Has the community spoken? Or the mob? If you were not part of the angry, raging, Reddit mob, speak up. Because the mods think all of Reddit was a part of it.
Most of us who didn't agree with what was going on have just been ignoring the threads. So only the part of Reddit that was an angry mob spoke up. And their opinion was taken for that of the everyone here. I know you guys are tired of seeing and discussing this, but if you don't speak up, the mods (and even admin) will only hear the raging part of Reddit that's not open to reason.
Part of reddit has gone nuts. They will blindly listen to anyone who agrees with them and frame him as some sort of hero. Anyone who tries to point out that the hero is not so perfect receives massive downvotes all around.
A user (robingallup) tried to post his photo on Reddit with a google ad beside it. The spam filter caught this. He was told to post the image by itself without the google ad. This is where he gets sneaky. He reposts a false image link that immediately redirects to his ad. The redirection lets his post bypass the spam filter, driving traffic on his ad up 30,000%, according to Rob himself. His second post with the redirecting link (not his first post) ends up getting banned. Rob is extremely angry with the situation.
Maybe he deserved a second warning, but he was not clear of blame. Followers argued "It's fine if he wants to make some money from posting links on Reddit." But he also circumvented the spam filter by posting a deceptive redirecting link. His second post with the redirect was banned, not his first.
Then, in his anger, he took the opportunity to make a vengeful rant because he was caught trying to trick the spam filter, and some Redditors take his word as the law and verdict. This really shows how oblivious to reason the "mob" was. They were also the only ones to voice their opinions, so the mods listened because they think that's what all of Reddit thinks. Seriously, you don't have to do much; just show them that the majority of Reddit isn't a mob.
Edit: Whatever. I've tried to phrase this. This entire post was not to address "what she did" or "why she was wrong" but what Reddit has been doing. I don't want to talk about Saydrah. I want to talk about the people that have turned into barbarians to bring her down. If you want to say she's wrong, do it. But people have resorted to: posting her personal contact information hoping she will be harassed and raging about how she should be killed (sometimes in detail). They also take this chance to martyrize a guy who was not free from blame.
But whatever. I've tried, but people just came here to say:
But Saydrah was wrong! (I don't care about how she was wrong. I want to talk about how Reddit was wrong)
It's fine to post a Google ad and trick the spam filter if you have to! (Google ad = not the focus. But you can't say a guy who deceived the spam filter to get his ad across is 100% free from blame).
Posted Mar 3, 2010, 8:07 AM UTC · edited
New evidence. The smoking gun?
http://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/b7xce/blogreddit_and_a_fun_weekend_was_had_by_all/c0lgl0m
Combined that with all the rest of the evidence, and I don't see how you apologists have a leg to stand on unless you are part of her spam team. (Associated Content)
There certainly is a conflict of interest even if she's completely innocent.
What do we have to gain, keeping her on as a mod in those subreddits? And how does that trump what our community has to lose credibility wise? Not being a mod doesn't stop her from submitting articles and contributing to the community. So again I ask, what do we have to gain?
edit: to answer your question, maybe we don't have much to gain from keeping her as a mod. There is a chance she might abuse her powers as a moderator in the future, but so far, I have not seen that (spammy links, yes, but no abuse of power). If you think she should be removed to eliminate the possibility of abuse, then there is something to gain from her ban. However, I am saying that the backlash that has resulted in the Reddit community is damn near barbaric. That's what I'm focusing on. If you think she should be removed as a mod, say so civilly. But some members have gone as far as to describe how she should be killed. If I think she should be removed as a mod, I'm not going to describe how she should be cut open and have her innards pulled out. That is sick, and the people acting like this are disgusting.
That's all I'm saying. Reddit, act like civil people, not a frantic lynch mob. And don't blindly martyrize a guy who got caught trying to sneak behind the spam filters just because he was caught by Saydrah. Yes, you're opposed to her, but that doesn't mean that anyone against her is right.
Since you edited your reply, I'm making a second comment to address it:
I agree. But can you blame them? (I haven't seen any death threats or the like, but if they exist, I'll take your word for it). But she should have stepped down right away. Instead, she chose to ignore all of this of her own volition or at her employers request.
As it stands now, She has yet to step down in spite of overwhelming proof that her being a moderator is a severe conflict of interest and hurts the community she 'supposedly' cares/cared about.
The more she ignores her own conflict of interest and the wishes of the community, or in the apologists terms, 'mob', the more restless they become. She's bringing this on herself.
Only, it's making the situation worse for her. She's hoping people will get tired of this and move on, only she's wrong. By ignoring it, she's exposed most of the community to it. Now, her reputation is already destroyed. Her staying on as a mod helps no one, she can no longer contribute the way she has before. She isn't a pillar of the community any longer.
She, within the next few months will become a reddit meme if she hasn't already.The damage to her is irreparable and will only get worse the longer she stays on as mod. It will not go away like she believes. That doesn't happen on reddit. She should be aware of this.
Do you have a link to where someone said this? If someone did, I'm sure it's just an isolated incident.
Did you miss all of the other evidence against her are or you just blind? That guy came a full day later into the fiasco. The main point was she worked for a company who is a social marketing spam company and she even made a video where she brags about becoming a staple in a community to promote her companies links. That's what started this whole thing, not "some guy who was caught by the spam filter".
The more I talk to you, the more I believe you have other motives for playing the "white night".
*knight
Did you miss my point or are you blind? I'm not addressing Saydrah's actions here. Yes, she is in the wrong. But I am not addressing her. I'm addressing the guy who tried to sneak behind the spam filter. He is not clear of blame. But people are making him sound innocent just because he was banned by Saydrah.
Let me ask, is everyone that a mod bans clear of wrongdoing just because the mod is not clear of wrongdoing? No. She's not clear of wrongdoing. But he is not either. People are making him sound innocent just to oppose Saydrah. Yes, you can oppose her. But that does not make a guilty man innocent.
That's all I'm saying. Despite that, you keep on bringing the point back to Saydrah ("Saydrah is wrong!" you say). I say "I'm discussing something else!"
You didn't answer my question.
[deleted]