Custom Item. Helpful Whistle

Posted May 9, 2019, 1:33 AM UTC

Posted May 9, 2019, 1:33 AM UTC
Agro pulls for your tank forever and it's free and not even a neck slot? O.P.
I thought about it having Forced - at the end of your turn if your hand slots are full, discard this asset. What do you think of that?
I think having it as an accessory slot would be better. Making it 2 resources and only have one agility icon would probably be a good idea.
Thank you for the suggestions.
I really like the picture and flavor test. Good idea for a card.
As others pointed out, it needs a balance pass, but I really like the idea!
[deleted]
Do I need to combo it with the taunt card? Wouldn't it work just as fine to have the fast key word, and say engage all enemies and your location.
You would not. I intended to word it like u/TipsyGamer mentioned above but fell short.
Made in Abyss?
I like, this but it needs to take a slot.
Maybe whistle only goes for certain groups of enemies. Dont think ancient ones or Humanoids are impressed
"Am I your dog?" - Yog Sothoth (probably)
I am NOT your dog! - Shoggoth
I'll be your dog - Crow.
I like the idea a lot and I've designed a similar asset a while ago. As most mentioned you need a slot or something to tone it down a bit though. But clearly Guardians need better access to engage actions for free.
Also, I'll probably add the "Charm" trait too as it seems fitting. Currently it makes no difference to the design at all but an investigator/card might use them at some point.
Love the art too. Is is yours?
The art is not mine. It is by Skim Milk on DeviantArt. It was used previously on a card called Silver Whistle on the Oz CCG according to him but couldnt find it when I tried searching for that card.
2 agility icons on this is way over budget.
Yeah. There is not a single asset at level 0 with 2 icons of the same type. The only ones with 2 or more of a different type are the basic Talents and Joey the Rat.
Events do, and a lot are usually somewhat conditional.
The art is really good. At first I thought it was a real spoiled card.
A bit on the stronger side, maybe remove on icon or put some sort of cost. Like 2r. Or make you discard one card as a cost to the additionnal action. Or some sort of clause that discard the whistle if you get injured.
I did think of having a discard clause at the end of your turn if your hand slots were full. I like your idea of losing it if you get injured though.
Calling it "Helpful" is weird, surely everything I put in my deck is helpful? I'd change it to "Old Police Whistle" (they were manufacturing police whistles all the way up to the early '20s so you could probably get away with just "Police Whistle") which should give you more Guardian flavour too. In that case I would also give it the Police trait, like the Handcuffs. (police badge doesn't have the trait but I think that's just an oversight).
I will admit, the name was the aspect of the card I was the least sure about. At first my idea for the card was more of a whistle anyone could use when they are in danger(2 agi icons) but I picked guardian for the ability.
That said, I like your idea of a police whistle.
The text is not clear since "taunt" isn't defined in the rules. It should be clearer, like "forces an enemy to engage you. This does not provoke an attack of opportunity." It also kinda makes Manual Dexterity pointless for blues.
I think a clearer version of the text could be:
Fast, Exhaust Helpful Whistle: Engage an enemy at your location. Use this ability only during your turn.
Do you mean *instant speed symbol? Because making this fast(taking no actions to play) is not how I envisioned it.
Cool idea. A bit overpowered/undercosted. Probably should be 2-4 cost and take a slot. Would enjoy this as an investigator special ability like finn/Ursula specials.
I like it but as other said i would make it 1 icon and cost an accessory slot.
That said, would be cool an upgraded version that cost 3 or 4 exp and that you can exaust to ready one of your allies.
Or, if you engage 2 or more enemies with its original effect you get a +1 "fist" for every enemy engaged by that effect for the next turn
This is a cool idea for a card, and I really like your choice of flavor text. My one nitpick would be to say that there is no 'Taunt' action in AH:LCG (though there is a 'Taunt' card)... It should probably be 'which can only be used to engage an enemy'
Ah, there it is. I got the action confused with the card. Thank you!
Did you also envisioned the effect of this card as being exactly like the card "taunt"? Because that causes every enemy at the location to engage you, while if you simply replace "taunt" with "engage" you only get an extra action to engage one and only enemy.
And honestly you should just go with that, and then you really wouldn't need many extra adjustments. Consider that taunt also doesn't provoke attack of opportunity while engaging does.
I’ll second that, but say, it’s from “To Have And Have Not”.
Speaking of flavor text, that seems like a weird source. Why isn't it attributed to To Have and Have Not? Some kind of time travel issue?
Haha, no time travel issue as far as I'm concerned. I wasn't sure of the exact source so I used a more generalized credit.