How many grams of protein are needed for a sedentary person?

it says the rda is 65 grams but if you don't get carbohydrates do you need extra protein since the body turns it into glucose? is the rda plain wrong and too low to start with?

Posted May 15, 2019, 4:24 AM UTC

310
LogicalLynxCarnivore 2+ years • Discord & r/KetoAF Admin•

I have 2 answers for you:

  1. A lot less than any other mixed diet or plant based diet. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLPCvkvY4xYYO_cW0-If6aesfpGmudTPnR see the presentations by Peter and Dave.

  2. as much as your body needs.

It's kind of an irrelevant question because it's nearly impossible to eat an inadequate amount of protein on this diet unless shooting for extremely therapeutic range of ketosis (epilepsy) like 4:1 (10% fat) and/or severely undereating - and in these cases it might not be the main concern.

Eat meat, start with cuts you enjoy and see how you feel and pivot from there. Don't get caught up in the macronutrient stuff unless there are specific issues that need troubleshooting. Take this advice and apply it to both calories, micronutrients and fat.

6
brainwizardphd•

See this Donald Layman video: https://youtu.be/4KlLmxPDTuQ?t=1592

3
keuliena•

There is normally no advantage to consuming more than 0.82g/lb (1.8g/kg) of protein per day to preserve or build muscle once you're past the novice level as a natural trainee. If you don't train, it should be even lower, I guess.

3
MAX_tmpu•

Gluconeogenesis is a demand-driven process, not supply driven, so don't worry about "eating too much protein" like what the keto bros would say. That advice made me tired and miserable for over a year.

If you're sedentary, maybe shoot for a minimum of 0.5g to 0.6g per lb of body weight, but don't pay attention to the numbers! Focus on becoming satiated. There's no harm in eating more if you feel like you need it, your appetite will tell you how to eat.

Eating 70g a day at 145lbs made me feel very low energy for a long time, and I was trying to build muscle and I couldn't do it. I feel much better around the 150g range now.

3
Meppy32•

Do you have any data for it being demand driven? I used to believe that, but now I'm less sure.

0
MAX_tmpu•

I don't believe there have been clinical trials trying to demonstrate this and I'm unsure of any mechanistic drivers for gluconeogenesis, so I can't help you there.

All I can say is that Dr Shawn Baker talks about consuming large amounts of protein in one meal and his blood glucose doesn't increase significantly afterward.

There might be a shift away from lipolysis as insulin does increase in the presence of protein, but that doesn't necessarily mean ketogenesis isn't occurring.

All I can say is that after upping my protein, my performance, mood, and recovery has improved significantly. I feel better, and I don't think my protein is being converted to glucose (other than for glycogen replenishment post-exercise).

Supplemental L-Glutamine is very gluconeogenic iirc, so perhaps taking 10-15g/day might benefit glycogen replenishment and preserve the aminos from your animal sources? Who knows?

0
LJM111•

I love how this woe simplifies my life. Not only did I get rid of plant foods from our fridge and cupboards, I was able to simplify grocery shopping and reduce the gadgets and pans, baking dishes, and appliances in our kitchen as well. I always hated measuring my food and recording it in an app. The Carnivore/zerocarb woe is calming, fulfilling and gives me more time, better health and a nicer figure. Only regret is I didn’t find it sooner. So relax and get to know your own body. It will tell you what you need when you need it. All you have to do is listen. 😀

1
antnego•

If you’re not weightlifting, just find a ratio of protein:fat that makes you feel best.

1
EleanorinaMODmod, :bacon::cutofmeat: carnivore 3 yrs +•

Something to keep in mind when evaluating the formulas offered here. Are they specifically intended for zerocarbers?

1
DocRock5672•

Research I’ve read have said 1/3 your lean muscle mass in grams for sedentary, 1/2 for runners, 2/3 for lifters and 0.8 grams if you’re trying to build muscle while lifting. No matter how you slice it we don’t need 100s and 100s of grams of protein like bro science wants to push. While 1 gram/pound is nice easy math for meatheads it isn’t based anywhere in reality.

Also notice I said LEAN MUSCLE MASS. Your fat doesn’t need protein. That will drop the numbers even lower and maybe much lower depending on your % of body fat.

0