khrfordayz•

do her ideas to break up companies like Amazon Facebook and Google work in practice? it seems like it wouldn't be productive to break up companies like those as opposed to breaking up like at&t or comcast or something. I'm not super knowledgeable about this stuff and I can't seem to find good information about how it would work.

anyone know about this stuff?

12
GoldenDesiderata•

do her ideas to break up companies like Amazon Facebook and Google work in practice?

Yes, it is possible, and it would be in fact easier than to do it than with telecomunication companies, which work regionally and are super entangled at all levels, not to mention oil giants.

In the case of alphabet, it can be easily divided into a branch for android, a branch of google itself with a branch for ad selling, other got gmail, other for hosting things, youtube, etc, etc, etc. In amazon, it could be one for Amazon website store itself, "amazon basics" which are amazon branded products, other for AWS servers, other for their package management logistics systems, other for that random ass cryengine version they bought (lumberjack), etc, etc, etc.

It would be relatively straight forward, there were couple documents on it, talking how it would be done, atm I can't search for them and link them as I'm on mobile, but google "breaking up google artstechnica" and you will get a good article about it

9
Predicted•

And how are these branches going to survive when theyre not interconncted? A lot of the services a company like google provides, at the scale they provide them is because they have the biggest ad platform in the world, if you separate them these services are going to either get more expensive, disappear or start growing their companies again until the strongest survive into a monopolistic situation again.

5
GoldenDesiderata•

are going to either get more expensive, disappear

That's the entire point of free competition, the idea of free competition isnt to have stable companies that last 129837129381729 years, but to provide better services for lower cost to consumers, if they go bankrupt, well, that's just how the game gets played.

Also, the "get more expensive" isnt true, as breaking up monopolies (such as in the case of Google Ads) would end up providing fairer competition allowing companies to give consumers of ads better ROI or better prices. Remember when in 2010-ish people used to get tons of money for running ads on streams? Well, the reality is that doesnt happen anymore, and this could actually help, same with providing more ad revenue to for example media companies, allowing them to continue pursuing investigative journalism, something that's less seen now days because in part of their poor revenue streams.

start growing their companies again

That's the same thing that happened with Bell and Telecoms, or big oil, and there's just no fix, it is a bug in capitalism itself and economies of scale, as companies get bigger they can use their size to gain efficiency in their production lines (legally or illegally), there's nothing that can be done against it other than breaking them up every 30 to 40 years or so.

10
Predicted•

That's the entire point of free competition

To lessen the services offered to the public? That doesnt sound right. If you split up a company like Google, how would you do it in a way that doesnt create just a bunch of mini-monopolies that have to pay adsense a fee or create their own adsense? It's impossible to break up google's products without extricating adsense from their service in some way. Youd essentially end up in the same place with the new companies expanding their services to make the most out of their ad sales. OR you'd end up with these services that might be loss leaders for the parent company (like Gmail) having to start demanding money for essential services.

Remember when in 2010-ish people used to get tons of money for running ads on streams? Well, the reality is that doesnt happen anymore, and this could actually help

No, the reason for that was that online ads were WAY overvalued, and as companies got wiser the providers had to adjust their prices. Creating a dozen new global companies trying to sell their ad service is going to further drive down prices and fuck creators.

there's nothing that can be done against it other than breaking them up every 30 to 40 years or so.

This doesnt work with online platforms, break up google, gmail is still going to be the main service, youtube is still gonna be a monopoly etc

Unless you're going to force people to use different websites breaking up these companies is only going to create inefficiencies that the consumer is going to have to pay for with either money or losing services.

6
Emosaa•

I can't remember if it was Warren or someone else who proposed this, but I know someone has suggested forcing Google, Amazon, Facebook, etc. to be required to share the majority of the data they collect with smaller companies. To basically even the playing field and allow smaller companies to compete against the massive, built in data advantage those companies have.

1
khrfordayz•

oh okay, that makes more sense. I thought it would be something else completely in practice. Facebook would still be a little different though from Google or Amazon though right?

1
GoldenDesiderata•

In the case of Facebook it might be harder, but they could rather easily split facebook from whatsapp, instagram, etc. Facebook also has got a serious video and image hosting service which they also sell adds for, so they could split those up aswell, hosting and, add services not to mention the video hosting system, which facebook presents very proudly because of the high amount of "views" it receives.

Oh they also had "free" services in countries such as India where people can iirc buy cellphones, and those cellphones can access only Facebook, so for many people Facebook is virtually the entire internet experience, and that obviously is super anti-competitive.

Planet Money, the podcast was doing a series of Podcasts on Anti-Trust Law and history these last few weeks, it is pretty good Id seriously recommend it.

7
khrfordayz•

cool thanks for the info

1
MagnaDenmark•

No it wouldn't the value from these companies comes In large from how different departments can use data and knowledge from other departments. Splitting them up will be a huge loss in data value

-1
-stinOPProfessional Richard Lewis critiquer •

The fact is google doesn't just provide one service, and with its size alone you've got what; youtube, the actual search engine, and their autonomous driving division, as well as maps, and fucking ANDRIOD ect. tons of things we use in our daily lives

These things aren't really physical products to be sold, but there tangible and valuable none the less. If you want competition, real capitalism this is how you actually achieve that. The more power these companies have, the more they act as oligopolies- which is bad for consumers objectively. Conservatives fever dreams of being censored will be well realized if the only mediums we have access news is through Facebook's approved sources, or we only hear good things about trailblazing workers rights through Amazon's Washington Post

if these small non-profitable projects fail on their own, they probably weren't that valuable to the company anyway. I'm also not convinced that lots of these companies should have such robust R&D departments to deliver on innovation that they can patent and hoard later to compound on stifling competition (remember that age long dispute between samsung and apple over some smartphone screen bullshit?)

If something isn't a profit driver immediately you can always find funding in the public sector :)

1†
Predicted•

if these small non-profitable projects fail on their own, they probably weren't that valuable to the company anyway.

That's bullshit, just because its not sustainable as a standalone company it can add alot of value, especially when your main business model is selling ads over multiple platforms.

1†
drugsrgaysmells like elmer's glue•

The main reason it has value for advertisers is because it's a defacto monopoly on non-TV/movie video on demand content

3
-stinOPProfessional Richard Lewis critiquer •

be a little more charitable with that, i could have probably worded it a bit better. obviously some non-profitable ventures now can yield massive gains later ect

2
Eccmecc•

Youtube as a standalone company would not exist in his current form. It is not profitable.

0
-stinOPProfessional Richard Lewis critiquer •

considering its a massive platform for WN i'm not convinced thats a bad thing hehehehee

but on a serious note i don't think this is entirely true. In fact i'd argue the fact that youtube has no financial incentive to produce value outside of google to be its primary thing holding it back

it doesn't have to ban groups of users until there's bad PR, entire content creators would be better off with an opensource stream embed on their own blogs and maintaining patreons of their own ect.

Streaming existed before youtube, and if it failed under its own weight streaming would still exist after in a much better state (imo)

1
FindersKeepersMatea singular braincell of destiny is stronger than a 100 of trains•

You know what can stand as a profitable form though? twitch and it's really bothered me how people like trainwrecks who are so flawed to have thousands of subs, he's not very entertaining and his arguments rely on strawman after strawman. I hope we can discuss this further.

-4
Eccmecc•

Twitch as it is now? No, not possible. If you remember Amazon bought Twitch a few years ago. Twitch as a platform got a big push in marketing by Amazon through Twitch Prime and the Fortnite/Amazon deal. Things like affiliate programm, loots, twitch prime and extra marketing are possible because Twitch is part of Amazon.

Would Twitch exist without Amazon? - Yes. Would it be the same as now? - No. You can ask the streamers what they think about Twitch Prime.

2
Predicted•

Probably not, because its not based on physical tangible assets in the same way as monopoly busts of the past has, the users create the monopoly not the other way round. Although forcing facebook to sell their other brands might be possible, breaking up facebook itself is completely unfeasible.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
DiversityDan79•

It seems like breaking up a social media company wouldn't do anything in the long run. The idea of social media is to interact with as many people as possible so let's say you break up facebook into three different social media services. People will pretty quickly migrate to one of these services, leaving us back where we started.

0
violet_athena•

Remember Standard Oil (actually no, because that happened 100 years ago, but bear with me)? Remember how its breakup solved the issues of aggressive multinationals in the oil business? Me neither.

-1
SuperNinjaNye•

And they claim to be the open commons?

6
frost102•

If someone is in your house and say "LETS BURN THIS SHIT DOWN" then you kick them out

1
SuperNinjaNye•

I don't advertise my home as the new public forum. And I also don't do that to avoid the terrible consequences of my home's business decisions. And my home never caused the 21st century murder and displacement of the Rohingya people.

2
frost102•

if someone is in your house and tries to break it down then you take them out of the house. its very simple

0
turinpt•

I work in advertising, everyone knows that facebook is incredibly protective of their logo, they have very strict usage guidelines. Whoever is responsible for those ads must have known they would be taken down.

5
AenonimosNanashi•

Sounds dumb AF. Facebook doesn't even sell information. You can use DuckDuck go right the fuck now if you don't like Google. Amazon on the hand is egregious and needs to be stopped.

3
borngamr•

I think their issue is that Facebook largely has a monopoly on social media and communication since it owns whatsapp, Instagram, and fb messenger. It also plans to combine the backend of the three basically making it much more difficult to decouple these three products. I don’t know much about facebooks ad platform so I can’t comment on that. I do agree though that amazon is worse in that they sell products on their own marketplace and are constantly making amazon basics versions of successful products and promoting them at the top which effectively screws the smaller businesses that have made a place for themselves on amazon.

1
BarrageTheGarage•

Clickbait, the ad was taken down because they broke Facebook TOS, you are not allowed to have an advertisement with the Facebook logo on it. This is not some political move

1
Cybugger•

Fundamentally, I don't have an issue with breaking up Amazon, Google or Facebook.

They're so vast and huge that they, essentially, have the power of a nation-state at this point. Google has its little sneaky fingers in a million different pies, having long ago abandoned any pretense at its old motto.

0
RecentPipe•

I do think it shouldn't be allowed, since it can create conflicts of interest, but I don't know how realistically it could be done. I think the bigger problem is companies like Verizon and Comcast though, they need to be broken up.

-1
30inchbluejeanssa•

Warren might actually be dumber than AOC, which I didn't think was even a possibility

Still better than trump tho

-2†
-stinOPProfessional Richard Lewis critiquer •

Yikes now this is a bad take

4