3.5 Meta Shift Report — First Anniversary!

There's a summary at the bottom!

 

 

Introduction

As with my previous entries, this is a fairly relaxed and mathematically flaky look at the meta of Betrayal and how it compares to Delve. All data are sourced (with permission) from http://poe.ninja/builds, meaning that there is an unavoidable bias towards builds that are fast and/or preferred by dedicated, experienced players. Unfortunately, unless you're GGG this is the best data set we have. Only the softcore trade leagues are examined (it's all I have time to do with my current methodology).

It's also been a year (give or take) since I started doing these! Whoo...

 

 

Ascendancy Breakdown

As a refresher, Occultist and Champion were the two ascendancy classes updated in 3.5.0. Both received changes designed to tie into the new and reworked skills also contained in the patch.

 

AscendancyDelve %Betrayal %Diff ↓Fold Change
Occultist7.2%15.6%+8.392.16
Assassin0.7%6.8%+6.159.87
Elementalist11.5%16.5%+5.051.44
Saboteur5.1%7.7%+2.601.51
Inquisitor0.8%1.4%+.541.67
Ascendant18.5%18.9%+.371.02
Raider1.0%1.2%+.171.17
Berserker0.2%0.1%-.030.83
Champion2.4%2.2%-.260.89
Hierophant3.3%3.0%-.280.91
Gladiator1.5%1.2%-.340.78
Slayer1.3%0.5%-.720.43
Chieftain1.5%0.5%-.950.36
Trickster1.9%0.8%-1.120.41
Necromancer3.7%1.7%-1.990.46
Guardian4.2%1.6%-2.560.38
Juggernaut14.6%11.5%-3.050.79
Deadeye8.9%5.2%-3.740.58
Pathfinder11.8%3.6%-8.230.30

 

There's a lot going on here this time, so let's try and break it down. Occultist is doing great, clearly. There are many factors potentially contributing to this. The class itself got direct buffs, the reworked cold DoT skills are strong and a perfect fit for her, the class's nodes are applicable to a broad variety of skills and builds, and she cannibalised a lot of the enduring popularity of last league's new chaos skills. She was already doing much better than any post-3.0 league in Delve thanks to those chaos skills and the accessibility of ES gear with dense fossils, so she's now climbed to third place overall.

Ascendant retains the top spot, showing off her versatility with a dizzying range of different types of builds. That said, while the rest of the Ascendant ladder is indeed extremely varied, her top three skills (representing about 45% of characters) are bow attacks (Elemental Hit, Scourge Arrow, and Rain of Arrows). There's definitely a theme running through the Ascendant's popular builds — most people are picking her for Slayer leech and/or her jewel socket access (whether that's for Might of the Meek, the now horrifyingly expensive Unnatural Instinct, or just stacking more conventional jewels). As I mentioned last report, Ascendant can do almost any build well, but it does seem to usually be for the same reasons.

Elementalist has also bounced back to reach second in the popularity contest, her best showing to date despite being popular for a few leagues running. Tri-Herald Blade Vortex is still a popular build for her of course, but new skills Winter Orb and Storm Brand are responsible for the bulk of her resurgence. These skills are showing up on a few classes, but Elementalist is by far the most popular for now. I'm sure she's slipping Inpulsa's money under the table.

Finally in the big winners, Assassin has showed up big time this patch! This probably isn't a surprise to the thousands of people who gasped in awe of the huge Cast on Crit buff in 3.5.0, and variations of that build are pretty much single-handedly responsible for his resurrection from Berserker Tier™. Dude might only do one thing, but damn he does it well!

Most of the classes that lost popularity this league seem to just be making room for everything mentioned above rather than being a response to specific changes, so I don't have a huge amount to say about them. There is one quite funny thing though. Pathfinder and Guardian, the two "featured" ascendancies of 3.4, suffered popularity drops almost exactly equal to their gains last league. Pathfinder of course lost two incredibly strong builds (Indigon Poet's Pen and the Immortal Build) to nerfs this league, and the skills tailored for her in 3.4 seem to have found more of a home with Occultist and Trickster. Guardian didn't really change at all — I'm guessing his new builds just felt more like novelties than anything people particularly wanted to come back to. It's also noteworthy that Champion is continuing to slip despite being an already-strong class that received buffs and targeted skills in 3.5. The Steel skills didn't land strongly, and...something something melee? More on that later.

(As a side note, I mentioned last time that Inquisitor was slowly slipping from dominance to irrelevance, despite barely being touched by balance. Winter Orb and Storm Brand helped reverse that trend this league! And with the way 3.6 is shaping up, it looks like he won't need much help with popularity any longer...)

 

 

Primary Damage Skill Rankings — The Top 50 of Betrayal

"Rank" here is based on popularity alone, i.e. rank 1 means the skill used by the largest number of characters. This is also using poe.ninja's criterion of only counting 5- and 6-linked skills, which is imperfect but about as good as you can feasibly get. Note that this does include links granted by items.

 

SkillDelve RankBetrayal Rank ↑Rank Change
Winter OrbN/A1New
Molten Strike220
Arc633
Cyclone17413
Ice NovaUnranked5New
Blade Vortex16-5
Storm BrandN/A7New
Vortex106898
Elemental Hit39-6
Tornado Shot510-5
Herald of Agony13112
Scourge Arrow18126
Rain of Arrows22139
Lightning Spire Trap271413
Barrage915-6
Righteous Fire716-9
Glacial Cascade1617-1
Blade Flurry1518-3
Cold Snap831964
Storm Call572037
Tectonic Slam1142193
Ice SpearUnranked22New
Consecrated Path1223-11
Summon Ice Golem29245
Frenzy425-21
Raise Spectre1926-7
Ancestral Warchief2427-3
Toxic Rain828-20
Double Strike2029-9
Herald of Ice2330-7
Armageddon BrandN/A31New
Caustic Arrow1432-18
Frost Blades39336
Reave1034-24
Flicker Strike573522
Ice Shot653530
Shield Charge3037-7
Raise Zombie2138-17
Summon Skeleton2839-11
Projectile Weakness994059
Scorching Ray1141-30
Shattering SteelN/A42New
Blight3443-9
Summon Flame Golem2643-17
Spectral Throw3545-10
Lightning Arrow3946-7
Essence Drain51474
Orb of Storms3148-17
Death Aura3749-12
Kinetic Blast3250-18

 

Most changes here are either a direct result of new skills coming in strong, a skill being buffed or nerfed, or stuff dropping a bit in order to make room for the new/buffed things. A few notes on the odd ones though:

  • Cyclone is mostly being used as a trigger skill for Cast on Crit builds now. Sorry to disappoint the Ngamahu cohort and friends.

  • Similarly, Frenzy's drop is tied directly to the strongest Poet's Pen builds being nerfed.

  • Storm Call is apparently meta now? This is a trend I have personally missed completely until I was writing this up, but Storm Call Pathfinders are all over the place all of a sudden! Some of these are just using Vaal Storm Call as a boss-nuking skill, but most of them have no other damage skills and appear to be pure Storm Call! This is exciting. What have I missed? I know the skill is pretty good, but still. Could someone please fill me in? (Edit: there's some good discussion of this in the comments if people are interested.)

  • Projectile Weakness is only showing up due to a legion of Herald of Agony Occultists using it in a Curse on Hit setup.

 

 

Skill Diversity by Ascendancy

 

Ascendancy ↓Number of Skills >1% Usage% Usage of Most Popular SkillMost Popular Skill…vs in Delve
Ascendant1519.1Elemental HitElemental Hit
Assassin641.4CycloneMolten Strike
Berserker1824.2Ancestral WarchiefAncestral Warchief
Champion1618.1Double StrikeDouble Strike
Chieftain1035.0Blade VortexBlade Vortex
Deadeye1047.9Tornado ShotTornado Shot
Elementalist841.4Winter OrbBlade Vortex
Gladiator835.3Herald of AgonyHerald of Agony
Guardian1029.9Righteous FireRighteous Fire
Hierophant1046.3ArcArc
Inquisitor1720.7Winter OrbMolten Strike
Juggernaut1056.4Molten StrikeMolten Strike
Necromancer938.6Raise SpectreRaise Spectre
Occultist1730.0VortexBlade Vortex
Pathfinder1818.7Storm CallFrenzy
Raider1718.8Tornado ShotTornado Shot
Saboteur464.6ArcArc
Slayer1537.3CycloneCyclone
Trickster2215.4Caustic ArrowToxic Rain

 

Most of this has stayed static or has already been discussed above. The overall number of skills used per class has increased vs Delve though, which is a good sign. Also Trickster is suddently a hive of diversity, going from sub 10 last league to 22 and first place this league. I wouldn't read too much into this as the class as a whole is pretty unpopular at the moment. At the other end, Saboteur is pretty much permanently at the bottom end of diversity, just using whatever few spells fit best with traps and mines. Slightly better than the 90% GC days at least. Finally, I've mentioned it already but wow, Storm Call is the most popular Pathfinder skill! I can't help but laugh.

 

 

Unique Item Rankings — The Top 100 of Betrayal

By my count, there are currently 908 unique items in PoE. Even in a thread of this size that's too many to show, especially since 250-odd of them don't show up on a single character in this dataset. So here's how the 100 most popular are doing!

 

Unique ItemDelve RankBetrayal Rank ↑Rank Change
Watcher's Eye110
The Wise Oak220
Atziri's Promise53+2
Dying Sun440
Loreweave95+4
Mark of the Shaper346+28
Tombfist37-4
Might of the Meek128+4
Unnatural Instinct229+13
Headhunter710-3
Taste of Hate611-5
Kaom's Heart812-4
Bubonic Trail1713+4
Wildfire1314-1
The Pandemonius13915+124
Starkonja's Head2116+5
Inpulsa's Broken Heart1617-1
Cinderswallow UrnN/A18New
Shaper's Touch2919+10
Energy From Within4620+26
Solstice VigilN/A21New
Shavronne's Wrappings2422+2
Blood of the Karui5223+29
Xoph's Blood1124-13
Essence Worm4425+19
Devoto's Devotion2426-2
Lycosidae10427+77
Kaom's Roots1428-14
Yoke of Suffering2829-1
Presence of Chayula4030+10
Cospri's Malice23831+207
Lavianga's Spirit6332+31
Dream Fragments5133+18
Frozen Trail32434+290
Sin Trek3235-3
Rumi's Concoction2636-10
Combat Focus2037-17
Lioneye's Fall3038-8
Goldwyrm3139-8
Queen of the Forest1940-21
Vessel of Vinktar8241+41
Lion's Roar2742-15
Kaom's Way43430
Cyclopean Coil6444+20
Conqueror's Efficiency4845+3
Mark of the Elder8846+42
Ventor's Gamble1847-29
Hand of Wisdom and Action8547+38
Conqueror's Potency1449-35
Sadima's Touch3650-14
Incandescent Heart5351+2
Pyre3552-17
Rigwald's Quills3853-15
The Green Nightmare19154+137
The Pariah8355+28
Clear Mind8656+30
Intuitive Leap7357+16
Windripper3958-19
Witchfire Brew3359-26
Pure Talent7160+11
Nebuloch7661+15
The Golden Rule10962+47
Fertile Mind9363+30
Grelwood Shank5464-10
Prism Guardian4165-24
The Vigil9466+28
Soul Strike16267+95
Soul Catcher17668+108
Farrul's Fur17169+102
Bisco's Leash7970+9
Esh's Mirror12771+56
Bated Breath8972+17
The Poet's Pen1073-63
Alpha's Howl5974-15
Lightpoacher5775-18
Atziri's Acuity11576+39
Forbidden Taste5077-27
Carcass Jack25378+175
Atziri's Reflection9579+16
Astramentis6580-15
Command of the Pit81810
Shroud of the Lightless10182+19
The Taming9683+13
Hopeshredder14284+58
Atziri's Step6985-16
Call of the Brotherhood7586-11
Void Battery18087+93
Inspired Learning4988-39
Sin's Rebirth6689-23
Aul's Uprising6090-30
Ephemeral Edge7090-20
Bisco's Collar7492-18
Victario's Influence9792+5
Lioneye's Remorse6894-26
Magna Eclipsis23195+136
Victario's Charity12296+26
Hale Negator16997+72
The Overflowing Chalice6198-37
Brute Force Solution14498+46
Healthy Mind42100-58

 

I won't parrot the last couple of these talking again about the usual versatile, popular items topping the list. Instead, let's go right ahead and zoom in on the biggest changes in popularity between Delve and Betrayal. For clarity, I'm sticking to items that were in the top 100 in either league. Shoutouts to Rime Gaze, Arakaali's Fang, Shade of Solaris and Gifts from Above, which all rose 4-500 places but still didn't break into the top 100!

 

The Biggest Unique Movers and Shakers of Delve

 

Unique ItemDelve RankBetrayal RankRank Change ↓
Cinderswallow UrnN/A18New
Solstice VigilN/A21New
Frozen Trail32434+290
Cospri's Malice23831+207
Carcass Jack25378+175
The Green Nightmare19154+137
Magna Eclipsis23195+136
The Pandemonius13915+124
Soul Catcher17668+108
Farrul's Fur17169+102

 

Two of 3.4's fourteen new uniques are doing well, which is about the usual ratio. Both are strong and versatile, so no surprises there. It's cool to see The Pandemonius shooting up to the top (and overtaking Breach-mate Xoph's Blood in price) thanks to the huge amount of new cold-based builds popping up. Cospri's Malice and Frozen Trail have ridden the Cast on Crit buffs to the top. Soul Catcher and Farrul's Fur are showing up again thanks to increased availability, as they've never been anything but insanely strong. Green Nightmare is mostly being used in speed-clearing Winter Orb builds where it can really shine. And Magna Eclipsis is a really interesting one — it's being picked up by Brand builds to abuse its +2 to socketed gems (with Empower on top), making for lightning-fast Brand Recall cooldowns.

 

Unique ItemDelve RankBetrayal RankRank Change ↑
Zerphi's Last Breath37463-426
Fevered Mind45252-207
Lightning Coil67216-149
Cloak of Defiance99246-147
Indigon47178-131
Divination Distillate23126-103
Atziri's Foible72173-101
Quill Rain58157-99
Doon Cuebiyari91190-99
Hrimburn100195-95

 

On the losing side, most of these are easy to categorise. Zerphi's, Indigon, Divination Distillate and Quill Rain got slaughtered by nerfs. All the mana items fell alongside Zerphi's and Indigon. Lightning Coil is no longer popular for deep delving, although version 2.0 of the Immortal Build still uses it. Doon and Hrimburn are less clear. I guess the natural drops in popularity of RF and Tri-Herald BV are enough to explain these? (Edit: a couple of people have pointed out that Hrmburn is dropping off because it's now possible to make rare gloves with 50% conversion. Thank you.)

 

 

Spotlight on...

 

...Class Popularity Over Time

Just for fun as an anniversary retrospective, I thought it would be cool to present class popularity in every league since these data became available. Please forgive me for the crappy Abyss data — my methods were not very sophisticated back then. I'm not going to comment on these, as I'm not sure there's much to be said. Mostly just interesting.

 

Class ↓AbyssBestiaryIncursionDelveBetrayal
Ascendant5%7.71%10.35%18.50%18.88%
Assassin2%2.00%0.73%0.69%6.85%
Berserker4%0.52%0.19%0.16%0.13%
Champion1%6.06%3.38%2.45%2.19%
Chieftain0.70%1.60%0.72%1.47%0.53%
Deadeye0.20%14.46%17.53%8.91%5.17%
Elementalist0.50%2.44%16.71%11.47%16.52%
Gladiator6%1.58%1.84%1.54%1.20%
Guardian5%6.16%1.98%4.16%1.60%
Hierophant0.20%4.53%5.27%3.28%3.00%
Inquisitor11%2.95%1.45%0.81%1.36%
Juggernaut2%18.54%7.76%14.58%11.53%
Necromancer16%7.63%2.86%3.67%1.68%
Occultist0.80%2.87%2.53%7.24%15.63%
Pathfinder8%5.71%3.15%11.81%3.58%
Raider16%4.76%1.25%0.98%1.15%
Saboteur2%3.39%17.70%5.11%7.72%
Slayer17%4.92%2.35%1.26%0.55%
Trickster2%2.15%2.26%1.89%0.77%

 

...Melee

Since melee balance is the focus of a lot of community discussion at the moment, here is the popularity of all the primary melee skills in the game since I started keeping records.

 

Skill ↓BestiaryIncursionDelveBetrayal
Blade Flurry5.23%1.35%1.90%1.86%
Charged Dash0.00%0.06%0.13%0.09%
Cleave1.04%0.12%0.14%0.10%
Consecrated Path0.00%0.00%2.33%0.93%
Cyclone5.37%2.38%1.75%7.79%
Double Strike0.01%2.73%1.45%0.69%
Dual Strike0.25%0.03%0.00%0.05%
Earthquake0.02%0.16%0.06%0.05%
Flicker Strike0.50%0.37%0.14%0.41%
Frost Blades2.16%0.40%0.29%0.54%
Glacial Hammer0.09%0.01%0.02%0.01%
Ground Slam0.00%0.14%0.08%0.01%
Heavy Strike0.23%0.03%0.01%0.01%
Ice Crash0.09%0.03%0.09%0.04%
Infernal Blow0.05%0.04%0.02%0.01%
Lacerate0.17%0.38%0.20%0.05%
Molten Strike5.26%3.79%10.37%10.78%
Reave5.51%2.35%3.24%0.50%
Smite0.00%0.00%0.21%0.07%
Sunder2.19%1.59%0.34%0.05%
Sweep0.01%0.00%0.00%0.00%
Tectonic Slam0.55%0.02%0.02%0.97%
Wild Strike0.37%0.08%0.18%0.09%
TOTAL29.07%16.06%22.94%25.03%

 

The more observant among you will immediately notice that this table is cheeky at best and outright misleading at worst. I definitely don't mean to be a melee apologist here. Very importantly, Cyclone in its current use case is not something anyone is likely to call a melee build, since it's overwhelmingly being used to trigger Cast on Crit. That leaves Molten Strike pretty much the sole standard-bearer for melee builds, as you might expect. You can definitely argue that the diversity of melee skill usage has dropped in recent patches, but 3.7 is already slated to be "the melee patch", so I might revisit this table in a few months' time!

 

...Sources of eHP

Finally, at the request of Discord user Bomars, here is one more set of trends over time — the proportion of builds using pure life to build their ehP pool vs other methods. Unfortunately, I don't have the means to detect hybrid builds (they will just be counted as pure life).

 

eHP TypeBestiaryIncursionDelveBetrayal
Pure life64.23%63.95%59.32%59.69%
Mind over Matter20.83%27.52%23.38%16.00%
Chaos Inoculation3.36%2.06%7.66%15.77%
Low life11.59%6.46%9.64%8.56%

 

Well, it's not much of a shock that CI is doing great. However, it's quite tough to untangle exactly why. What proportion of that rapid rise is due to dense fossils, for example? What about the fact that Occultist is a natural fit for both the new cold DoT skills and CI builds? And so on. For me, the most interesting thing is that MoM is losing popularity. I sort of figured that the increasing popularity of CI would come at the expense of regular life builds (presumably non-casters). Evidently not! Based on everything above, the caster meta is also not quite as entrenched as you might expect, so that ties into this.

 

 

Summary

  • A fairly build-agnostic league (compared to Incursion favouring ranged speed clear and Delve rewarding tanky builds) has lead to a fairly stable meta. Most changes in the meta appear to be direct results of buffs and nerfs to core parts of builds in 3.5.0.

  • Of GGG's promoted archetypes for 3.5, cold casters have been enthusiastically embraced and impale-focused champions mostly ignored.

  • Melee builds are stagnant and lacking diversity, but casters aren't dominating in the numbers as much as you might expect.

  • The number of people hyped about the CoC buff seems to be reflected by the large numbers following through and actually playing it.

  • Storm Call Pathfinders!!! Sorry, I'm still hung up on this...

 

As always, thank you for reading these huge lumps of text, and please let me know if there's anything you think could be improved or that you would like to see in future threads. See you in three months to pick apart what a patch packed with caster buffs has done to the meta!

Posted Mar 3, 2019, 11:15 AM UTC · edited

413154
Loading comments…