voltage onto the grid causing clipping in the tube, which translates into the thwack on the speakers. I am not sure how to correct this at the moment. I believe the output tubes in this circuit are cathode biased, and so they should be “self regulating”. If I go down this path should I start with the 12AX7, work towards the output tubes, lowering the quiesce voltage until the issue is resolved? How do I lower that quiesce voltage correctly? Would I increase the cathode resistor value so that it is less negative to the plate/anode?
- Previously I felt the issue was that I did not have a “Lo” impedance jack on the amp. I recently corrected this, but I do not find a difference between the hi and lo. The speaker still “thwacks” with the humbuckers. Is there a way to make the “Lo” even more “Lo”?
- I made the adjustment that Rob Rinette mentioned on 5e3 mod page that should address Humbuckers “Farting Out” but this did not solve the issue. (I totally thought this was the fix, and it seemed so easy too) But this did not work. https://robrobinette.com/5e3_Modifications.htm#Humbucker_Switch
- Rob also heavily recommends adding negative feedback from the speaker output to the preamp, which I have not done yet. This seems like it might help prevent the tube from clipping, but I am not sure. (ultimately this sounds like a great solution to make the amp louder, just not sure it will help with my issue)
- Would a 16 Ohm speaker thwack less than my current 8 ohm 12” speaker? Should I just change the speaker (current speaker = ted weber 12" 8ohm alnico)
To digress a bit.
What are some circuits that work well with humbuckers? Should I study the Marshall JCM800 rather than the Fender circuits to accommodate the humbucker?
Additionally I found a general reference to this issue in Merlin Blencowe’s book “Designing Tube Pre-amps for Guitar and Bass” he discusses Hi and Lo impedance, and he posits that Lo impedance / gain inputs are not needed in modern amps. “Traditional Amps have two inputs jacks as shown in fig 4.9. J2 is switched so that if only J1 is used, R1 and R2 form a potential divider that attenuates the guitar signal by half, giving a “low gain” option. However, it probably fair to say that few musicians ever used the low gain input, with multiple channels and voicing being easily implemented nowadays, there is little call for low-gain input on a modern amp.” (Page 89)
Finally to further digress, how is this not a common issue with guitar pedals? I suspect that pedal voltage is higher than the common single coil. It seems like Lo impedance would be the norm if you were using pedals? But from my experience, this amp sounds good with the a fuzz pedal on, and the speaker does not "thwack"as much as it does with just the humbuckers and no pedals? Maybe pedals are more like a single coil voltage than a humbucker?
Thank you for any “input” you can provide on this issue.
Update: Thank you for the quick suggestions regarding changing the speaker, I feel that is the next best step. The current speaker is a Weber 12A125A 30 watt which may not be adequate. I have read that the circuit design is 18-22 watt, but that is from the 50's / 60's and that new transformers put the circuit a bit hotter than originally designed.
I think I am going to order a Celestion Gold (12" 8 ohm 50 watt) or a Scumback M-75 (12" 8ohm 65 watt)
https://celestion.com/product/6/celestion_gold/
https://www.scumbackspeakers.com/m_series.html
I will follow up in a few weeks with an update. And maybe some sound clips. Thanks!
Posted Mar 2, 2019, 8:06 AM UTC · edited