Continuous Swings vs Sets)

Depending on how I feel on a given day I'll do, say, 140 single arm swings (24kg), switching hands every 20 swings with no rest period (continuous swings for lack of a better term). This is quite a bit harder than taking a rest (10-15 secs) between sets of 20 swings (10/arm). I often see recommendations for KB training where swings are described in sets of 10 or 20 or in some pyramid configuration (5-10-15-20, e.g.).

It seems to me that as an endurance strength exercise actually enduring (i.e. doing swings continuously) would be preferred. Recommended workouts seldom seem defined on that basis, however. So, what gives? Are sets preferred for some reason, why? Is there any benefit to doing 140 without break vs. with brief rest periods at some interval?

Posted May 1, 2019, 11:12 AM UTC

410
PolarPriceCapps•

I think both methods have their advantages. Pavel recommends in S&S that every two weeks, you should take a bell that is one or two sizes lighter than your usual working weight, and do as many swings as possible without setting the bell down.

10
SantiGM86•

Got this from the Strong First forum. Posted by Anna C, Strong Fist instructor. Pretty much answers your question. (If you can do non stop 140 swings, then it's time for a bigger weight).

"The swings in S&S are about technique and power. So the recommended daily practice is 10 powerful swings R, fully recover (1 min or more). Then 10 powerful swings L, fully recover (1 min or more). Repeat that 4 more times for a total of 10 x 10, which might take 12-15 minutes to do. 

In contrast to the other extreme, if you were to do say 20 swings R, 20 swings L, and repeat that 4 more times without setting the bell down you would finish in 3 minutes or so. Possible? Sure, but you are no longer working on alactic power, technique, and strength. It is more of a gylcolytic endurance exercise. This has its place too, but not great for daily practice.

The 5-minute test will be somewhere in the middle of these two. Ideally you do it only once every couple of weeks, or less, to test yourself and/or to give a bit of a different stimulus than the regular daily practice. The daily practice will get easier and you will recover faster (to a point) between sets of swings, so it is possible to do 10 x 10 good powerful swings in 9, 8, 7... then 5 minutes. (Here's a video of me doing a complete session to the time standards). So, would 10+10 every minute be as good? Or multiple sets? I think not as good, because the test should be a condensed version of the daily practice, which does have some recovery after each set of 10. That said, a lot of people do the test as 10+10, and it's really not that much different when you condense down to 5 minutes. I just prefer to follow the prescribed format as much as possible. "

So I guess: do non stop every two weeks as S&S recommends, but then do it with rest intervals to get stronger with a bigger bell than you are using today.

8
GreenStrongKettlebell Victim•

Large numbers of swings work the legs, and the cardiovascular system.

For your heart, that's equivalent to a thousand yard dash. That's definitely a good thing, but generally you get better results with either High Intensity Interval Training (sets of swings or sprints) or Long Slow Distance

For the leg muscles, it is debatable whether that would be the optimal way to build overall stamina. (Obviously it is the best way to do 140 swings specifically) Strongfirst tells you not to train in a way that causes you to "feel the burn" and this is effective for both strength and muscle endurance. This is an example of Strongfirst programming for a large number of swings. I'm currently doing a modified version of that program, and I've done it completely as written, so I can answer questions from experience if you're curious.

I hope someone with girevoy experience will talk about their training, their competition event is very similar to what your're doing, except with snatches or C+J.

1
gleepglapOP•

Thanks. Your first link provides a good point of view on why making swings easier via rest periods would be beneficial. I like having an excuse for making a workout "easier.". I do need to get my head ok with the idea of spending a lot more time to do 100 swings.

2
GreenStrongKettlebell Victim•

I'm currently doing 10 swings, one burpee, one dip, and one pull up every minute on the minute. If I move as quickly as possible between each station, I get 30 seconds of rest. I'm using 20 kg kettlebell. That's a pretty light weight for me, that pace feels easy for the first twenty minutes. But I'm following the Serious Endurance plan, so I'm currently doing sessions over 30 minutes, it gets very tiring, in a good way.

2
double-you•

as an endurance strength exercise

But a swing is a swing. It is not an endurance strength exercise. How you do things makes them strength or endurance or something in between. So the premise is wrong but that's okay. If we decide that we want to do endurance, we still have to choose which aspects of endurance we want to work. Continuous sets are heavy on the grip while a bit of rest can still be endurance but lighter on the grip allowing you to do more without the grip being a limiter. But S&S for example is strength (or power) training and that works best with full recovery between sets and sets being so short that you can keep the same level of quality (and use the anaerobic energy system instead being aerobic or glycotic while doing work).

1
sandwichocheese•

In the context of S&S, you are correct. The emphasis is to treat the swings as more of a strength exercise over endurance (thus the 10 rep sets). Using full recovery and building up your volume over time should work for everyone to a point. Everybody's different, but if you stick with the program long enough and make progress, you'll hit a particular weight where just doing 10x10 with full recovery won't get you to hitting the time standard (5min swings, 1min rest, 10min TGU). You need to put some focus on endurance at that point. It seems that the popular thought is that you should be able to hit simple standards with your prescribed method, but after that it may get dicey.

1
double-you•

The finer details of S&S aren't really what we were talking about, but yes, it can include endurance work in the form of rest compression, which is what I started with in my reply. OP did not state what program they are on, but was talking about general programming. You are correct in what you say but I am slightly confused about your point.

1
sandwichocheese•

I think kettlebell endurance training has many benefits, and it will ultimately depend on your goals, In my mind, density is density. When you're training endurance style swings, it comes down to how many swings you can do in an amount of time. Obviously you can't get denser than continuous.

When I first started kettlebells, all I did was 2 hand swings. one of my favorite workouts was one from Tracey Riefkind. It was, take 3 different size bells, do 400 swings in less than 15 minutes, you have to do a minimum of 100 swings which each size bell. I played around with different rep/rest schemes, but in the end, it didn't matter much. My most successful strategy was just to keep going continuous for as long as I could take it, take a brief rest, then keep going for as continuous as I could make them. Obviously my sets progressively got shorter.

If endurance/conditioning is your goal, then there really is no wrong way to do it as long as you progress some how. (More reps/more density/more weight.)

1
TheWolfAndRaven•

If you can run 140 without stopping you're not driving hard enough and/or the weight is too light for you.

1