[deleted]•

While the witch hunt was disturbing, and I think it took a mind of it's own because 1) she consistently and coherently can argue points that go against the popular opinions in mensrights and similar subreddits, and 2) because of her whole "whats the big deal/redditors are assholes" rant that she did after the fact. She did not do herself any favors.

With that said, it is slightly disappointing that you don't really understand or acknowledge the original gripe.

Reddit has tools that allow it to be moderated by the community. You don't need moderators demanding and threatening to ban people who made popular submissions because they didn't follow "reddiquette", or any other rule from some random subreddit. There is no way that you can enforce this without playing favorites.

There are certain cases where mods are needed to kill a submission, or to ban users, like linking to warez/malware/childporn etc.

From what other users have demonstrated, Saydrah had been a bit heavy handed in her efforts to curb spam on the site, specifically people profiting off their own submissions. That is a problem in itself, but not really that big of a deal. When, however, it turns out that Saydrah is on the payroll of associated content, and submits their articles, there is an immediate conflict of interest. That, right there, is why many of your users got pissed.

It almost instantly took a life of it's own for the two reasons (and probably more) that I mentioned in the first paragraph of this post.

296
thatguydr•

When, however, it turns out that Saydrah is on the payroll of associated content, and submits their articles, there is an immediate conflict of interest. That, right there, is why many of your users got pissed.

It's not just that conflict of interest that pisses people off. It's the reddit mods' tacit acceptance of that conflict of interest that pisses people off.

Reddit is full of libertarians who naturally chafe at moderation. They don't chafe at spam filters usually (there's the occasional exception) because it's an automated system and nobody thinks a robot has a motivation against them, specifically.

Libertarians are libertarians because they don't like other people having power over their lives. On reddit, there's precious little of that, due to the remarkable work done to ensure spammers and power users can't game comments/submissions. That's why all the progressive libertarians love it here.

Except now there's tacit acceptance of a person (all personality defects of said person aside) who is quite obviously spamming for profit, however indirectly, and extremely unrepentant/willing to mislead about the whole affair. It leaves an exceptionally bad taste in the mouth.

reddit is extremely small potatoes (though it seems to be one of the primary early-adopter aggregators for new links). It's entirely probable that Saydrah's net spam contribution here is negligible, especially compared to her non-spam contributions. It's also entirely probable that it nets her employer next to nothing. But by allowing her to continue, reddit has tacitly acknowledged something that people hate: it has power users who profit from the site. This would make everyone a bit antsy, except that this one power-user has a habit of pissing off large swaths of the user base.

Ultimately, it just means the reddit experience is now downgraded. We'll all keep coming here, but we won't love it as much. Ultimately, when something better comes along, we won't feel as guilty when we leave. But that's the natural order.

Thanks for listening.

203
tephe•

Thanks, an extremely insightful comment. The experience has been downgraded for me ever since I realized 4chan memes have become a part of reddit. At first I thought no problem, I'll just unsubscribe to fuuu. After a month pics, then after another reddit.com. About a month ago i decided i'm going back the the google reader for actual news and come here just for laughs. Now I realize that a lot of the links I thought were authentic links have been fed to me through a marketing schema that I never wanted to be a part of. This has a bad vibe to it and kills all the community feeling.

61
[deleted]•

I've got to admit that I'm plenty guilty of spewing /b/ullshit far too often, but it seems to me to be a natural consequence of /b/tards growing up. Hell, I'm sure reddit's got some pretty hefty overlap in demographics with 4chan, especially now that the earlier users there are a bit older now.

Also, 4chan's memes have a strange way of worming their way into most communities online. Many are legitimately funny (at first), and it's only through endless repetition that they get this annoying, I think. Hell, I get pissed off when I see /b/ memes from non /b/ sources most of the time, not the least because it's a shitty implementation of a meme that I've already seen beaten to death, raped, and then beaten some more.

Anyway, that's my 2 cents as a person who found /b/ and reddit separately and has enjoyed them both for separate reasons.

11
EverybodyNobody•

...and my disappointment with reddit is now lessened because I found a well written comment that eloquently sums up the situation. Such a strange place, this internet is.

19
Fat_Dumb_Americans•

I'll enjoy while it lasts because payola will kill it and a little part of reddit died today.

12
[deleted]•

Libertarians are libertarians because they don't like other people having power over their lives.

Then they shouldn't use sites that have moderation. QED

4chan is right over there.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

36
TheEllimist•

Libertarians are libertarians because they want a minimal amount of interference in their lives. If they didn't want any, they'd be anarchists.

23
Grue•

May I suggest Usenet? It's about time people realized the alternative was here all along.

1
lolbacon•

Asking the admins to intervene and remove a moderator from a privately-created subreddit seems pretty antithetical to the libertarian ethos.

8
AbsoluteTruth•

This would be a good post if you had read what she actually does for a living. She's a consultant on proper self-promotion. Not a spammer.

1
Sunny_McJoyride•

Reddit is full of libertarians who naturally chafe at moderation.

I think that's about right. The official views of the reddit admins of what reddit is is not the same as the views of a large proportion of redditors.

These redditors are assuming that reddit should work the way they want it to, or imagined it to work and are now getting pissed off because it doesn't and because the reddit admins have no intention of making it do so.

As usual a few people will quit forever, a few will quit for a while and come back, and in the mean time, the number of subscribers to sub-reddits which Saydrah is a moderator will keep on going up. So actually, while there are outraged libertarians, a lot of other people couldn't care less.

1
AlSweigart•

who is quite obviously spamming for profit, however indirectly

But she isn't profiting from it at all nor is she "spamming" outside of accepted reddiquette. The only AC posts she puts up are on subreddits she doesn't moderate. (Her AMA: "In fact I'll go a step further and state that I will refuse to submit anything related to me or my employer to any Reddit I moderate. I don't think I've done so in the past, though there might be one or two exceptions I've forgotten about.")

I haven't found any going through her submissions.

The problem is that people's idea of what's going on is a far bigger demon than what is actually going on. People hear "spammer" and automatically think the situation is much worse than it really is.

0
[deleted]•

A conflict of interest does not require a smoking gun. Merely the situation where such an abuse of power can occur.

13
FromTheIvoryTower•

A witchhunt of this scale really should require a smoking gun, but people are also stupid, which is how this situation has occurred.

0
[deleted]•

How do you know she hasn't deleted any of those other submissions when she was found out? I'd assume that would be the first thing to do in order to cover up your tracks... aside from calling 90% of Reddit "shitheads," that is.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
noveltyaccountscore•

9/10

-1
zem•

personally, i'd be very disappointed if the reddit admins (or anyone!) did anything to remove saydrah's mod status. if she had been demodded for the whole duck house incident, i'd have been the first to cheer for it, but saying that she should be demodded for a potential conflict of interest or (to quote an especially egregious phrase i've seen someone use), "to avoid even the appearance of impropriety" sickens me. there is no evidence that saydrah has misused her "moderator powers" in service of her career. whatever happened to "innocent until proven guilty"?

-1
[deleted]•

You're kidding yourself.

And you don't need a smoking gun for conflict of interest, just the appearance of impropriety.

Though, in my opinion, the fact that it has been demonstrated she bans users for profiting off their popular submissions in ways acceptable to the community, yet submits her companies articles and content while on their salary...and claims it's OK because she's paid a general salary, and not "paid per post".

3
zem•

no, i'm not kidding myself. i am just disgusted that reddit-as-a-whole seems to feel that "the appearance of impropriety" is something we need to pay actual, punitive attention to. i know that this happens in the "real world", and often for compelling if not good reasons, but i thought we could afford[1] a saner culture than that.

[1] the reason the real world cannot "afford" to sit by until a potential conflict of interest develops into a real one is that there is often a lot at stake, and irreversible consequences to a mistake. reddit both has less at stake, and the ability to maintain full audit trails and undo mistakes after the fact (e.g. raldi mentioned reexamining the cr3 ban; this is one of the better-known blots on the reddit escutcheon, and it was done by an admin, and it can still be fixed long after the fact)

0
xinu•

potential conflict of interest

almost all conflict of interest is potential. if it were not, it would be abuse or fraud

"innocent until proven guilty"

while she may not have misused her mod powers to directly make money off it, it is impossible for us to know if she let other AC content through the filter (or simply did not ban it in the first place) because it was AC content.

she has also been shown she has abused her mod powers to ban submissions she alone has a problem with (while the community does not) while submitting similar things herself. hypocrisy is not something to be taken lightly from people in positions of power, no matter how powerless.

2
zem•

she has also been shown she has abused her mod powers to ban submissions she alone has a problem with (while the community does not)

so she's a crappy mod. the admins have repeatedly said they aren't going to police that

while submitting similar things herself.

evidence? either way, the admins aren't policing that either. the suggested remedy is to go start a better subreddit. (and if you have any ideas in that direction, do share them)

1
mossyskeleton•

I think Saydrah and the other mods have been extremely reasonable. The hive is scary as fuck.

-5
Im-Lying•

As a libertarian on Saydrah's side, I'm insulted. Don't ruin the good libertarian name by associating us with this witch hunt. I'm not against moderation, I'm against compulsive moderation. See that big "create your own subreddit" button on the right? It instantly eases all my fears. I can get away from any potential shitty moderation if I see fit.

That said, it probably wouldn't hurt if Reddit was designed with a little more transparency in regards to the moderators' actions. But even without this, any reasonable person should be able to see that 1) the moderator's tools are not THAT powerful, and 2) Saydrah most likely did not abuse them. After all, Saydrah's fellow mods back her up. Reddit's admins back her up. Her story is dumb enough to be true. What the hell else do you people need?

-7
shakbhaji•

See that big "create your own subreddit" button on the right? It instantly eases all my fears. I can get away from any potential shitty moderation if I see fit.

In theory. In practice? Good luck getting more than 10 subscribers.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
pupdike•

Thanks for pointing this out.

I still haven't heard a good response to this point by anybody official and that isn't a good sign.

I still want to think those in power will eventually understand why this is frustrating to common users.

31
junkit33•

I'm convinced that they understand, they just don't care, for reasons most of us are not privy to.

23
[deleted]•

I'm guessing this site, outside of a few normal user created subreddits appealing to niche crowds, gets a shockingly large % of its content from so called 'power users', that is people who directly profit from reddit's eyeballs. Its also why its in their interest to keep the quality of things like AskReddit and IamA high. Come for the interviews, stay for the SEO targetted links!

3
pupdike•

I think you may have nailed it here.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-5
junkit33•

Sorry - you were pointed out the direct evidence in an earlier thread and ignored it. I have nothing further to discuss with people who either can't see the obvious or think that spamming is not a bad thing.

EDIT:

don't care why their users are upset (which sounds unreasonable)

They clearly don't, and I'm not sure why that is surprising. Often times businesses simply sit and wait for things like this to blow over. If they cared it would have been addressed a lot better than it was.

I don't understand how you can make that leap.

There's no leap. The overwhelming majority of the community sees this one way, and a handful of people see it the other way. There is a reason people posting valid complaints are getting +1000 on their comments while defenses of Saydrah are getting -1000. The evidence is clear, the community has spoken, and the admins went the other way with it.

So yes - there clearly is some kind of "below board" reason why they didn't delete her account. That doesn't make it a conspiracy, or even wrong - it's their site. But don't kid yourself into believing that this was handled in an identical manner to anybody else who has ever been kicked off of this site for spamming.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

18
[deleted]•

The ideas of men's rights are perfectly sound in both concept and practice. However, due to the inherent nature of the ideas therein, men's rights movements attracts a number of characters: misogynists, victims of the system who may be too emotionally involved, and even just plain immature twats.

It's kind of like how Republicans jump on the Libertarian bandwagon when the argument suits them.

26
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
Seppuki•

The 2XC thread, was full of "outsiders" and the regulars there barely commented.

14
sakabako•

You may be underestimating how loud and sexually frustrated r/MensRights can be.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
sakabako•

I'd like to see if a small number of commenters are responsible for a majority of the anti-saydrah comments, and if so, what subreddits they're subscribed to.

5
acousticcoupler•

Personally I think calling the members of r/MensRights sexually frustrated is both uncalled for and hurtful.

0
junkit33•

I've never even heard of /mensrights, and the concept seems kind of silly to me. I definitely don't think that has anything to do with anything.

-1
sumzup•

The concept is certainly not silly...there are legitimate issues that Men's Rights movements are concerned with, and I think it's wrong to dismiss it out of hand.

I do agree with you, though, that r/MensRights has nothing to do with this Saydrah situation.

1
[deleted]•

I've never even heard of /mensrights, and the concept seems kind of silly to me.

Whoa, men with rights. What a ridiculous concept.

1
cc81•

The concept is not silly as there are real issues that people are generally not aware of. For example there is usually a big bias against men in custody battles. But the /mensrights/ itself is not something good, it is a pretty sucky place with weird people in it.

0
[deleted]•

Well put.

I did some research on the ethics of conflicts of interest in professional and academic literature, and presented my case here. 'Twas too long to put into a quote.

1
HazierPhonics•

*its

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
norm_•

The fact that we need moderators never made sense to me.

There are sites/servers in this world that process more data than reddit does daily and are run on scripts.

The main difference between a data-crunching server and reddit is probably the human involvement. On that; there is a reporting mechanism for community control.

I don't know what that report feature does, but if I was the one coding it, I would automate everything.

If a user has more karma, his/her report carries more weight.

If a reporting burst in the last 30 minutes was received, delete the post and issue a warning with the possibility to appeal.

Keep a log of reports for the last month and if an appeal goes through, investigate into who reported it and why it was done. Was it a botnet? Were there a group of sockpuppets unleashed for personal vendetta?

That requires only local moderators that are only allowed to investigate and a bunch of global moderators who will do the actual enforcing.

After this weekend, I am beginning to form conspiracy theories specialized for reddit. Report and Search are two broken features of the site and I think there is a purpose to that.

0
Poromenos•

Maybe you should become a mod for a while. Report and the post being bannable or not have no correlation. All the reported posts I've seen were innocuous, even if they had multiple reports, while the posts that needed to be banned (personal data et al) were never reported.

Don't get me started on the filter, it's false positive county.

19
norm_•

I won't do that again. Being a moderator of any kind on the net is nothing but asking for trouble.

Fresh admins usually get drunk with newfound power, then start crying wolf when they are caught bending the rules. This weekend was nothing new, but there were a lot of newcomers in this one.

How can the two have no correlation? If you think it should be removed from this site, report it. Simple as that. Your opinion will be shared or not is something entirely different.

We make the website self-sorting when casting our votes, why aren't we trusted to moderate ourselves? I can't find a reason for that.

edit : for clarification; i am a creator and moderator of 2 subreddits for more than 6 months. I have received a total of one moderator question. If one of them gets big enough to need moderating, I am asking someone else to do the job.

-2
Poromenos•

I don't know why, I just know that whenever someone has reported a post, it was because they couldn't downmod hard enough, not because the post was bad. Or maybe it was by mistake, I don't know. It doesn't work for removing the posts, though.

5
[deleted]•

I dunno, I believe there is some value in human mods. I'm also not a math or science person, so it could have a lot to do with my own personal bias. It just seems like it would be too easy to squelch a controversial discussion that way. Just because someone has a lot of comment karma does not always mean they're acting in good faith.

Also, they really do add something intangible that I can't put into words, but I don't think something like r/AMA, arguably one of the biggest traffic drivers to this place, could exist without humans moderating.

edited: spelling

9
norm_•

The first rule any admin needs to follow is; "Don't get involved."

Squelching a conversation by flashing your admin badge will do one of two things;

1 - The Gollum types will say what a magnificent creature you are, then continue being trolls the moment you turn your back.

2 - Valuable members of the community who are offended by your "I am the boss here, cease & desist!" attitude will start to lose faith.

At the end of the day, it's not the trolls who drive the traffic, it is the members who create the content, who do interesting things.

Bash 4chan all you want, but I have never seen the level of creativity displayed there in anything else. That site creates something new with every few posts.

Reddit already started to succumb to repetitiveness.

-1
[deleted]•

You hear that mods? You could be replaced with machines.

4
FillInTheBlank•

You can be replaced with a machine yourself.

Moderation is mostly taken care of by a machine anyway.

2
norm_•

Almost everyone can be replaced with machines.

In fact, once we get the hang of this AI thing, there will be no reason not to.

-2
[deleted]•

Heck, why have users? YOU ALL COULD BE REPLACED, REDDITORS.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

270
[deleted]•

[deleted]

227
rightc0ast•

It's insane people are defending that.

I'm forced to think they don't know about it, and think people are worried about "potential" conflict of interest (as if potential isn't enough).

90
NotSoToughCookie•

It's insane people are defending that.

I don't think many are. Only those in her elite reddit social 'clique', die-hard fans, perhaps AC employees and everyones related sock puppets. Hivemind mitigation damage control 101.

47
FromTheIvoryTower•

lol. That's kinda impressive. No one but overly biased people can agree with her, or they're a sock puppet.
I'm going to agree with the fact that she didn't abuse her power, even if she could have, and that the other moderators who knew her and the admins are standing behind her. I don't agree with his whole 'OMFG WTF SHE HAS THE POTENTIAL TO ABUSE HER POWER BBQ" thing that the hivemind has going. Convict for actions, not doubleplus ungood futurecrime.

-2
Gravity13•

And then there's me, who isn't in any one of those categories. I'm just pissed that reddit has the fuckin' maturity level of a 15 year old.

Nobody is defending that it's cool to work for AC and also post to reddit, but I am, in fact, defending her right to do that because she found a way to make money doing what she loves - so fucking what.

There is absolutely no "conflict of interest" - being a mod has no added benefits (really, go create a subreddit and be a mod to see what I mean), it's a volunteer thing and the community, in typical internet fashion, will throw a fit until we "get our way."

I thought it was finally clearing up.

Grow the fuck up, she did absolutely nothing to hurt you.

-34
insomniac84•

I would not doubt if other mods are afraid to speak out because it will get them kicked off reddit. It is clear reddit is protecting her due to a business relationship between her employer and conde nast.

4
[deleted]•

Yeah, I messaged the moderators regarding Saydrah, and qgyh2, PhilxBefore, and karmanaut (all prominent redditors) have absolutely no problem with letting her stay on and they all claim she didn't break any of the rules. So the mods are all in on it, and they don't care one bit. I'm guessing all of them get some kind of kick back or are in a similar boat as Saydrah.

72
[deleted]•

Kickbacks? Fuck, I knew it! I want in on the kickbacks!

27
dearsomething•

You haven't been getting your kickbacks? We need to fix this, ASAP.

7
kwelstr•

Wake up sheeple!!!

1
pablozamoras•

an interesting accusation. I'm not joining in on it (or upvoting it), but it's interesting nonetheless.

16
typographicalerror•

You fuck goats.

Well, isn't that an interesting accusation up there?

-10
Gareth321•

I think they're worried unique content won't be posted often enough and their traffic will begin to diminish. I like to think that dismissing the users will lead to a far worse backlash in terms of morale and traffic.

5
FromTheIvoryTower•

And you'll probably be wrong. I'd be seriously offended if they decreased the unique content to bend to a lynch mob.

0
FromTheIvoryTower•

lol... *Everyone with actual evidence or actually knew her: * She didn't do anything wrong and hasn't abused her power.

ChantryChantry: OMG INSIDE JOB, WAKE UP SHEEPLE!

0
[deleted]•

PRECISELY

2
mensrea•

The modding here is generally poor IMHO.

-2
shadowsurge•

Or because she legitimately did nothing wrong and reddit is throwing a shit fit because that's what they're good at.

-3
wardrox•

the mods are all in on it

If you have a problem, vote with your ad-views. I know of at least one alternative.

-5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

After seeing this and knowing for a fact that she is doing exactly what she is reprimanding that user for doing, I have a hard time just letting it go.

QFE because I think this has become the crux of the argument.

59
[deleted]•

[deleted]

20
emmster•

No. But it could have, and apparently, that's enough for some people.

-7
[deleted]•

Thus the definition of conflict of interest.

17
probably2high•

What makes everyone think she hasn't already started a new "trust building" account? She has clearly lost all credibility as "Saydrah" within the community. I'm sure she knows this. Now the next logical step would be to start a new account, rinse, and repeat.

12
insomniac84•

Except she knows her account is being protected by a relationship between her employer and the reddit staff. I would not doubt other moderators have been told to not get involved and leave her alone or they will themselves be banned.

5
zem•

ok, the Saydrah Incident has officially hit its nadir. you can all go home now.

1
smpx•

As an attempt to prevent this kind of thing repeating itself, I asked if it would be ok to add a new reddiquette rule, was given a go-ahead, and then made a post about it here to see if people had any major objections.

2
mensrea•

Argggggh! That voice!!!

1
noveltyaccountscore•

10/10

1
Ma8e•

she is doing exactly what she is reprimanding that user for doing

I have yet to see any proofs for that is what she is doing.

-1
[deleted]•
1
smpx•

Actually, reddit does have a problem with it. MMM was just removed as a moderator because he confessed to using reddit for SEO/profit.

Let me repeat that: MMM, a less popular moderator, was just kicked off as a moderator for gaming Reddit for profit, while Saydrah has not, even though she has confessed to doing the exact same.

Edit: MMM has contacted me with more information-- he said he removed himself from moderator status ahead of time because of the potential conflict of interest, and has been posting all of his SEO-related content under a full-disclosure username of "amazon_associate". He also did not brag about his actions, but rather discussed it in private with his friends.

Edit 2: So there seems to be some conflicts between variations of the sides of the story. I don't mean to spread false information, merely interpreting and communicating information I receive-- please take the information above with a pinch of salt as there seems to be a game of telephone being played here...and I'm the telephone. Read krispykrackers reply below for more information.

173
Jamon•

archived('c0let2n')

35
[deleted]•

[deleted]

29
smpx•

Funny thing, actually-- Saydrah was reported to r/reportthespammers and... the moderators there actually decided that Saydrah is indeed an official spammer.

But does this mean she will step down? No.

25
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
kwelstr•

Politics is made up of two words: -Poli- which is Greek for -many-, and -tics- which are bloodsucking insects --Gore Vidal

5
krispykrackers•

MMM has contacted me with more information-- he said he removed himself from moderator status ahead of time because of the potential conflict of interest

Wow um... that is 100% a lie.

He was removed and banned from /pics and /comics by another mod after being found out bragging about gaming reddit on his facebook page, and after some discussion amongst the mods in /modtalk. I won't link to it because I don't believe in sharing personal information with the public, but it was not "discussion". He even goes in to detail with his facebook friends on how he did it through Amazon affiliate accounts using a referral link, the best things to sell, how you should word your title, and basically dancing the jig to how much money he made overnight.

He removed himself from some smaller subreddits (RelationshipAdvice being one, and I don't remember the others) after about a day after he was removed from the others, and after he was invited to finally weigh in on the discussion in private. He hadn't yet, and we wanted to get his side of the story. He basically apologized, removed himself from some other smaller subreddits, and basically said he wouldn't consider himself a moderator anymore. It was all quite honest and genuine, but when I hear that he's going to people in private and lying about how things went down... well, that's not cool.

I'm not trying to create more drama. I'm just tired of his using you all to spread his false claims.

Saydrah's situation is different, and is still under discussion.

Is that better for moderator transparency?

23
mrmaster2•

While I think this "controversy" is overblown, it is disturbing how none of the mods/admins have addressed the point that Saydrah has banned users for doing the exact same thing she does.

Instead, the mods go after the easy point, that Saydrah has not affected Reddit's algorithim to artificially boost her submissions.

Why can't someone confirm/deny Saydrah's perceived abuse of power in banning users for engaging in her exact activites?

27
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
jedberg•

reddit and AC have no relationship.

41
glengyron•

Not directly, but AC were a sponsor of the reddit Fantastic Voyager trip which is a link to many people.

And Saydrah did organize it.

The blog about the voyage makes it clear that reddit didn't participate directly of course. Although clearly the voyage was a great community building experience for reddit.

81
TheUltimateDouche•

WHATEVER MAN. WE ALL KNOW THE TRUTH:

  • REDDIT AND AC HAD SEX AND NOW THEY ARE IN LOVE

  • SAYDRAH IS REALLY P-DUB'S MOTHER AND THEY USED ALL THAT CASH TO BUY ATV'S AND POT

  • THE HAITI MONEY YOU ALL COLLECTED JUST WENT TO DOWNLOADING MORE RAM

WE'RE JUST SICK OF THE LIES, MAN. COME CLEAN.

10
KeyserSosaOP•

AC probably has some kind of contract with Reddit.

At least keep your accusations outside the realm of outright bullshit.

Then again, clearly no admin can ever be believed.

15
[deleted]•

Do you think, generally speaking, that people should take everything someone says at face value when that person has a profit motive?

I don't agree with the comment you linked to, but neither do I think the author of the comment is wrong in not fully trusting you. You haven't earned it.

71
SVTBert•

I hope you saw the sarcasm in that, and were just going along with the joke rather than mocking them, heh.

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

It's interesting that you didn't deny the other points written by users above your comment.

1
andrewinmelbourne•

I feel sorry for you guys who have to deal with shit like this.

0
[deleted]•

You know what? Accusations like this occur when people's legitimate concerns are not answered. When you bury a statement that in no way addresses the underlying issue in a blog post about some generic programming stuff you don't exactly inspire confidence in the community.
If you want to stop accusations, maybe you should speak frankly about the whole thing instead of regurgitating boilerplate policy statements and vague generalizations.

0
smpx•

How so? I just found out about this.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

38
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
dearsomething•

MMM lost his moderatorship in IAmA for double-dealing behind other moderators backs. In addition to his recent "release" from several subreddits, he did it himself, in response to offenses far, far more egregious than what Saydrah is being blamed for, as pointed out by krispykrackers

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

12
dotrob•

Actually, the more it just makes me cry.

15
addandsubtract•

...and is full of sarcasm.

0
[deleted]•

He was removed and banned from r/pics and r/comics prior to his stepping down from the others.

9
KeyserSosaOP•

Define "reddit". The mods keep their own house and we admins had nothing to do with kicking MMM from those reddits, and he was convicted by his peers on 3 separate occasions, as you can see from the very comment you linked.

5
smpx•

Actually, I really didn't mean the administration-- you guys have always chosen to let the users define the direction, only providing the mechanism by which we do it-- and I'm truly greatful for this. Honestly, you guys created an amazing system and the way that you guys keep it up is fantastic. "Reddit" refers to the collective, the users as well as the moderators (and in that regard, the admins as well).

This is why the administrators standing up for Saydrah specifically seems somewhat odd, since it's not typically the style to interfere either way. I understand that it was to stop people from posting personal info, which I think is fantastic.

So why not impose a new guideline (not a rule), that those who could use it for profit should not be in a significant power position? It seems to fit the rest of reddit's spirit (i.e. stopping a user from gaming the system for more votes)-- here's where you guys can take a stand and help the system. Add a note into reddiquette that it's preferred for those whose careers involve social marketing to not be moderators in subreddits that could be heavily gamed in their favor for profit.

Edit: By the way, I didn't mean it as a rhetorical question, I'm really asking if this could be done, and your opinion on it, since it would fit perfectly into the current spirit of reddit (i.e. not gaming it for profit) and be incredibly easy to implement.

44
DubDubz•

But what about a programmer being the mod for a programming subreddit, or an engineer being the mod of an engineering subreddit or an atheist being the mod of an atheist subreddit? The list could go on.

My point is that no matter what the mod will have some sort of bias or conflict of interest. You can't stop that. The only way around it is to do what the admins said and make your own community away from the "corrupt" mods. Although, how are we going to be able to trust you won't do the same?

1
zem•

how do you define moderating a subreddit as a "significant power position" in such a way that it doesn't conflict with "you create a subreddit, you mod it"?

1
pjd9000•

Keyser, banning competitors isn't being impartial. Just how in depth did your "investigation" go?

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
AnnArchist•

MMM was apparently removed for threatening in a PM to expose IAMA's personal information. Once that threat is made, regardless of the rhyme or reason, its fairly necessary to ensuring the integrity of IAMAs that particular event never happens.

4
smpx•

That was just for IAmA, actually (from about 3 months ago). He was later removed from other subreddits he was moderating as well just a couple days ago.

4
AnnArchist•

Did not know that part..... what caused that removal?

3
sidewalkchalked•

MMM is also a very good rapper. I have never seen Saydrah rap, but MMM threw down pretty well in my rap battle. See? This is evidence people. All Saydrah did was ask to translate my sick verse into "white guy." Weak.

I say we all pour out a 40 oz for MMM.

3
Ma8e•

even though she has confessed to doing the exact same.

I must have missed that confession. Could you please point out where it is?

2
wardrox•

I like you add the edit, but then don't remove the inaccurate statement in bold.

0
smpx•

I dislike posts that edit out their original comment. At worst, it's kind of dishonest, and at best it loses the context for the replies. As a side note, another comment informed me that he was kicked off as well as stepped down, so I guess now both statements are true!

2
jedberg•

We don't care why you are submitting a link. We only care whether or not you cheated and if the community likes your stuff.

If you are submitting because you found it interesting, great. If it's your uncle's wife's roommate's favorite website, great. If you got paid to submit it, meh.

Did you cheat? Did you pay people to vote for it? No? Then fine. If real, legitimate users are upvoting the content, then clearly that is something the community wants to see. Your motivation for submitting is irrelevant.

We (reddit the company) don't take money from anyone ever to put a link at the top, unless it has been specially marked as a sponsored link.

Saydrah does not cheat to get her content seen -- the community votes for it. Sometimes it is because someone paid her to submit it. We have not seen any indication that she abuses her moderator powers. Sometimes she may make a bad decision, but it isn't because she was paid.

In the end, it is up to the other moderators of those communities to decide if they want to keep her. We didn't create the communities -- they are not ours.

We just provide the platform. In the course of doing that, we try to help out by removing spam, but ultimately that is in the hands of the moderators (not us admins).

86
SVTBert•

Interesting. Is this a recently implemented policy (i.e. a day ago) or is there some other explanation for this then?

174
Quel•

Oh snap.

76
wuddersup•

DOUBLE SNAP.

24
[deleted]•

the silence is deafening.

30
[deleted]•

Nice work, guy. I don't understand where the Reddit moderators became this kind of European-style inbred aristocracy where everyone is somehow related to each other. They've closed ranks, they say shit like "I only care what the other moderators think, not you people", and they've refused to remove Saydrah. I'm going to leave for the shores of Hacker News if this shit isn't cleared up.

17
sidewalkchalked•

I think a lot of people will leave if this shit keeps up. The only reason I tolerate reddit's bullshit is because I felt it was a legit community, and as such, organic. If I start sniffing that people are making money off this shit, I'm out, because that brings in the motivation to appeal to the lowest common denominator. Reddit WILL get stupider if this is allowed.

4
insomniac84•

Wow, even knothing was overruled in this case. Amazing. Her boss must be chummy with the CEO of conde nast.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
NSNick•

I'm guessing that would be that "cheating" jedberg was talking about, but I'm just guessing.

1
jedberg•

This has always been the policy. Alexis was trying to be nice in explaining to that blatant spammer why he had been banned. There was a lot more to that situation than you can see.

-27
SVTBert•

Reading over his comments in the submission he got banned for, he certainly didn't seem like a "blatant" spammer. Rather than just posting a spam submission and leaving it alone he actually participated in the discussion and answered questions that were asked. Seemed pretty down to earth to me.

And if his reasons for submitting a link aren't important, what exactly made him a spammer, and what was blatant about it? Further, how is that any more blatant than having a job that's sole purpose is to submit content to 3rd party media sites?

Sorry if I'm coming across as a dick here, and to bother you with questions, but I'm curious.

61
Fat_Dumb_Americans•

We don't care why you are submitting a link.

@cr3 Like I said, you were banned for violating site guidelines. Viral marketing may pay your bills, but the community doesn't care for it

This has always been the policy.

We have always been at war with spammers.

12
redditsoldout•

Some people are just more equal than others, right?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
NotSoToughCookie•

Saydrah does not cheat to get her content seen -- the community votes for it. Sometimes it is because someone paid her to submit it.

I disagree. She admitted in her video that she contributes, builds relationships and a following to gain acceptance into communities. She's admitted she has worked at it. And she was successful.

People definitely like her, and will upvote her stuff regardless of the actual content. That's exactly what she was bragging about in her video.

Technically, that's the worst form of "cheating". It's social manipulation. And you're saying you are ok with it... It's a sad day. A day filled with revelations, but sad nonetheless.

71
Kitchenfire•

A sad day that makes me await a replacement for this site.

29
[deleted]•

Well, you can just go to Digg and don't add any friends. Then you'll be cheated and manipulated less. They only have powerusers there.

2
jedberg•

She is a member of this community with a following. She got that way by working very hard making this community a place people enjoy. The fact that she did it for money somewhat sullies that, but I'll be honest -- I've talked to her over private message, and she loves this community. I'm pretty sure she would do it without getting paid for it.

The fact that she has a following is something that happens in real life and is unavoidable. Steve Jobs has one too -- but that doesn't mean that Apple doesn't make stuff people like. Some people buy it because they like Steve Jobs, some people buy it because they like the gear.

And you're saying you are ok with it... It's a sad day. A day filled with revelations, but sad nonetheless.

Why is that sad? Because we allow people to participate and build a following? How could we even prevent such a thing? And furthermore, how do you know that we don't already?

2
NotSoToughCookie•

She got that way by working very hard making this community a place people enjoy.

I don't disagree. She definitely did contribute to the community. I don't doubt she's a true reddit addict. She's an asset here.

However, her actions, leadership role and employment have conflict of interest. It taints our community as a whole.

If she would have announced her relationship with associated content much earlier, there would not have been this kind of blow back. That was her greatest mistake. Or employers.

Because we allow people to participate and build a following?

Building a following is OK. If it's your job too, it's not. It's dishonest.

How could we even prevent such a thing?

Moderators of the most popular subreddits should not be involved with social media to keep reddit honest. How do keep it honest you ask? You tell me. You were aware of saydrah's actions and the potential for conflict of interest for quite some time and did nothing about it.

And furthermore, how do you know that we don't already?

I believe you allow it, if not promote it. Personalities are the new staple of social media. Do you deny it? Which (again dons tinfoil hat) is why you admins are soundly backing Saydrah in spite of overwhelming evidence.

25
PHermas•

Everybody knows Steve Jobs works for Apple, and measure what he says about them accordingly.

...she loves this community. I'm pretty sure she would do it without getting paid for it.

That very well might be true, but apparently is not the case. Just because you like your job doesn't mean you don't have obligations to fulfill.

14
Kitchenfire•

She is a member of this community with a following. She got that way by working very hard making this community a place people enjoy. The fact that she did it for money somewhat sullies that, but I'll be honest -- I've talked to her over private message, and she loves this community. I'm pretty sure she would do it without getting paid for it.

Just like politicians, right?

6
Xet•

I've talked to her over private message, and she loves this community.

Yes, but apparently only 10% of the community.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
NSNick•

It's a lot harder to conclusively say someone has socially manipulated a system than to prove they cheated it in other ways.

1
resonanttoe•

The worst form of cheating is apparently what is also the best form of being a community member?

Everything that you described is what you would applaud in an unpaid member. It doesn't make sense.

Personally, I don't particularly much care. Its a trivial issue for the rest of us. I err on the side of the admins that it isn't their job or responsibility. I didn't even know of a Saydrah before all of this bollocks and I can't say after tonight that I will know of a Saydrah again.

1
NotSoToughCookie•

The difference is, she has elevated authority thanks to modship, and her contributions to the community are questionable because it's part of her job.

There are people who have authority, and contribute just as much, if not more and are not "paid" nor brag about how successful they are about it in interviews.

2
ycc2106•

where is that video?

1
shadowsurge•

People definitely like her, and will upvote her stuff regardless of the actual content.

So? It's social-media, if people like it, they upvote it, if they don't, they downvote it. Whatever reason they choose for doing so is their's and their's alone, such is democracy. All I've seen the past few days are people bitching about how their personal preferences aren't being served, and as such some great injustice has been committed.

Thank you Jedberg, KeyserSosa, and all the rest for handling this all in a level-headed responsible manner, instead of engaging in the mindless internet rage that seems to have been prevalent the last few days.

Now commence the downvotes!

0
rvf•

Technically, that's the worst form of "cheating". It's social manipulation.

Then why are you here? Reddit is all about social manipulation. How many news headlines are upvoted into the thousands when if you actually read the linked article you'd realize the link title was sensationalist bullshit? How many people are commenting in this thread due to merely being told of what has happened rather than finding out for themselves?

EDIT: Nice downvotes. The truth hurts, doesn't it?

-1
NotSoToughCookie•

Then why are you here? Reddit is all about social manipulation.

Because moderators should be setting the standard, not contributing the mess. They should be trying to actively minimize it. It's a conflict of interest when a mod is one of said spammers. The more vetted the mods are, the more trustworthy the system.

I don't care if she spams. I care that (this is key) she's a mod and actively trying to pander the community to get away with it as proven by her video. It's her job to befriend you, and get you to like her. She admitted that. I say cool, she's done an amazing job. But should she remain in power?

7
mrmaster2•

Exactly. This whole "controversy" is laughable. At least 50% of Reddit - the big reddits anyway - is full of biased, sensationalist garbage.

For all I know, the stuff that Saydrah submits is some of the better content.

People seem to be under the delusion that all of Reddit is made of rainbows, and Saydrah is the omnious black cloud.

0
flashgasoline•

She admitted in her video that she contributes, builds relationships and a following to gain acceptance into communities. She's admitted she has worked at it. And she was successful. People definitely like her, and will upvote her stuff regardless of the actual content. That's exactly what she was bragging about in her video.

You could say the same thing of Karmanaut or any other well known redditor. People that use the site more are going to have more influence. You can't avoid that and probably shouldn't.

-2
NotSoToughCookie•

Karmanaut - 4,179 link karma

Saydrah* - 79,429 link karma

(* = after massive downmod brigade)

Karmanaut isn't spamming reddit for money. He barely submits anything at all in comparison. You're comparing apples to oranges.

17
headinthesky•

If you're upvoting her stuff because you see her name on it, then it's not social manipulation, it just makes you an idiot for blaming her for that.

-2
[deleted]•

Just like the Germans were idiots for being manipulated by Hitler.

1
academician•

Do you deny that she provided value to the community, regardless of her motivations?

If someone gives me value, I don't really care if they did it for a million dollars or nothing. In fact, I'm actually kind of happy when people get rewarded for doing good things rather than for being assholes. I don't call contributing content that redditors find valuable to be acting like an asshole.

At the same time, it doesn't seem that Saydrah's membership in the reddit community was ever disingenuous. Just because you get paid to do something doesn't mean that you don't love it in its own right. Don't we all want a job doing what we love?

-5
NotSoToughCookie•

The activity in comments might have been genuine but still ultimately furthering her goal. To become a staple of our community which allows people to promote her to modship, which she then can take advantage of.

Once a mod, you can create sock puppets which to spam from an unban if caught by the spam filter. This is not traceable by other mods. Since she works in the business of social media, it's a severe conflict of interest.

So while her intentions to contribute may be genuine, her video asserting her mastery over reddit combined with being a mod is disingenuous at best, and a severe conflict of interest.

8
locuester•

People definitely like her, and will upvote her stuff regardless of the actual content.

If that's the case, why is it her fault? If you see bad content, down vote it. Just because she's popular isn't a reason to stone her.

-6
NotSoToughCookie•

It's her job to contribute and befriend you in hopes you will upvote her stuff, regardless of content. That's her hook. If you don't see what is wrong with that, I'm not sure what else to say.

11
wtfrara•

Just because she's popular isn't a reason to stone her.

Sure it is! *cough* *cough* P-dub *cough* *cough*

5
[deleted]•

Just because she's popular isn't a reason to stone her.

You don't get the good crowds when stoning people no one's ever heard of.

3
insomniac84•

I think you are seeing this backwards.

Just because she is popular isn't a reason not to stone her.

0
emmster•

Do we not all contribute, comment, build relationships, and try for acceptance into the community? (Trolls excepted of course.) It's different because we do it for fun rather than money? Why?

-6
NotSoToughCookie•

Do you believe the kids from the Big Bang Theory are actual geniuses because they play one on show and entertain you? It's one thing to be an actor and everyone knows it. It's quite another to pretend to be something you are not. Saydrah admitted to using these tactics in her video.

It's different because doing it for money is deceptive and dishonest. Doing it out of the goodness of your heart is not.

14
bonoes•

She's banning people for doing what she's doing.

61
jedberg•

We haven't seen any evidence of that. And if she is, then it is up to the other moderators to call her out on it and remove her.

-16
verifythisforme•

Please take off your rose-coloured glasses. There has been plenty of posts in the past day on this issue and the anger of the other redditors is due to the lack of transparency and double standard of this particular person. Your lack of acknowledgment of the sentiment is showing disrespect to my fellow redditors. Please be up front and honest in what you do here on reddit so that we can all decide.

Considering that mods are the ones with the power, they should disclose their associations as to what may be perceived as a conflict of interest. We don't accept that from our politicians and we certainly do not accept it from the mods. We are not idiots.

Make it a rule that mods should disclose that they are paid for submissions. I see this as a way out.

Please learn from this and move on.

18
KoNP•

I'm not willing to say this with the eloquence of verifythisforme, but it needs to be said.

YOU ARE A FUCKING IDIOT. We provided you the evidence over the last 2 days and you have predictably looked the other way.

6
jiggle_billy•

I'm not worried about it, because although it's bullshit, it's your business if you want to let spam in and let it overrun the place like someone's forgotten Yahoo webmail account. Your site will be just another web carcass and that's fine with me. I can post links and argue with trolls anywhere once this site is gone or rendered entirely unusable.

Considering that MMM was chased off for the very same thing (by the mod in question, no less), I suspect that she has a personal relationship with some of you.

37
jedberg•

I suspect that she has a personal relationship with some of you.

She has as much a relationship with us as any other active user.

6
jiggle_billy•

Does that mean then that you are explicitly denying that she has any sort of personal relationship with anyone who works for reddit, to the best of your knowledge?

I understand that what you said sounds like that, but "as much as" does not always mean "no more than".

And a side point: you guys have declared open season for spammers. I'm suprised that you think this will end well.

16
FromTheIvoryTower•

lol... wow. Thanks, captain hyperbole. I think there's a situation a million billion times worse somewhere else for you to deal with. If the spam is interesting and gets upvoted, it's good, and I, for one, will continue to come here to see it. As will the supermajority of people who come here for interesting links.

1
Gravity13•

I'm not worried about it, because although it's bullshit, it's your business if you want to let spam in and let it overrun the place like someone's forgotten Yahoo webmail account

Is that really what's happening? You make it sound like Saydrah ruined your fucking Reddit, like reddit no longer works and is nothing but spam now, just because she got paid to submit links (which probably failed, except for when they were actually noteworthy and succeeded, then anybody could have posted them, if somebody gets paid for it, good on them!).

No doubt, if there was abuse, I'd be right up there with all of you. But there isn't. So shut the fuck up and move on already. No more fucking harassing people just because they slightly inconvenienced you.

-16
jiggle_billy•

Whatever asshole, anyone can see by your comment history that you're a sock puppet. You've been absolutely working overtime to try to quash this issue and responding to every criticism of her that you can find.

10
vemrion•

We have not seen any indication that she abuses her moderator powers.

And if she does her day job well, you never will. I suspect she has a ton of sockpuppets, but I can't prove it.

Personally, I'm fine with people getting paid to submit links and chat up people. That's a little sketchy, but it's 21st century marketing. However, I think it should disqualify you from ever becoming a moderator. Depending on their employer, it's either a conflict of interest or a potential one.

She can still be a valued member of the community, but when reddit and her meal-ticket fall into conflict (as they inevitably will), which do you think she will choose?

36
raldi•

We are very, very good at detecting cheating. Either Saydrah's a superhacker who's come up with a brilliant, impossible to detect sockpuppetry method that completely evades all of our defenses and even manual auditing, despite her having no computer programming experience... or she's not cheating.

Occam's Razor says it's probably the latter.

5
insomniac84•

She banned a guy for doing what she is paid to do. And then it turns out the guy wasn't doing any of that.

I fail to see how she isn't cheating.

1
DirtyHerring•

In the end, it is up to the other moderators of those communities to decide if they want to keep her. We didn't create the communities -- they are not ours.

This is the best defense for your policy I have heard so far. And I respect it.

I guess the best action for us as a community is to unsubscribe from all Saydrah moderated reddits and start replacements.

Here are are some reddits I have just unsubscribed from:

http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/

http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/

http://www.reddit.com/r/comics/

Please add to this list and post alternatives. I'm going to especially miss r/comics.

35
jiggle_billy•

Edit:

In the interest of cohension, I have removed my alternative in favor of the alternatives provided below.

Everyone unsubcribe the old ones and join the new!

8
DirtyHerring•

I have found 2 that should pretty much match what we want:

http://www.reddit.com/r/pics2

http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit2/

And founded a new one:

http://www.reddit.com/r/comics2

Co-moderators are welcome! Please apply.

22
1up•

done and done.

0
igavefoucaltaids•

if you turn a blind eye to any fiscal influence on the content that is going to be seen by most users then this is going to undermine the spirit of reddit

24
jedberg•

if you turn a blind eye to any fiscal influence on the content that is going to be seen by most users then this is going to undermine the spirit of reddit

Why? The spirit of reddit has always been to put good content in front of users. Having money involved doesn't change that, unless the money is in the form of paying for votes. That will not be tolerated.

1
callumn•

Which is not what most people have a problem with.

They do have a problem that she is abusing her moderator powers to do this.

9
[deleted]•

Why? If a subreddit chooses to allow paid-votes, I don't see an issue. Especially since the Admins have stated they are totally and completely powerless apparently.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Kitchenfire•

So I can trick a few hundred redditors into being followers, make a few pointed comments, SPAM THE FUCK out of reddit with dozens of links per day, and profit off the few that make it to the top?

Sorry, but what the hell do you guys consider spam? If one person is allowed to get away with it, why do you even have a spam filter? What is the difference between one person with a name doing it and a dozen people with random accounts? I fail to see your logic. She's not gaming the system, but she is absolutely, 100% a spammer and as far as I know, reddit doesn't allow spamming.

19
jedberg•

So I can trick a few hundred redditors into being followers, make a few pointed comments, SPAM THE FUCK out of reddit with dozens of links per day, and profit off the few that make it to the top?

No, and Saydrah doesn't do that either.

She's not gaming the system, but she is absolutely, 100% a spammer

First of all, keep in mind she isn't being paid for what she submits -- her employer pays her to do other things. Secondly, would you still call her a spammer if there were no money involved?

-1
shakbhaji•

I'm not sure why he hasn't mentioned it, but HueyPriest spoke to me on the phone a couple of days after I was hired at AC and we talked about what I'd be doing. He offered to help me by providing some data Reddit has collected about how web traffic actually improves when you stop paying based on hits.

Is that true?

First of all, keep in mind she isn't being paid for what she submits -- her employer pays her to do other things.

I'll agree that we have no proof that she gets paid to submit links to reddit, but we also have no proof that she isn't getting paid to submit links to reddit. How can you say this with any certainty and how do you know what her employer pays her for other than what she claims?

8
[deleted]•

Do your advertisers care if you knowingly let the scummy-SEO types run key parts of the site?

I also find it interesting that the Admins claim 0 ownership over any content in any subreddit. I assume then you'd respond to a DCMA takedown request the same way? or any other request from LEO? Because otherwise your just choosing to ignore what's quickly looking like a majority of your active users.

14
jedberg•

Do your advertisers care if you knowingly let the scummy-SEO types run key parts of the site?

I guess not. They see our content, they like our content, they pay to get in front of our users. How the content got there is irrelevant to them.

-1
[deleted]•

The mod in question has stated the other mods and i believe, although I could be wrong, that the admins were also aware of her employment. Does Reddit disclose to its advertisers that it is aware, and now encourages SEO-type services to use reddit, for no cost, for the benefits of their clients?

11
smpx•

I mentioned this question elsewhere, and similar sentiment has been echoed but haven't gotten an answer yet so I'll pose it again-- would you guys be willing to support some kind of addition to reddiquette, as a suggestion not a rule that those with careers in direct conflict of interest with the non-spamming spirit of reddit should refrain from taking on power positions at reddit? It would be completely within the same concept as the other anti-spamming tools in place, and you would not at all be pushing your power (as making a suggestion does not infringe upon users anyhow).

9
jedberg•

The reddiquitte is user editable, so you have the power to make that change.

I would support that.

12
smpx•

Whoa. You just blew my mind there.

Sincerely, I have never felt such tremendous respect for reddit until just now discovering that this is how much dedication you guys have to keeping this place truly defined by the user experience. Thank you for your work.

[Edit:] Changes have been made, and an announcement was made here to see if anyone had any comments or edits to advise.

7
S2S2S2S2S2•

We don't care why you are submitting a link. We only care whether or not you cheated and if the community likes your stuff.

This is really interesting to me, and it's a new perspective for me to consider. But it raises the question: What is spam, then?

In the course of doing that, we try to help out by removing spam

If paid content, filled with ads is okay, what defines spam? Is it defined strictly by group voting and other shady practices? I find that interesting because that means that no site by itself would be spam, but even an innocuous and silly image with no advertising could be, due to voting rings, et c.

7
jedberg•

Spam are links that the community doesn't like. Things that are always downvoted. The spam filter does its best to predict what will be universally unliked and removes it. Sometimes it makes a mistake, which is where the mods step in and hopefully fix that mistake.

-4
S2S2S2S2S2•

So if the community likes v1agrA and c14li$, then it's okay? If someone creates a subreddit for the purposes of filling it with advertisements and solicitations for knock-off watches and such, that'd be fine? These exist, as you know, but they are very obviously spam to me. I can't imagine not considering them as such, but maybe that's due to my lack of imagination. I'm trying to wrap my head around this.

6
Pappenheimer•

Spam are links that the community doesn't like. Things that are always downvoted.

Bullshit. The community likes the Hungarian blogspot spammer, because his stolen content is good. It's still blatant spam and you know that and try to catch him.

3
[deleted]•

Does that mean people only have to consequently mass-downmod* someone elses posts + report them for a while and then he/she'll get banned as a spammer?

edit for clarity

*mass-downmod meaning here: many people have to do it, not one person with many accounts.

2
insomniac84•

http://www.reddit.com/user/Saydrah/submitted/

It would seem she has a habit of posting pictures she didn't make and does not own that are hosted by anonymous picture hosts. Considering she is paid to post here, I would say she is one giant walking copyright violation.

Yet she banned a guy for posting original pictures because she didn't like how he used adsense. Why do reddit mods police adsense? She also reported him to google to get his adsense account pulled. And wrote a message to the guy she banned outlining exactly what she does on reddit and claiming it was a bannable offense. Yet she is still not banned based on her own rules.

Now that you are officially endorsing her via your protection, you become responsible for these actions. This is why it is best to just let mods ghost her spam account and let everyone move on.

2
jedberg•

Considering she is paid to post here

As far as we know, she isn't paid to post on reddit.

Why do reddit mods police adsense?

They do what they want. The users of their communities have the choice to participate in that community or not.

Now that you are officially endorsing her via your protection, you become responsible for these actions.

We are not endorsing her actions. We simply said that she hasn't violated any rules and that posting her personal info wasn't cool

Yet she is still not banned based on her own rules.

Perhaps someone should notify the mods where she is submitting.

This is why it is best to just let mods ghost her spam account and let everyone move on.

They are free to ban her from their reddits if they so choose. We will not stop them. We also won't force them. It is up to them.

1
insomniac84•

As far as we know, she isn't paid to post on reddit.

She admits it in a video. You seem to be splitting hairs. When people say she is paid to post on reddit, that does in fact include being paid a salary to work for a spam house and submitting links to reddit on behalf of clients when her boss tells her to. She admits in her own words that she submits at least 4 "legit" posts for each spam post. You seem to be saying she does not get paid to post by using a narrow definition of her being paid specifically per post. Please stop the ignorance, that is not what people are talking about and technically there is no real difference.

In the end you are saying that her tactic is good enough to not look like spam so we will leave her alone. But she admits she is here to spam. So it doesn't matter what it looks like. She admitted that she is here to spam and that her legit posts are being done so she can get spam posts through undetected.

No one is accusing her of this she admitted it. It's not a witch hunt when the witch admits to being a witch.

Perhaps someone should notify the mods where she is submitting.

Come on, you definitely know by now the mods are ignoring the community and the evidence. Please don't piss on our shoes and tell us that it is raining.

They are free to ban her from their reddits if they so choose. We will not stop them. We also won't force them. It is up to them.

Except you ghosts accounts all the time. Why give this spammer special treatment? You have more than enough evidence that she is a spammer, she directly admitted it. Accounts have been ghosted for much less.

6
jedberg•

Considering she is paid to post here

As far as we know, she isn't paid to post on reddit.

Why do reddit mods police adsense?

They do what they want. The users of their communities have the choice to participate in that community or not.

Now that you are officially endorsing her via your protection, you become responsible for these actions.

We are not endorsing her actions. We simply said that she hasn't violated any rules and that posting her personal info wasn't cool

Yet she is still not banned based on her own rules.

Perhaps someone should notify the mods where she is submitting.

This is why it is best to just let mods ghost her spam account and let everyone move on.

They are free to ban her from their reddits if they so choose. We will not stop them. We also won't force them. It is up to them.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SpaizKadett•

After reading this I voted gumbasia down

0
Tromad•

Reddit has a serious mod problem and it evident that the admins don't care. At least with slashdot they have meta-moderation. Mods shouldn't be shills for other companies (look up conflict of interest as clearly few of you understand what it actually means), and a popular subreddit shouldn't be locked down by a single user. The fact that serious points have been made, with evidence, and ignored or swept under the rug by her mod (and now the admin) clique demonstrates this clearly.

56
jedberg•

Reddit has a serious mod problem and it evident that the admins don't care.

It's not that we don't care -- it is that we have a policy of self-governance. Each community is created by a user, and it is theirs to do with as they please.

They make the rules, they pick the enforcers.

If you don't like their picks, make your own community and get people to use it.

44
RagingIce•

A sound policy. Although I think that if this is the case, reddits shouldn't be officially endorsed (When you sign up, you're automatically subscribed to a number of reddits - including pics).

51
jedberg•

Although I think that if this is the case, reddits shouldn't be officially endorsed

You make a valid point. Although, we aren't really endorsing them -- it is sort of a side effect of the way the system works. We are probably going to change that in fact to get more content in front of users who haven't customized their experience.

32
DubDubz•

Then how do you advise the homepage works for people who haven't signed up?

3
unitmike•

You'd have more support if you'd posted this in the Libertarian reddit. :)

5
rightc0ast•

We love spammers. They aggregate the best content and give it to us to upvote and sort the wheat from the chaff. Our video spammer kicks ass, and we love him/her/them/it.

Though granted, I think that can only work because Sam and I don't work in social media and don't ban anyone. Not even our trolls who pretend they are the daughters of prominent LP politicians, our prolific spammers, or even the people who call us hiney-poopie-faces.

Amazing concept, I know. ^_^

0
pjd9000•

When the community is clearly having a problem, how can you stand idly by while this is occurring?

This seems like the fact you want to ignore it rather than deal with a growing problem.

Laissez-faire in this kind of situation never works.

3
jedberg•

Our policy has always been one of non-intervention.

The community will work this out itself -- it always does.

4
Jelena_Whore•

Thanks for your input.

Adblock re-enabled.

3
jedberg•

Adblock re-enabled.

That's nice.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Tromad•

Which, no offense to you, is probably one of the most retarded policies ever.

0
jedberg•

Which, no offense to you, is probably one of the most retarded policies ever.

It is what it is. That has been and always will be our policy.

8
[deleted]•

It is a brilliant policy. For me Digg failed because I didn't like the "top submitters" and that was pretty much the end of the story. Don't like then leave it, altogether.

The reddit system is very much different. Reddit treats the landscape of social media as an unlimited resource mostly because it is. If you are unhappy with any subreddit you just unsubscribe and seek out another. Will that take some effort? YES. If you can't find a suitable subreddit then you can make your own and as your VERY FIRST act you can ban saydrah. And guess what, the admins won't reverse your decision. See how elegantly that works out?

The frontier of reddit is an endless vista of possibilities. The primary reason for that is the hands off policy that admins adhere to. I don't know if they even know how brilliant the setup is or how revolutionary it is.

3
Kitchenfire•

It's not that we don't care -- it is that we have a policy of self-governance. Each community is created by a user, and it is theirs to do with as they please.

They make the rules, they pick the enforcers.

If you don't like their picks, make your own community and get people to use it.

Yeah, I'll just click the "Create community and carry-over 10,000 followers" button on the right hand side of my monitor. Oh wait, where'd that thing go? I can create a community of one, but I can't seem to find out how to move the 10,000+ subscribers over to my subreddit. Hmmmm. Wonder why?

-1
jedberg•

If your community is really better, people will follow you there. It has already happened a few times.

5
Nerdlinger•

I can create a community of one, but I can't seem to find out how to move the 10,000+ subscribers over to my subreddit. Hmmmm. Wonder why?

Because 9,800 of those 10,000 don't share the outrage that caused you to create your new community and see no point in it?

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

I've lost a lot of faith in the admins now. This Saydrah character has been using her position to favour her links she wants promoted, and the real burner is when she warns others who do the same.

31
apmihal•

I think the real issue here is that she has banned people for basically doing what she herself was doing, and for that I really don't think she should be a moderator. I don't think she should have the power to ban people when she is paid by a company that produces content that she submits. To be fair, I haven't seen any actual proof (The mere existence of a conflict of interest does not actually prove anything. What we actually know would be referred to by the dudes on Law and Order as circumstantial evidence.) that she has been paid specifically to submit a certain article, as in "we'll pay you x amount of money to submit this article." Nor do we have proof that she banned people in order to "eliminate the competition."

Other than that I don't actually see anything wrong with getting paid to submit, as long as you don't hold power. The reason for submission does not necessarily affect it's value to the community. If it's shitty, then it's downvoted, if it's good, then it's upvoted.

Also I do find it ridiculous that people think Saydrah contributes legitimately to this site for the sole purpose of disguising her spamming. Just look back at her comment and submission history, if she's trying to trick us, don't you think she's gone a little over board?

My take on this is that she means well. She wants to be part of the community, but she also wants to have a career in social media. She doesn't realize that she can't have that job, and be a moderator at the same time.

6
monoglot•

So... Reddit has no problem with users submitting links to their employer's websites (as part of their job description) and getting paid for it (in the form of a salary)...

If Peter Jackson (or someone who draws a salary from Peter Jackson) wants to post links to each scene of his Narwhals! movie as he completes it, would that be cool with you, or would that be spam?

If cool, then you're getting worked up for different reasons than you think you are.

5
pablozamoras•

If they submitted something every five minutes like she does, then yes i would consider it spam since it was taking up the new queue.

6
monoglot•

So why isn't your anger directed against the admins who set the rules for how often a veteran user/mod can submit a post?

Honestly, the outrage-o-meter is pointing in so many different incoherent directions in here it's like being at a Teabagger rally.

6
pablozamoras•

I'm not at all outraged at what you said. as a matter of fact, what you said is completely against what actually happened. being a mod gives them no extra posting power. the fact that she feigned interest in reddit just to boost the page rank of her employers is what pisses me off.

0
spammishking•

check out r/repostthespammers. Many of them submit other material, and contribute to conversations, but they just reek of disingenuous people. So I guess if a person seems genuine or as you point out really famous they should be allowed to use this site as a marketing tool. amiright?

2
the_foo_maker•

This site is a marketing tool.

3
electricboogaloo•

Peter Jackson's not a mod

1
[deleted]•

It's clearly not ok and that's not a good analogy. First, Peter Jackson is actually making something. Second, if you make something and put it on the internet, someone else needs to like it and want to tell the community. Otherwise, it's self-promotion. Peter Jackson will always have people who want to talk about him. And if he doesn't, he can go to r/somethingimade, where that kind of thing is appropriate.

0
sakabako•

Actually, depending on the subreddit, it is most likely ok. If the community likes it then it will get voted up, the motivation for posting is not important.

Peter Jackson could also make the mistake of plastering his page with ads, or of not linking directly to the images in the pics subreddit.

2
monoglot•

Clearly not ok? That's not clear to me.

1
the_foo_maker•

I wonder about this sort of thing every time I see a Geek Dad or a Wired submission. I mean Conde Nast purchased reddit for a reason. Not saying that everyone who submits Conde Nast content is spamming. Maybe it's all legit. I'm just suspicious of the way this community always seems to tell me what the great new movie is that I should see and what band is coming out with a new album and what TV show to love. I guess I just assume I'm always being marketed to on the internet.

4
jedberg•

We do not give priority to any link over another, unless it is specifically labeled as a sponsored link.

14
mrmaster2•

I think the issue isn't with the prioritizing of certain links, it's the perceived abuses of power by Saydrah.

Are you saying that you looked into the story of the guy who says he was banned by Saydrah for doing exactly what she does and you found no misconduct?

If so, then fine, but you should be more clear. Your posts are only addressing the easy issue - Reddit's algorithim - and not hitting the "unfairness" that people perceive in her banning users.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MaxEPad•

The definition of spam is subjective. If a link makes the front page, it is almost certainly not spam, regardless of the source ... simply because it is generally liked by the community.

In other words - feel free to spam us with quality sites, that's what reddit is all about!

4
SVTBert•

Except when the mods tell you not to do so, and then ban you for it. Even if it's your own stuff.

Or if you make a cool video showing off what a bunch of SSD drives can do when hooked together, and then get banned simply because you happen to work in IT for a marketing company that's sponsored by the makers of said SSD drives.

Yes, feel free to do that. The mods won't care one bit. /s

17
Eever•

I never knew he got banned for submitting that video.

7
SVTBert•
9
Nerdlinger•

So... Reddit has no problem with users submitting links to their employer's websites (as part of their job description) and getting paid for it (in the form of a salary)... as long as they disguise it by participating in discussions and submitting non-work-related links? Is that correct?

I'm cool with it.

4
KoNP•

Please define spam for us.

I'll define it for you.

Posting content at a pace that floods the submission boards with your submissions.

Unless you're a mod, in which case it's ok, because as we know, one rule for us, another rule for them.

Christ, it's like we've got our very own corrupt cop drama unfolding in our laps.

2
[deleted]•

All persons are equal here. Some are more equal than others...

5
Enoxice•

I don't call it "disguising" anything - I call it contributing to the community and maybe (I guess this is the main point of contention in all of this) making money at the same time. I see no issue there.

-1
thatguydr•

You see positive value in a guaranteed positive net contribution, even if some of it is negative. Other redditors are angry that someone who has removed people with small positive contribution (crying SPAM!) is allowed to profit from identical activities.

You are right that, overall, her small amount of spam doesn't really hurt the value of submissions here. You're wrong that there's nothing off-putting about it.

15
Enoxice•

It's true. Maybe I only see this situation in the way I do because I very rarely submit links, and do not have my own website/blog to submit links from.

7
defproc•

Personally I'm sick of money being a deciding factor in what I see and read.

3
Nerdlinger•

Too bad money's been behind pretty much anything you've ever seen and read, and it always will be.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
ScottColvin•

According to her interview at Associated Content, on Reddit the ratio is 4 random kitty submissions to 1 paid for Associated Content article, in the same breath StumbleUpon is a 20-1 ratio in her own words not be considered a spammer.

This is what settled it for me, but hey I'm just part of the 90% shithead ratio.

15
[deleted]•

90% shithead. 10% bought and paid for.

4
Enoxice•

There's no rule, as far as I'm concerned, but if she wasn't positively contributing to the community she probably wouldn't have been made a moderator in the subreddit(s?) she is. And even if she somehow managed to make a secret deal with another crooked moderator to "buy" her way in, her contributions have mostly been well-received (as far as I can tell).

The fact that she may have been making money off of this seems ancillary.

0
carelesswhisper•

I agree. I can see why people would be off put by this, sure. That being said, people need to calm down about this. I browse reddit quite a bit and could name very few "power user" type individuals, which do exist here. People voting for submissions simply because of who posts them, rather than content, are messing with the system just as well.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
PHermas•

It's fairly easy to figure out he's got a horse in this race. His reasons remain unclear as do many of his arguments.

2
Gravity13•

So we are supposed to believe, that a complete stranger, who has no stake inthis whatsoever, is willing to put their own life on hold, for almost 2 full days (at least 2 evenings) defending someone for something that 95% of the rest of reddit seems to have a problem with.

Yes. A random stranger who happens to appreciate one of the best commentors on reddit. Perhaps I was just sold the 50th time I read her commenting to somebody asking for advice about animals, relationships or just about anything, but she is a rather intelligent and mature commentor. I appreciate that, and I'm not going to throw a damn fit just because she found a way to monetize her joy - in fact, I'd congratulate that because it's quite an achievement.

By looking at your profile, you throw around the words "sexist and misogyny" almost as much as Saydrah herself.

Regarding comments calling her "bitch," "cunt," and "unattractive anyways," - well yeah that is pretty fucking misogynistic. It's no secret that reddit has a slight misogynist tendency...

Once again, I have to bring up the fact that YOU led the "witch hunt" against B34nz.

b34nz = abusive mod

Saydrah = pissed you off.

Big difference there, buddy.

Gravity13 is one of Saydrahs accounts that she used to try to get rid of b34nz after she got rid of MMM

This is stupid, I also defended MMM when his shit went down, I happen to like that guy too. In fact, somebody here apparently remembered that and then criticized me of doing that!

You're fucking stupid.

-7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
junkit33•

What I find very interesting is that precedence has now clearly been set, so if they ever try to ban a spammer in the future they are just opening themselves up to a giant lawsuit. Some clever person is going to make some good money off Reddit for this one.

-12
yasth•

What would be the grounds of a suit? Reddit is not government. They can censor what they want. They don't have to make sense. Indeed as long as they don't deny things based on a protected class they are home free.

9
junkit33•

Imagine you walk into a store and there are two identical bobbles sitting on the table for sale. You walk in and pick one up and try to purchase it, and the store says "nope - sorry - you can't have that". Then Saydrah walks into the same store, picks up the same bobble, plunks down her cash and walks out with it. There's no rhyme or reason to why that just happened, other than the story liked Saydrah better.

You simply can't do that without a valid non-discriminatory reason.

-2
yasth•

Yeah you can. You can even say, "Darling you don't pay", because someone is a friend of your cousins. You can give away discounts on your product to orphans or felons. Discrimination is an explicitly governed system. If you aren't a Protected Class for the purpose of that transaction (n.b. not all protected classes apply to all transactions). Speech regulation is by far the lightest in terms of burdensome restrictions, especially when it doesn't involve licensed use of public airwaves.

Now some of this changes under other legal systems, but really it doesn't change that much. As long as the reason isn't illegal, it is legal.

6
poopshoes•

A lawsuit for what? Moderating traffic on a privately-owned website? They can ban whomever they like for whatever reason they like, and people uncomfortable with that can take their viewership elsewhere.

7
junkit33•

When there is money at stake the game changes. To allow the same thing from one person and disallow it from another is blatant discrimination. You watch what happens. Google and Yahoo fight off these types of lawsuits all day every day.

-1
theHM•

You think Reddit has good money?

0
norm_•

Conde Nast has.

4
PHermas•

What's bad money?

2
[deleted]•

"we've "investigated" Saydrah, and we didn't find any indication of her cheating or otherwise abusing power."

Ok, now you are splitting hairs.

While she may not have abused her power or otherwise cheated, we, the plebes of reddit feel cheated and abused.

It's pretty shameful the way the admins are defending and covering for her.

Yes, it's nice ya'll are investigating and giving it due process, but it seems like you fail to see the forest through the trees.

EDIT: This is a deja vu over the r/Marijuana brouhaha with b34nz a while back. With his mass-banning and basically destroying a community over a power trip gone bad. Rather than work to keep the community intact, you supported b34nz and fragmented a community.

Rather than deal with a problem that the community is asking for help with, you support a clearly rogue mod and stick your heads in the sand chanting "La la la we don't care..."

Fuck you.

<re-enables Adblock>
133
thatguydr•

The obvious problem with Saydrah is that she does contribute and is very interested in getting eyeballs to/keeping eyeballs at reddit. BUT, she's also just a really difficult person to deal with. The reddit admins don't want her gone, and removing her moderator status will likely make her go all scorched earth and leave in a huff.

If that's not true, then remove her from her moderator positions. I have zero problems with her current position provided there's no obvious conflict of interest, but she is doing what lesser spammers have done (at the same low level) and is getting away with it. The gross double-standard is what people here are having problems with.

I'm personally POed that, based on such overwhelming anger about all of this, the other moderators have taken the lazy route of "we need her because she takes workload off us" rather than "oh everyone really seems angry about this - maybe we should do the smart thing and listen to people." I could make a tone-deaf-Democrat healthcare analogy, except that changing healthcare is a good idea, whereas keeping Saydrah is ultimately not.

53
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
ycc2106•

Highlight:

The reddit admins don't want her gone

4
junkit33•

This "investigation" is a crock. There are still active spams from her on the site today.

51
NotSoToughCookie•

It is a crock. Makes one believe reddit has a (monetary?) vetted interest in the 'Saydrah' brand.

Here is solid proof she abused her power:

http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b7sse/saydrah_i_would_like_to_take_a_moment_to_give_you/c0ldur2

So either the investigation was a sham, or they didn't do enough "investigating".

And that was only once. I wonder how many more times she's done it. It's not that submitting good articles and getting paid for it is wrong. It's that being a moderator and doing it is a huge conflict of interest. And that's what the reddit admins don't/can't/won't seem to comprehend.

48
Som12H8•

In what world does that users post constitute "solid proof"? It's his version of what happened, highly subjective. I for one would rather take the admins word. Wait, are you a republican senator?

-9
NotSoToughCookie•

Ignoring the ad hominem:

He provided a screenshot of the exchange between him and Saydrah, and the link to the submission in question. Not sure how you get more solid then that.

It would be subjective on it's own, perhaps. But added to the other evidence against her, it's solid proof that there is a clear conflict of interest with her being a mod and an abuse of power intended or not.

13
AlSweigart•

Could you point out her spam posts? I've been looking into this, and the more I look into it the more it looks like the reddit community overreacting.

15
junkit33•

I was almost with you until I saw this. That's the company she works for. I realize it has nothing to do with her mod status, which is why I think her account should just be banned just like every other spammer. Everybody is equal around here IMO.

28
encinarus•

http://www.reddit.com/user/Saydrah/submitted/

8 of ~100 posts in the last 10 days doesn't strike me as particularly spammy.

10
AlSweigart•

The thing that those 8 posts in your comment have in common is that she's not a moderator in any of those subreddits, she's not the author of those posts (AC pays the post authors for traffic), and none of them are for penis pills or finding old classmates (they seem like legitimate posts of info people might like). And 2 of them have positive ratings.

Where's the spam? Is everyone who posts something from AC a spammer?

5
Silver_•

Take a look at her posted history and you'll see that he's just making crap up.

3
AlSweigart•

Again, could you point out some of her spam posts? I'm looking for something specific.

The majority of her posts seem to be well received and are not from associatedcontent.com. And the ones that are do not look like spam but content that people might enjoy (a few have some net upvotes).

I think this is an overreaction because people seem to be more concerned with the potential for inappropriate behavior rather than her actual behavior (which seems to be great and what Reddit could use more of)

and you'll see that he's just making crap up.

Thanks.

2
universl•

The only things that are suspicious about Saydrah is her employment in social media, and her banning that guy posting his own pictures.

Being employed in social media in and of itself isn't a conflict of interest. I'm sure she's not the only one on this site who works in that field or for a company that could benefit from their user account. And as for the guy she banned - it seems like it was a bad judgement call, or an overzealous attempt to enforce the rules of the subreddit, or a situation where we only have half the facts. Maybe all three.

11
Quel•

Being employed in social media in and of itself isn't a conflict of interest.

There is a distinction here though. Being employed by a social media company doesn't create a conflict of interest. However, being employed by a social media company for the purpose of promoting their content does create a conflict of interest. Just to be lazy and steal some text from Wikipedia:

A conflict of interest (COI) occurs when an individual or organization is involved in multiple interests, one of which could possibly corrupt the motivation for an act in the other.

Seems pretty cut and dry in this situation.

Now, whether or not you believe she acted upon that conflict of interest to game reddit is another question, but it definitely is one.

14
universl•

But that's not the description of her job as far as anyone can prove. Her claim is that she consults clients on how to interact with social media and communities. I worked for a company that hired a social media consultant once, they didn't promote crap for us on digg or reddit - they basically were hired to prove to owners of the business that spamming people on facebook would not increase sales.

2
Quel•

This is from her Linked-In profile, which someone posted earlier:

Identify and promote Associated Content's top content and Contributors on third party content-sharing sites and blogs. Identify the "must-see" content and Contributors living elsewhere on the Web and recruit them to publish with AC. Develop promotional tools and tutorials to help Contributors promote their content, along with other programs all designed to drive traffic and recruit talent to AC.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
yasth•

The admins had to investigate her because people were hollering about her potential conflict of interest, which justifies the hollering because there was an investigation?

Ummm, no. That is like saying because a mod looks at whatever I click report on, it is a justified report.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
yasth•

I must have missed the mandatory reddit moderator background check. I hope my multiple felonies don't cause a problem....

Seriously, unless they say otherwise, they investigated her activity this weekend because of the hullabullu.

1
rightc0ast•

Well said. Incidentally, I just posted yesterday about not using adblock and you know what, that's my counter as well.

Adblock's been re-enabled for reddit. "Blocked items on this page 1 out of 22".

7
voltagex•

This isn't actually a logical way to deal with things.

1
FillInTheBlank•

Oh dear god no!

What will reddit ever do now that you've enabled adblock!

If you don't this place, then leave.

-4
Tommstein•

But what if he the whole place?

5
FillInTheBlank•

Well, then we will the new.

1
AlSweigart•

brouhaha with b34nz a while back. With his mass-banning and basically destroying a community over a power trip gone bad

Has Saydrah been acting this way? From what I've seen, she hasn't at all. The other moderators all seem to be supporting her.

5
[deleted]•

Admittedly she is not acting like that, but damaging a community nonetheless.

-3
AlSweigart•

Admittedly she is not acting like that, but damaging a community nonetheless.

This whole witch hunt has damaged my view of the Reddit community far, far more than Saydrah's behavior.

8
Kitchenfire•

People are forbidden from asking questions! FORBIDDEN!

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

That's true - ad block can be enabled as a means of protest. And I guess I could see if there's still a grease monkey script to downvoted spammer's submissions.

0
ModernRonin•

we, the plebes of reddit feel cheated and abused.

So, the people who run reddit should run it based on your feelings?

Jesus. If I ever make a website, remind me to insta-ban anyone who ever makes that argument...

-1
[deleted]•

... then I guess you won't have much luck with social media sites.

Good luck to you sir.

1
big_cheese•

If you're fine with your site getting zero to little traffic, then I guess you get what you wished for.

1
ModernRonin•

Probably why I only have a LiveJournal, and don't care if anyone reads it.

2
[deleted]•

Rather than deal with a problem that the community is asking for help with, you support a clearly rogue mod and stick your heads in the sand chanting "La la la we don't care..."

Fuck you.

Shockingly, the Saydrah-hate isn't universal. A great number of people think that such erudite fellows as yourself, HolodeckJizzmopper, are acting like cocks with an entitlement complex.

Grow the fuck up.

-9
shakbhaji•

To be clear, he was still referring to b34nz. b34nz was the "rogue mod."

Edit: maybe...

1
thernkworks•

I don't want to start a bitchfest about reddit's search engine, but the obviously worthless search result you linked to made me laugh.

113
nevinera•

I've hit that bug a few times in the last week. Going to that url/link works fine for me. In the past when I've hit that screen, refreshing doesn't fix it, even changing the sort algorithm does nothing. I've also hit a couple of list pages that absurdly only have 2-3 entries showing.

I guess I should be bug-reporting those; I forgot how decent reddit is at fixing things when they have the data.

12
thernkworks•

Yeah... this is the first time it's happened to me, but I figured it was a bug. No search engine is that useless.

1
reddithatesjews7•

Karmanaut and Keysersosa are racist against Jews

-23
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
misternuge•
8
rej1587•

In all seriousness, every time I try to search I just get an error message that the servers are overloaded and to try again later. I haven't been able to successfully search on reddit in weeks.

5
Measure76•

I use the reddit search function all the time, because it is the easiest way to search all reddits for submissions including a particular word in the title.

When I started redditting several months ago, this was always easy.

Now the search function hardly ever works, maybe once in 10 tries, and I don't mash reload, I wait hours and try again.

2
CD7•

redditsearch.com?

2
probably2high•

Yea, I abandoned the search function on reddit a while ago. I know it's not a great idea, but getting rid of the search function, and replacing it with directions on how to use google to search reddit, or linking to redditsearch.com could take some of the load off of the servers.

1
Measure76•

Neither of those is as good as the reddit search box itself.

When it worked, the reddit search box was a real-time search of article titles.

Using google or redditsearch gives you a search that is not real-time, (in other words, the results displayed are hours or days old,) and does not seem to differentiate between article titles, self-posts, and comments.

1
cloondog•

Saydrah's postings have been additive to the community, and we have no indication that she's been anything but a great moderator to the communities she moderates. Moderators are not exempt from our anti-cheating measures, and, though I hate to have to put it in these terms, we've "investigated" Saydrah, and we didn't find any indication of her cheating or otherwise abusing power.

The problem here is twofold. One, that Saydrah is a spammer. This is undeniably fact. She floods the new queue with stories - a direct violation of reddiquette. In her capacity as a social news consultant, she advises spammers to submit three or four "legitimate" links along with their self-promoting links - a tactic she clearly engages in on reddit. She submits links to her employer's website as part of her duties as a Content Promoter - as she admits here. While despicable behavior, I don't have too much of a problem with this, even if reddit has banned users for such behavior before.

Secondly, Saydrah is a moderator, and therefore has a position of authority in the community. This creates a conflict of interest. Conflicts of interest are not dealt with after the person has abused their authority. They're dealt with before. Your "investigation" turned up no evidence of abuse on Saydrah's part, but this is irrelevant. The potential for abuse is there, and that's the real problem. As a spammer, she no longer has credibility as a moderator, and the lack of response from any other moderators or the admins damages their own credibility as well. Try to imagine this from the point of view of your average redditor: you've just been told that a person in a position of authority over you is corrupt. When you complain about it, that person calls you a shithead, then seriously suggests as a solution that she be allowed to retain her position of authority, but hide any of her corrupt activities from public view. This is no longer a person fit to be in a position of authority, regardless of whether she has abused her authority already or not.

97
[deleted]•

This comment should be top.

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
bluequail•

She floods the new queue with stories - a direct violation of reddiquette.

Can you show me a way to skip the new queue, and submit directly to the old one?

-6
bairy•

Yes, submit to digg. Their front page is reddit's front page minus a day.

7
sumzup•

You're either trolling or you completely missed the point. Or I'm just confused and need to go to sleep.

3
bluequail•

They made a stupid comment, I gave them a stupid answer. Of course her submissions went into the "new" queue, there is no "old" queue to submit to.

-2
cloondog•

It's not a stupid comment, though you definitely gave a stupid answer. The issue is not with posting to the new queue, every post needs to go to the new queue. The issue is with flooding the new queue, submitting many links in a short time frame. This is something that Saydrah does, and is explicitly listed as a no-no in reddiquette as it monopolizes the new queue. Of course, you could have just read the original comment to begin with.

1
digitaldevil•

A lot of admin cocksucking and ball-licking going on in here.

77
Seppuki•

I will add to it. Please remember to disable adblock on Reddit! I just did.

21
digitaldevil•

I'm addicted to AdBlock. When I see an ad I get excited that I have something new to block.

32
puggydug•

I saw an animated ad on Reddit about an hour ago. That mouse was hovering. Hovering, I tell ya.

8
azreal156•

If you're like the rest of us, then you depend on reddit to kill time. If everyone were to enable AdBlock on reddit then there would be no more reddit. You can set site exceptions in AdBlock.

2
lolbacon•

Or maybe Saydrah should finance the site.

24
digitaldevil•

Bully for you! People like you allow people like me to fully use AdBlock.

1
ycc2106•

I like ⬆ =)

1
furburger•

I just put it back on after all this bullshit. I left digg because I was sick of being marketed to and now it looks like I'm going to have to find somewhere new.

1
flashman•

A lot of internet tough-guying going on in here.

3
[deleted]•

They also like it when you scratch their bellies.

3
itsbri•

I think you need more hamsters. Hamsters never fail.

75
Booster21•

Tell that to Richard Gere.

18
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
owenstumor•

Yes. It was.

29
noseeme•

Goodnight sweet prince.

6
Richeh•

The story I heard was that he went in for cosmetic surgery to get rid of a large freckle, and the whole shitstorm was caused by a press release that "Mister Gere has been admitted to hospital to have a mole removed from his bottom".

I choose to believe it, because it is funnier.

22
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
chamois•

shitstorm

1
zem•

this is officially the best thing i've read on reddit all day.

1
zem•

i could truly cry....

sunshine says:

I believe the story. I did NOT want too. I love this man, he is gorgeous, and very talented. But you can only hear a story so much till you have to believe it. If it was not true after all these years it would have died down by now. Don’t ya think??????

1
karmanaut•

Lemiwinks is proof positive.

5
IConrad•

Especially since he's a shithead.

8
Greg112390•

Or we could get one of the world's greatest hamsters. Richard Hammond.

1
[deleted]•

Hrm. I missed the drama. Hooray for road trips!

Marketing companies have been violating the social contract for ages now(Remember that you're paying 100 bucks a month for the privilege of watching 15 minutes of commercials in an hour long program), and it will get much worse before it gets better. The directive "Become a trusted member of the community so you can sell things covertly" is going to leave a bitter taste in people's mouths, and just like telemarketing, people who decide to get into that line of work will have to deal with the consequences. Reddit isn't being maintained by some douchebag pretending to be a real person for the sole purpose of having a persona from which to hawk products. I'm confident there hasn't been a penny contributed to the site through shills, it's just infiltration.

SEOs in particular take the social contract and shit on it. Google is a perfectly functional search engine without some company gaming the system. In fact, the millions of dummy sites they create to game the system actually reduce the effectiveness of Google. They aren't value added, they're just parasites.

As for the rest, I like reddit because it's the only site that doesn't cripple my browser. If servers are a bit slow at times, it's a small price to pay.

72
[deleted]•

It's actually 40-20 split per hour...

2
[deleted]•

Google is a perfectly functional search engine without some company gaming the system. In fact, the millions of dummy sites they create to game the system actually reduce the effectiveness of Google. They aren't value added, they're just parasites.

Except that SEO sites mostly serve ads through Google adsense. When you factor in Adsense For Domains, their domain squatter service, Google is making a lot of money off of bad practices on the web, so they don't have a real incentive to clean things up. They get to have it both ways, profiting from SEO spam while the public thinks of them as innocent victims.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jrblast•

and it will get much worse before it gets better

Actually, it's already gotten better

1
[deleted]•

That's just us violating another social contract.

6
ModernRonin•

Sauce for the goose...

2
badfish•

I am disappointed in the reaction to the Saydrah situation from the admins. Yes, it was terrible that her personal info was posted. However I also believe that it is terrible--though not as terrible--that there is compelling evidence that she has tried to game reddit. I have seen evidence that she has several aliases on other sites and promotes her own links as various individuals. I have have lost confidence in reddit as being "the best of the web".

53
raldi•

there is compelling evidence that she has tried to game reddit

What is it?

-1
badfish•

It is late, please take a look at some of my recent submissions, or tomorrow I could give you a summary.

3
raldi•

Just post the #1 most flagrant violation you've found, please.

1
badfish•

So basically I did a Google search for the Lisa alias that was found. I found on Stumbleupon where someone had posted an offer code with "Lisa's" name in the email address. Okay so maybe they were just forwarding a code that was not theirs, correct? Well the ID that posted the email address was LaurieJupiter which had submitted a bunch of stuff to Stumbleupon which was right up Saydrah's alley. Associated Content, Disaboom, Doglvr, etc. Also, This "Laurie" commented on the Saydrah stuff as if she was not the one submitting it. Stuff like, "that's funny, thanks!".

Basically, if she was cross pollinating her own stuff there, how do we know she did not do it here as well?

1
big_cheese•

I thought it was all over reddit. Check user SirOblivious.

0
kevin19713•

What personal info did they post? I only saw a video and her myspace/facebook accounts. Afaik thats not personal and if it is then it doesn't belong in public. I don't post anything on my facebook that I don't want anyone to see(mostly small talk on my wall, some pics of me on vacation and at concerts). I don't post my real DOB, SSN, bank accounts or anything that can be used against me. But if someone hacked any of her accounts or posted her passwords then thats wrong.

-5
hueypriest•

Several people posted her address, full name, DOB, etc. And her family's names, DOB, addresses.

13
kevin19713•

I saw her post on that but I have no way to verify. She could easily have made all that up. And why would someone post their address online? I dunno, I don't work online for a living, but if I did I'd get a PO box.

-4
hueypriest•

There are government records and other sources. It's likely that with a little searching someone could find a street address for most people whether they've ever posted one online or not.

5
lukemcr•

Full name, address and phone number...

3
badfish•

Well they dug deep and posted her address plus info of what may be her relatives.

3
kevin19713•

They should ban anyone that posted her address but she should be banned for using reddit for spamming.

0
Fat_Dumb_Americans•

Her sock-puppets posted it to garner the sympathy vote. That's what I'd do if I was "social media expert".

2
applextrent•

You know for a second I was about to let this go, then I came across this comment, and got pissed off all over again.

This Google search indicates there are nearly over 1000 Associated Content references from Saydrah.

If this is not spam, or abuse, or conflict of interest then I don't know what is.

46
eet•

Google search also indicates over 4000 twitter references from Saydrah, over 20,000 for imgur and over 33,000 for reddit

Hi guys. Long time lurker. One time poster (x-ray chick). Just here to state I think

This Google search indicates there are nearly over 1000 Associated >Content references from Saydrah.

is invalid as an argument. Not taking sides. Just, this is not a convincing point. Test things things out before you make conclusions blah blah blah.

1
[deleted]•

Although I agree there's a conflict of interest, google searches of reddit are pretty unreliable. They index a lot of pages they probably shouldn't, like related links, mobile links, links to comments, etc, rather than just the links to stories. A while back, someone made a tool for checking a user's submission history with regards to spam, but I don't know what happened to it.

-7
applextrent•

The fact she's also used comments to link to Associated Content is still a way to drive traffic and boost SEO. This issue is now above and beyond submissions, she's been linking from comments as well.

8
superiority•

Also foreign-language links, e.g. de.reddit.com. This can cause duplicate results.

0
[deleted]•
6
NotSoToughCookie•

I don't know why everyone is ignoring the fact, including the reddit admins, that she did abuse her power at least once as is instanced here:

http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b7sse/saydrah_i_would_like_to_take_a_moment_to_give_you/c0ldur2

If that's not abuse, and acknowledged by the admins or the mods of the r/pics subreddit, then their "investigation" methods are nothing but a sham. I apologize for being a tad harsh, but facts are facts.

All I see now is reddit admins trying to mitigate the damage to saydrah.

If you don't admit to yourselves that the damage to her is irreparable, then you admins are condoning this behavior. Or (dons tinfoil hat) have a vetted interest in Saydrah.

44
Zenislev•

This whole situation is ridiculous... I can't see how some people aren't outraged by Saydrah's misconduct. I'm going to wait and see how this turns out, and if she's still a mod (let alone user, if you consider her to be a spammer), I'm out of here.

4
Leprecon•

Bye

Last time I checked the mods did investigate it and then they said she can still be a mod. Are you gonna man up and leave or make more false threats?

Actually, I will one up you, if you don't leave, I will.

1
Zenislev•

No, trust me, I'm out of here if she remains a mod after everything that's come to light. I haven't left yet because I have hope that the mods will reconsider that decision.

I'm not sure what the "investigation" entailed, but the evidence I saw in several threads is damning enough, to me, to warrant at least the removal of her mod status. If you don't agree with that, then fine, stay here. But the reason I was drawn to reddit in the first place was the sense of community. To have a mod shown to be building fake rapport so that she can spam her employer's websites more successfully is frankly in the very least insulting, and at worst a sign that other such corruption might exist in our community. So yes, if the mods don't reverse their stance, then reddit is not the place I thought it was, and I will gladly spend my time elsewhere.

1
Leprecon•

To have a mod shown to be building fake rapport so that she can spam her employer's websites more successfully is frankly in the very least insulting, and at worst a sign that other such corruption might exist in our community.

That is the whole point, the "proof" isn't as clear cut as you think it is.

The main argument against her is that she spams the site she works for. Here you can see she barely submits from her companies site. Those are just submissions, not front page stories. (also, they are not in subreddits she is a mod of, hence it is impossible for her to affect the submissions)

Then there is the whole "She abuses her mod powers for her own good", which isn't true since other mods can see what another mod does. The mods have been looking at each other a lot in the past, and recently they have intensively studied Saydrahs behavior.

Then there is the guy "she" banned from r/pics.

The other evidence you must be referring to is the video where she says what she does ? I watched the video, she basically tells people to use social networking sites responsibly. If you read her IAmA, and then watch the video, you might realize that she isn't someone who wants to spam this place.

And another thing: Her being a mod doesn't affect her submissions even in the subreddit she moderates. She can't do anything, only the community can upvote submissions. If you really need to know, the only thing she can do is unban submissions that are auto-banned by the spam filter. She could also ban other submissions for no reason and make her submissions more likely to succeed, but such a thing would leave evidence for all the other mods.

So now we have some people with a vendetta who sought to annoy a mod, and some other people (you included) who like to follow some shoddy "evidence" that the entire of reddit is a huge conspiracy. If you wanna delete your account because of that and leave reddit, than please be my guest.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Leprecon•
1
Silver_•

Er, that guy is just a prick with a stick up his arse. Any mod would ban those submissions, I see nothing more than someone doing their job.

-12
iliketokilldeer•

How is the Chomsky interview coming along?

43
hueypriest•

It's fine. We only had 30 min and he gave awesome 10 minute answers to 3 questions. He is trying to answer another 5 via email, and I am waiting for a few more days to (hopefully) get those. His schedule is insanely full. He's doing his best, and gave us a lot of his time already.

54
acousticcoupler•

Is it possible to post the video before the other questions come in? The wait is killing me.

5
hueypriest•

possible, but we still have two older videos to put up first :) be patient.

5
lolard•
<insert praise for admins and badmouth haters>
40
karmanaut•

This calls for a circlejerk!

14
[deleted]•

you're not even trying anymore.

32
noseeme•

More like karmastagnant, amirite?

8
Seppuki•

Don't say that! That is what made Bozarking leave.

1
[deleted]•

Annnnd thank you for my comment of the day.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ScottColvin•

Thank you, circlejerk is the essence of Social Media.

1
zachv•

All glory to the admins!

7
B-Con•

Huh. According to the architecture diagram, reddit has some sort of "search" module. Anyone have an info on how to access it?

39
Dax420•

It's located on another domain:

http://www.searchreddit.com/

28
nannerpus•

Yeah, the domain is google.com

26
wickedcold•

Posting personal information crosses the line, and it has been our policy since the beginning to remove it when we see it or when it is pointed out to us.

THANK YOU. I was not aware of this policy. I've been greatly disappointed in the past when I've seen the 'channer mentality come out of some redditors and their posting of personal information about people, inviting which-hunts and harassment. This sort of shit ruins lives.

In the future when I see such activity I will report it vigilantly.

33
antisense•

You have not been aware of this policy because it hasn't existed, at least not anywhere visible in the three years I've been a part of this community. I have seen personal info posted as top comments on front-page postings on more than one occasion.

I agree with the fact that we shouldn't have people's information posted, but I call BS on the fact that this has always been a policy. It seems rather too convenient of a situation to begin saying this has always been the case.

32
hueypriest•

Always been a policy, but we can only remove what we know about. I removed the links to that girl involved with the whole Epic Beard Man thing the other week to give you one example.

11
antisense•

You've been here longer than I, so you should definitely remember this and this (oh, and look at the commentor) and maybe even this.

17
hueypriest•

The first link is just to the person's bebo account. I'm ok with that. You've got a good point on the second one, and I've banned the post with the full name and facebook pics, and no the irony of the commenter is not lost on me. The third one is not relevant unless I'm missing something in the comments.

5
romcabrera•

Did you also remove the "Win at chatroulette" (Jonas Brothers) of yesterday?. Just curious.

1
hueypriest•

Sorry? link?

1
wickedcold•

I have no doubt in my mind that it was a policy, even if it wasn't enforced as well as it could have been. After all, its in reddit's best interest to not end up on CNN implicated in a story about someone who's kid was assaulted or home vandalized as a direct result of having their personal information distributed through this site.

I know people make comparisons all the time (I'm as guilty as anyone), but this isn't 4chan. Unlike 4chan, there's actually grown ups running the show here, not to mention a corporate owner.

1
[deleted]•

Reddit has been slow for many many months (for me anyway) taking between 1 and 3 seconds to load, but for every second I wait the content I get offsets that wait a lot. So you're excused for being so slow, yesterday was scary though.

How much traffic were you getting yesterday causing the slowdown?

32
KeyserSosaOP•

That's the thing: only marginally more than usual. It was really one of those cases where going from "almost out of RAM" to "out of RAM" is the difference between being up and down.

55
FillInTheBlank•

http://www.downloadmoreram.com/

I thought we told you about this!

As I'm here, I'm getting 403 errors with several of the ads.

29
KeyserSosaOP•

Sure. Now you tell us.

18
FillInTheBlank•

You obviously don't care for the valuable effort we put in to help you.

runs off crying

I think I edited my post too late, but I'm getting 403 errors for some ads.

5
mtkz•

I don't think they had enough RAM to download more RAM.

1
willis77•

going from "almost of RAM" to "out of RAM" is the difference between being up and down

That's what she saI'll just shut up now.

19
bdfortin•

I downvoted you, but only because you didn't finish.

3
[deleted]•

That's what she... oh, never mind.

9
[deleted]•

I think you accidentally the out

10
KeyserSosaOP•

outed

13
Random_Question•

Why is r/etard banned?

3
KeyserSosaOP•

Not sure. It isn't now though.

4
Poromenos•

I know it wasn't built for this, but what about using MongoDB/CouchDB as caches? They're supposed to scale well and be fast...

1
ketralnis•

We're looking at alternative stores for the permacaches as we outgrow memcachedb, and those are on our list to investigate.

2
raldi•

I'm not sure if our traffic stats are confidential, but I can say that it's tripled in the last 12 months.

25
Fauster•

Holy crap. Was reddit's growth rate the previous year similar?

14
KeyserSosaOP•

Yup.

28
raldi•

How bout the one before that?

19
sje46•

This reactionary witchhunt against Saydrah has made me really disappointed with reddit.

Good job, admins, for addressing it, and investigating.

29
fox2319•

No need for a witch hunt.

1 - Witches float

2 - Ducks float

3 - Use scales with a duck on one side to check all redditors. If they weight the same as a duck then they're a witch

QED

61
Richeh•

Build a bridge out of her!

29
[deleted]•

She got called out for being a witch. Let's see if she floats or not.

I guess everyone has noticed her enough to notice if she turns them into a newt in the near future?

4
[deleted]•

She turned me into a newt already. (but I got better)

0
R1cheh•

Well yeah, ish. Except replacement accounts are so cheap I'm writing this message from one, and there's no real benefit to being a Reddit celebrity of the level Saydrah is; she makes her money by knowing the best ways around the machine, and which buttons to press to rally the hivemind.

Besides, I'd be amazed if a marketing specialist only had one account, or any less than a dozen. For all you know I could be her.

-1
Lut3s•

Ah, but can't you also make bridges out of stone?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
fox2319•

Eureka! I think he's got it.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
rkcr•

Thankfully, we're now entering the second phase of a standard reddit witch hunt, which is when the majority of people lose their bloodlust and it becomes cool to have been anti-witch hunt the entire time.

61
stutheidiot•

Psh, I was against the witch hunt back when it was on vinyl.

34
[deleted]•

Psh, I didn't even know about the witch hunt.

21
willis77•

I listen to witch hunts that don't even exist yet.

12
Gravity13•

But seriously, I thought this was uncool before anybody else. Don't believe me? Look at my profile.

Now that it's becoming mainstream... well, nevermind.

5
thephotoman•

And I'm still sitting over here wondering what the fuck happened in the first place, as I spent most of the weekend AFK.

3
Shadowrose•

Same. If you find out, let me know?

2
Quel•

I'm mixed on this one. The only part that really disappoints me is the personal attacks and posting of personal information. Otherwise, what can you expect? The appearance of impropriety is a powerful thing, even if it is only an appearance. People feel duped, and probably rightfully so. The monetary issue is a side-issue compared to that.

30
rm999•

Why should people feel rightfully duped if everything was only in appearance?

7
Quel•

I would still say it's a conflict of interest, even if she isn't actually benefiting from it, which is why people feel duped.

The best example I can think of is in court. If you are in a lawsuit against Haliburton and the judge owns stock, he'll recuse himself. If they didn't, and the ruling went against you and you later found out he owned Haliburton, you would feel "wronged". Even if his actions were 100% correct.

Obviously a reddit mod and a judge aren't on the same scale, but it's the best parallel I can think of at the moment.

Edit: another way I might put it is that it is the difference between "legal" and "ethical". Legally (according to reddit rules that is) she did nothing wrong, but ethically it's probably a mixed bag.

14
shsmurfy•

Exactly. Judges in court may preside over far more weighty matters. The point is moderators, like judges, are supposed to be impartial despite the difference in the gravity of what they judge. While some people have overreacted, the point is that Saydrah has a clear conflict of interest. She can't prove her impartiality, because she earns money from some of the content she is supposed to monitor.

Would she mark spam from her employer as such? Did she mark competing websites and posts as spam? These questions are subjective and thus difficult to "investigate". Furthermore, such investigation wouldn't be necessary if Saydrah had recused herself in the first place.

The fact that Saydrah has since called 90% of the community she is "contributing" to shitheads has only thrown gas on the flame.

9
dieselmachine•

SHE IS PAID TO SUBMIT CONTENT TO REDDIT.

SHE BANNED SOMEONE CLAIMING HE WAS TRYING TO MAKE MONEY OFF SUBMITTING CONTENT TO REDDIT.

HYPOCRISY, TRUE OR FALSE ASSHOLES.

sorry for the caps, just trying to MAKE THE LETTERS BIGGER SO THEY AREN'T MISSED.

0
karmanaut•

This reactionary witchhunt against Saydrah has made me really disappointed with reddit.

Me too, very much so. People seem to think that being invested in the quality and success of one's content is a bad thing. I would love it if more people took the time to actually care about what the reddit community wants and to find content to match that.

As a moderator, I see this as a moderator witch hunt. People are assuming that we have all kinds of powers (like avoiding the rate limit: that has nothing to do with being a moderator) and that Saydrah has repeatedly taken advantage of her position. I have said it before and will say it again that any moderator can investigate another's actions, so if you have a comment or post that you think was unfairly banned, or if a moderator took an unfair action against you, then just let us know. Don't bother with vague accusations.

29
Byeuji•

As completely not a moderator, this exact mindset has been bothering me quite a bit during all this.

I spent all of yesterday in the LGBT and TwoXChromosomes IRC channels on freenode dispelling all these ridiculous ideas people had about what mods could and shouldn't do (specifically Saydrah). It truly amazed me at how adept some redditors can be at being completely blind and two-faced.

We're incredible at picking apart the logical fallacies of religious fundies, haters and politicians; but we use the same fallacies and sensationalism to pick apart and destroy someone who has been submitting valuable content to reddit for years and adding the most informational and thoughtful comments to threads consistently.

Good on her if she takes a professional pride in it, I say. And good for her for figuring out how to make a living doing something that all of us love. You'd be crazy to turn down a job doing this for a living. We could all be millionaires with this addiction :P

Anyway, I'm really glad the admins have investigated this and I hope things calm down a bit. We all need to remember what makes us a community, not what separates us all.

25
mitchandre•

keyword: valuable

-6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
Byeuji•

Gotta admit, the fires were too hot for me... I didn't do any public defense on reddit... just on the IRC channels

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
bondagegirl•

Honestly, after dealing with this nutjob, I just gave up and moved on to circlejerk. And then it even got all serious business in there.

You did make some very good arguments during all of this and quite a few times I read something I agreed with, saw you posted it and nodded while upvoting.

2
romwell•

Good for you, I just couldn't comment at all. There was more wrong on Reddit than I could attempt to address. I only tried to give upvotes/downvotes to stop the tempest.

2
karmanaut•

I did earlier, but I haven't been redditing much in the past few days because I have a big assignment due at the end of the week and I'm trying not to procrastinate too much.

0
Gravity13•

Doesn't seem to matter anymore, looks like Reddit is still in puritanical kneejerk mode.

Number of users who have called me a Saydrah sockpuppet: 11.

-4
jmnugent•

Fair and sensible responses like this are a beacon of hope in the darkness that is the misguided and mob-like hive mind.

6
[deleted]•

I would love it if more people took the time to actually care about what the reddit community wants and to find content to match that.

So... you don't like Saydrah, then? Because the shit she submitted was... well, shit.

If you type in her full name in google search, which I won't provide, you will see that she has submitted huge volumes of totally frivolous content on dozens and dozens of different sites. At one point she apparently was shilling for the publisher or author of a book called Superfoods Rx, saying that she was in the process of reading it and provided a few sample recipes from it. It was total fluff, that article. Superfoods? What a load of bullshit; according to that book, anything that isn't fast food is a "superfood". When you define the term that loosely, it has no real value or practical meaning. I know for a fact that Saydrah isn't that stupid. It seems fairly clear to me that she is totally in this for profit and barely puts any effort at all into providing quality content. IF she had provided quality content, then I wouldn't take nearly as much issue with her; but her main focus was volume.

Don't bother with vague accusations.

They aren't vague and they aren't accusations. They're very clear admissions on Saydrah's part: She does SEO and isn't suspected of it by and large because she's managed to earn the trust of Redditors through subterfuge and affectation. You needn't bother making use of the strawman fallacy. The main issue here is not that she abused her powers as a mod, but that, despite her spamming ways, she continued to be a mod and the admin looked the other way. What other spammer gets that kind of treatment?

4
potatolicious•

I'm with you until I remember that Saydrah specifically picked out and railed against another submitter for using Reddit for self-promotion. You can go see the evidence on the front page right now - I find the hypocrisy to be more galling than anything else, really.

3
[deleted]•

(like avoiding the rate limit: that has nothing to do with being a moderator)

Well, that's not entirely true, but it's usually negligible.

3
khafra•

Let me list the reasons that lots of redditors getting in a tizzy about this hasn't made me disappointed with reddit:

  • Sturgeon's Law
1
shakbhaji•

Complete non-sequitur, but I just remembered it and I found it funny: http://sturgeonface.com/

1
NotSoToughCookie•

I have said it before and will say it again that any moderator can investigate another's actions

You are incorrect. A moderator cannot investigate what submissions have been unbanned by another moderator. If she created sock puppet accounts which to spam from, it would be very, very hard to tell as there is almost no trail left behind.

(like avoiding the rate limit: that has nothing to do with being a moderator)

This is also incorrect. Mods are automatically immune to the rate limit in the subreddits they moderate.

Think you need to get your facts straight. I'm amazed you are being upvoted.

0
akkoow•

Remind me why we need a clique of moderators? To get rid of spam? The spam filter is pretty awesome at that - so awesome, in fact, that it blocks a lot of real submissions. So the only things mods should be able to do, is unblock submissions that got falsely labeled as spam, and mark spam that somehow got through this ridiculously strict filter.

How does that include "banning users from r/pics because they link to a blog instead of imgur"? Why do we need an extra set of gatekeepers? A horribly clique-y set of gatekeepers who think they're "powerusers" and more important than regular users? Who defend each other's actions, no matter how obviously wrong they are? I don't want a clique like that. The outrage you saw (and the horrible behaviour like posting adresses and namecalling), is a direct result of this community rejecting this clique - WHICH WE DO NOT NEED.

Finally, if you're this dissappointed in Reddit, please leave. I generally like your comments and upvoted a lot of them, so I'll miss those, but I won't miss your mod-attitude. Get out if you think we're this bad, people will forget you sooner than you think and in the end, we won't miss you (nor Saydrah).

0
Grue•

Have you seen this: http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b7sse/saydrah_i_would_like_to_take_a_moment_to_give_you/

Here's concrete evidence of abuse. I was kinda pro-saydrah during the weekend, but this convinced me she should be banned.

12
krispykrackers•

I'm also glad that the admins intervened on this one! I know you guys take the stance of not intervening on moderation issues, but this was twice as hard for us to deal with since it as not only to do with moderating issues, but spamming as well.

I think it was a good decision to look in to it, since we as mods aren't provided the tools we need to investigate on that level, but more because to do our job requires the trust of our communities, and this was turning into a moderator-wide hate fest. I hope everyone understands that we are nice, normal people, and if there are any, any concerns about anything, please ask. We aren't trying to hide anything from anyone, and are always happy to help with any questions or suggestions you might have. Pinky swear.

Thanks admins, this was every moderators nightmare. Saydrah is a valuable redditor, an excellent mod, and it would have been hard to lose her. We all really like her, but also wanted to do the best for our respective communities, and the vocal torch weilding jury was making so much noise, it was hard to decipher truth from angry accusations. I, and I'm sure the rest of the mods, really really appreciate this.

10
junkit33•

I'll ask it then. Why are the admins/mods/powers that be ok with Saydrah spamming articles from the company she works for when spamming is frowned upon to the point that there is an entire subreddit dedicated to pointing out obvious spam.

She may be everything else you mention, but she's also a spammer and that's not ok with me, or what appears to be a very large portion of the community.

31
[deleted]•

The subreddit for pointing out spam was user created. While it's somewhat admin endorsed, they've said self promotion of legitimate content is a gray area, and that we should just submit obvious spam. That's what I've been told as mod of that subreddit. I can't do anything about self promotion I feel is spam other than to talk to the mods of the subreddits it's being posted in.

My personal two cents on this: if you're being paid to submit or have a conflict of interest, you should upfront with it. If not, you should be banned. It doesn't matter who you are, I don't feel that sort of community undermining should be tolerated, period.

14
[deleted]•

a very loud portion of the community.

FTFY.

Saydrah's been unfortunate enough to fall prey to the Reddit Hate Machine. Nothing more.

-4
junkit33•

I'm pretty sure that simply being loud does not amass downvotes well into the hundreds. If the genuine feeling was neutral she'd be hovering somewhere around zero.

7
akatherder•

We aren't trying to hide anything from anyone

I believe the majority of the shitstorm was caused by someone hiding something and getting caught.

Note: I'm not commenting on whether it's something that needs to be "out in the open" or whether that hurts someone's ability to effectively moderate. Just saying, is all.

16
krispykrackers•

For what it's worth, I try and be very transparent in my moderation, and have taken this as a lesson to continue to do so. If I had suspected anything funky was going on, I would have said so. Ask the other mods. I've done it before.

I hope that this incident doesn't start a precedence as to how to handle this type of incident in the future. If you have any suggestions to what we could have done to better handle this, please speak up. I'm open to listen.

2
[deleted]•

I'll back you up on the "usually being transparent". I don't think I've ever seen you mod anything on Ideas for the Admins without warning, even when it was someone downright hateful to you.

As for transparency, I'd like to see some direct discussion of the mods she's co-modding with. Qgyh2 stated that he'd prefer she stepped down herself, and it's probably inappropriate for her to mod in the other subreddits. However, I've not seen any actual discussion other than this. At one point, karmanaut even stated that he hadn't seen any yet. What's going on guys?

5
akatherder•

To be transparent on my side, I've never had an issue that needed moderation and I've never had an issue with moderators. That's proof of a job well done on the admin and moderation sides of the fence. Of course I've submitted less than ten articles in the two years I've been here, so I don't have anything at "stake" as long as there are quality stories on my front page.

The only thing that irks me is the possibility that a moderator could be gaming submissions. If Joe Scammer was able to game a few submissions to the front page, that doesn't bother me. It's a lesson learned for the admins and a chance to improve. But I'm getting off topic, so I digress.

1
thatguydr•

We all really like her

I don't like to be so off-putting and tactless, but no. We don't all really like her. Saydrah is often a terrible person. I actually will occasionally feel revulsion reading her posts.

I'm no misogynist at all, krispy, and I'm sure that a bit of this springs from that side of reddit, but Saydrah is clearly gaming this system. No matter how many positive things she contributes, it saddens me that she gets a special spam token AND the power to deal with similar posts from others. It's just hypocritical and disgusting.

16
krispykrackers•

I meant us mods. I know that a lot of people don't like her, and that's okay. There is no way we can like everyone here, and there's no reason we should have to.

4
[deleted]•

WHITE KNIGHTS, ASSEMBLE!

7
Seppuki•

28 upvotes in 18 minutes! We have reached this stage already! Backlash to a backlash!

4
dieselmachine•

It's easy to make it look like support when you're censoring the opposing viewpoint.

Somehow, my comment was deleted for "not being related to programming", but the comments where people are praising Saydrah are not anymore related to programming, yet... yet they're still here.

Talk about hypocrisy.

Get fucked, Jedberg. How about you start wiping out the pro-Saydrah comments as well? Those aren't programming related, are they?

-4
jedberg•

Dude, that was in the other programming thread. Take your meds dude.

3
dieselmachine•

I can swear all I want. Go fuck yourself, prick.

EDIT: Also, fuck you.

-2
verdammt•

Now hopefully Saydrah can stop bitching about her woes with the administration "not attending" to her special needs. Done deal.

3
fauxromanou•

I think it's just as bad to call it a "witchhunt". Very polarizing word.

1
[deleted]•

witchhunt

The use of this profoundly hyperbolic term instantly undermines and casts the light of doubt upon the actions and motives of people who just wanted a democratic, non-spammy community and felt betrayed by Saydrah and the admins' actions.

It must be nice being on the side of the issue that you are and having such a loaded term to throw around to promote your cause and shame your opponents. We on this side don't have that luxury.

We're not seeking to kill anyone or burn anyone alive; we're seeking merely that Saydrah should cease to be a moderator or be banned. When described that way, our actions don't seem nearly so rash, foolhardy, cruel or insane as they do when they're described with the pejorative, though-terminating cliche "witchhunt".

It seems to me that you can take the wind out of the sails of any movement that sought to punish wrongdoers simply by using that term, without having to make any real arguments, much less substantiate them.

Here's the problem, though: Saydrah outright admitted to doing things that have gotten others banned in the past - things for which she has banned others! The proof that she was attempting to increase the google search rankings of various sites for which she was shilling is to be found right in her submission history. The mere fact that she didn't use imgur when submitting that vast quantity of incredibly uninteresting pics with vapid headlines, to me, is more than enough evidence to justify banning her - especially in light of the fact that others have been banned for gaffes far less injurious to the community.

I don't think I need to go into the reasons why the admin, though knowing that she was a spammer, would connive and pretend that she'd done no wrong. In increasing the search rank of those other sites, Saydrah was increasing Reddit's in a way and keeping throngs of boobs entertained with vast quantities of extremely low-quality content. This site is fucked without content and she was one of the biggest contributors. I wouldn't be surprised if many of the other major contributors are in very similar positions to Saydrah's, making money by dumping huge volumes of consummate garbage onto this community. If the admin ban Saydrah, they jeopardize their professional relationships with those other content providers.

This community - purportedly - aims at being a democratic one. I was under the impression that that was the most basic principle of its operation. Whether content is garbage or not, if users want it, they get it. (I haven't always agreed with that, but that's a topic for another day.) But here we have the majority of the community calling for Saydrah not to be a mod any longer, and what does she continue to be? A mod. What of the democratic values upon which this community was founded?

1
unrealious•

Damn power users sucking up all the internets...

0
smpx•

I was pretty disgusted with the outing of personal issues, but I'm pretty proud to see how fast reddit users immediately downvoted it into oblivion. There's still hope, after all.

0
shakbhaji•

They haven't addressed anything, they've just attempted to sweep this under the rug. The thing is, most people will forget about this in a few days anyway so, I guess that's your idea of "addressing it."

0
noveltyaccountscore•

0/10

0
ciaran036•

Reactionary witchunt

There isn't a better way to put it!

I'm a little sickened by the actions of Redditors in recent weeks. I was damn proud of how much Redditors donated to the Haiti appeal... after that things went downhill. From racist comments being upvoted, to this... my regard for the Redditing community has decreased.

-1
Rubin0•

Shit happens. We'll move on.

-4
thedragon4453•

Shit does indeed happen. However, I am saddened in this particular instance because several things happened, which I feel reddit would normally be against:

  1. Posting personal info in a very 4chanesque manner.
  2. Making fun of her appearance, which has nothing to do with anything, and I found to be childish.
  3. Effectively damning her without any real investigation, and retroactively complaining about a ban which was agreed with at the time.

But the really disappointing thing in all this comes up with the fact that the comments that pointed these things out were downmodded to oblivion most of the time. This is really not what I expected from reddit. Usually this type of things flaps up and the community does the right thing. Whether she's a spammer or not (I suspect not, although she should have disclosed her affiliations), reddit went on a witch hunt, which is never cool

19
[deleted]•

I certainly agree with the first two points. I also dislike the constant mention of sexism in the argument, from both sides.

However, I highly disagree with the 3rd point. That was fairly clear cut evidence that SirOblivious posted. It's hard to get more damning evidence of being a shill than that. If you're referring to "mod power abuse", I agree that may not be an issue here. However, there was still trust abuse.

5
Rubin0•

Hey man, I defended her too. I was accused of being Saydrah 7 times. I'm not going to hold a grudge though. This is the nature of reddit and I don't believe I can change it. However, this is my home. I intend to stay.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-5
crazytiredguy•

Funny how 'investigating' works around here. Like when they investigated my friend's banning then made up the ban reason before unbanning him.

Bottom line, I have zero faith in the Reddit admins.

Why am I still here? Because it kills time. I do have Adblock on for the site now, however. Fuck 'em.

Edit: Heh, my most heavily down-voted comment to date. I need to balance it out. Bacon, Narwahls and cute kittens.

-17
jedberg•

Funny how 'investigating' works around here. Like when they investigated my friend's banning then made up the ban reason before unbanning him.

That's bullshit and you know it. Why do you keep doing this? You need to stop talking for your "friend" in public, because then you force us to respond and defend ourselves.

Your friend knows why he was banned. I told him as much. Maybe he isn't being honest with you, or maybe you really are him and are just trying to stir up shit -- I don't really know.

But you need to stop speaking on behalf of cweaver -- he needs to speak for himself.

18
crazytiredguy•

I will stop speaking on behalf of him. Look, I want to be friends with everybody (you do still have an F by your name, btw) but lately I've felt very cynical.

In spite of CoCo pleading with me not to be cynical.

I do apologize for the tone there, and I will turn Adblock back off (and click a few times) but over the past month I've just felt really disenfranchised by everything thats gone on. I don't know if its me or Reddit that has changed but I miss the way Reddit and I used to be (secret lovers refusing to get work done).

-3
Gravity13•

Bottom line, I have zero faith in the Reddit admins.

Why? I hate to sound like a kiss-ass right now, but the reddit admins are an exemplary example of how admins should act. When shit breaks - it doesn't matter if it's a Sunday or they're in the middle of the damn googleplex, they drop what they're doing, find a computer, and get to work.

And plus they have an extremely hands-off approach to these things - they let the community decide, and that is, after all, the principle of reddit, a community driven site.

On top of that, the ads themselves are never intrusive - the admins actually give a shit about the users.

Naturally, there will be people who always complain, but I don't think you realize just how lucky reddit is to have admins like it does. Reddit has lots of problems - admins are definitely not one of them.

15
digitaldevil•

Why am I still here? Because it kills time. I do have Adblock on for the site now, however. Fuck 'em.

Ditto.

-4
kevin19713•

I just wanna let everyone know that I don't get paid to post anything. However, I have posted links in wearethemusicmakers to some music that I made. But thats what everyone in that particular subreddit does. I don't see whats wrong with yesterdays witchhunt, I followed it and agreed with the grievances that were raised(I still agree that they were legitimate gripes). And what personal info are they talking about? If you post video's online or allow everyone to view your myspace/facebook, thats not personal. If it is personal then take it down. Or just don't get caught bragging about the power you have in reddit(which seems to be so true now). BTW if anyone wants to get paid to post on reddit, I guess its OK if you put a disclaimer on each post(although I'm not sure if thats good reddiqette).

26
Kitchenfire•

Your suggestion wouldn't work because most people would downvote anyone who is up-front about their making money off that submission. You have to go Saydrah's route and spam reddit while surreptitiously posting links you've been paid to, then sit back and spam comments till the community knows you enough to upvote your submissions without actually looking at them, then post 9 out of 10 submissions that you are being paid to, then PROFIT!

6
[deleted]•

And what personal info are they talking about?

Users were posting the phone numbers and street addresses of her and her family.

2
superiority•

For serious? People be crazy.

2
[deleted]•

It's all good. Hypno-Saydrah has them under her spell once again. We all obey.

2
EatSleepJeep•

Your questions will never be answered. Apparently Saydrah wields a pretty big ban hammer, swings it quickly and does so without quarter. Her detractors are long since silenced. I shall be next, too. Watch.

1
AlSweigart•

Which accounts has Saydrah banned? What were her reasons, and what did the banned people have to say about it?

10
[deleted]•

You don't understand how mods work. She isn't even a mod here, and can only ban you from posting in subreddits she mods in. Stop the witch hunt against the mods. We really don't have any power except in our subreddits. Even then, there's only so much we can do.

8
electricboogaloo•

I respect the mods a lot. You do a thankless job that's essential to the smooth running of the site. Thank you

2
[deleted]•

Thanks, but I'm not even a mod of any of the major subreddits. It's the guys like Masses of the Opiates, British English Police, and qgyh2 that really deserve thanking. I try to send them a PM every once in a while to show some appreciation.

3
superiority•

I thought many people overreacted to Saydrahgate. Personally, I don't have a huge problem with her working for Associated Content and submitting their links. What bothers me is that she was never transparent about it. If pressed (and she has been once or twice in the past), she would deny that she was "paid to spam", which was technically true but was (imo) deceptive inasmuch as her job involves content promotion on social media websites. Contrast this with GiantBatFart, who makes money (by way of ads and merch) from the content he creates and submits, but is entirely open about the fact that The Oatmeal is written by him.

1
epalla•

anyone else try to go to staging.reddit.com?

22
jedberg•

You didn't actually think that would be the hostname for the real staging server, did you? :)

Besides, it is behind multiple methods of auth.

11
FillInTheBlank•

And those are...

7
jedberg•

Well, first you have to find the special phone booth. Enter it, dial the secret code, which activates the elevator. That takes you into the underground bunker. Then you have to do a dual handprint scan and a retinal scan.

After that, you walk up to another door, where you have to have another mod turn their key simultaneously with you to open the door.

Then you both enter the room, which has a computer in it. You crack open the plastic holder, which has a one time use password to log into the computer.

Once logged in, you access our staging server, but you must reauth with the retinal scanner every 6 seconds.

It's a real pain.

32
AmazingSyco•

Sounds easier than Assassin's Creed II's DRM.

8
FillInTheBlank•

Hmmm....

How long do you think it'll be before mind control becomes possible?
Are you 'willing' to become a test subject for it?

1
PlNG•

After that, you walk up to another door, where you have to have another mod turn their key simultaneously with you to open the door.

Must be a painful that when you get there, the mod is unresponsive, then spontaneously disappears from inactivity, leaving you with a long wait for another mod to do the same thing to.

1
munificent•

Besides, it is behind multiple methods of auth.

How do you even do the secret handshake over the internets? <mind boggles>

2
PaiTrakt•

I was disappointed.

6
[deleted]•

I found out that subdomains go to the subreddit with the same name.

2
a_redditor•

Holy crap, I didn't know you could do it like that (staging.reddit). I always put reddit.com/r/staging, or whatever. I've been wasting keystrokes!!!

6
boa13•

Actually, it used to be that subreddit.reddit.com was the way to access a subreddit, way before the /r/ was introduced.

12
a_redditor•

This sounds familiar. Was it a long ass time ago?

1
RobbStark•

If memory serves, the switch happened when (or around when) they added the user-defined subreddits. Prior to that, there were only a handful of admin-created subreddits so there was no problem in assigning everything a unique sub-domain.

4
joshdick•

Yes, immediately. It took me to the create-a-subreddit page for r/staging.

2
bdfortin•

I also tried beta.reddit.com, but it only brought me to the front page.

...

Is reddit still in beta?

1
wtfrara•

No, it wasn't written by google.

2
superiority•

I think when they have a new feature they want to try, they roll it out to beta.reddit and tell people to check it out. I vaguely remember them doing this sometime in the past 6 months or so (maybe longer).

1
jedberg•

Yeah, that is how it works. Otherwise beta.reddit just points to the main site.

1
DirtyHerring•

Moderators are not exempt from our anti-cheating measures, and, though I hate to have to put it in these terms, we've "investigated" Saydrah, and we didn't find any indication of her cheating or otherwise abusing power.

That is not the point. There clearly is a conflict of interest. You wouldn't want Steve Ballmer on a board consulting your government if a switch to linux would save them money. Even if he never was caught abusing his power. Even if he actually tried his best not to abuse his powers and be objective.

You're doing an amazing job keeping reddit working!

22