Anthem: The State of Loot and Progression Post 1.0.3

Meta

With all of the talk about loot quality and drop rates after the recent patch, I thought it would be a good idea to consolidate my feedback on loot and difficulty in the current build.

I'm going to split this into 3 parts: Loot "Feel", What is Loot?, and Pinnacle Rewards.

Loot "Feel"

What do I mean by loot "feel"? To me it is the feedback loop of progression and acquisition. If I perceive my time spent doing certain tasks is given the rewards it deserves, that's a good loot "feel".

SO, how does this translate into Anthem? With the way Grandmaster difficulties appear to be designed, it's an equation of: More enemy health/damage = more loot. I think that from player feedback, and dev responses, it's pretty clear that this equation is off.

How do we fix it? With the new combo/melee/ultimate damage scaling it is pretty clear that the higher your gear score, the more powerful your javelin is.

Great, now we have somewhere to start. The purpose of Grandmaster difficulties should be to improve your gear score so that you can tackle the next difficulty. How do we do this well, so that you're not just loaded up with masterwork/legendary items immediately and steamroll through content?

Where should a player's power be in a given Grandmaster difficulty? This part is subjective from my own experience. If you disagree, don't hesitate to give your reasoning.

​

Starting GM1: 2 masterwork weapons (from hard), all other items epic.

Finishing GM1: All masterwork items, a handful of legendaries.

​

Starting GM2: All masterwork items, a handful of legendaries.

Finishing GM2: Enough legendaries for a Legendary Javelin, sub-optimal inscriptions.

​

Starting GM3: Enough legendaries for a Legendary Javelin, sub-optimal inscriptions.

"Finishing" GM3: Full legendary gear, decent to perfect inscriptions.

​

This is where BioWare is in control, they have the numbers on how drop rates work, how quickly we can be fed loot, and how difficult the activities need to be.

I won't get into loot per hour, or how many drops you should be getting per activity. That's where loot "feel" comes back in. You'll know it's right when players are no longer complaining about never finding items, and start showing off the drops that they get. (Travis Day hit the nail on the head here)

I'd like to gauge how long players think it should take you to reach any of these points. Please comment your thoughts.

​

What is Loot?

Now that we're getting some loot. What is it?

At the moment you can split it up into 2 categories: Progress, and materials.

What is considered "progress"? In Grandmaster activities, progress comes in the form of masterwork/legendary items that improve on your build, or give you a doorway into a new play-style.

With the way the inscription system currently works, a lot of the "damage-boosting" masterwork perks fall flat. (Have a look at u/AcidicSwords excellent post on scaling for why: https://www.reddit.com/r/AnthemTheGame/comments/ay70ma/scaling_the_make_or_break_equation_why_you_should/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share)

​

The masterworks that really shine are those that change the way you play, having spent the majority of my game time as the Ranger, I can tell you that he doesn't have many. The Last Argument grenade allows you to use your Ultimate more often, encouraging you to push into clusters of enemies to take advantage of its effect. The Tip of the Spear component gives you back armour on combos, turning your Ranger into an excellent combat medic who can REVIVE nearby teammates by just scoring combos near them. That teammate that went down in the midst of 4 Scar Enforcers, you can dive head first into the danger and revive them!

These are the masterworks that we need more of. From the few new Universal components that I've seen post-patch, they are excellent examples of the perks we need.

​

So these are the items that are worth using, what makes one more useful than another? The inscriptions. If you already have a build that you like, the only progress that you're going to make is through inscriptions. So how do you balance this sort of progress? With a good loot feel. In the current system, it would come in the form of more drops.

You could also change inscription value thresholds to reflect the difficulty it was acquired from.

​

What about everything else? The rares, epics, masterworks, and legendaries that don't give you any progress? They get broken down into materials to craft sigils, and to go towards a better roll on that one piece of gear you really like.

At the moment we're seeing too much material-loot, and not enough progression-loot. So we're stuck accumulating a large quantity of sigil materials, and a few blueprint materials.

Bring up the loot feel, and you should see a steadier rhythm to progression-loot.

​

And finally:

Pinnacle Rewards

If we're getting good loot, and making progress into the hardest activities, should we be worried about running out of content?

With the way inscriptions work, I wouldn't be too concerned about that. It's going to take you a long time to get a perfectly rolled build on all 4 of your Javelins.

So what if I'm happy with my builds, and I'm not interested in chasing perfect gear?

​

I would bring in some exclusive cosmetics. Make them exciting, and make them scarce.

For instance: An item that changes the colour of my 1st ability slot, so instead of sending out a regular explosion/flame/lightning bolt, make it bright blue! Or green! Or pink!

These cosmetics are instantly recognizable to the player, and squad-mates. They'll be something to show off, they'll POP on the battlefield, so even if you're running with randoms, it'll be noticed.

Where should these items come from? I'd put them as extremely rare rewards for specific encounters. Each stronghold could have effects relating to their theme: red for Heart of Rage, green for Tyrant Mine, and blue for Temple of the Scar.

You could also have something along the lines of exclusive emotes as a drop from legendary contracts. Yarrow's dance emote from a Hazard Pay contract anyone?

​

​

Ooh boy, that was a long one. Now I'm not an experienced game designer, or anything of the sort, I've just played a lot of loot-driven games and these are the things that excite me.

If you see any problems, or things you would change, comment it! I'd love to see where my opinions hit the mark with the community, and where they fall flat.

​

P.S. Big props to the Algorithmic Freelancers Discord for grinding their heads against a wall to get the numbers we need for these discussions.

​

Posted Mar 10, 2019, 3:54 AM UTC

41
Easay9PC - :Ranger:•

༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽ ༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽

1