Is my luck just bad or am I missing something?

I was reading the post about how people think about their exes and it got me thinking. The last couple of women I dated (2 LTRs from 22-32) I remember fondly. We had a ton in common, did lots of stuff together etc etc. On the surface, seems like everything should be great.

But then it occured to me, that when I met both of them, neither of them really DID much of anything. One just hung out with friends, pretty average I'd say. But the second had pretty much no social life and no friends outside of me. I'd often ask both for input on things to do, places to go etc, but was always met with some form of "Oh whatever you want to do".

Now, I'm a huge motorcycle buff, I work on all my own bikes, I own many of them, and I'm just generally all around passionate about racing and motorcycles. #1 took a liking to my sport bikes I was riding at the time. Rode late with the group I rode with and pretty much abandoned her old friend circle. That ended in disaster when she decided to cheat. So bullet dodged-ish.

2nd came along from an OLD match and we got to talking, hanging out and what not. In pretty short order she was riding her own bike, we'd go riding and so on. Again, at the time it looked like we had a bunch in common. Ultimately it ended for other reasons (I lost a job and couldn't get a grip on things).

But now that I'm thinking about it. Does it seem like I actually had anything in common with this people? I always made sure never to force the issue if they didn't want to do something and was, and still am, always interested in meeting people and doing other things. It's just starting to seem like I didn't really share a passion because they both just jumped on mine. Did I completely wiff on finding a real connection because I mistook them having my huge passion in common for them just going with the flow?

Posted Apr 10, 2019, 6:11 AM UTC

324
Manners2210•

You don’t need to share a passion to have a connection. I’m into hiking and trekking, plus I love going to watch football. My wife hates both. She’s always been into crafts, which I’ve always been indifferent about. On the surface we don’t have much in common, but I think she’s gorgeous, she’s funny, Intelligent and compassionate, plus a stack of other little things which aren’t related to having common interests.

15
ubrokeit•

Man, I think a lot of people fail to understand this. They're prioritizing and hunting for some activity or interest in common, but what matters even more are the mental and emotional connection. Guys and girls will have their separate interests, and that's ok, as long as you can communicate and understand each other.

12
paso507♀ 35•

I disagree I was married for 13 years to someone who shared zero of the same interests. By the end we were roommates. We didn't do anything together outside the house.

Depending on the couple's love languages it could work, but for me - never again.

5
DemonViceOP♂ 32 It's riding season!!•

I actually had mentioned the roommate comment to the second woman I dated. I don't need a roommate nor do I want one. So this really resonates and I really want to make sure it doesn't happen again.

1
paso507♀ 35•

I have three active hobbies and a bunch of minor interests. I specifically looked for someone who shared at least one and would participate or encorage the others.

I was very clear with my BF from the beginning that I expected he do stuff with me and participate in my life.

Although he is always asking what I want to do. I have made a point to notice his interests and make sure to suggest/schedule those as often as possible.

1
DemonViceOP♂ 32 It's riding season!!•

I've thought about that too. I've also wondered if I was the oblivious one not digging into the things they liked to do more than I did. Ultimately I just want to not make the same mistakes. But dang if it ain't hard to figure out where things when pear shaped sometimes.

3
spanishbanana•

I think some over lapping interests are important. You dont have to do everything together, because you now have something to talk about.

1
huggsypenguinpal♀ 30•

Maybe it's not the lack of hobbies, but actually your partners not contributing to your shared experiences? It sounds like perhaps they didn't bring much to the table when it came to new experiences for you or together as a couple. Perhaps they were the passive participant, depending on you to lead the way, and now you are looking for someone who actively participates in creating experiences for the two of you.

1
DemonViceOP♂ 32 It's riding season!!•

That's actually really insightful. Very possible I wanted that all along and didn't know what it actually was

2
Caroline_Bintley•

It's just starting to seem like I didn't really share a passion because they both just jumped on mine.

Plenty of people discover a passion when someone else introduces them to it.

In my opinion, having someone to expand your worldview and introduce you to new experiences is one of the best things about relationships.

4
WhyNotWhoKnows38♀•

Right, isn't this normal? If I'm into someone I want to know about their hobbies and interests. I'll almost always give their "thing" a try or two just out of curiosity

4
DemonViceOP♂ 32 It's riding season!!•

Oh sure, I'm not saying I'm at all upset that they have my thing a shot and liked it. It's that there really wasn't anything going on on their end that I could give the same shot. So it just feels like we had nothing in common, even though both did end up liking my thing.

3
WhyNotWhoKnows38♀•

I get that, I just don't think having a similar hobby is actually all that important. Maybe in the future you and your SO can try a completely new to both of you hobby to get into together.

Or maybe these women were just boring, I don't know. I enjoy alone time, maybe a little too much, so it wouldn't bother me if the person I was dating had hobbies I had no interest in. It would be different if I had no hobbies/interests of my own and always had to tag along with them because I wasn't ok with them doing their own thing.

1
DemonViceOP♂ 32 It's riding season!!•

I'm actually starting to think it's more of a drive issue rather than a specific activity thing. Reading through the responses, it's true I was really happy they enjoyed riding. But there was really not much drive on their end to reciprocate that process.

1
Hoooer♂ 34•

You are choosing a dvd for tonight

1
Squirmme•

I think it’s cool they jumped on your hobbies. It takes a lot of love to do something like that for the person your with.

But now you know what you want: A partner who has enough going on where they can live their own life while being apart of yours.

3
applefae♀ 35•

Having lots in common can be nice, but it’s not a prerequisite for a good connection! I personally prefer dates and friends who have interests and hobbies that are different to mine, because it introduces me to new things, ideas and activities that I haven’t experienced before.

What I do require is that the person I’m dating actually has a personality, interests and life of their own. I especially love people who are quite passionate about something, I really enjoy the energy and positivity that can bring.

What I also think is more important is sharing common values with a date/partner. Shared hobbies aren’t so important to me.

If we share some passions that’s awesome, and I do prefer to date people who at the very least like to get out in nature and hike. But mostly as long as they’re interesting and interested in the world, it doesn’t matter how little we have in common.

It sounds like the women you dated didn’t have too much going on in their lives, so while it’s fun that they enjoyed your own passion, it’s not great if they don’t have solid interests of their own. I think you probably would prefer a woman who has her own independent happy life that she can share with you, rather than adapting completely to your world.

3
DemonViceOP♂ 32 It's riding season!!•

That might be more accurate. Neither could have introduced me to anything new just because there wasn't much going on there. I honestly hasn't considered that aspect.

3
Stebben84♂ 44•

I'm looking for some things in common, but also some things that are not. It gives me a chance to learn about new things even if I'm not as into it as them. It also would give us a chance to do things on our own that we enjoy as individuals. Everyone's mileage will vary on this topic although.

1
deathbyfractals♂/36/dead inside•

Have you tried getting into their hobbies? I am getting the impression that they were reaching for you, but you haven't reached back?

1
DemonViceOP♂ 32 It's riding season!!•

That's the thing, I feel like I tried. I gave lots of openings to do something they had as hobbies. I'd been pretty explicit that I wanted to do something they were interested in. It's possible I didn't do enough there.

1
Hoooer♂ 34•

You go to Egypt

1